Al-Madinah free school in Derby labelled 'dysfunctional' by Ofsted

Dr Stuart Wilson, interim head: "We fully accept the report. It does match our judgement of where the school is"

A Muslim free school has been described by Ofsted inspectors as "dysfunctional" and rated inadequate in every category - within a year of it opening.

An inspection at Derby's Al-Madinah school was brought forward after fears were raised over teaching standards.

The report says teachers there are inexperienced and have not been provided with proper training and that the school requires special measures.

The school said it accepted the report and would use it to move forward.

Reacting to the findings, David Cameron told BBC Radio Derby: "If they don't take immediate action to deal with these things then I think it is right it should close and I think it's absolutely right to intervene rapidly when these things aren't working properly."

However, he added: "Let's not use this as a stick with which to beat the whole free school movement - there are now hundreds of schools which have set up as free schools, and on average they have more outstanding and good ratings than established schools.

"When it goes wrong - just as with a state school - you've got to get in there and sort it out, or close it down," he said.

The Ofsted inspection had been due to take place by the end of the year but was prioritised following initial allegations that female teachers were obliged to wear hijabs and boys and girls were segregated.

Analysis

There can be no more controversial policy than Michael Gove's free school project.

Some welcome the DIY school idea as a breath of fresh air in a stale system.

Others, including Labour, see it as a dangerous ideological experiment, with our children its guinea pigs.

But one thing is certain, Ofsted's report on the Al-Madinah School could not be more damning.

Questions will be asked how the Department for Education could approve a school for opening one year, only for it to be found to lack the "basic systems" it needs to operate the next.

Were the checks necessary for ensuring the school would be fit for purpose undertaken in a sufficiently rigorous way?

Al-Madinah is not the first free school to be put on special measures, another the Discovery Free School in West Sussex was also put in this category in July 2013.

And at least five others have been labelled "requiring improvement".

But none has unravelled quite so publicly as this Derby faith school.

It is this added religious dimension that makes the issue so tricky for Mr Gove.

In the early days of his free school project, applications from minority faith groups seemed to come in thick and fast. Not all went on to open, but some may ask whether more schools than should have been were approved for opening.

The school has since written to pupils and staff telling them there is no requirement to cover their hair.

Education minister Lord Nash last week warned the school it faced closure unless discrimination against female staff and pupils stopped.

A spokesperson said: "We were already investigating this school before allegations became public. We discussed the problems with Ofsted and it launched an immediate inspection.

"We have received a response from the Al-Madinah Education Trust as well as a report on the school from Ofsted. Any decisions made will take into account all the available evidence."

Cut and paste

Parents of students at the school have had a mixed reaction to the report

The Ofsted report found that pupils were given the same work "regardless of their different abilities" and the governing body was "ineffective".

It said basic systems were not in place, describing the school as being "in chaos" and "dysfunctional".

Boys and girls had different lunch sittings but the report said this was due to the small size of the canteen.

Inspectors gave the school the lowest ranking - "inadequate" - in every area, prompting the chief inspector of schools Sir Michael Wilshaw to call for it to be placed in special measures.

This means Ofsted will carry out inspections at the school at short notice to monitor improvements. If poor performance continues the school could be closed.

Dr Stuart Wilson, the acting head teacher, said there were "significant and serous problems" at the school and accepted some of the lessons were not meeting necessary standards.

"Are special measures a disaster for the school? Yes, they are," said Dr Wilson.

"It's not where we want the school to be at this time but we accept the report."

In one mathematics lesson, described by Ofsted as "insufficiently challenging", pupils spent the majority of their time cutting out and pasting shapes.

Dr Wilson said the school, which has 412 pupils aged between four and 16, had a lot of issues to deal with but he insisted it did have a future.

"Obviously the report doesn't make pleasant reading for anybody - we don't want to be in this position - we wish we weren't in this position - but what we need to do now is to accept the report in full and use it to move the school forward."

Writing to the school's chair of governors on Thursday, Lord Nash said the Ofsted report was "further compelling evidence of the breaches of the funding agreement I have required you to address".

Al-Madinah School Ofsted will carry out short-notice inspections at the school to monitor improvements

"Contrary to your suggestion that I have acted prematurely, I am even more convinced of the need for very decisive and urgent action on the part of the trust to comply with all your obligations and remedy the serious failings at the school."

One parent told the BBC: "I know they are teaching my children well. I'm seeing their progress and I have no concerns at all about the school."

Another, Razwana Akbar, said: "I am very angry. They have broken the trust as professional teachers, they have let us down."

Chris Williamson, MP for Derby North, said: "Frankly, the position of Al-Madinah school is now untenable and I would fully expect the school to close and for the children to be found alternative places in the council schools in the city."

'Total opportunism'

Speaking in Parliament earlier, shadow education secretary Tristram Hunt said the Ofsted report was a "devastating blow to the education secretary's flagship policy".

He said: "It reveals that pupils have been failed on every possible measure and parents will want to know why the education secretary has allowed this to happen."

He described the government's free school programme as a "dangerous free-for-all".

Are free schools succeeding?

  • Of England's 24 first free schools, three-quarters were rated good or outstanding by Ofsted
  • Four - outstanding
  • 14 - good
  • Five - require improvement
  • One - Discovery New School, West Sussex - inadequate

"David Cameron and Michael Gove can no longer ignore this issue - it is a crisis entirely of their own making," he said.

But speaking at the weekend, Mr Hunt told BBC One's Andrew Marr programme that although Labour would not open new free schools "along the Michael Gove model", the bulk of existing free schools would be kept open as his party wanted to "keep the good free schools".

Responding to Mr Hunt's more recent comments, the schools minister David Laws said that the government had taken "swift action" to deal with failings at the Al-Madinah free school told MPs that no school would be allowed to "languish in failure".

He also accused Labour of "total and utter opportunism" using the report "to shift its position".

More on This Story

Related Stories

BBC Derby

Weather

Derby

18 °C 13 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    18:00:

    Today's Local Live updates have now come to an end. The service will resume at 08:00 on Friday.

     
  2.  
    Coming up 17:55: East Midlands Today

    On BBC One at 18:30, see our report on the 9/12th Lancers from Leicestershire on parade in France - 100 years after their last cavalry charge during World War One.

    Military re-enactment
     
  3.  
    Housing decision overturned 17:52: Derbyshire Times

    A decision to refuse permission for a housing development in Matlock has been overturned by planning chiefs.

     
  4.  
    Summer to return 17:47: Kaye Forster BBC Weather

    We have some fairly breezy conditions on the way for the next couple of days but it looks like there will be some summer returning next week! Watch this space!

     
  5.  
    M1 lane closed 17:42:

    One lane is closed and there's heavy traffic on the M1 southbound between J29, A617 (Chesterfield) and J28, A38 (Alfreton), because of an accident involving a lorry, BBC Travel News reports.

     
  6.  
    Future of Local Live 17:36:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place.

    We'd love to know how you think it could be improved.

     
  7.  
    More than 250 exploitation claims 17:30: Chris Doidge BBC Radio Derby political reporter

    It's emerged hundreds of children were feared to have been sexually exploited in Derbyshire last year.

    The figures, released today, show there were 268 "potential" cases of sexual exploitation referred to Derbyshire social services in the last financial year.

    It doesn't mean there were necessarily that many cases of abuse though - the council acknowledges reporting levels are high because of increased awareness.

     
  8.  
    Smoke grenade fan gets ban 17:22:

    A man who took a smoke grenade to an Alfreton Town game has been banned from attending football matches for three years.

    The 23-year-old was also fined £470 after being caught with the canister during the game against Woking on 9 August.

     
  9.  
    Your photos: Reservoir view 17:11: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Thank you to John Leigh for this splendid photo of Strines Reservoir.

    Strines Reservoir

    If you've taken any great photos in our county, send them to derby.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet us at @bbcderby

     
  10.  
    Latest headlines 16:58: Jenni Hulse Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The top story in my 17:00 bulletin is about new figures showing there were more than 250 "potential" cases of sexual exploitation referred to social services in Derbyshire last year.

     
  11.  
    Gun report prompts police swoop 16:54: Derby Telegraph

    Armed police swooped on a Derbyshire home following reports there was a gun inside the property.

     
  12.  
    Ibe to Derby? 16:44: Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Steve McClaren is hoping to meet with Liverpool forward Jordan Ibe and his representatives today.

    Jordan Ibe

    He says Derby, Liverpool and Ibe still all need to decide if the move will be right for them.

     
  13.  
    Crash on the A38 16:33:

    An accident is partially blocking the A38 northbound near Kingsway Island, warns our travel news team.

     
  14.  
    Ward gets call-up 16:26:

    Derby County forward Jamie Ward has been called up to the Northern Ireland squad for their European Championships qualifier in Hungary.

    Jamie Ward

    The game will be played in Budapest on 7 September.

     
  15.  
    Inside Out is back 16:15:

    BBC Inside Out East Midlands returns to our screens on Monday.

    Inside Out logo

    In this blog entry, the BBC's Controller of English Regions explains why he considers the programme so important.

     
  16.  
    Latest news 16:06: Jenni Hulse Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    It's emerged hundreds of children are feared to have been sexually exploited in Derbyshire last year. More on BBC Radio Derby

     
  17.  
    Jail for fire attack 15:55:

    A Buxton man who squirted lighter fluid on another man and then set him on fire has been jailed.

    John McLaughlin suffered serious burns to his face and body after being attacked by Jake Grimshaw at his home in Fairfield Road in February.

     
  18.  
    Bakewell jam 15:50:

    The A6 Matlock Street in Bakewell is blocked with traffic congestion near the Granby Croft junction because of an accident involving four cars, BBC Travel News reports.

     
  19.  
    Scarecrow record claim 15:43:

    A Burton farm claims to have created the largest single-site scarecrow display in the world.

    Scarecrow display

    The National Forest Adventure Farm says it has collected more than 3,312 mannequins - trumping the record of 3,311 in Cincinnati, USA.

     
  20.  
    Robber on the run 15:31:

    A convicted robber has absconded from Sudbury open prison.

    Andrew Taylor

    Andrew Taylor, 25, was given an 88-month sentence in February 2013 but disappeared earlier today.

     
  21.  
    Teacher banned after kiss 15:24:

    BBC News Online has more on a Derbyshire teacher being banned for kissing and hugging a pupil.

    School campus

    A panel heard Christopher Mallinson, 57, was sacked from William Allitt School, Swadlincote, Derbyshire, following allegations he had an inappropriate relationship with a Year 10 girl.

     
  22.  
    Spectacular Stanage 15:14: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Here's another great pic of Stanage Edge, this time sent in by Simon Bull.

    Stanage Edge

    Email or tweet us your finest shots of Derbyshire and East Staffordshire. I'll feature the best on Local Live.

     
  23.  
    Farewell to long-serving John 15:04: BBC Radio Derby

    One of the first apprentices at Rocester-based JCB is clocking off for the final time today.

    John Smith joined the company in 1964 after his father arranged an interview for him.

     
  24.  
    News on the hour 14:56: Jenni Hulse BBC Radio Derby newsreader

    In my 15:00 bulletin, Staffordshire's police and crime commissioner offers his thoughts on whether his South Yorkshire equivalent should resign in the wake of the Rotherham child abuse scandal.

     
  25.  
    Your news 14:45: BBC Radio Derby

    We're always on the look-out for interesting stories...

    Story appeal postcard
     
  26.  
    Dog mess promise 14:30:

    Erewash Borough Council has pledged to clean up dog mess quicker from next month.

    The authority says it is investing an extra £25,000 to ensure that any fouling reported before 14:00 is removed by 16:00.

     
  27.  
    Thursday afternoon 14:18: Charlie Slater BBC Weather

    A couple of showers are possible this afternoon but otherwise it should stay dry and bright with some sunny spells. Highs of 21C (70F).

     
  28.  
    Scarecrow record 14:07: Faye Chambers BBC News Online

    I've just spoken to an elated farm manager, Julian Fisher, who said, as of five minutes ago, he believes he has the largest display of scarecrows in the world.

    Scarecrow record

    The National Forest Adventure Farm in Burton-upon-Trent hoisted into place a 12-foot scarecrow called Big Ernie to be number 3312 in the display.

    The current record is for 3,311 scarecrows, in Cincinnati, USA.

     
  29.  
    News on the hour 13:58: Jenni Hulse Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    Ten new members of staff are being recruited at Burton's Queen's Hospital to help dementia patients. Find out more in my 14:00 bulletin.

     
  30.  
    M1 delays 13:49:

    BBC Travel News warns travel time is about 45 minutes between J29 and J29a of the M1 northbound because of a broken down lorry.

     
  31.  
    Police boss's ice challenge 13:40:

    Derbyshire's police and crime commissioner Alan Charles has taken part in the Ice Bucket Challenge, after being nominated by his daughters.

    After recording the video he made a donation to Macmillan Cancer Care and nominated his deputy Hardyal Dhindsa and Derbyshire's Chief Constable Mick Creedon to follow his lead.

     
  32.  
    Shaping our service 13:28: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place.

    We'd love to know how you'd like to see the service develop.

     
  33.  
    Alfie goes to school 13:12:

    East Midlands Today tweets: Alfie, born 16 weeks early,off to school for the first time.Send photos of your little one's 1st day to emt@bbc.co.uk

    Alfie
     
  34.  
    News on the hour 12:58: BBC Radio Derby

    The writer of a play about child sexual exploitation says there are almost 7,000 young people in Derbyshire waiting to see it. Hear more in the news at 13:00.

     
  35.  
    Squad shuffle to continue 12:55:

    Derby County boss Steve McClaren says he plans to continue using fringe players in the third round of the Capital One Cup against Reading.

    Steve McClaren

    He told the official Rams website: "It's another game in which I can look at the squad and have a look at our younger players."

     
  36.  
    12:38:

    Burton's Queen's Hospital is expanding its dementia support team.

    Ten new posts are being created to help the hospital cope with a rise in demand.

     
  37.  
    Car hits horse 12:34: Derbyshire Times

    A horse had to be put down after being hit by a car in Bolsover this morning.

     
  38.  
    Special trip 12:26: Andy Potter Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    After 13:00 I'll be talking to a Derbyshire student who's been out in Slovenia helping to excavate a World War One bunker. Listen live.

     
  39.  
    M1 disruption 12:10:

    A broken down vehicle is causing delays on the M1 northbound between J29a and J30, warns BBC Travel News.

     
  40.  
    Latest headlines 12:03: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    Staffordshire's police and crime commissioner comments on calls for South Yorkshire PCC Shaun Wright to resign over the Rotherham child abuse scandal.

     
  41.  
    War memorials plan 11:45:

    Derby City Council says it wants to restore war memorials using money from local businesses and organisations like the Heritage Lottery Fund.

    In a statement, it said: "We will be working closely with relevant local groups such as the civic society and neighbourhood boards to make sure fund raising opportunities are maximised and resources used wisely."

     
  42.  
    Rowett: 'Fantastic win' 11:34:

    Burton Albion boss Gary Rowett paid tribute to his side after they dumped QPR out of the Capital One Cup.

    Gary Rowett

    He told the club's website: "It was a fantastic win. They were a top side and they were full of household names."

     
  43.  
    Free computer coaching 11:23:

    Derbyshire County Council tweets: Today FREE computer sessions at Shirebrook library for those looking for info about benefits/advice about money worries. 01623 742425

     
  44.  
    Pupils to watch exploitation play 11:19: BBC Radio Derby

    Almost 7,000 school pupils in Derbyshire are on a waiting list to see a touring play about child sexual exploitation.

    The issue has come to the fore after it was revealed more than 1,400 children were sexually exploited in Rotherham over a 16-year period.

     
  45.  
    Your photos: Dramatic Stanage 11:12: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    National park ranger Keith Singleton sent us this dramatic photo of Stanage Edge in the Peak District.

    Stanage Edge

    Email or tweet us your best photos of Derbyshire and I'll feature the cream of the crop on Local Live.

     
  46.  
    News on the hour 10:59: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 11:00 bulletin, Staffordshire's police and crime commissioner Matthew Ellis offers his thoughts on whether his South Yorkshire equivalent should step down following the Rotherham child abuse scandal.

     
  47.  
    Teacher 'got too close' 10:51: BBC Radio Derby

    Derbyshire drama teacher Christopher Mallinson's ban follows 11 incidents of inappropriate behaviour at William Allitt School over the past two years.

    A disciplinary panel heard he had kissed and hugged one girl, ruffled the hair of another and arranged a solo rehearsal for a female student - which led to her concerned mother chaperoning her.

     
  48.  
    Buxton supermarket plan 10:37: Buxton Advertiser

    Plans for a £35m redevelopment of the former Buxton Water site, which includes a hotel and supermarket, have been unveiled.

     
  49.  
    WW1 centenary filming 10:29: Dominic Heale Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    Just about to film a re-enactment of a World War One cavalry charge in France.

     
  50.  
    Mountain bike crash 10:18:

    Edale Mountain Rescue Team were in action last night, attending to a mountain biker who was knocked unconscious when he crashed into a tree in Sheffield.

    Bike crash scene

    He was treated for chest and back injuries before being moved to an ambulance.

     
  51.  
    Bin switch reminder 10:07:

    Derbyshire Dales District Council tweets: Gentle reminder that bin collections here in the #DerbyshireDales are 1 day late this week because of the bank holiday

     
  52.  
    Latest headlines 09:59: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 10:00 bulletin, I'll have more on school pupils in Derbyshire watching a touring play about the sexual exploitation of children.

     
  53.  
    Kai Lambe shirt tribute 09:50: Burton Mail

    Kai Lambe's junior football team has decided to retire his shirt number in his honour.

    Kai died after falling into a weir.

    Kai Lambe
     
  54.  
    Hospital hygiene praised 09:47: East Midlands Today

    Health managers in Derby say two hospitals in the city have been rated above the national average for cleanliness.

    London Road Community Hospital and the Royal Derby Hospital were given high scores by NHS England. They also rated highly for patient privacy and dignity.

     
  55.  
    Cup draw 09:36:

    Burton Albion's reward for knocking QPR out of the Capital One Cup is a third round home tie against Brighton.

    Derby County were also drawn at home, against Reading.

     
  56.  
    Teacher kissed girl 09:27: BBC Radio Derby

    A drama teacher from Derbyshire has been struck off for getting too close to his pupils.

    An independent panel said 57-year-old's Christopher Mallinson's actions including kissing a girl on her forehead and letting a girl ruffle his hair.

    The panel concluded there was no sexual motivation or harm to pupils at Swadlincote's William Allitt School but said his behaviour blurred professional boundaries.

     
  57.  
    Antiques TV star reflects 09:17: Derby Telegraph

    Derbyshire antiques expert Charles Hanson has opened his heart to talk about his cancer battle and the loss of his son.

    Charles Hanson
     
  58.  
    News on the hour 09:00: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    Almost 7,000 young people in Derbyshire are on a waiting list to see a play which draws attention to the issues of child sexual exploitation. I'll have more on this in my 09:00 bulletin.

     
  59.  
    War memorials 'need attention' 08:45: BBC Radio Derby

    The city council says it wants to secure external funding to renovate Derby's war memorials.

    War memorial in Normanton

    The authority says most of the city's 18 memorials require a "gentle clean" but some require more work.

     
  60.  
    Rain and sun 08:32: Charlie Slater BBC Weather

    Today should be a mixture of showers and bright, sunny spells with highs of 21C (70F).

     
  61.  
    As it happened
    • News, sport, travel, weather for Thurs 28 Aug
    • More updates from 08:00 on Friday
    • Listen to BBC Radio Derby
     
  62.  
    Giant killers 08:21:

    League Two Burton Albion are through to the third round of the Capital One Cup after knocking out Premier League side QPR.

    Burton Albion celebratrions

    A 77th-minute Adam McGurk free-kick was enough to see Gary Rowett's side through, in front of 3,999 supporters at the Pirelli Stadium.

     
  63.  
    Bolsover route closed 08:12:

    BBC Travel News warns the B6419 Shuttlewood Road in Bolsover is closed at its junction with Clowne Road because of a police incident.

     
  64.  
    Good morning 08:00: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Hi everyone. I'll be bringing you today's news, sport, travel and weather updates.

    If you want to share your views or a photo, you can email, tweet or join in on Facebook.

     

Features

  • A painting of the White House on fire by Tom FreemanFinders keepers

    The odd objects looted by the British from Washington in 1814


  • Chris and Regina Catrambone with their daughter Maria LuisaSOS

    The millionaires who rescue people at sea


  • Plane7 days quiz

    What unusual offence got a Frenchman thrown off a plane?


  • Children testing a bridge at a model-making summer school in Crawley, West SussexSeeding science Watch

    The retired professor who turned village children into engineers


Elsewhere on the BBC

Programmes

  • A map of social media interactionsClick Watch

    Twitter's map of the Middle East conflict – how the two sides react to each other on social media

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.