Al-Madinah free school in Derby labelled 'dysfunctional' by Ofsted

Dr Stuart Wilson, interim head: "We fully accept the report. It does match our judgement of where the school is"

A Muslim free school has been described by Ofsted inspectors as "dysfunctional" and rated inadequate in every category - within a year of it opening.

An inspection at Derby's Al-Madinah school was brought forward after fears were raised over teaching standards.

The report says teachers there are inexperienced and have not been provided with proper training and that the school requires special measures.

The school said it accepted the report and would use it to move forward.

Reacting to the findings, David Cameron told BBC Radio Derby: "If they don't take immediate action to deal with these things then I think it is right it should close and I think it's absolutely right to intervene rapidly when these things aren't working properly."

However, he added: "Let's not use this as a stick with which to beat the whole free school movement - there are now hundreds of schools which have set up as free schools, and on average they have more outstanding and good ratings than established schools.

"When it goes wrong - just as with a state school - you've got to get in there and sort it out, or close it down," he said.

The Ofsted inspection had been due to take place by the end of the year but was prioritised following initial allegations that female teachers were obliged to wear hijabs and boys and girls were segregated.


There can be no more controversial policy than Michael Gove's free school project.

Some welcome the DIY school idea as a breath of fresh air in a stale system.

Others, including Labour, see it as a dangerous ideological experiment, with our children its guinea pigs.

But one thing is certain, Ofsted's report on the Al-Madinah School could not be more damning.

Questions will be asked how the Department for Education could approve a school for opening one year, only for it to be found to lack the "basic systems" it needs to operate the next.

Were the checks necessary for ensuring the school would be fit for purpose undertaken in a sufficiently rigorous way?

Al-Madinah is not the first free school to be put on special measures, another the Discovery Free School in West Sussex was also put in this category in July 2013.

And at least five others have been labelled "requiring improvement".

But none has unravelled quite so publicly as this Derby faith school.

It is this added religious dimension that makes the issue so tricky for Mr Gove.

In the early days of his free school project, applications from minority faith groups seemed to come in thick and fast. Not all went on to open, but some may ask whether more schools than should have been were approved for opening.

The school has since written to pupils and staff telling them there is no requirement to cover their hair.

Education minister Lord Nash last week warned the school it faced closure unless discrimination against female staff and pupils stopped.

A spokesperson said: "We were already investigating this school before allegations became public. We discussed the problems with Ofsted and it launched an immediate inspection.

"We have received a response from the Al-Madinah Education Trust as well as a report on the school from Ofsted. Any decisions made will take into account all the available evidence."

Cut and paste

Parents of students at the school have had a mixed reaction to the report

The Ofsted report found that pupils were given the same work "regardless of their different abilities" and the governing body was "ineffective".

It said basic systems were not in place, describing the school as being "in chaos" and "dysfunctional".

Boys and girls had different lunch sittings but the report said this was due to the small size of the canteen.

Inspectors gave the school the lowest ranking - "inadequate" - in every area, prompting the chief inspector of schools Sir Michael Wilshaw to call for it to be placed in special measures.

This means Ofsted will carry out inspections at the school at short notice to monitor improvements. If poor performance continues the school could be closed.

Dr Stuart Wilson, the acting head teacher, said there were "significant and serous problems" at the school and accepted some of the lessons were not meeting necessary standards.

"Are special measures a disaster for the school? Yes, they are," said Dr Wilson.

"It's not where we want the school to be at this time but we accept the report."

In one mathematics lesson, described by Ofsted as "insufficiently challenging", pupils spent the majority of their time cutting out and pasting shapes.

Dr Wilson said the school, which has 412 pupils aged between four and 16, had a lot of issues to deal with but he insisted it did have a future.

"Obviously the report doesn't make pleasant reading for anybody - we don't want to be in this position - we wish we weren't in this position - but what we need to do now is to accept the report in full and use it to move the school forward."

Writing to the school's chair of governors on Thursday, Lord Nash said the Ofsted report was "further compelling evidence of the breaches of the funding agreement I have required you to address".

Al-Madinah School Ofsted will carry out short-notice inspections at the school to monitor improvements

"Contrary to your suggestion that I have acted prematurely, I am even more convinced of the need for very decisive and urgent action on the part of the trust to comply with all your obligations and remedy the serious failings at the school."

One parent told the BBC: "I know they are teaching my children well. I'm seeing their progress and I have no concerns at all about the school."

Another, Razwana Akbar, said: "I am very angry. They have broken the trust as professional teachers, they have let us down."

Chris Williamson, MP for Derby North, said: "Frankly, the position of Al-Madinah school is now untenable and I would fully expect the school to close and for the children to be found alternative places in the council schools in the city."

'Total opportunism'

Speaking in Parliament earlier, shadow education secretary Tristram Hunt said the Ofsted report was a "devastating blow to the education secretary's flagship policy".

He said: "It reveals that pupils have been failed on every possible measure and parents will want to know why the education secretary has allowed this to happen."

He described the government's free school programme as a "dangerous free-for-all".

Are free schools succeeding?

  • Of England's 24 first free schools, three-quarters were rated good or outstanding by Ofsted
  • Four - outstanding
  • 14 - good
  • Five - require improvement
  • One - Discovery New School, West Sussex - inadequate

"David Cameron and Michael Gove can no longer ignore this issue - it is a crisis entirely of their own making," he said.

But speaking at the weekend, Mr Hunt told BBC One's Andrew Marr programme that although Labour would not open new free schools "along the Michael Gove model", the bulk of existing free schools would be kept open as his party wanted to "keep the good free schools".

Responding to Mr Hunt's more recent comments, the schools minister David Laws said that the government had taken "swift action" to deal with failings at the Al-Madinah free school told MPs that no school would be allowed to "languish in failure".

He also accused Labour of "total and utter opportunism" using the report "to shift its position".

More on This Story

Related Stories

BBC Derby



Min. Night 14 °C

BBC Local Live


    Today's updates have now finished. Local Live will return at 08:00 tomorrow.

    Temperature drop 17:50: Kaye Forster BBC Weather

    It will be getting a little cooler through tonight and tomorrow. Wednesday will be mostly dry with a fair amount of cloud and highs of 21C (70F).

    Buxton Crescent to be transformed 17:41: BBC Radio Derby

    A contractor has been chosen to restore Buxton's famous Crescent building.

    Buxton Crescent

    Vinci will take on the main construction work in a £37m project to turn the grade I listed building and grade II listed baths and pump room into a five-star spa hotel.

    Drug dealer absconds 17:34:

    Anyone who spots missing Sudbury prisoner Asaf Mahmood is asked to call 101 or Crimestoppers on 0800 555111.

    Asaf Mahmood press release

    The 35-year-old drug dealer is 5ft 11in, (1.8m), of slim build with brown eyes.

    Chesterfield pitches being reopened 17:31:

    A "football festival" is being promised for the reopening of refurbished pitches at Chesterfield's Holmebrook Valley Park on Sunday.

    The event, which kicks off at 10:00, will feature matches for men, women, children and people with mobility problems, as well as a bouncy castle and climbing wall.

    Feedback 17:29: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live - written here in Derbyshire - to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think of the service.

    Farewell to Nobby 17:22:

    Burton Albion's first ever captain has died.

    Bert 'Nobby' Hadfield led out the team for their first game against Gloucester City on 19 August 1950 and went on to make 274 appearances for the Brewers.

    The club said the player would be remembered with a minute's applause before tonight's pre-season friendly against Derby County at the Pirelli Stadium.

    More pupils have school meals 17:18:

    The number of Derbyshire children opting for a school meal has gone up over the past 12 months, the county council says.

    The figure stands at 52.2% in the county's primary schools (up 2.4%) and 48% in secondary schools (a 2.2% increase).

    Ex-Ram joins Tangerines 17:13:

    Former Derby County midfielder Tomasz Cywka has joined Blackpool.

    Tomasz Cywka
    Proud squash coach 17:00: Richard Spurr BBC Radio Derby presenter

    In a few minutes, I'll be asking Duffield Squash Club's team manager how he feels about seeing two of his players pick up medals at the Commonwealth Games. Listen live.

    Duffield's Nick Matthew and Laura Massaro
    News on the hour 16:57: Alex Howick BBC Radio Derby newsreader

    Our top local story at 17:00 is a 35-year-old drug dealer failing to return to Sudbury open prison.

    Nearly time for Y Not 16:54:

    The Y Not Festival has some important safety advice for anyone heading to Pikehall this weekend.

    Thousands of music fans are expected at the event, which features live sets from Dizzee Rascal, De Le Soul and Shed Seven.

    Howell returns 16:36:

    BBC Sport Online has more on midfielder Anthony Howell signing for Alfreton Town on a one-year deal.

    The 28-year-old joins from Mansfield Town, who he helped to win the 2012/13 Conference Premier Division title.

    Last looks on the bright side 16:26:

    Despite missing out on a medal, cross-country cyclist Annie Last, from Bakewell, said she was glad to have been able to compete at the Commonwealth Games following a run of injuries.

    Annie Last

    She said: "I have spent the past 18 months watching bike races sat on the sofa or doing rehab, so to actually be here is amazing."

    Human trafficking crackdown 16:16:

    Businesses in Derbyshire are to be given help to identify workers who may have been trafficked into the UK, reports BBC News Online.

    Derbyshire Police is teaming up with the Gangmasters Licensing Authority (GLA), which deals with exploitation, to visit firms that might be at risk.

    New deal for Rams forward 16:06:

    Derby County forward Mason Bennett has signed a new four-year contract with Derby County.

    Mason Bennett

    The 18-year-old is the sixth player to commit his future to the club this summer, following in the footsteps of Jeff Hendrick, Craig Forsyth, Will Hughes, Jake Buxton and Craig Bryson.

    News on the hour 15:57: Alex Howick Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 16:00 bulletin, police appeal for information after a drug dealer goes on the run from Sudbury open prison. Listen live.

    'Oyez oyez' 15:34: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    We've had a few comments on Facebook about Sally Pepper playing a town crier in a new short video celebrating BBC Radio Derby's arrival on DAB Digital Radio.

    Sally Pepper

    Lynne Land wrote: "Microphones are overrated"

    Sarah Bestwick quipped: "New job then Sally!"

    Bad news for Rolls-Royce 15:14: Derby Telegraph

    Rolls-Royce's order book has taken a £350m hit after an airline cancelled an order for aircraft which would have been powered by its engines.

    Latest headlines 14:59: Alex Howick Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    A convicted drug dealer is the latest prisoner to go on the run from Sudbury open prison. I'll have all the details in my 15:00 bulletin.

    Your photos: Chatsworth in the sun 14:42: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Michael Anderson is the talent behind this glorious shot of a sun-drenched Chatsworth House.

    Chatsworth House

    Email or tweet us your great shots of Derbyshire and East Staffordshire. I'll feature the best on Local Live.

    On air 14:31: Andy Potter Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    After 15:00, you can find out how I got on when I visited a farm in Draycott which is used to give vulnerable young people therapy and vocational education. Listen live.

    Andy Potter with donkey
    Good news for splash fans 14:21:

    Derbyshire Dales District Council says its splash pads at Bakewell Recreation Ground are working again.

    No medal for Last 14:09:

    Bakewell's Annie Last failed to add to Derbyshire's medal haul at the Commonwealth Games, finishing fourth in today's cross-country mountain bike event.

    Annie Last
    News on the hour 13:56: Alex Howick BBC Radio Derby reporter

    The top local story in my 14:00 bulletin is news that a convicted drug dealer has failed to return to Sudbury open prison.

    Drug dealer absconds 13:40:

    A 35-year-old drug dealer has gone on the run from Sudbury open prison.

    Asaf Mahmood

    Asaf Mahmood, who has links to Birmingham, was jailed for more than three years in 2013 but failed to return from temporary leave yesterday.

    East Midlands Today 13:31: Dominic Heale Presenter

    On BBC One this lunchtime, we've got some useful ideas for school holiday outings in Derbyshire.

    Burton v Derby 13:25:

    Derby County will go head-to-head with Burton Albion in a pre-season friendly at the Pirelli Stadium this evening.

    Both sides are preparing for a fresh promotion push after being beaten in their respective play-off finals at the end of the previous campaign.

    Today's Facebook photo 13:16:

    Check out our latest Facebook cover photo, taken by Dave Maynard at Kinder Scout.

    Facebook cover photo

    If you've taken any pictures worthy of adorning our little corner of Facebook, email them to

    High sheriff's charity challenge 13:05:

    Derbyshire's High Sheriff David Coleman is planning to walk the full length of the county's 220-mile boundary to raise money for charity.

    The challenge begins on Friday and will see the former police officer covering the distance in 16 separate one-day stages over the next six weeks.

    News on the hour 12:56: BBC Radio Derby

    East Staffordshire digger maker JCB has secured an order for more than 1,000 machines worth £35m.

    Hear more in our 13:00 bulletin.

    Barcelona train in Burton 12:51: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Barcelona FC are training at the FA's St George's Park complex near Burton this week.

    Barcelona training session

    Lionel Messi and Luis Suarez are not with the squad, but some of the Spanish club's best-known stars, including Andres Iniesta and Sergio Busquets, are there.

    Arrest after pub assault 12:40:

    A 24-year-old man was arrested on suspicion of wounding after an alleged assault outside a pub in Chesterfield, reports the Chesterfield Post.

    How can council save money? 12:30:

    Derby City Council's Big Conversation, in which the public are being asked for their ideas on how the authority can save money over the next few years, is at Keldholme Lane Recreation Ground this afternoon.

    Tomorrow it will be at Derby Arboretum and on Thursday at Chaddesden Park.

    Midfielder signs for Alfreton 12:19:

    Alfreton Town have made their 11th signing of the summer, snapping up versatile midfielder Anthony Howell on a one-year deal.

    Anthony Howell

    It will be the 28-year-old's second spell with the Reds after he was part of their promotion winning side in 2010/11.

    Burton crash 12:07:

    An accident involving a lorry and a car is causing delays on the A5121 northbound in Burton, reports BBC Travel News.

    News on the hour 11:57: Kelly Smith Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    My 12:00 bulletin has details of Severn Trent Water ruling out a hosepipe ban for Derbyshire and news of a major order for Rocester-based JCB.

    Ten years in record books 11:50: Belper News

    An Alfreton firm is marking its 10th year in the Guinness World Record books for producing the lightest tent in the world.

    More Games success 11:37:

    Long Eaton's William Sharman (pictured left) has made it through to the final of the men's 110m hurdles which is due to take place this evening.

    William Sharman
    'A new way of broadcasting' 11:28: BBC Radio Derby

    Sally Pepper is the star of our latest trailer celebrating our arrival on DAB Digital Radio.

    Sally Pepper

    The short video shows her trying out a new way of broadcasting. Watch it on our Facebook page.

    Play area closed 11:16:

    The splash pads at Bakewell's park are currently out of action due to a faulty water pump, the district council says.

    Peaty: 'Room for improvement' 11:05:

    Derby swimmer Adam Peaty admits he is some way off being the finished article, despite winning a silver medal at the Commonwealth Games last night.

    Adam Peaty

    He said: "I've still got a weak start and plenty of things to work on for next year and many years after that but I'm really happy with that swim."

    News on the hour 10:58: Kelly Smith Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The top local story in my 11:00 bulletin is Severn Trent Water assuring customers there should be no need for a hosepipe ban in our area this summer despite the recent hot weather.

    School meal price freeze 10:53:

    Derbyshire County Council is planning to keep its school meals prices the same when the new academic year begins in September.

    The authority said the prize freeze - due to be voted on next month - would keep prices lower than many neighbouring councils (£1.95 for primary, £2.30 for secondary).

    Medieval market 10:36:

    Chesterfield Borough Council tweets: The scene at #Chesterfield Market as we prepare for today's medieval market. . Starts at 10am

    Chesterfield Market
    Medal winner is 'Staffordshire boy' 10:27: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Darren Bryan has emailed to say: "You are claiming that Adam Peaty is from Derby. He is a Uttoxeter boy born of Uttoxeter parents, therefore he is a Staffordshire boy."

    Adam Peaty

    While Darren is of course right that the medal-winning swimmer hails from Uttoxeter, his place in the City of Derby Swimming Club means we're definitely claiming him for Derbyshire too!

    The sandal that grows 10:21: Sally Pepper Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    On my show today I'll be meeting a Derbyshire designer who has has created a sandal that can grow along with the child. Listen live.

    Trains replaced by buses 10:10:

    A replacement bus service is running between Derby and Matlock today due to industrial action by Unite union members at East Midlands Trains.

    News on the hour 09:59: Kelly Smith Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 10:00 bulletin, Severn Trent Water says it wont be introducing a hosepipe ban - despite the hot weather.

    JCB wins £35m deal 09:43: BBC Radio Derby

    JCB has secured a £35m order to build more than 1,000 machines for the equipment hire firm A-Plant.

    All the machines will be built at the firm's factories in East Staffordshire.

    Very slow traffic 09:31:

    There's very slow traffic on the A61 Jaw Bones Hill inbound in Chesterfield, between the St Augustines Crescent junction and the A617 junction in the roadworks area, reports BBC Travel News.

    • News, sport, travel, weather for Tue 29 Jul
    • More updates from 08:00 on Wednesday
    • Listen to BBC Radio Derby
    Your views 09:20: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We write all our news, sport, travel and weather updates from right here in Derby. Let us know your views.

    Ambulance driver 'tried to groom girl' 09:09: Burton Mail
    More on medal rush 08:55: Kelly Smith Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 09:00 bulletin we'll have more on five Commonwealth Games medals being claimed by Derbyshire competitors in one day.

    'Team Derbyshire' in medals table 08:48: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Derbyshire-based competitors have now won seven medals at the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow. Here's how the medal table would look this morning if we were an independent nation.

    Medals table with Derbyshire inserted
    Street scenes from 100 years ago 08:39: Derby Telegraph

    Can you identify these Derby street scenes of 100 years ago?

    Pictures showing historical scenes of Derby have gone on display to mark the reopening of a refurbished art gallery.

    Hosepipe ban not needed 08:27: BBC Radio Derby

    Severn Trent has ruled out a hosepipe ban in Derbyshire, despite the hot weather.

    The firm says its reservoirs are more than 90% full and levels have been topped up by regular rain.

    Community buses funding fear 08:18: BBC Radio Derby

    A service providing a "lifeline" for elderly and vulnerable people in rural parts of Derbyshire fears it could lose all its funding from the county council.

    Eight community transport schemes in the county have been warned the authority is struggling to afford the £1.46m it will cost to keep running over the next few years and their grants may be cut.

    Silver for Peaty 08:07:

    Swimmer Adam Peaty, who trains in Derby, claimed his second medal of the Commonwealth Games last night, winning silver in the 50m breaststroke.

    Adam Peaty

    The 19-year-old's success followed a remarkable afternoon in which Derbyshire competitors picked up four medals, in squash (two), shooting and table tennis.

    Cloudy afternoon 08:03: Sara Blizzard BBC Weather

    A sunny morning but cloud will thicken during the afternoon with the odd light shower possible in places. Highs of 25C (77F).

    Good morning 08:00: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you all Tuesday's news, sport, travel and weather for Derbyshire and east Staffordshire.

    Email or tweet us if you'd like to contribute a picture, comment or question. You can also get involved on Facebook.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • SkatesCity-dweller's dream

    These motorised roller skates allow you to cruise to work - without breaking a sweat


  • A digger operated via an Oculus Rift and a controllerClick Watch

    Why controlling a heavy digger with a virtual reality helmet might improve safety

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.