Mark Duggan inquest: Why killing was deemed lawful

Mark Duggan Mark Duggan was shot by police in north London in 2011

The jury at the inquest into the death of Mark Duggan has concluded by a majority of eight to two that he was lawfully killed by police. The inquest raised important questions about the way the police carry out firearms operations on the streets of Britain.

Mark Duggan may have been a gangster in possession of a gun, but that alone would not have made his killing by police lawful.

The law and police guidelines say that an officer can only shoot someone if absolutely necessary, and they honestly believe that person was an imminent threat.

Police witnesses say Mr Duggan was such a threat when they killed him. The officer who shot him, V53, and another officer, W70, standing alongside the first, said that when Mr Duggan got out of the cab he reached toward the waistband of his trousers and pulled out a gun.

A third officer standing behind Mr Duggan said he shouted "he's reaching, he's reaching". After V53 fired a first time, he said he "reassessed", Mr Duggan still had the gun, and he shot him again.

However, the inquest had other evidence to consider. The account above was given by police officers. The inquest heard from only one civilian witness to the shooting itself and he gave a very different account.

"Witness B" said he was watching through the open window of a ninth floor flat on the other side of the road. He described what he saw as "an execution".

Gun disappeared

Mr Duggan was not holding a gun, he said, but a mobile phone. He said Mr Duggan tried at first to run away, but was "trapped", appeared "baffled" and was holding his arms up as if to surrender when he was shot by an officer within five to seven steps of him. But Witness B's evidence was not enough to convince the jury.

Pamela and Mark Duggan Mark was described by his mother as shy when he was younger

The inquest was shown police briefings which said Mr Duggan was a senior member of a gang called Tottenham Man Dem, he had previously been arrested on suspicion of attempted murder and possession of guns, and on the day that he was shot he was being followed by police.

They believed he had collected a gun from another man, Kevin Hutchinson-Foster, and the inquest was told that the aim of the operation was to take that gun off the streets.

As soon as Mr Duggan was shot by police the gun apparently disappeared. One officer at the scene said that even as he fell to the ground, and the officer grabbed his arms, the gun was nowhere to be seen.

Nobody said they saw him throw it, either before or after. Officers said they later found the gun, wrapped in a black sock, some 20ft (6m) away on the other side of some railings.

An independent pathologist said that because of Mr Duggan's injuries it was "very unlikely" - but not impossible - that he would have been able to throw the gun such a distance after he had been shot.

During his summing up, the coroner told the jury the conviction of Hutchinson-Foster for supplying the gun was "not determinative" of Mr Duggan having a gun in the minicab, but it was "very strong evidence".

Lawyers for the Duggan family suggested police had "planted" the gun on the grass after the shooting. That was vehemently denied by the police.

In their findings, the inquest jury decided that the police were right to choose the location they used for the "hard stop" - and they decided by a majority of nine to one that Mark Duggan had thrown the gun way from his minicab before he faced police. They concluded by a majority of eight to two that Duggan was lawfully killed.

Crime scene

The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) was also scrutinised during the inquest. Because of a lack of resources, the IPCC lead investigator - a former police officer of 30 years' experience - explained that the organisation was reliant on police officers to secure the crime scene.

Jurors visit the scene of the shooting Jurors have visited the scene of the shooting

He admitted he had not known "for some days" that the gun was found 20ft from the shooting and had not been present when the police officers sat in a room together to compose their witness statements.

In the hours that followed the shooting the IPCC was also responsible for making public the most incendiary claim of all - an entirely incorrect suggestion that Mr Duggan had himself fired at police officers.

The IPCC has yet to publish its long-awaited report into the Duggan shooting, but has apologised to his family.

By the time relatives and friends of Mr Duggan arrived to protest at Tottenham police station 48 hours after the shooting, they were angry and suspicious.

They had not been properly notified of Mr Duggan's killing, and had heard conflicting accounts of what had happened. The riots began that night.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 12 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Good evening 18:00:

    That's all for the BBC London live page for today. We will be back with more news, travel, sport and weather updates on Tuesday from 08:00.

     
  2.  
    Coming up 17:58: BBC London News TV

    On BBC London News at 18:30 on BBC One: Ford announces 300 new jobs at Dagenham, the African community in London responds to Ebola and Londoners seek refuge in Wales away from their electronic devices.

     
  3.  
    Rain overnight 17:48:

    The evening will be dry and largely clear at first, before windy conditions with cloud and outbreaks of locally heavy rain spread east across the area after midnight.

    Weather

    The maximum temperature will be 16C (61F).

     
  4.  
    Coping with effects of Ebola 17:39: BBC London News TV

    Sonja Jessup visited PowerXtra Radio, in south-east London, for her report at 18:30 on how the African community in London is coping with the effects of Ebola in their home continent.

    PowerXtra Radio
     
  5.  
    Tube disruption 17:28: Fiona McKinnon BBC London Travel

    Trains are not stopping at Latimer Road on the Circle Line and Hammersmith and City Line eastbound because of engineering works.

     
  6.  
    Rizzle Kicks relive schooldays 17:17: BBC News School Report

    Rizzle Kicks duo Harvey and Jordan relived their school days when they met at the Teen Awards at Wembley.

    Rizzle Kicks duo

    The singers revealed they had not forgotten how to dress smartly as they donned the school's colours.

     
  7.  
    On air 17:08: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On Drivetime - The head of the National Crime Agency, Keith Bristow, says some paedophiles who've downloaded images of child abuse will not face prosecution because police will have to focus on the worst offenders.

    Call 020 7224 2000 to have your say.

     
  8.  
    News on the hour 17:00: Will Shindler BBC London 94.9

    The headlines this hour include:

    • A man accused of decapitating his wife in their west London home has denied killing her
    • Police in south London investigating a violent break-in in Carshalton at the weekend, have told BBC London 94.9 they believe the victims were deliberately targeted
    • Screening for Ebola will begin at Gatwick's north terminal tomorrow and then at the south terminal on Wednesday
     
  9.  
    Travel delays 16:40:

    There are delays and cancellations on Chiltern rail services between London Marylebone, Banbury and Aylesbury after an incident at Sudbury and Harrow Road station.

    Southeastern train services are revised between Dartford and Victoria owing to repair works at Lewisham.

    On the roads the serious collision involving a bus this morning has left the A1081 St Albans Road in South Mimms closed in both directions between Trotters Bottom and the M25 J23 junction.

    For the latest news go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel

     
  10.  
    Underground WW1 centenary 16:27:

    Over 3,000 poems are visible on Tube and over ground trains and stations as the London Underground commemorates the centenary of World War One.

    The General The General by Siegfried Sassoon

    Travellers can also acquire one of the 90,000 copies of the free booklet, War Poems on the Underground, 1914-1918.

     
  11.  
    Have Your Say 16:16:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to know what you think.

     
  12.  
    Cafe fire 16:05:

    Around 20 firefighters are tackling a fire at a café on Stockwell Road. The fire is affecting the basement and the ground floor says London Fire Brigade.

    Fire fighters outside the cafe.
     
  13.  
    News on the hour 16:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The headlines this hour include:

    • A man accused of decapitating his wife in their west London home has denied killing her.
    • A woman has died after being stuck in the back of an ambulance when the tail lift broke outside a north London accident and emergency department.
    • A cyclist has died three days after a collision involving a lorry in the City of London.
     
  14.  
    Watch: Cutty Sark fire 15:50:

    The Cutty Sark avoided major damage when a fire broke out on board over the weekend, London Fire Brigade says. Watch Tarah Welsh's report.

    Cutty Sark
     
  15.  
    'Big changes' to rail services 15:40:

    Train operator Southeastern's new managing director tells This is Local London about the "big changes" to services in south-east London and north Kent.

    London Bridge Station

    David Statham talks about the Thameslink Programme, services out of London Bridge and more.

     
  16.  
    Cyclist death 15:29: Tom Edwards Transport correspondent, London

    Following news of a 26-year-old cyclist dying, there have been 11 cycling deaths in London so far this year, five involving HGVs - one didn't involve a collision with any vehicle.

     
  17.  
    'Spies’ in Starbucks 15:20: The Daily Telegraph

    A pregnant Sudanese woman who met a friend for coffee and cake in a Shepherd's Bush Starbucks was confronted with pictures of the encounter and detained for five days by Sudanese officials at Khartoum airport.

     
  18.  
    Ford's £190m Dagenham investment 15:10:

    Ford has announced a £190m investment in the production of new low-carbon diesel engines at its Dagenham plant.

    The company said the money, which includes £8.9m from the Government's' Regional Growth Fund, will create more than 300 jobs.

     
  19.  
    News on the hour 15:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The bulletin includes:

    Police in South London investigating a violent break-in at an address in Carshalton at the weekend, say they believe the victims were deliberately targeted.

    Landscape gardener Eliot Smith was pistol whipped and knifed in the hand, before being bound up alongside his wife Izabela, during an aggravated burglary at their home in Stanley Park Road.

     
  20.  
    Bus overturns 14:46:

    A 41-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of causing serious injury after a double decker bus overturned on the A1081 St Albans Road between South Mimms and Barnet.

    Police examine the overturned bus

    Forty-five people were injured after the bus collided with a car at about 08:25 BST today.

     
  21.  
    Council cuts 14:34:

    This Is London Local reports that "no service is safe" as Merton Council announces £32 million of cuts.

    Adult education is "staring down the barrel of a gun" - according to the website - and everything from language classes to pottery courses could be axed. But the council has warned that none of its services are safe.

     
  22.  
    Lunchtime news query 14:16: Josephine McDermott BBC News Online

    Chiswick Scottish tweets: What tartan is the lovely tie that Asad is wearing today, lunch news?

    Asad Ahmad

    I will endeavour to find out.

     
  23.  
    News on the hour 14:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The bulletin includes:

    • Warm tributes have been paid to the actress Lynda Bellingham, who has died from cancer at the age of 66.
    • Police in south London investigating a violent break-in at an address in Carshalton at the weekend, say they believe the victims were deliberately targeted.
    • A man accused of decapitating his wife in their west London home has denied killing her.
     
  24.  
    Watch: Smartphone retreat 13:55: via Facebook

    Watch Gareth Furby's report on the Londoners going to extreme lengths to give up their smartphones and tablets.

     
  25.  
    Phil Collins drum shop to shut 13:44:

    The Evening Standard reports the music shop in Twickenham where Phil Collins bought his first drum kit is to close.

     
  26.  
    On this day 13:35:

    In 1632, architect Sir Christopher Wren, whose work includes St Paul's Cathedral and the Royal Hospital Chelsea (pictured), was born in East Knoyle, Wiltshire.

    Royal Hospital Chelsea
     
  27.  
    Coming up 13:25: BBC London News TV

    Car manufacturer Ford has announced a £190m investment in its plant in Dagenham.

    The money will will see the plant turn out up to half a million new low-carbon diesel engines a year and create more than 300 jobs. Karl Mercer has more at 13:30.

     
  28.  
    Cyclist dies 13:16: Tom Edwards Transport correspondent, London

    A cyclist in her 30s who collided with an HGV on Friday at Ludgate Hill has died.

     
  29.  
    Have your say 13:08:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  30.  
    BBC London News 12:50: Asad Ahmad Presenter, BBC London

    Join me at 13:30 on BBC One, when we speak to members of London's west African community who fear losing relatives to Ebola.

    Londoners on retreat

    We also travel with a group of Londoners trying to wean themselves off smart phones and computer tablets by going on retreat to Wales.

     
  31.  
    Bus overturns 12:39:

    About 35 people were injured this morning when a double decker bus overturned on the A1081 St Albans Road between South Mimms and Barnet.

    Overturned bus on St Albans Road

    The East of England Ambulance Service said no-one was thought to be critically injured.

     
  32.  
    #askboris 12:29:

    Mayor Boris Johnson has taken part in a public Twitter question session this morning. As part of #askboris Jon-Pol Freixes asked: Will any more skyscrapers be built around Canary Wharf or elsewhere in London?

    He replied: There will be more tall buildings - but we want them to be lived in by Londoners...and to look great.

     
  33.  
    Weather 12:19:

    Largely cloudy and remaining dry this afternoon. Sunset at 17:57.

    Weather
     
  34.  
    Man denies decapitation 12:13:

    A man who allegedly decapitated his wife has pleaded not guilty to murder. Naveed Ahmed, 41, is accused of killing mother-of-two Tahira Ahmed, 38, at their home in Merton Avenue in Northolt, west London, on 27 May.

     
  35.  
    News on the hour 11:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The news bulletin this hour includes:

    • The actor Christopher Timothy - who starred with Lynda Bellingham in All Creatures Great and Small - has joined others to pay tribute to the actress and presenter who has died from cancer aged 66.
    • Kensington Palace says the Duchess of Cambridge's baby is due in April.
     
  36.  
    Warehouse fire 11:52:

    Here's a picture from Bow taken earlier by the London Ambulance Service cycle response team.

    Warehouse fire
     
  37.  
    Warehouse fire 11:43:

    London Fire Brigade tweets: Fire fighters have now got the warehouse blaze on Monier Road in #Bow under control. Crews will remain at the scene to damp down the fire.

     
  38.  
    Leinster beat Wasps 11:32: BBC Sport

    In the European Rugby Champions Cup, Leinster hit back to overcome a nine point deficit to beat London Wasps 25-20 yesterday in Dublin. The three-time champions were 20-11 down at the break.

    Leinster vs Wasps
     
  39.  
    Gay kiss bus investigation 11:19:

    Transport for London has begun an investigation after a gay couple reported being thrown off a number 89 bus near Blackheath for kissing, the Evening Standard reports. Jack James, 23, said he and his partner were subjected to a volley of abuse from the driver.

     
  40.  
    Royal Baby 11:09:

    The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge's next child is due in April, Kensington Palace has said.

    The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge and Prince George

    A statement said Catherine continues to be affected by Hyperemisis Gravidarum, but her condition is steadily improving.

     
  41.  
    News on the hour 11:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The news bulletin this hour includes:

    • A London woman, whose son went to Syria to join a group linked to Islamic State militants, has expressed concern at the level of support given to young British Muslims who go to fight abroad and then realise they've made a terrible mistake.
    • Kensington Palace says the Duchess of Cambridge's second baby is due in April.
     
  42.  
    Free school cost revealed 10:56: The Independent

    reports more than £1m of taxpayers' money has been spent on proposals for free schools that never opened, including Hartsbrook free school in north London.

     
  43.  
    Coming up 10:46: BBC London News TV

    Over the weekend, demonstrators congregated in Parliament Square. Alex Bushill will be bringing an update in the 13:30 BBC London News.

    Parliament Square
     
  44.  
    Fire alarm disrupts show 10:35:

    TV host Lorraine Kelly apologised to viewers this morning after her ITV show was pulled off air as a result of a fire alarm, Press Association reports.

    She and staff on the show had to file out of the studio at London's South Bank and the final few moments of the live edition of her Lorraine programme had to be replaced.

     
  45.  
    Lynda Bellingham remembered 10:20:

    Actress Lynda Bellingham, whose death at a London hospital was announced earlier, trained at London's Central School of Speech and Drama. On stage, she appeared at the Old Vic and the Royal Court and in the West End production of Calendar Girls.

    Lynda Bellingham starring in an Oxo advert

    Read her obituary here.

     
  46.  
    Engineering work 10:16:

    Trains are not stopping on the Bakerloo Line or Northern Line at Embankment, or on the Circle Line and Hammersmith And City Line Eastbound at Latimer Road, because of engineering works.

    For the latest travel news go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel.

     
  47.  
    News on the hour 10:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The headlines this hour include:

    • The head of palliative care at Public Health England has praised the actress Lynda Bellingham for speaking out about her terminal cancer in the run up to her death yesterday at the age of 66.
    • More needs to be done to support young Muslims who travel to Syria or Iraq but then realise they've made a mistake, according to a mother from London who travelled to Turkey to bring her son home.
     
  48.  
    Taarabt weight debate 09:52: BBC Sport

    Adel Taarabt is three stone overweight and unfit to play for Queens Park Rangers, claims manager Harry Redknapp.

    The Moroccan midfielder has not started for QPR since 27 August.

     
  49.  
    Diwali pictures 09:41: Josephine McDermott BBC News Online

    Sanjay Khetani tweeted us this picture of Willesden Temple, ready for the start of Diwali, or the "festival of lights" on Thursday.

    Willesden Temple

    Send us your pictures.

     
  50.  
    Warehouse fire 09:31:

    Thirty-five fire fighters are at a warehouse fire in Monier Road, Bow, says London Fire Brigade.

     
  51.  
    Angel fire alert 09:21:

    Northern line tweets: Angel station is currently closed while we respond to a fire alert.

     
  52.  
    Watch: Weather 09:11:

    Here's Kate Kinsella with today's forecast.

    Kate Kinsella
     
  53.  
    News on the hour 09:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Richard Main has the BBC London 94.9 headlines at 09:00 including:

    • The actress and presenter, Lynda Bellingham, who had been suffering from cancer, has died at the age of 66.
    • London's leading housing associations are joining forces with the Mayor this week to launch a campaign to get more Londoners on the housing ladder through shared ownership.
     
  54.  
    Cutty Sark damaged in fire 08:52:

    Famous 19th Century ship Cutty Sark was damaged in a fire in Greenwich yesterday.

    London Fire Officers attend Cutty Sark A small section of the hull on deck three was damaged in the latest fire

    A small part of deck three and the hull timbers were damaged, however firefighters managed to contain the blaze, London Fire Brigade said.

     
  55.  
    As it happened
     
  56.  
    Coming up 08:43: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    With Vanessa from 09:00, people who post abusive or threatening comments online are to face tougher sentences. The Justice Secretary, Chris Grayling, has said internet trolls could face up to two years in prison. What do you think? Call 020 7224 2000.

     
  57.  
    London mother on Syria 08:35:

    A mother from north London whose son joined a militant group linked to IS in Syria has described how she travelled to Turkey and managed to persuade him to return home.

    London mother
     
  58.  
    Brad Pitt's Fury closes festival 08:23:

    Brad Pitt said he hoped his new film Fury recognised the trauma suffered by soldiers in World War Two as it closed this year's BFI London Film Festival last night.

    Brad Pitt on the red carpet with war veteran Peter Comfort Brad Pitt on the red carpet with war veteran Peter Comfort

    "War is hell," said Pitt, who plays a Sherman tank commander on a mission behind enemy lines in 1945.

     
  59.  
    Road reopens 08:15: Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    The A406 at Bounds Green has reopened following a burst water main yesterday.

    For the latest travel news go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel.

     
  60.  
    Train delays 08:06: Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    There are delays to Southeastern services from Charlton via Greenwich to London Bridge.

    For the latest travel news go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel.

     
  61.  
    Sunny intervals 08:02:

    It will be largely cloudy, with only limited bright or sunny intervals throughout the day.

    There will be some isolated showers, however most places will remain dry, but will become more breezy into the evening. Maximum temperature: 15C (59F).

     
  62.  
    Good morning 08:00: Josephine McDermott BBC News Online

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather from across the capital today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or Tweet @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • MoviesMovie magic

    Tech that reads your desires is helping to increase your odds of producing a hit film, says BBC Future

Programmes

  • Ade Adepitan at the ColosseumThe Travel Show Watch

    The challenge of providing disabled access at Europe’s leading ancient monuments

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.