Mairead Philpott televised sentence appeal rejected

INTERACTIVE
  • ×

    Appeal court

  • The Court of Appeal

    ×

    The Court of Appeal is the second most senior court in the English legal system. Its criminal division hears appeals against conviction and sentence from the Crown Court. It is not one physical court. It sits in up to 12 courts in the Royal Courts of Justice in the Strand in London. But it can sit elsewhere.

  • The judges

    × Lord Chief Justice

    There are 38 permanent judges who sit in the Court of Appeal. They are known as Lord or Lady Justices of Appeal. There were three judges sitting today.

    Lord Thomas, the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales (pictured), is head of the judiciary and head of the criminal division of the Court of Appeal Mr Justice MacDuff and Mr Justice Flaux are High Court judges.

    Lord Thomas dismissed Mairead Philpott's appeal, saying the trial judge was right in her assessment of the case and that the 17-year sentence could not be criticised.

  • The hearing

    ×

    Today's hearing was what is known as a renewed application by Mairead Philpott, who was seeking to appeal her sentence for the manslaughter of six children following a trial at Nottingham Crown Court in April.

    This means that an application to appeal has been considered by a single judge, who acts as a filtering system for the full Court of Appeal, and has been rejected.

    Mairead Philpott exercised her right to renew her application in front of the whole court - but it was dismissed.

  • The appellant

    × Mairead Philpott

    Mairead Philpott was not in court on Friday - which is not unusual for these sorts of hearings.

    For an appeal against sentence to succeed, the Court of Appeal must be satisfied that the sentence is excessive. That means it must be satisfied that the sentence passed was outside the appropriate range for the offence and the offender in the particular case. It is not enough that it was more than the Court of Appeal itself would have passed.

  • The lawyers

    × Lawyers

    Shaun Smith QC (right), counsel for Mairead Philpott, argued that she had not been strong enough to stand up to her husband, Mick Philpott.

    Richard Latham QC, for the prosecution, said she was very much part of a plan hatched over a period of time.

Related Stories

A mother who was convicted of killing her six children in a house fire in Derby has had an appeal against her sentence rejected.

Mairead Philpott, who was handed a 17-year sentence for manslaughter last year, had her appeal televised from Nottingham Crown Court.

Paul Mosley, who received the same sentence for the children's deaths, withdrew his appeal.

Mick Philpott, the victims' father, has not appealed against his life sentence.

'Loving parent'

Court of Appeal judges dismissed a renewed application by Mairead Philpott to challenge the length of her jail term.

Analysis

The most common ground for appealing a sentence to the Criminal Division of the Court of Appeal is that it is "manifestly excessive".

That means the court must be satisfied that the sentence passed was outside the appropriate range of sentences available for the sentencing judge in respect of the offence and the offender in the particular case.

Although it is important for public confidence there is consistency in sentencing, judges who pass sentence at the crown court are entitled to use their discretion.

They will consider the particular case and any sentencing guidelines, but it is only if they stray outside a reasonable range of sentences that an appeal can succeed.

The Appeal Court judges will have considered written grounds of appeal before the hearing, a written response from the Crown, and the remarks of the sentencing judge.

Winning a sentencing appeal can be an uphill task, but sentencing judges do make mistakes, and the appeal process is a vital safeguard in ensuring that sentences are fair and appropriate.

Lord Chief Justice Sir John Thomas said: "We have after examination of the circumstances and careful consideration of the judge's remarks come to the conclusion without any hesitation that this appeal must be dismissed.

"There is no doubt at all that she [Mairead Philpott] was a loving and caring parent. She brought up the children well. There was no doubt she had genuine grief at the loss of her children."

But he added that it was "extremely difficult" to understand why she did not "expose Michael Philpott's lie" during the trial and the extensive period when she was separated from his "controlling influence".

"She will always be seen, as Mr Smith [her barrister] put it, as a child killer. She will never be allowed children or contact with children," Lord Thomas said.

Speaking outside court, Mairead Philpott's sister Jennifer Duffy said: "She should have been given life.

"She should have spoken up for her children but she decided not to."

Filming at the Court of Appeal was allowed for the first time last month following a partial lifting of the long-standing ban on cameras in court.

Courts minister Shailesh Vara said giving people the opportunity to see and hear the decision of judges sitting in Nottingham was a "significant step towards achieving our aim of having an open and transparent justice system".

"Justice must be seen to be done and today marks another important step towards opening up the court process to bring justice closer to the public," he added.

Lord Chief Justice Sir John Thomas handed down the ruling.

Mairead Philpott's first appeal, along with Paul Mosley's, was rejected in July. The reasons for this were not made public.

Earlier this year, Mairead's legal team said an appeal would be made on the grounds her role was "not as substantial as the trial judge had assessed".

Philpott, her husband Mick and family friend Mosley were convicted of manslaughter for the fire at Victory Road, Derby, in May 2012.

Jade Philpott, 10, and brothers John, nine, Jack, seven, Jesse, six, and Jayden, five, died in the blaze.

Duwayne Philpott, who was 13, died three days later in hospital.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby

Weather

Derby

19 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Your feedback 14:55: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like to know what you think about our news, sport, travel and weather updates.

     
  2.  
    Live cricket commentary 14:40: Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Derbyshire's teenage wicket-keeper Harvey Hosein has pouched another catch in Surrey's second innings, after becoming a Championship record-breaker yesterday.

    Harvey Hosein

    You can listen to live cricket commentary here.

     
  3.  
    Inquest: Neighbour 'went back to sleep' 14:30: Matthew Barlow Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    The neighbour of a Derbyshire house where four people died in a fire, has told an inquest she went back to sleep despite hearing a smoke alarm.

    Josie Leighton with her son Tyler Green

    We will have more on this on BBC Radio Derby this afternoon.

     
  4.  
    Three arrested over robbery 14:17: Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Three men have been arrested in connection with a robbery at the Co-operative store in Spondon at about 20:50 yesterday.

    The men - aged 23, 35 and 38 - were arrested on suspicion of robbery and are currently being questioned by detectives.

     
  5.  
    Spondon robbery cordon lifted 14:04: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    The cordon outside Spondon's Co-operative supermarket on Sitwell Street has been taken down after a robbery last night. The store is open as normal.

    The Co-operative supermarket
     
  6.  
    News on the hour 13:56: Wesley Mallin Newsreader, BBC Derby

    Police have arrested three men in connection with a robbery at the Co-operative store in Spondon last night. You can hear more on this in the news bulletin at 14:00.

     
  7.  
    Queen's bench destroyed 13:44:

    Arsonists have destroyed a commemorative bench installed at Sandiacre's Stoney Clouds for the Queen's Diamond Jubilee celebrations.

    Burned bench

    The bench was one of 60 seats installed by Erewash Borough Council to mark the occasion in 2012.

     
  8.  
    Teenage record breaker 13:33:

    Derbyshire's Harvey Hosein has become the youngest wicketkeeper to take seven catches in the Championship.

    The 18-year-old, from Chesterfield, said: "I didn't realise when I was out there but as soon as I got back to the changing room they told me some kind of record had been broken.

    "I looked to do my usual thing out there and that was just a bonus to get the records."

     
  9.  
    Coming up 13:20: East Midlands Today

    We will hear how the seven-year-old daughter of a woman who died in a house fire tried to raise the alarm by banging on a neighbour's door at 13:30 on BBC One.

    The blaze in North Wingfield claimed the lives of three other people. Watch the programme here.

     
  10.  
    Video: Proton clinic 13:08:

    A Derbyshire charity is paying for five-year-old Ashya King to undergo proton beam treatment in the Czech Republic.

    Jenny Hill at Proton Therapy Centre

    BBC News's Jenny Hill visited Prague's Proton Therapy Centre to find out what the treatment entails.

     
  11.  
    News on the hour 12:57: Wesley Mallin Newsreader, BBC Derby

    In the 13:00 bulletin our top story is an inquest that has heard how a young girl tried unsuccessfully to alert neighbours to a house fire which killed four people in North Wingfield, north Derbyshire. Listen live here.

     
  12.  
    Chesterfield Hotel finances 12:43: Derbyshire Times

    The company which owns Chesterfield Hotel has just £5 in the bank, the Derbyshire Times has learned.

    Latest accounts submitted to Companies House also show Accelerator Concepts Ltd - which took over the running of the hotel last October - has total liabilities of £3,500.

     
  13.  
    Sunny afternoon 12:29: Charlie Slater BBC Weather

    This afternoon we should see plenty of sunshine and blue skies as the cloud thins and breaks, with temperatures reaching about 20C (68F).

     
  14.  
    Fire deaths inquest 12:18: Matthew Barlow Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    An inquest has started into the deaths of four people in a house fire in North Wingfield.

    North Wingfield fire

    Josie Leighton, 32, her sons, nine-year-old Tyler and 12-year-old Jordan, and her friend Claire James, 27, died in the fire.

    The inquest heard that Ms James' seven-year-old daughter Tia unsuccessfully tried to alert neighbours to the fire, which happened on Williamthorpe Road in November.

     
  15.  
    Roberts to miss Preston clash 12:06:

    Chesterfield winger Gary Roberts will miss tonight's trip to Preston North End with a hamstring injury.

    Gary Roberts

    PNE are unbeaten at home in the league since December.

     
  16.  
    News on the hour 11:56: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 12:00 bulletin I'll bring you the latest from an inquest into the deaths of four people in a house fire in North Wingfield last year.

     
  17.  
    Proton treatment 'milder' 11:50: BBC Radio Derby

    Mike Hyman is from Derbyshire-based charity Kids 'n' Cancer, which is paying for Ashya King's proton beam treatment in Prague.

    He said: "It's not like having chemotherapy or traditional radiation, it's much milder because it's more targeted.

    "They can send in a higher dose without the rest of the effects that happen to the body."

     
  18.  
    National role for fire boss 11:37:

    Staffordshire's Chief Fire Officer Peter Dartford has been appointed President of the Chief Fire Officers Association.

    Peter Dartford

    The association represents chief fire officers, senior managers and executives from fire and rescue services across the UK.

     
  19.  
    Watch record-breaking keeper's catches 11:27:

    England and Wales Cricket Board tweets its congratulations to record-breaking Derbyshire's young wicket-keeper Harvey Hosein.

    Fans can see three of Hosein's seven catches on debut here.

     
  20.  
    Stanton Ironworks concerns 'ignored' 11:14: Ilkeston Advertiser

    A parish council claims its concerns over 2,000 new homes planned for the former Stanton Ironworks have not been listened to.

     
  21.  
    Your photos: Bakewell 11:05: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Thanks to David Hudson for sending us this photo of Bakewell.

    Bakewell

    Email or tweet us your finest shots of Derbyshire and I'll show the best on Local Live.

     
  22.  
    News on the hour 10:58: Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    In the 11:00 bulletin we will hear from residents who want more reassurances about contamination on the site where 200 new homes are planned in Somercotes. Listen live here.

     
  23.  
    House prices recover 10:48:

    The East Midlands is one of six UK regions with average house prices higher than the pre-financial crisis peak, official figures show.

    The other regions are the West Midlands, South West England, London, South East England and East England.

     
  24.  
    Library closed after robbery 10:33:

    Derby City Council tweets: Spondon Library currently closed due to police investigation at nearby incident. We're not sure when it will open, but will keep you posted

     
  25.  
    Christmas gesture 10:23: BBC Radio Derby

    A woman from Derby is organising a free Boxing Day meal for 85 older people who will be spending Christmas by themselves.

    Lauren Brown said she wanted to help people who were lonely and plans to organise a talent contest to raise money for the event.

     
  26.  
    Wanted: Your photos 10:07: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Wendy Scott's superb photo of Ladybower Reservoir is our new Facebook cover image.

    Facebook cover photo featuring Ladybower Reservoir

    If you've taken any pics you think would look good on our Facebook page, send them to derby@locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     
  27.  
    News on the hour 09:58: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 10:00 bulletin, I'll have more on concerns from residents about plans to build 200 new homes in Somercotes.

     
  28.  
    Somercotes homes plan 09:52: BBC Radio Derby

    Plans have been submitted to build 200 new homes on the site of Amber Valley Rugby Club in Somercotes.

    Residents have raised concerns about chemical contamination at the site but developers say it is low-grade and could remain in place, although the borough council will have the final say on how it is dealt with.

     
  29.  
    Record-breaking debut 09:37:

    Derbyshire's 18-year-old wicketkeeper Harvey Hosein took seven catches on his first-class debut yesterday, setting a new Championship record.

    Harvey Hosein

    Day two starts at 10:30 with Derbyshire on 164-5 in response to Surrey's 181 total.

     
  30.  
    Brewers 'have moved on' 09:23: Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Goalkeeper Jon McLaughlin says Burton Albion's impressive start to the season shows the players have put last season's play-off final defeat behind them.

    The Brewers head to Wimbledon tonight three points clear at the top of League Two and looking for a fifth straight win.

     
  31.  
    Spondon shop robbery 09:09: BBC Radio Derby

    Police are investigating a robbery at the Co-operative supermarket in Spondon last night.

    The area around the store has been cordoned off following the raid, which happened shortly before 21:00.

     
  32.  
    News on the hour 08:58: Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 09:00 bulletin I'll have more on Ashya King starting his proton beam treatment in Prague, funded by a Derbyshire charity.

     
  33.  
    Missing man found 08:53:

    A man who went missing from his home in Melbourne has been found safe and well.

    John Davidson, 55, disappeared on Saturday, but police say he was found in Shepshed, near Loughborough, yesterday afternoon.

     
  34.  
    Top headlines
     
  35.  
    Where should our flag go? 08:40: Rob Watts Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    With Derbyshire Day fast approaching, this week we're trying to find somewhere really prominent to fly our big Derbyshire flag.

    Derbyshire flag

    This morning I'm at Ripley Town Hall, which was nominated by a listener yesterday. You can still submit your ideas on Facebook.

     
  36.  
    Parents jailed over truancy 08:26: Derby Telegraph

    Four parents have been jailed and five others given suspended prison terms in a blitz on truancy in Derby.

     
  37.  
    Ashya treatment starts 08:14: BBC Radio Derby

    A course of treatment has started in Prague for Ashya King, the boy with a brain tumour whose parents were arrested for taking him out of a hospital in this country.

    Ashya King

    The proton beam treatment has been paid for by the North Derbyshire charity Kids 'n' Cancer.

     
  38.  
    Swarkestone crash delays 08:05:

    A four-vehicle accident has closed a lane of the A50 eastbound in Swarkestone, warns BBC Travel News.

     
  39.  
    Sunny day 08:03: Charlie Slater BBC Weather

    After a misty and murky start it should become a largely dry and bright day with sunny spells throughout and highs of 21C (70F).

     
  40.  
    Good morning 08:00: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you all of today's news, sport, travel and weather updates.

    Email or tweet us if you'd like to contribute a photo or comment on any subject.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Green animalLife in green

    BBC Earth discovers some of nature's weird and wonderful creatures dressed in a colourful coat

Programmes

  • Three men solving a puzzleThe Travel Show Watch

    Why tourists are heading to Budapest for the chance to break out of a room

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.