Lack of staff at Royal Derby Hospital contributed to baby death

Amy and Michael Amy Wray and her husband Michael say they were told staff shortages meant the hospital had to delay inducing their daughter Georgina

Related Stories

Poor staffing levels at a Derby hospital were a contributory factor in a baby's death, a report has found.

Amy Wray's daughter Georgina was stillborn at Royal Derby Hospital in March 2012.

An investigation into Georgina's death said staffing levels on the labour ward were "below minimal levels" at the time, the labour ward was "busy" and communication between staff was "poor".

The hospital offered its condolences to the family.

'We were just left'

Mrs Wray and her husband Michael are now suing the hospital for negligence.

She was 12 days overdue when she was admitted to the hospital for an induction on 15 March last year.

However, she said the induction was delayed because of staff shortages and she was admitted to a ward overnight.

"They said, 'We are really short of staff and therefore it's not safe to induce'," said Mrs Wray.

"You can understand if it's not safe because of staffing levels but they are there to provide a service.

"The NHS gets a lot of negative press and I don't think most of the time it deserves it. But we were just left."

No heartbeat

On 16 March, the induction process began at 06:00 BST and, shortly afterwards, Mrs Wray's waters broke.

Start Quote

They tried to resuscitate her but it was too little, too late”

End Quote Amy Wray

However, during the afternoon, Mrs Wray was left by her midwife who went to attend another birth.

"At this point, the pains were getting quite severe," she said. "There was nobody there to give any care.

"At about 16:45 my husband ran out to grab anybody because I was on my hands and knees in so much pain.

"A nursing sister came in and couldn't find Georgina's heartbeat."

Georgina was then delivered by Caesarean section, but she was not breathing.

"They tried to resuscitate her but it was too little, too late," said Mrs Wray.

A hospital investigation report said better monitoring of Mrs Wray could have identified problems earlier.

It said high levels of sickness and maternity leave among staff meant there were not enough midwives on duty, while the high volume of cases meant the consultant did not do his ward round, as usual.

The report also highlighted confusion among staff as to whether Mrs Wray, who had had a difficult pregnancy, should be classed as a high or low-risk case.

Cathy Winfield, chief nurse and director of patient experience, said: "On behalf of Derby Hospitals I would like to offer our sincere condolences to Mrs Wray's family.

"A full investigation has been undertaken. However we are unable to comment any further at this stage as legal proceedings are under way."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby



Min. Night 0 °C

BBC Local Live


    Today's Local Live updates have now come to an end. The service will start again at 08:00 on Tuesday.

    17:50: Cold and foggy Kaye Forster BBC Weather

    A dry but potentially foggy evening with light winds and temperatures as low as -3C (27F) in rural areas.

    17:40: Offender exposed himself Derby Telegraph

    A convicted sex offender exposed himself in public three times less than a month after being given a community order for the same offence.

    17:36: Robber absconds from prison

    A convicted robber with no front teeth has gone on the run from Sudbury open prison.

    Almas Ullah

    Almas Ullah had served six years of an indeterminate public protection sentence when he absconded on Friday evening.

    17:24: Newcomer faces world champion

    Derbyshire snooker player Oliver Brown says he is eager to show his 5-0 win over world number three Ding Junhui earlier this season was not a one-off.

    The 20-year-old amateur is due to play Mark Selby in round one of the UK Championship in York on Wednesday.

    17:16: WW1 rose auctioned

    A rose picked from a World War One battlefield by a soldier and sent to his wife in memory of a dead daughter has sold for £3,600 at an auction in Derbyshire.

    Flowers From The Battlefield

    Louis James Young's granddaughter, from Buckinghamshire, sold the rose mounted on a card bearing the inscription "Flowers from the Battlefield".

    17:07: Cheers for recovering Ram

    Derby County midfielder George Thorne received a round of applause from his team-mates as he ran on grass for the first time since suffering a serious injury in pre-season.

    The 21-year-old jogged across pitches at the club's training ground today as he continues his rehabilitation from a ruptured anterior cruciate ligament.

    16:58: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 17:00 bulletin, police release footage of the moment a shop assistant was hit around the head with what appears to be a gun.

    CCTV footage
    16:48: Fine for piercing infections BBC Radio Derby

    A Derby man who ran a body piercing studio has been ordered to pay £500 compensation to five customers after causing ear infections which left them in hospital.

    Jordan Bruce, 32, admitted failing to ensure the health and safety of customers at Skin Deep, on Sadler Gate, between May and June 2011.

    16:30: Feedback Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think of the service, which we write here in Derby.

    16:17: Video: Shop worker threatened with gun

    Police have released CCTV footage showing the moment a shop worker had a gun pointed at his head during an armed robbery in Derby.

    CCTV still of armed robbery in Derby

    Three masked men took £1,600 from Goodcheers convenience store, on Arthur Street, on Saturday evening.

    Anyone with information is asked to call 101.

    16:06: Big month for Rams

    Derby County are starting to pull away at the top of the Championship but have some tough fixtures coming up, including a League Cup quarter-final against Chelsea.

    Derby County fixtures

    You can browse the full fixture list on the BBC Sport website.

    15:54: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    CCTV footage released by Derbyshire Police shows the dramatic moment a shop assistant was threatened with a gun at a shop in Derby.

    I'll bring you the details in the news at 16:00.

    15:47: Train assault appeal

    Police have released photos of two men they want to speak to after a passenger was attacked on a train travelling from Birmingham to Derby.

    CCTV still

    The 22-year-old was hit on the head as two men left the train at Burton on the morning of 17 October.

    15:33: Terror briefings for Derby shops BBC Radio Derby

    Derbyshire Police will join other forces around the UK this week in delivering briefings to shops and businesses on spotting possible terror threats.

    Supt Gary Parkin, from the force, said: "The business community can help us and if we all do our bit then Derbyshire, as well as the UK, will be a very much safer place."

    15:23: Cash bid for attraction

    Derbyshire County Council is to bid for a lottery grant to help it restore Elvaston Castle.

    The authority said it had not yet been decided how much cash it would apply for, but some of the money would be used to transform the grade II listed property into a venue for weddings and conferences.

    15:10: Video: Frosty facts

    Did you have to scrape your car's windscreen this morning? BBC Weather's Philip Avery has this handy two-minute guide to the different types of frost we get.

    Philip Avery

    He says sub-zero temperatures don't necessarily guarantee an icy windscreen.

    14:59: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    Shocking CCTV footage released by Derbyshire Police shows the moment a shop assistant was hit around the head with what appears to be a gun, at a shop on Arthur street in Derby.

    You can see the CCTV footage on our Facebook page now. More on this and other stories in our 15:00 bulletin.

    14:50: New wildlife crime leader

    Derbyshire Police has taken on a wildlife co-ordinator to help tackle poaching, badger baiting, bird poisoning and the theft of wild eggs.

    Liz Hadfield

    Liz Hadfield's role was created by police and crime commissioner Alan Charles after he pledged to prioritise wildlife crime across the county.

    14:38: Midfielder's loan extended

    Darragh Lenihan's loan spell at Burton Albion has been extended for a further month.

    Darragh Lenihan

    The 20-year-old Blackburn Rovers midfielder will now be with the club until the new year.

    14:18: Teenage biker injured

    A 17-year-old motorcyclist was seriously injured in a crash in Ambergate on Friday.

    The accident, which did not involve any other vehicles, happened on the A610 Ripley Road at about 19:30.

    14:08: Listen: New cycling boss Andy Potter Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    At 14:15, Ruth Taylor, the new co-ordinator of cycling in the Derbyshire Dales, will be telling us why the district is one of the best areas to cycle in the country. Listen live.

    Ruth Taylor in Derbyshire
    13:54: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    A Derby man who ran a body piercing studio has been ordered to pay £500 compensation to five customers after causing ear infections which left them in hospital.

    I'll have the details in my 14:00 bulletin.

    13:44: Family reclaims WW1 medal BBC Radio Derby

    A Derby man has come forward to reclaim his great-grandfather's World War One medal which was found in a skip after going missing 30 years ago.

    WW1 medal

    Colin French got in touch after he heard the medal mentioned on BBC Radio Derby last week and realised its JW French inscription referred to his relative, John Walter.

    Email: 13:34: Your photos: Morning mist Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Here's a moody early morning shot, taken at an old quarry near Hathersage by John Thornton.

    Hathersage mist

    Email or tweet us your finest pictures of Derbyshire and east Staffordshire. I'll share the best on Local Live.

    13:25: Strictly viewers suffer power cut Burton Mail

    A power cut affected 4,000 homes across Burton and South Derbyshire during Strictly Come Dancing on Saturday.

    East Midlands Today 13:15: Geeta Pendse Presenter

    On BBC One at 13:30, a Derby shop worker is left terrified after being held at gunpoint by three masked men.

    CCTV footage

    And we look at the reported rise in voluntary projects run by faith groups across the region.

    13:05: 'King of fish'

    Ian Marshall got in touch after reading about salmon returning to Derbyshire's River Dove.

    He tweeted: "great to see the king of fish returning well done to the guys looking after the river."

    12:58: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 13:00 bulletin, police in Derbyshire are briefing local businesses and shopping centres on detecting and responding to terrorist threats.

    12:47: NHS strike ends

    East Midlands Ambulance Service tweets: #NHSstrike action has ended. This is followed by a period of action short of a strike during the rest of the week, until Sun 30 Nov #999wise

    12:39: Video: Leaping salmon

    BBC News has more on salmon returning to the River Dove in Derbyshire.

    Leaping salmon

    Many people have reported seeing the fish leaping from the water to overcome obstacles.

    12:25: Island work nearly finished BBC Radio Derby

    Work to upgrade Derby's Markeaton roundabout is due to be completed on Friday.

    The Highways Agency said it had hoped to have the work finished by now, but it had been held up by stormy weather.

    12:16: Jungle snacks

    Some of the unusual treats cooked up in honour of former Derbyshire MP Edwina Currie arriving on I'm A Celebrity...Get Me Out Of Here! have now been brought in to the BBC Derby newsroom for hungry reporters to snack on.

    Lamb testicles and mealworms

    The selection includes crickets, mealworms and deep-friend lamb testicles.

    12:07: Have your say Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    11:55: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    Derbyshire police are spending this week briefing local businesses and shopping centres on detecting and responding to terrorist threats.

    Find out more in my 12:00 news bulletin.

    11:45: Threatened shop worker won't return BBC Radio Derby

    A shop assistant who was threatened with a gun by three men who stole hundreds of pounds on Saturday is too afraid to return to work at the store.

    Another staff member at the Goodcheers shop, on Arthur Street, said his colleague was now working at a different shop.

    11:35: Delays in Ashbourne

    An accident is partially blocking the A515 in Ashbourne, advises BBC Travel.

    11:22: Afternoon temperatures

    BBC Weather has shared a map of this afternoon's predicted temperatures across the country.

    Weather map
    Email: 11:12: Watford winner

    Laura Pinney emailed us to say: "I put £5 on Derby County to beat Watford on Saturday. I spent my £12 winnings on a woolly hat for winter."

    10:59: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 11:00 bulletin, I'll bring you more on shops and businesses in Derby being given fresh advice on terrorism.

    10:50: Armed robbery stuns customer

    BBC News Online has more on a man who had a gun pointed at him after walking in on an armed robbery at a Derby shop.

    Robert Brown

    Robert Brown says he "froze" when he realised what was happening at the Goodcheers store, in Arthur Street, on Saturday.

    10:37: Burton's Christmas lights go on Burton Mail

    Burton was bustling with revellers yesterday as hundreds of people gathered for the annual switch-on of the Christmas lights.

    10:28: Talismanic Bryson Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Craig Bryson's winner at Watford on Saturday was his 30th goal for Derby County.

    Craig Bryson

    The Rams have never lost a game in which he has scored. Decent record.

    10:15: Uttoxeter schools rethink BBC Radio Derby

    Plans to overhaul Uttoxeter's three-tier school system are being considered by Staffordshire County Council.

    The authority is holding drop-in sessions to discuss the idea of scrapping the town's current education system, which sees pupils attending primary, middle and secondary schools, in favour of a two-tier primary and secondary system in line with most other areas.

    10:06: Celebrity diet

    As former Derbyshire MP Edwina Currie gets used to jungle life in I'm A Celebrity... Get Me Out Of Here!, BBC Radio Derby's breakfast show replicated some of the unusual food featured on the show.

    Martyn Williams

    Here's Martyn Williams with some deep fried lamb testicles, described by sports reporter Owen Bradley as tasting "a bit like chicken nuggets".

    09:58: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    Derby's local businesses and shopping centres are being briefed on detecting and responding to terrorist threats.

    I'll bring you more on this in my 10:00 bulletin.

    09:50: Health staff walk out

    NHS staff across the East Midlands are striking again this morning as part of a pay dispute.

    Union members are taking industrial action from 07:00 to 11:00 in protest at the decision not to implement a 1% rise for all staff.

    09:41: Salmon comeback

    BBC Breakfast's John Maguire visited the River Dove in Derbyshire this morning following reports salmon had been "extremely active" there in recent weeks.

    John Maguire at the River Dove

    The river is one of several UK waterways where conservation projects to boost their numbers are starting to bear fruit.

    09:29: Terror briefings for shops BBC Radio Derby

    Derby's businesses and shopping centres are being briefed on detecting and responding to terrorist threats as part of a national counter-terrorism effort.

    Supt Gary Parkin, from Derbyshire Police, says although there is no known direct threat locally, there's no place for complacency.

    09:17: Players 'ready for promotion push' Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Derby County head coach Steve McClaren says his players are better equipped to mount a promotion challenge than they were 12 months ago.

    Steve McClaren at Watford

    Saturday's 2-1 win at Watford saw the Rams strengthen their place at the top of the Championship, with a trip to Leeds United next on the agenda.

    09:05: Repeated burglaries force woman out Derby Telegraph

    Fear forced a 68-year-old disabled woman from her home of 30 years after a burglar targeted her property four times in nine months.

    08:55: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 09:00 bulletin, I'll have more on this weekend's armed robbery at a shop in Derby.

    08:41: Icy road warning

    BBC Travel warns icy conditions are making Lime Lane, in Morley, a difficult proposition this morning.

    08:30: Silver for Ryan Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Derby boxer Sandy Ryan has won a silver medal at the AIBA World Championships in South Korea.

    She lost to Russia's Anastasia Beliakova in the light-welterweight final earlier this morning.

    08:20: Customer encounters gunmen BBC Radio Derby

    A man says he had a gun pointed at him after he walked into a Derby convenience store as it was being robbed at the weekend.

    Goodcheers shop

    Robert Brown says he entered the Goodcheers shop, in Arthur Street, on Saturday night and encountered three masked men holding a gun to a shop worker's head before they left with £1,600.

    08:10: Sun to follow cold start Sara Blizzard BBC Weather

    It's starting cold with a widespread ground and air frost in rural locations.

    Then it will be dry and sunny with very light winds and highs of 8C (46F).

    08:03: Crash blocks lane

    A lane is blocked on the A50 westbound between Scropton and Hilton following an accident, reports BBC Travel.

    08:00: Good morning Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Hi everyone. I'm here to bring you all of today's news, sport, travel and weather updates for our area.

    We love to feature your pictures and comments, so email or tweet us at any time.



Elsewhere on the BBC


  • Ebola patients in Sierra LeoneHARDtalk Watch

    Dr Geraldine O'Hara recalls the horrors of working on the Ebola frontline in Sierra Leone

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.