Newham Council issued illegal parking fines after camera error

Camera (library) The cameras took £350,000 in unlawful revenue but the council refuses to refund it to fined drivers

Related Stories

Parking tickets were illegally issued by a dozen cameras over at least two years, a London council has admitted - but it refuses to refund fined drivers.

Local authorities are only allowed to use cameras authorised by the Vehicle Certification Agency (VCA).

But a Newham Council internal report, obtained by the BBC, shows between 2011 and 2013 it issued 6,840 tickets from unauthorised cameras - making £350,000.

The council says previous cases show it does not need to repay drivers.

By law, only camera models that have been specifically authorised by the VCA can be used by councils.

Otherwise authorities might use cameras that are not of a high enough calibre to be relied upon for evidence.

But Newham Council was using cameras that did not have approval.

When the problem came to light in February 2013, it commissioned accountancy firm PricewaterhouseCoopers to carry out an audit of how many unlawful tickets it had issued.

Start Quote

They expect us to abide by the rules, but when they're caught they seem to be above the law”

End Quote Paul Pearson

BBC London has now obtained a final copy of that report, which covers tickets issued in the years 2011-2012 and 2012-2013.

It reads: "Compliance is high (97%); however, due to the volume of parking penalty charge notices issued even a small percentage of non-compliance will have a significant impact on the council's finances.

"Clear instructions should be issued to the parking contractor only to use certified cameras for the identification of parking offences."

With regard to two of the unauthorised cameras, the report detailed: "The parking contractor was instructed not to use these cameras to identify offences. However, 151 PCNs were issued."

The audit recommended the council improves the accuracy of its camera register and monitoring of the private companies it uses to enforce parking.

'Disgraceful conduct'

The council has now cancelled all the parking tickets that were unpaid, writing off a total of £347,376.

But it is refusing to refund those drivers who settled the unlawful fines straight away.

Newham Newham was the principal Olympic borough

Paul Pearson, of ticket appeal website Penalty Charge Notice, said: "If the cameras are uncertified they can't be used for enforcement - that's the law.

"The law is there to make sure cameras councils use are fit for purpose. They are relied on for evidence, otherwise councils could use any old camera.

"They should contact the motorists who've paid their fines, apologise and offer a refund.

"They expect us to abide by the rules, but when they're caught they seem to be above the law.

"It's disgraceful conduct."

The BBC has also learned some tickets were unlawfully issued before the two-year period covered by the report, but the authority is unable to say how many.

Laura Macowski, who lives in Newham, believes she may have been issued with one of the illegal tickets.


  • The Certification of Approved Devices Order 2008 meant that by law councils could only use authorised cameras for parking enforcement
  • It was intended to prevent authorities using sub-standard equipment which could not be relied upon for evidence
  • London councils had until 1 April 2009 to ensure all their cameras were approved

She told the BBC: "I paid a fine issued via a camera on the Romford Road about six months ago which I believe was unlawful. I have absolutely no idea why I got the ticket.

"I've lived in Newham since September 2012 and received a ridiculous amount of PCNs.

"I haven't taken any of my appeals further as I just didn't have time to go through the long process."

In light of the BBC's investigation, Local Transport Minister Norman Baker said: "When councils are carrying out parking enforcement using cameras they must make sure they are only using equipment which has been properly certified.

"This certification process is vital in ensuring that the system is fair and that motorists can have confidence in the standard of evidence being used to issue penalties."

A Newham Council spokesman said: "An internal review in June 2013 of 169 cameras operated by Newham Council found that 12 cameras used to issue parking tickets were not fully certified at that time.

"The council has decided that all outstanding fines from tickets issued via these cameras will be cancelled."

He added: "The cameras recorded vehicle use which was liable for enforcement.

"As other councils have established in law when involved in similar cases on a much larger scale, we will therefore not be allowing appeals on tickets paid in relation to these cameras."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



23 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    News on the hour 12:56:

    Top London headline on BBC London 94.9 this hour:

    London Mayor Boris Johnson insists it is not "game over" for his vision of a new airport in the Thames Estuary even though it has been rejected for being too risky and too expensive.

    Central line disrupted 12:44:

    Central line tweets: No service between Marble Arch and Liverpool Street eastbound only. Severe delays on the rest of the line.

    Councillors complete Ice Bucket Challenge 12:32:

    Senior councillors at Brent Council took part in the social media charity phenomenon Ice Bucket Challenge outside the Brent Civic Centre, London Evening Standard reports.

    The video of the challenge was posted on YouTube with the group nominating secretary of state for local government, Eric Pickles, for the challenge.

    Killer doctor's prescription books 12:22:

    Prescription books used by the murderer Dr Hawley Crippen are expected to be sold for about £5,000 at auction in Shropshire.

    Dr Crippen was hanged in 1910 at Pentonville Prison for poisoning his wife Cora, whose dismembered body was found under the basement floor of their house.

    Ledgers used by Dr Crippen The ledgers contain a list of patients and the homeopathic remedies they were given

    The two leather-bound ledgers, which were seized by police and used in the prosecution case, cover a period from 1893 to 1896 when Dr Crippen ran the London office of Munyon Remedies.

    Thames estuary airport rejected 12:12: Debabani Majumdar BBC London News

    Thanks for your comments on Facebook on the decision to reject a plan for an island airport in the Thames Estuary - backed by London Mayor Boris Johnson.

    Anthony Cummings said: This airport was always a non starter, now the studies should be stopped and new runway built elsewhere

    But John McGeehan said: That's a shame, the location's ideal for London. Looks like Gatwick is going to get a new runway then!

    News on the hour 11:56:

    The top London headlines at midday on BBC London 94.9:

    • Scotland Yard says there will be more vehicle checkpoint searches and extra police patrols following the decision to raise the terror threat level to severe.
    • Ceremonial uniforms belonging to British Army units which guard the Queen have been stolen in a robbery at a military supplier in Haringey.
    Met criticised over race bias case 1 11:48:

    An employment tribunal has criticised the Metropolitan Police for trying to "deflect" negative publicity by releasing details linked to the arrest of PC Carol Howard, a firearms officer who suffered race and sexual discrimination.

    PC Howard received more than £37,000 after she was discriminated against for being a black woman by her boss in the Diplomatic Protection Group.

    PC Carol Howard

    The tribunal said the officer has not received an apology and was called for the force's internal Fairness At Work scheme to be overhauled.

    Teen rescued from Thames after dare 11:37: via Facebook

    Thanks for your comments on Facebook on the teenager who had to be rescued after he accepted a dare to jump in the River Thames.

    Mark Baird said: So if he was dared to put his head in the gas oven would he have done that too

    Lali Wanjara said: Moron ... but thank God he survived & wont be stupid enough to do it again!

    Bakerloo line severe delays 11:28:

    Bakerloo line tweets: Severe delays between Queens Park and Harrow & Wealdstone while we fix a signal failure at Stonebridge Park.

    Ceremonial garments stolen 11:26:

    Nine ceremonial British Army garments and two silver Household Cavalry helmets have been stolen from a military supplier in Haringey, north London, on 18 August, police have said.

    Ceremonial garments stolen from Haringey

    The combined value of these items exceed £60,000. The garments are worn by the senior army units when they undertake ceremonial roles, including Trooping the Colour at Horse Guard's Parade in London on the Queen's official birthday, and the State Opening of Parliament.

    QPR sign Sandro and Kranjcar 11:16:

    QPR have signed Tottenham's Brazil midfielder Sandro and Dynamo Kiev's Croatia playmaker Niko Kranjcar.

    QPR midfielder Sandro Sandro joined Spurs from Brazilian club Internacional in 2010

    Sandro, 25, has agreed a three-year deal to link up again with manager Harry Redknapp, who signed him for Spurs from Internacional in 2010. Kranjcar, 30, returns to Loftus Road for a second successive season on loan.

    Mayor on airport capacity 11:07: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    @VanessaOnAir tweets: .@MayorofLondon speaking to Vanessa about #airportcapacity

    Boris Johnson
    News on the hour 10:56:

    Top London headlines on BBC London 94.9:

    • Boris Island: Mayor's opponents accuse him of wasting more than £5m on a "pie in the sky vanity project"
    First Great Western disruption 10:51:

    First Great Western trains are not running between West Ealing and Greenford in west London because of a signalling problem near Greenford, National Rail has said.

    There is no firm estimate yet of how long disruption will last but it is likely to continue until at least 11:00.

    Metropolitan Police HQ moves 10:43:

    Scotland Yard, which has been the home of the Metropolitan Police Service moved from Whitehall Place to Great Scotland Yard in 1875, and then to the Norman Shaw building in 1890, before its current home in 1967.

    The move to the Curtis Green Building marks a return to nearer its founding location.

    Met Police HQ The Metropolitan Police moved to its current home in 1967

    The Met Police estate has up to 500 buildings, costing £203m a year to run. Since March 2013, 32 sites have been sold and 22 leaseholds terminated. Up to 200 buildings will be sold by 2016/17.

    Uber banned in Germany 10:31:

    Car pick-up service Uber has been banned across Germany after a Frankfurt court ruled the firm lacked the necessary legal permits to operate under German law.


    The ruling is a temporary injunction, Der Spiegel reported. The summary judgment follows the decision by London's transport authorities not to pursue a case against Uber in June this year.

    'Bobbies before buildings' 10:20:

    The sale of the New Scotland Yard building is part of Mayor Boris Johnson's plan to reduce the force's estate by a third and saving £60m on annual running costs. About £125m has already been raised through the sale of 32 under-used and dilapidated buildings.

    The mayor said: "Londoners have backed our drive to put bobbies before buildings and the long-awaited sale of New Scotland Yard building will allow us to boost frontline policing and keep officer numbers high."

    New Scotland Yard for sale 10:10:

    The 1960s office block in the heart of Victoria, which has been the Metropolitan Police HQ since 1967, has been put on the market with a guide price of £250m.

    The HQ will relocate to the Curtis Green Building on Victoria Embankment, which is owned by the Mayor's Office for Policing And Crime and been empty since late 2011.

    New Met Police HQ The new Met Police HQ on Victoria Embankment will house 1,000 officers and staff

    The move will save the force over £6m a year in running costs and Westminster Council granted planning permission for the new site last month.

    News on the hour 10:00:

    Top London news on BBC London 94.9:

    • The New Scotland Yard building is going on the market for £250m
    • A 24-year-old woman's in a critical condition after being stabbed at a property in Walthamstow
    Met Police HQ for £250m 09:50: Danny Shaw Home affairs correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: New Scotland Yard officially up for sale. Offers in excess of £250m. A lot of interest in the site already apparently

    Parcels delivered on Sundays 09:40:

    From this weekend the Royal Mail will deliver parcels on Sundays within the M25 area.

    As part of the trial customers will also be able to collect parcels from about 100 offices on a Sunday, with offices open for four hours from noon.

    Woman stabbed in Waltham Forest 09:30:

    A 26-year-old woman is in a critical condition in hospital after being attacked at a residential property in Hatherley Road, Walthamstow, east London, yesterday afternoon.

    Officers and London Ambulance Service attended and found her suffering from stab wounds to her arm and neck. A six-year-old child at the address received treatment at the scene for a minor injury, police said.

    VIDEO: Row over Barbican exhibition 09:17:

    The Barbican Centre has been criticised for planning to host an exhibition that has been branded racist by some critics.

    Exhibit B

    Exhibition B by Brett Bailey features live performers including black men and women shackled and caged.

    Airport decision 'myopic' 09:07:

    Reacting to the rejection of the Thames estuary airport London Mayor Boris Johnson said: "In one myopic stroke the Airports Commission has set the debate back by half a century.

    "Gatwick is not a long term solution and Howard Davies must explain to the people of London how he can possibly envisage that an expansion of Heathrow, which would create unbelievable levels of noise, blight and pollution, is a better idea than a new airport to the east of London."

    News on the hour 08:57:

    Top London headlines on BBC London 94.9:

    • Plans for a Thames estuary airport rejected
    • Londoners will now be able to have parcels delivered on a Sunday or collect them from a delivery office
    Economic and environmental hurdles 08:50:

    Stating his reason behind rejecting the Thames estuary airport plan Sir Howard Davies said: "There are serious doubts about the delivery and operation of a very large hub airport in the estuary.

    "The economic disruption would be huge and there are environmental hurdles which it may prove impossible, or very time-consuming to surmount." The least ambitious version of the island scheme would cost £70bn to £90bn, much more than other options, he said.

    Top headlines
    Thames estuary airport rejected 08:40: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The Airports Commission has rejected a plan for an island airport in the Thames estuary. The idea had been strongly pushed by the Mayor of London Boris Johnson.

    More with Vanessa Feltz from 09:00.

    Teen rescued from Thames after dare 08:30:

    A teenager was rescued from the Thames near Westminster after jumping into the river for a prank.

    Still from RNLI video footage The boy was rescued from the water on Sunday and treated by London Ambulance Service

    The 16-year-old, who was rescued by Tower RNLI, said he had been dared to jump in so his friends could upload video footage to YouTube. Tower RNLI said it was already on a call near Waterloo Bridge on Sunday when crew members heard radio traffic saying a person was in the water near Westminster.

    Road delays 08:24:

    There are delays on the M1 northbound between junctions 5 and 6 due to an overturned car.

    This has also caused delays on the M1 southbound as drivers slow down to take a look. Get up to date travel information on BBC London Travel News or on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

    Tube delays 08:14:

    There are minor delays on the Northern line, Bank branch - Camden Town to Kennington - after a train broke down at Euston.

    The Victoria line also has delays following problems with a train at Brixton.

    'Boris Island' rejected 08:09:

    A plan for an island airport in the Thames estuary has been rejected by a commission looking into the UK's airport needs.

    Boris Island

    The proposal was dubbed Boris Island because of strong backing from Mayor of London Boris Johnson, who said the decision was "myopic" and had put back debate on the issue.

    Weather forecast 08:03:

    There will be varying amounts of cloud throughout today, but also some warm sunny spells once early mist and low cloud gradually lift and break.

    Highs of 21C (70F).

    08:00: Debabani Majumdar BBC London News

    Good morning, I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to



  • Cesc FabregasFair price?

    Have some football clubs overpaid for their new players?

  • Woman and hairdryerBlow back

    Would banning high-power appliances actually save energy?

  • Members of staff at James Stevenson Flags hold a Union Jack and Saltire flag UK minus Scotland

    Does the rest of the UK care if the Scots become independent?

  • Women doing ice bucket challengeChill factor

    How much has the Ice Bucket Challenge achieved?

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • BlueNew blue

    Meet the artist, showman and inventor who created a colour that had never existed before


  • Stranded shipThe Travel Show Watch

    Stranded in the icy Northwest Passage where only the polar bears move freely

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.