Does London need a £4.2bn 'super-sewer'?

Tom Bateman explores the existing Victorian sewers

Related Stories

A preliminary hearing on Thursday sees the beginning of a planning inquiry into a controversial new "super-sewer" under London - which would be 15 miles (25km) long, cost £4.2bn to build and create the UK's biggest sewerage system - but do we need it?

Deep below the City of London is a world few people ever see.

Iron girders span the length of a vast subterranean space - the floor is thick with river silt and the Victorian brick walls drip with condensation.

Workers here in the Fleet mainline sewer call this the "viewing gallery" - a space the size of a church hall cut into the earth, from where you can see millions of litres of raw sewage flowing from 500,000 homes on its long journey to treatment works in the east.

THAMES TUNNEL

Map showing route of the tunnel

PDF download Map of route[7KB]

Most computers will open PDF documents automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader

The sewers are part of a 20,000-mile network owned and run by Thames Water - and are a unique piece of British history.

They were built in the 1860s by the engineer Sir Joseph Bazalgette to intercept raw sewage that previously ended up being flushed straight into the Thames.

It followed a series of outbreaks of cholera that killed 40,000 people in the first half of the 19th Century - the Victorians believed the disease was contracted through airborne "miasma" due to sewage in the open air.

Their solution was a 1,000-mile network of underground sewers, the construction of which caused much controversy thanks to the £4.2m cost (the equivalent of £430m today), but prevented sewage being dumped in the river.

It was not until after the vast project was complete that the Victorians finally understood that cholera was waterborne - the deaths had actually resulted from pumping drinking water straight from the river into which raw sewage had been flushed.

"They got the right answer to the wrong problem," says Dr Stephen Halliday, author of The Great Stink of London.

He says: "One of the things about cholera and typhoid and other waterborne diseases is that they affect everyone - they affect the rich as well as the poor," he says, explaining what drove the decision to build the Bazalgette sewers.

Tom Bateman speaks to opponents of the Thames Tideway Tunnel

"Waterborne diseases, unlike the diseases of urban filth carried by rats and fleas, [affected] members of parliament and the Royal Family as well as the poorer people, who in those days of course didn't have the vote."

Today Bazalgette's network remains in superb condition - the lack of sunlight, the moisture and the regular temperature are perfect for maintaining the Victorian brickwork, according to one worker.

But there is a problem - the sewers are being deluged.

They were built to take not only waste water from people's homes, but to act as London's drainage system - when it rains, the sewers fill up.

The population they serve has quadrupled since the 1860s and vast areas of land have been concreted or paved over.

Where storm water once drained into the earth, now it surges straight into the sewage system.

The sewers overflow on a weekly basis, flushing 39 million tonnes of raw sewage straight into the Thames each year, according to Phil Stride from Thames Water.

He says: "It is absolutely not consistent for a world-leading city to be using its river as an open sewer.

"We need to build a project that will intercept those flows and take them off to east London for treatment before they are discharged into the river," says Mr Stride, who is overseeing the Thames Tideway Tunnel project.

The 15-mile tunnel would start in Acton, west London, and follow much of the route of the river, capturing raw sewage and taking it to a pumping station in Stratford in the east of the city.

Those in the engineering business call it a "megaproject" - a 200ft (60m) deep tunnel, as wide as the Channel Tunnel, which will take 10 years to build and cost £4.2bn - nearly half the cost of the 2012 Olympics.

It would eventually add up to £80 a year to Thames Water customers' bills.

A preliminary hearing on Thursday will start the Planning Inspectorate's long inquiry process before a final decision could be taken by the government next year. If the tunnel gets the go-ahead, it is due for completion in 2026.

The Fleet Main Line The Fleet mainline is named after the river that runs under Fleet Street and into the Thames

But the scheme faces strong opposition.

Much of the building work will take place around the clock, causing "mayhem" for people who live near the tunnelling sites, says Christian Sarrasin, from the environmental group, Clean Thames Now and Always.

"We've concreted over all the cities and that's why we've got this issue with the Thames Tunnel," he says.

He says there are cheaper, greener alternatives to it that involve preventing storm water flooding into the sewers in the first place.

So-called "green infrastructure" projects - often involving rooftops being covered in soil and plants - are being used extensively in the US city of Philadelphia where officials say they provide a "model" for flood and sewage management.

"You actually get massive benefits from this," says Mr Sarrasin, "it improves everybody's quality of life."

His group claims another green innovation - porous asphalt roads that soak up or store water - are a better alternative, and believe that converting half of the roads in central London would mitigate the entire need for the Thames Tunnel.

Both sides of the argument will be fully aired during the planning inquiry but there is no doubt that without some help the Victorian sewers will continue to struggle to meet the demands of 21st-Century London.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

12 °C 5 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    13:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Friends and colleagues have been paying tribute to a woman who was stabbed to death in Harrow following what police say was a dispute between next door neighbours, possibly over a parking space.

    Listen to BBC London 94.9.

     
  2.  
    12:48: Teens jailed over axe killing

    Three teenagers have been jailed at the Old Bailey for their part in a axe and knife attack on Handyman Paul Thrower, who died at a block of flats in Hayes, west London, on 20 February.

    The defendants

    Kiro Halliburton was found guilty of murder while Zakariya Subeir and Mahdi Osman, also 18, were found not guilty of murder but convicted of manslaughter.

    Halliburton was jailed for a minimum of 16 years, Subeir to eight years in a young offenders' institution with an extended licence period of a further four years, and Osman to five-and-a-half years.

     
  3.  
    12:40: Cycle Superhighway upgrade

    Responding to Transport for London's announcement on strong public support for the Cycle Superhighway 2 upgrade, Labour London Assembly member Val Shawcross said: "It comes as no surprise that the vast majority of people support plans to make Cycle Superhighway 2 safer with greater segregation.

    "Whilst the upgrade is entirely welcome the fact that CS2 is having to be entirely re-done shows just how wrong Boris Johnson got the scheme in the first place."

     
  4.  
    12:32: 'Money ploughed into the project'

    Responding to the Mayor of London's approval for the Garden Bridge, Labour London Assembly's John Biggs said: "It's obvious that the Garden Bridge is primarily a tourist attraction not a transport scheme, as such you really have to wonder whether this TfL funding could not have been better spent.

    "The mayor needs to be clear that no more taxpayer money will be ploughed into the project."

     
  5.  
    12:22: Homophobic abuse on Tube

    British Transport Police officers are appealing to the public to help identify a woman after a 23-year-old man was subjected to a prolonged homophobic verbal tirade by on the Tube.

    Police want to identify this woman

    "As the train approached Northwood, a woman opposite the man began shouting foul-mouthed homophobic abuse at him," PC Natalie Fairhurst said. "She followed the victim off the train, haranguing him all the way to the station exit."

     
  6.  
    12:13: East London 'priority' for bridges

    Business group London First's David Leam responded to news that a garden bridge across the Thames has been approved saying: "The short-term the Bridge's impact on jobs and growth in the city would be dwarfed by tunnels or bridges proposed at Silvertown and Gallions Reach in east London, on which progress has been painfully slow."

    "We'd like to see the London mayor applying a similar bit of elbow grease to getting crossings built east of Tower Bridge. In terms of economic growth, those are the priorities. "

     
  7.  
    12:06: Murder in 'parking row'

    A woman fatally stabbed in a north-west London street may have been attacked in a row over parking, Scotland Yard said.

    Alexandra Avenue, Harrow

    Alison Morrison, 45, was attacked in Alexandra Avenue, Harrow, at about 07:45 yesterday and died four hours later in hospital.

     
  8.  
    11:59: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    An open verdict's been recorded on a nurse who worked in the special care baby unit at Homerton Hospital, and whose mummified body was discovered in her flat.

    Listen to BBC London 94.9.

     
  9.  
    11:50: Marcus Innocent shooting

    A 26-year-old man has been jailed in connection with the death of a man who was shot dead in Woolwich.

    Raffael Scialo, of Elmbrook Road, Shooters Hill, was jailed for two years for violent disorder.

     
  10.  
    11:39: Festive travel

    Find out what Tube, train and bus services are running over the Christmas break - and when the Congestion Charge takes a holiday - with our comprehensive travel guide (pdf), courtesy of BBC London 94.9's travel presenter Paul Murphy-Kasp.

     
  11.  
    11:31: 'Pointless' and 'expensive' bridge Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Thanks to Robert Hanks who emailed in to say the approved Thames garden bridge is "pointless, expensive, destroys views" and "sucks in public subsidy for private development".

    Do you agree? Email london.locallive@bbc.co.uk

     
  12.  
    11:26: 'Very unique' Facebook

    On the approved garden bridge that will be built across the Thames, reader Oyuna Oyuna says on Facebook: Would be great to see that bridge, no doubt that would be something very unique and fantastic!

     
  13.  
    11:17: Ruling on police shooting death

    The Court of Appeal is due to rule on a challenge by the family of Mark Duggan - who was shot by police in 2011 sparking riots in Tottenham - after an inquest jury found he was lawfully killed by a police marksman.

    Mark Duggan

    His family claim there was an unlawful failure to prevent police officers conferring with each other before making statements.

     
  14.  
    11:06: Garden bridge 'modern day folly' Facebook

    On the story that a garden bridge has been approved to cross the Thames in central London, BBC website reader Ella Mitchell commented on Facebook: That's a lot of dosh for a modern day folly!! How many libraries and hospitals would this help!?!

    Do you agree? Join the discussion on Facebook.

     
  15.  
    10:57: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Friends and colleagues of a woman who was stabbed to death in Harrow yesterday morning have been paying tribute to her.

    Listen to BBC London 94.9 at 11:00 to find out more.

     
  16.  
    10:50: Your comments on the garden bridge Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Thanks for your comments on the story that a garden bridge across the Thames has been approved by Boris Johnson.

    Annie Cee said: £175 million would go a long way toward ending food poverty, homelessness and endless social issues effecting vulnerable folk in this City. Priorities, Boris!

    Do you agree? Comment on Facebook.

     
  17.  
    10:37: London Bridge partly closes

    One of London's busiest transport hubs partly closes today which could disrupt up to 12 million commuter journeys over Christmas.

    New platforms at London Bridge

    A reduced service will run from London Bridge station while work is under-taken to open two new platforms at a cost of £6.5bn. Southern and Thameslink trains will not call at London Bridge for about 16 days.

     
  18.  
    10:27: Camden Labour councillor dies

    Following news that Camden Labour Councillor Peter Brayshaw has died, Camden Labour's leader Sarah Hayward said: "The whole of Camden Labour is shocked and saddened by the death of our dear comrade."

    Mr Brayshaw served three times as a councillor - since 2010, in the mid 2000s and in the early 1990s.

     
  19.  
    10:17: Garden Bridge's opponents

    The Garden Bridge has previously been criticised by nearby residents and political opponents for its location and design.

    Earlier this year, shadow transport minister Lord Davies of Oldham described the bridge as a "very expensive piece of public art".

     
  20.  
    10:10: Cycle Superhighway 'watered down'

    A revised plan for the Cycle Superhighway 2 upgrade, between Aldgate and Bow roundabout, has been published.

    cs2

    But the London Cycling Campaign says the plans are "watered down".

     
  21.  
    10:05: NHS strike

    NHS workers in England will strike for 12 hours on 29 January, and ambulance staff will walk out on 29 and 30 January in disputes over pay, Unison and the GMB have announced.

     
  22.  
    10:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    London Cycling Campaign's accused Transport for London of "watering down" plans to upgrade Cycle Superhighway 2 between Aldgate and the Bow roundabout.

    Listen to BBC London 94.9 to find out more.

     
  23.  
    09:47: 'Stunning oasis'

    Mayor of London Boris Johnson said: "The Garden Bridge will provide a fantastic new landmark for London whilst supporting regeneration and economic growth on both sides of the Thames.

    Garden Bridge

    "It will create a stunning oasis of tranquillity in the heart of our city and boost our plans to encourage walking in the city."

     
  24.  
    09:40: Hero PC reunited with rescued baby

    Here's a heart-warming story for Christmas.

    Quick-thinking police officer Steve Norton, who saved baby Harrison Paine's life when he sprinted to hospital with him in his arms, has been reunited with him for Christmas. Full story and photos in the Wandsworth Guardian.

     
  25.  
    09:28: Bridge to attract 'seven million people'

    It is estimated that the Garden Bridge will attract seven million trips per year using it as a new way to cross the river.

    Garden bridge

    The bridge will include a major new public space and garden that will be free to access and will feature 270 trees as well as shrubs, climbing plants, hedges and flowers.

    What do you think? Email us.

     
  26.  
    09:21: Have your say Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  27.  
    09:12: Garden bridge

    Designed by Thomas Heatherwick - who created the cauldron for the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games - the Garden Bridge will be 366m long and will connect Temple on the north bank to the South Bank.

    Garden Bridge
     
  28.  
    09:02: Vanessa Feltz BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Parking in London - how big a problem is it?

    Can you park outside your house ? Tell Vanessa on BBC London 94.9 now.

     
  29.  
    08:57: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Police investigating a fatal stabbing in Harrow say it was triggered by a dispute between neighbours, possibly over a parking space.

    Listen to BBC London 94.9 to find out more.

     
  30.  
    08:49: Garden Bridge approved

    Construction of a new Garden Bridge over the River Thames could begin next year after the scheme was given the green light by the Mayor of London's office.

    Garden bridge

    Lambeth and Westminster councils had already granted planning permission for the bridge which was the idea of the actress Joanna Lumley. But opponents say it will block views of St Paul's Cathedral and, at £175m, is too expensive.

     
  31.  
    08:38: Gas work delays BBC London Travel

    The A23 Brixton Road is down to one lane northbound at the junction with Stockwell Road while gas works are carried out which is causing queuing traffic along Brixton Hill

    And there are anti-clockwise delays on the M25 between J25 A10 Enfield towards J23 A1(M) at South Mimms following an accident.

     
  32.  
    08:29: Broken down train BBC London Travel

    South West trains between Wimbledon and Waterloo are disrupted due to a broken down train.

    And Southern trains between Brighton and Victoria, Thameslink services between Brighton and Bedford and the Gatwick Express are running with delays of 30 minutes following signal problems.

     
  33.  
    08:25: Charge over teen abduction attempts

    A man from Wood Green has been charged with two counts of attempted abduction after a man allegedly tried to persuade teenage girls to get in his car in Hornsey High Street.

    The 25-year-old is due before Highbury Corner magistrates on Monday, police said.

     
  34.  
    08:19: Anniversary appeal over shot father

    Police are appealing for witnesses to come forward with information about the murder of Davion Watt, who was shot dead on Coldharbour Lane in Brixton exactly six years ago today.

    Davion Watt

    On the anniversary of his death, police say they're hoping for new evidence to emerge so Davion's family can get the justice they desperately want.

     
  35.  
    08:10: Temperature to drop

    Any rain and cloud should clear to the south-east this morning leaving plenty of sunshine for most of the day.

    Highs of 12C (54F) are expected to be reached this morning before temperatures gradually drop through the day.

     
  36.  
    08:00: Good morning Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Good morning, I'll be guiding you through BBC Local Live today.

    Get in touch with your comments and photos by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet us @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

Programmes

  • A prosthetic legClick Watch

    How motion capture technology is being used to design bespoke prosthetics

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.