Does London need a £4.2bn 'super-sewer'?

Tom Bateman explores the existing Victorian sewers

Related Stories

A preliminary hearing on Thursday sees the beginning of a planning inquiry into a controversial new "super-sewer" under London - which would be 15 miles (25km) long, cost £4.2bn to build and create the UK's biggest sewerage system - but do we need it?

Deep below the City of London is a world few people ever see.

Iron girders span the length of a vast subterranean space - the floor is thick with river silt and the Victorian brick walls drip with condensation.

Workers here in the Fleet mainline sewer call this the "viewing gallery" - a space the size of a church hall cut into the earth, from where you can see millions of litres of raw sewage flowing from 500,000 homes on its long journey to treatment works in the east.


Map showing route of the tunnel

PDF download Map of route[7KB]

Most computers will open PDF documents automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader

The sewers are part of a 20,000-mile network owned and run by Thames Water - and are a unique piece of British history.

They were built in the 1860s by the engineer Sir Joseph Bazalgette to intercept raw sewage that previously ended up being flushed straight into the Thames.

It followed a series of outbreaks of cholera that killed 40,000 people in the first half of the 19th Century - the Victorians believed the disease was contracted through airborne "miasma" due to sewage in the open air.

Their solution was a 1,000-mile network of underground sewers, the construction of which caused much controversy thanks to the £4.2m cost (the equivalent of £430m today), but prevented sewage being dumped in the river.

It was not until after the vast project was complete that the Victorians finally understood that cholera was waterborne - the deaths had actually resulted from pumping drinking water straight from the river into which raw sewage had been flushed.

"They got the right answer to the wrong problem," says Dr Stephen Halliday, author of The Great Stink of London.

He says: "One of the things about cholera and typhoid and other waterborne diseases is that they affect everyone - they affect the rich as well as the poor," he says, explaining what drove the decision to build the Bazalgette sewers.

Tom Bateman speaks to opponents of the Thames Tideway Tunnel

"Waterborne diseases, unlike the diseases of urban filth carried by rats and fleas, [affected] members of parliament and the Royal Family as well as the poorer people, who in those days of course didn't have the vote."

Today Bazalgette's network remains in superb condition - the lack of sunlight, the moisture and the regular temperature are perfect for maintaining the Victorian brickwork, according to one worker.

But there is a problem - the sewers are being deluged.

They were built to take not only waste water from people's homes, but to act as London's drainage system - when it rains, the sewers fill up.

The population they serve has quadrupled since the 1860s and vast areas of land have been concreted or paved over.

Where storm water once drained into the earth, now it surges straight into the sewage system.

The sewers overflow on a weekly basis, flushing 39 million tonnes of raw sewage straight into the Thames each year, according to Phil Stride from Thames Water.

He says: "It is absolutely not consistent for a world-leading city to be using its river as an open sewer.

"We need to build a project that will intercept those flows and take them off to east London for treatment before they are discharged into the river," says Mr Stride, who is overseeing the Thames Tideway Tunnel project.

The 15-mile tunnel would start in Acton, west London, and follow much of the route of the river, capturing raw sewage and taking it to a pumping station in Stratford in the east of the city.

Those in the engineering business call it a "megaproject" - a 200ft (60m) deep tunnel, as wide as the Channel Tunnel, which will take 10 years to build and cost £4.2bn - nearly half the cost of the 2012 Olympics.

It would eventually add up to £80 a year to Thames Water customers' bills.

A preliminary hearing on Thursday will start the Planning Inspectorate's long inquiry process before a final decision could be taken by the government next year. If the tunnel gets the go-ahead, it is due for completion in 2026.

The Fleet Main Line The Fleet mainline is named after the river that runs under Fleet Street and into the Thames

But the scheme faces strong opposition.

Much of the building work will take place around the clock, causing "mayhem" for people who live near the tunnelling sites, says Christian Sarrasin, from the environmental group, Clean Thames Now and Always.

"We've concreted over all the cities and that's why we've got this issue with the Thames Tunnel," he says.

He says there are cheaper, greener alternatives to it that involve preventing storm water flooding into the sewers in the first place.

So-called "green infrastructure" projects - often involving rooftops being covered in soil and plants - are being used extensively in the US city of Philadelphia where officials say they provide a "model" for flood and sewage management.

"You actually get massive benefits from this," says Mr Sarrasin, "it improves everybody's quality of life."

His group claims another green innovation - porous asphalt roads that soak up or store water - are a better alternative, and believe that converting half of the roads in central London would mitigate the entire need for the Thames Tunnel.

Both sides of the argument will be fully aired during the planning inquiry but there is no doubt that without some help the Victorian sewers will continue to struggle to meet the demands of 21st-Century London.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



Min. Night 2 °C

BBC Local Live

    18:00: Beth Rose BBC News

    That's all for Local Live today. I'll be back from 08:00 tomorrows bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London. Have a good evening.

    17:57: Evening bulletin BBC London News TV

    On the programme at 18:30 on BBC One: There are fears for a teenage girl who is believed to have travelled to Syria to join in the fight against Islamic State.

    And the residents facing a massive rent increase after their flats were sold off to a developer.

    17:51: Anyone for tennis?

    Mayor of London Boris Johnson joined some of world's best wheelchair tennis players outside City Hall earlier as they showed off their skills ahead of the forthcoming NEC Wheelchair Tennis Masters in Birmingham.

    Boris Johnson
    17:41: Frost and freezing fog

    This evening and tonight clear spells will lead to frost and patchy freezing fog forming. However it will probably tend to lift later in the night, as thicker cloud spreads from the south, giving a little rain in places.

    Minimum Temperature: -2C (28F).

    17:31: Mayoral candidate steps forward London Evening Standard Newspaper

    Entrepreneur Ivan Massow has launched a bid to stand as the Tory candidate for Mayor of London in 2016.

    Ivor Massow

    He told the Evening Standard his reputation as a "loose cannon" who was not afraid of putting "principle before party" would serve his campaign well.

    He said that, unlike Tory leader David Cameron and Mr Johnson, he was a "rags to riches boy" who left school at 16 and "didn't go to Oxford or Eton".

    17:21: Christmas is coming

    If you're looking forward to getting into the swing of December's festivities London 24 has compiled a list of London's best Christmas markets.

    Covent Garden
    17:12: Severe delays on M25 BBC London Travel

    There are severe delays of up to an hour on the M25 clockwise, with the inside lane closed between J16 M40 and J17 Maple Cross after a crane fire.

    And in Primrose Hill, Prince Albert Road is closed in both directions between B525 Avenue Road and Albert Terrace because of flooding. There is a diversion in place for bus route 274 via the A501 Marylebone Road, and A4201 Albany Street.

    17:00: News on the hour

    The lead story at 17:00 on BBC London 94.9: London Underground drivers on the Northern Line are to take part in a 24-hour strike next Monday over the dismissal of a worker.

    16:52: Tower of London viewing platform shatters

    A layer of glass on Tower Bridge's new viewing platform shattered on Friday evening when an empty beer bottle fell on to it, the attraction has confirmed.

    Visitors try out the new glass walkway at Tower Bridge

    In a statement, it said: "The floor was immediately inspected and covered to protect guests from glass splinters....Tower Bridge Exhibition's engineering team attended the site on Saturday morning and the sacrificial glass panel was replaced on Sunday morning.

    The Exhibition space remained open to the public as normal."

    The glass which smashed was one of four layers.

    16:39: Chelsea's John Neal dies

    Former Chelsea manager John Neal has died after a long career in football which took in Hull, Swindon, Aston Villa and Southampton as a player, as well as Wrexham, Middlesbrough and Chelsea as a manager.

    John Neal

    The London club released a statement which said: "Chelsea Football Club is deeply saddened by the passing of John Neal, one of the most significant and loved managers in our history."

    Appointed by Chelsea in 1981, Neal prevented the Blues from slipping into the Third Division and in 1984 guided them to the Second Division title. He died on Sunday aged 82.

    16:28: Hospital chief exec stands down

    The chief executive of Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, Tony Bell, has stepped down from his position.

    Mr Bell said: "I believe that this is the right time for me to hand over the reins as a new Trust Board establishes itself and reviews its priorities for the future."

    The reason for his departure has not yet been disclosed, but Mr Bell is set to start working at NHS England on national policy.

    16:19: Who, what and why Occupy? Lucy Townsend BBC News Magazine

    Activists from the Occupy movement held their latest campaign in London this weekend. The protest movement, now three years old, has global recognition.

    Occupy London camp outside St Paul's Cathedral, London 2012

    But how can its impact be measured?

    16:09: 'Oldest' hockey player at 84

    A former teacher from London has completed a full 70-minute game of hockey at the age of 84.

    Robert Adams

    Robert Adams played in West Derby Hockey Club's 4-1 win over Golborne on Saturday. He now has to wait for Guinness World Records to confirm his place in the history books where he would take over from the current holder - 83-year-old Roger Jones from New Zealand.

    16:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at 16:00 on BBC London 94.9: London Underground drivers on the Northern Line are to take part in a 24 hour strike next Monday over the dismissal of a worker.

    15:50: Crossrail tracks laid in London

    The first section of track to be used by Crossrail trains has been laid on a new bridge in west London with the Heathrow Express and Heathrow Connect services set to use it from next year.

    Crossrail engineers

    Crossrail services between Paddington and Heathrow are due to begin in 2018.

    15:41: Campaign to save floating bookshop

    A campaign has been launched to help save London's floating bookshop Word On The Water which has been trading on the River Thames for the last four years after it had its permanent mooring application on the Regent's Canal at Paddington turned down by the Canals and River Trust.

    Word on the Water barge

    The trust awarded the mooring to British Land which will open a coffee shop and information centre at the sire. A petition has been launched in support of the floating shop.

    @RobertElms 15:32: Listen again

    BBC London 94.9 presenter Robert Elms tweets: Thanks to @idriselba for being #ListedLondoner @bbclondon949. You can listen again after 4pm

    Robert Elms and Idris Elba
    15:20: Friends of 'teacher affair' girl told police

    Friends of a schoolgirl who had sex with a married teacher warned police about the illicit affair, but were told there was nothing they could do unless the girl herself report it, Inner London Crown Court heard.

    Stuart Kerner, 44, of Aylesford, Kent who was vice principal at the school denies having a secret relationship with the 15-year-old girl at Bexleyheath Academy in south-east London. He has been charged with six counts of sexual activity with a child by a person in a position of trust.

    15:09: The world's first loyalty card Will Smale Business reporter, BBC News, Soccerex, Rio

    From the kitchen of a Chiswick house to changing the way the nation shops, Edwina Dunn looks back on how she and her husband helped Tesco launch its Clubcard.

    Edwina Dunn
    15:00: News on the Hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top London story at 15:00 on BBC London 94.9: London Underground drivers on the Northern Line are to take part in a 24 hour strike next Monday over the dismissal of a worker

    14:58: Three guilty of axe killing
    • Kiro Halliburton, 18, from Tollgate Drive, Hayes, was found guilty of murder
    • Mahdi Osman, 18, from Hoskins Close, Hayes was found not guilty murder but guilty of manslaughter
    • Zakariya Subeir, 18, from Rockingham Road, Uxbridge, west London, was found not guilty murder but guilty manslaughter
    • A 17-year-old, who cannot be identified due to his age, was found not guilty of murder and not guilty of manslaughter
    14:53: Three guilty of axe killing

    After the attack Haliburton fled to Leeds, where he changed his appearance and Zakiriya Subeir travelled to Somalia but was arrested at Heathrow on his return.

    Another defendant Mahdi Osman also went to ground and was arrested five days later.

    14:47: Three guilty of axe murder

    The Old Bailey jury heard how handyman Paul Thrower became enraged when a group of youths who hung around outside the block in St.Dunstan's Close where he lived allegedly spat at his girlfriend, throwing a drink at her and calling her names.

    The victim confronted them on a balcony. Two of the youths barricaded themselves in the bin chute area, but Paul Thrower broke through a glass panel and climbed through the gap.

    Zakariya Subeir, 18, admitted striking Paul Thrower three times with an axe and Kiro Haliburton, 18, accepted stabbing the victim, but both denied murder claiming they acted in self-defence.

    14:38: Three guilty of axe killing

    Three teenagers have been found guilty of killing a man by attacking him with an axe and a knife after he confronted them for abusing his girlfriend.

    Paul Thrower, 46, was murdered in February in Hayes, west London.

    14:27: Youngest actress gets Bafta

    Nine-year-old Cherry Campbell who plays the title role in CBeebies show Katie Morag has become the youngest-ever winner at the Bafta Children's awards while Dick and Dom - Richard McCourt and Dominic Wood - won the presenter prize 10 years after first scooping it.

    Katie Morag

    This year's ceremony was hosted by Doc Brown at the Roundhouse in London last night.

    14:21: Afternoon weather

    The afternoon will remain dry and sunny with light winds. Top temperature will be 8C (46F).

    However, the Met Office has tweeted a yellow fog warning. It says the fog will creep in after dark and could reduce visibility down to less than 100m.

    14:06: Northern Line strike

    Nigel Holness, London Underground's Operations Director for the Jubilee, Northern and Piccadilly lines, said: "To ensure the safety of our customers we operate a zero tolerance policy towards alcohol at work.

    "Anyone found to be in breach of this policy faces a disciplinary process and possible dismissal."

    He added: "The RMT leadership has balloted its members whilst the appeal process is still in progress. This is in breach of its agreement with us to exhaust all processes, including ACAS, before balloting members in such cases. The result of the RMT leadership's ballot will not influence our decision and will achieve nothing. Any strike action by the RMT will simply lose its members pay."

    14:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at 14:00 on BBC London 94.9: London Underground drivers on the Northern Line are to take part in a 24 hour strike next Monday over the dismissal of a worker.

    13:50: Peruvian sunshine fails at premier

    Hollywood actress Nicole Kidman relied on a trusty umbrella when she attended the premier of Paddington in London yesterday after the bear's Peruvian sun failed to shine in the capital.

    Paddington premier
    13:39: Northern Line strike planned

    Drivers on the southern end of London Underground's Northern Line are to stage a 24-hour strike in a row over the dismissal of a worker on 1 December.

    Members of the RMT Union will walk out over the dismissal of an employee which it says was part of a "new culture of harassment and misuse of procedures".

    13:28: Bond Street station partially reopens

    Jubilee line customers heading to the West End can now get off at Bond Street station after works to connect the new ticket hall to the existing station infrastructure were completed ahead of schedule.

    London Underground sign

    Passengers can now exit or change lines at the station. The work is part of London Underground's £10bn programme of improvements which includes modernising and enlarging the station ahead of the arrival of Crossrail.

    13:19: Matisse expected to fetch £12m

    Sotheby's in London has put Henri Matisse's Odalisque Au Fauteuil Noir on display ahead of it being auctioned in February where it is expected to fetch up to £12m.

    Henri Matisse's Odalisque Au Fauteuil Noir

    The picture, completed in Nice in January 1942, shows one of his favourite subjects - Nezy-Hamide Chawkat, an exiled Turkish princess who was the great-granddaughter of the last sultan of Turkey and fled to France with her grandmother when the royal family lost power.

    13:09: Lunchtime bulletin BBC London News TV

    On the programme at 13:30 on BBC One: The family of a woman from south London who was jailed in Iran for watching a men's volleyball game say she's been freed on bail.

    And we meet this year's unsung hero of the capital's's sporting community - a judo teacher from Bexley and Sidcup.

    13:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at 13:00 on BBC London 94.9: NHS workers in London have returned to work after staging a four-hour strike in a dispute over pay.

    12:50: No further action for Lawrence suspect

    A sixth man held over the murder of black teenager Stephen Lawrence will not be prosecuted due to insufficient evidence the Crown Prosecution Service has confirmed.

    Stephen Lawrence

    The suspect arrested 11 months ago has never been named. Mr Lawrence, 18, was stabbed to death by a group of up to six white youths in an unprovoked racist attack in Eltham in 1993.

    @NetworkRailLBG 12:45: Southern Trains temporarily cancelled

    London Bridge's communication team tweets: Due to an operational incident under investigation there are no Southern trains until further notice. We are working hard to restore trains.

    12:40: Jutting ruled fit to stand trial

    British man Rurik Jutting, 29, charged with the murder of two women in Hong Kong has been ruled fit to stand trial by a judge.

    Rurik Jutting arrives at court in Hong Kong (24 Nov 2014)

    Sumarti Ningsih and Seneng Mujiasih who were domestic workers but working in the sex trade were found dead at his apartment on 1 November. Before moving to Hong Kong, Mr Jutting worked at Barclays in London for two years.

    12:29: Brit wins World Scrabble Championship

    A British man has won the final of the World Scrabble Championship in London with the word "talaq" which means a Muslim form of divorce.

    Craig Beevers (right) beat Chris Lipe from New York

    Craig Beevers, 33, from Guisborough, beat Chris Lipe, 34, from Clinton, New York, three games to one in the final at the Excel Centre.

    12:20: Mary J Blige's London love affair Michael Osborn Entertainment reporter, BBC News

    US soul singer Mary J Blige has worked with a host of young British musical talent to create her latest album The London Sessions.

    Mary J Blige

    Blige, who has nine Grammy awards and 20 years of experience to her name, has worked with the likes of dance duo Disclosure, Sam Smith and Emeli Sande to produce her latest opus in the UK.

    12:11: Have your say PM Beth Rose BBC News Online

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    12:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at midday on BBC London 94.9: NHS workers in London have returned to work after staging a four-hour strike in a dispute over pay.

    11:50: GP conflict of interest concern

    A "large number" of GPs on Haringey's Clinical Commissioning Group, which decides who to buy services from, also have "shareholdings in the organisation that provides out-of-hours care" raising a possible conflict of interest, according to the Tottenham, and Wood Green Journal.

    11:40: Tottenham beat 10-man Hull

    Tottenham came from behind to beat 10-man Hull 1-2 to leave the Tigers with only one win in 11 Premier League matches.

    Harry Kane
    11:30: Have your say Beth Rose BBC News Online

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    11:20: Google case settled

    The case of a London businessman who wanted Google to stop malicious web postings about him appearing in its search results has been settled.

    Daniel Hegglin said he had been wrongly called a murderer, a paedophile and a Ku Klux Klan sympathiser during a malicious online campaign against him. Google has asked him to provide a list of web links to be removed.

    11:10: Where did the poppies go?

    Members of the public who purchased Tower of London poppies have started to receive them in the post after a team of volunteers have been removing about 75,000 of the ceramic flowers each day since 12 November.

    Beatrice Gardner

    Find out where some of them have been sent.

    10:55: News on the hour

    The lead story at 11:00 on BBC London 94.9: Health workers across London are returning to work now after a four-hour strike over pay.

    @HeathrowExpress 10:44: Heathrow Express delayed

    The Heathrow Express team tweets: Due to another operators broken-down train, Heathrow Express services are currently delayed - Sorry for the inconvenience.

    10:30: Girl's campaign gets secret donor

    An anonymous donor has pledged £2,000 towards helping the family of a young girl buy an accessible car so she can return home from hospital after spending a year on a children's ward, the Croydon Advertiser.

    @RabbiJeremy 10:21: London sky-lines

    Sunrise in @WHampstead streaky!

    West Hampstead sky line
    @BBCTomEdwards 10:16: No trains from London Bridge

    BBC London's transport correspondent tweets: Big changes to services one month away at London Bridge

    Rail changes
    10:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at 11:00 on BBC London 94.9: Patients at NHS hospitals across London are facing disruption this morning because of a four hour strike over pay.

    @MPSMerton 0948: NHS strike in London

    Scotland Yard officers in Merton tweet: Approximately 170 police officers driving and staffing up ambulances across London today and responding to calls due to NHS strike

    09:38: London sky-lines

    Tower RNLI took this picture of their view of the city this morning.


    If you have a great view of London you can email it to

    @victorialine 09:28: 'Severe' Tube delays NEXT PLS

    Transport for London's Victoria Line team tweet: There are severe delays due to an earlier faulty train.

    While commuter Nicola Heath tweeted this picture: Avoid Victoria at all costs this morning! @BBCTravelAlert

    Victoria station
    09:19: Banker sues Google

    A former London banker is suing Google in the High Court in an attempt to prevent what he calls "vile and abusive" material about him repeatedly appearing in search results.

    Daniel Hegglin's claim has been described by lawyers as "a test case with enormous consequences". It is believed to be the first trial in England against Google by a claimant relying on the "right to be forgotten" rule.

    09:10: Firearms amnesty ends

    London's first firearms amnesty in six years has ended with at least 240 weapons and more than 8,000 rounds of ammunition handed in to Scotland Yard.

    Selection of guns

    It was hoped the two week amnesty would help take guns off the streets to stop them falling into the wrong hands.

    09:00: News on the hour

    The lead story at 09:00 on BBC London 94.9: Nurses, midwives and London paramedics are among thousands of NHS workers who've walked out for four hours this morning over pay.

    Do you support NHS strike action? 08:50: On air BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Vanessa Feltz will be be talking about NHS workers going on a four-hour strike this morning over pay. Do you support the strikers and will the action affect you?

    You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

    08:42: Bakerloo Line Suspended BBC London Travel

    Services have been suspended on the Bakerloo Line between Queens Park and Harrow And Wealdstone and there are minor delays on the rest of the line due to flooding at Harlesden.

    For the latest travel news go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel.

    08:32: First Crossrail tracks being laid

    The first section of track to be used by Crossrail trains has been laid on a new bridge in west London.

    Tracks being laid at Stockley

    The 120 metre long Stockley Flyover will be used by Heathrow Express and Heathrow Connect services from next year and is the largest single span bridge to have been installed anywhere on the Great Western railway since the days of Brunel.

    08:23: Counter terrorism awareness operation launches

    The Metropolitan Police is joining officers from across the country to take part in national Counter Terrorism Awareness Week, launching in London today.

    Policing activity involving over 3,000 officers includes briefing thousands of businesses - shopping centres, cinemas, sports stadiums - to help them step up their security and train their staff at venues across London.

    08:12: Rail and road delays BBC London Travel

    Flooding in the Harlesden area yesterday has caused a signal failure: London Overground have severe delays between Euston to Watford and the Bakerloo Line has severe delays Queen's Park to Harrow & Wealdstone.

    On the roads in Primrose Hill, Prince Albert Road remains closed past London Zoo after floods yesterday. Bus route 274 is on diversion.

    For the latest travel news go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel.

    08:04: A cold start to Monday

    There will be a cold start to the day with a slight frost in places but early patchy fog will slowly clear.

    The weather forecast

    The day will be dry and predominantly sunny, with light winds.

    The top temperature will be around 8C (46F).

    08:00: Good Morning Beth Rose BBC News

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather from across the capital today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to or Tweet @BBCLondonNews.



Elsewhere on the BBC


  • Ebola patients in Sierra LeoneHARDtalk Watch

    Dr Geraldine O'Hara recalls the horrors of working on the Ebola frontline in Sierra Leone

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.