Mark Duggan inquest: Why killing was deemed lawful

Mark Duggan Mark Duggan was shot by police in north London in 2011

The jury at the inquest into the death of Mark Duggan has concluded by a majority of eight to two that he was lawfully killed by police. The inquest raised important questions about the way the police carry out firearms operations on the streets of Britain.

Mark Duggan may have been a gangster in possession of a gun, but that alone would not have made his killing by police lawful.

The law and police guidelines say that an officer can only shoot someone if absolutely necessary, and they honestly believe that person was an imminent threat.

Police witnesses say Mr Duggan was such a threat when they killed him. The officer who shot him, V53, and another officer, W70, standing alongside the first, said that when Mr Duggan got out of the cab he reached toward the waistband of his trousers and pulled out a gun.

A third officer standing behind Mr Duggan said he shouted "he's reaching, he's reaching". After V53 fired a first time, he said he "reassessed", Mr Duggan still had the gun, and he shot him again.

However, the inquest had other evidence to consider. The account above was given by police officers. The inquest heard from only one civilian witness to the shooting itself and he gave a very different account.

"Witness B" said he was watching through the open window of a ninth floor flat on the other side of the road. He described what he saw as "an execution".

Gun disappeared

Mr Duggan was not holding a gun, he said, but a mobile phone. He said Mr Duggan tried at first to run away, but was "trapped", appeared "baffled" and was holding his arms up as if to surrender when he was shot by an officer within five to seven steps of him. But Witness B's evidence was not enough to convince the jury.

Pamela and Mark Duggan Mark was described by his mother as shy when he was younger

The inquest was shown police briefings which said Mr Duggan was a senior member of a gang called Tottenham Man Dem, he had previously been arrested on suspicion of attempted murder and possession of guns, and on the day that he was shot he was being followed by police.

They believed he had collected a gun from another man, Kevin Hutchinson-Foster, and the inquest was told that the aim of the operation was to take that gun off the streets.

As soon as Mr Duggan was shot by police the gun apparently disappeared. One officer at the scene said that even as he fell to the ground, and the officer grabbed his arms, the gun was nowhere to be seen.

Nobody said they saw him throw it, either before or after. Officers said they later found the gun, wrapped in a black sock, some 20ft (6m) away on the other side of some railings.

An independent pathologist said that because of Mr Duggan's injuries it was "very unlikely" - but not impossible - that he would have been able to throw the gun such a distance after he had been shot.

During his summing up, the coroner told the jury the conviction of Hutchinson-Foster for supplying the gun was "not determinative" of Mr Duggan having a gun in the minicab, but it was "very strong evidence".

Lawyers for the Duggan family suggested police had "planted" the gun on the grass after the shooting. That was vehemently denied by the police.

In their findings, the inquest jury decided that the police were right to choose the location they used for the "hard stop" - and they decided by a majority of nine to one that Mark Duggan had thrown the gun way from his minicab before he faced police. They concluded by a majority of eight to two that Duggan was lawfully killed.

Crime scene

The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) was also scrutinised during the inquest. Because of a lack of resources, the IPCC lead investigator - a former police officer of 30 years' experience - explained that the organisation was reliant on police officers to secure the crime scene.

Jurors visit the scene of the shooting Jurors have visited the scene of the shooting

He admitted he had not known "for some days" that the gun was found 20ft from the shooting and had not been present when the police officers sat in a room together to compose their witness statements.

In the hours that followed the shooting the IPCC was also responsible for making public the most incendiary claim of all - an entirely incorrect suggestion that Mr Duggan had himself fired at police officers.

The IPCC has yet to publish its long-awaited report into the Duggan shooting, but has apologised to his family.

By the time relatives and friends of Mr Duggan arrived to protest at Tottenham police station 48 hours after the shooting, they were angry and suspicious.

They had not been properly notified of Mr Duggan's killing, and had heard conflicting accounts of what had happened. The riots began that night.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

22 °C 14 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    News on the hour 09:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    A book of condolence has opened at Ealing Town Hall for people to leave messages for the family of Alice Gross.

    Ealing Council leader Julian Bell tells the 1000 bulletin that the community is "united in grief".

     
  2.  
    Step free Tube investment 09:46:

    Transport for London is to spend £75m on making the Tube more accessible for disabled people, including installing more lifts.

    The lifts will be added to 12 Tube stations over the next decade. It follows an announcement that all 30 Crossrail stations in the capital will be step-free.

     
  3.  
    HK protest in London 09:34:

    Demonstrators gathered outside the Chinese embassy in London last night to support pro-democracy protesters in Hong Kong.

    Hong Kong protest in London Organisers said thousands had gathered in London

    Organisers of the London protest said 3,000 people had gathered to show people in Hong Kong "they are not alone".

     
  4.  
    Alice Gross 09:26:

    The leader of Ealing Council, Julian Bell, has told BBC London 94.9 the flag above the town hall is flying at half mast today as a mark of respect for Alice Gross.

    The council's also opened a book of condolence for people who want to leave a message for Alice's family.

     
  5.  
    Alice Gross tributes 09:17:

    BBC London 94.9 reporter Richard Main tweets: Hanwell clock tower is starting to fill up with tributes to Alice Gross this morning #AliceGross

    Hanwell
     
  6.  
    On air 09:11: Vanessa Feltz Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    On today's show: David Cameron has pledged to cut tax for 30m people if he won the next election. Is this a welcome idea or with council services already stretched would you be worried by possible funding cuts?

    What do you think? Call 020 7224 2000 to let us know.

     
  7.  
    Alice's parents 'devastated' 08:59:

    Alice's parents Jose Gross and Rosalind Hodgkiss say they have been "left completely devastated" and thanked the local community for its help in the search.

    Jose Gross and Rosalind Hodgkiss

    "It is difficult to comprehend that our sweet and beautiful daughter was the victim of a terrible crime."

    They added: "Alice was a loving and much loved daughter and sister, a quirky live spark of a girl, beautiful inside and out."

     
  8.  
    News on the hour 08:56: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the bulletin at 0900: Reporter Richard Main is in Hanwell with reaction from the community following the confirmation that a body discovered in the River Brent is Alice Gross.

     
  9.  
    Fulham thrash Bolton 08:47:

    Fulham thrashed fellow strugglers Bolton 4-0 for their third successive win under caretaker manager Kit Symons.

     
  10.  
    M25 delays 08:39:

    The M25 clockwise is blocked between J15 M4 and J16 M40 following a collision.

    For the latest disruption information go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel.

     
  11.  
    Top headlines
     
  12.  
    Alice post-mortem exam to resume 08:31:

    A post-mortem examination on the body of murdered schoolgirl Alice Gross will resume later.

    Alice Gross

    Police confirmed the body found in a west London river on Tuesday evening was that of the missing 14-year-old.

     
  13.  
    Revised Southeastern services 08:23:

    There is a revised Southeastern rail service between Dartford and Victoria until the end of October because of unplanned works at Lewisham.

    For the latest disruption information go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel.

     
  14.  
    Foggy start, warm later 08:14:

    Any mist or fog will clear through the morning to leave a fine day with bright or sunny spells. A few showers may develop during the afternoon but most parts should stay dry.

    The light winds and sunshine will make today feel warm with temperatures reaching 22C (72F).

     
  15.  
    08:00: Rebecca Cafe BBC News

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or Tweet @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • SailingGame on

    BBC Capital discovers why certain sports seem to have a special appeal for those with deep pockets

Programmes

  • European Union's anti-terrorism chief Gilles de KerchoveHARDtalk Watch

    Anti-terrorism chief Gilles de Kerchove on the threat from returning Islamic State fighters

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.