PC Blakelock murder trial: Why did the latest case fail?

Related Stories

Another trial has ended with no-one convicted over the brutal murder of PC Keith Blakelock in the Broadwater Farm riots in north London almost 30 years ago.

So why did the latest attempt fail?

PC Keith Blakelock PC Keith Blakelock was murdered as he tried to protect firefighters

The family of PC Keith Blakelock have been trying to seek justice which has eluded them since 6 October 1985 when he was so savagely cut down in Tottenham.

Beaten back by young men wielding an array of weapons, PC Blakelock fell and was attacked and sustained multiple injuries which proved fatal. He was stabbed 43 times.

The riots were an unmitigated policing disaster. They failed to act on intelligence, conduct inquiries within the rules, deploy officers appropriately, protect their own officers from serious harm and to secure the crime scene.

They were also an unmitigated catastrophe for the residents of Tottenham. It led to the stigmatising of more than 300 families as their young men were sent to custody or acquired criminal records for their part in the riots.

It is this that has meant to this day the community remains traumatised and is still desperately seeking to overcome the mark that hangs over this part of north London.

'Inconsistent' witness

The trial has been a long and arduous one for all involved. In the absence of any forensic evidence against 45-year-old Nicky Jacobs, a successful prosecution was always going to be a challenge.

Firstly it was not broadly fresh evidence. Two anonymous witnesses using the pseudonyms of "John Brown" and "Rhodes Levin" had previously not been seen as credible witnesses to mount a successful prosecution.

Both men were adults when they themselves were involved in the attack on PC Blakelock, while Mr Jacobs was a juvenile.

Man being arrested by officers during the riot The police carried out mass arrests after the riots

During the second investigation into the murder that concluded in 1994, these men were offered immunity from prosecution on the grounds they admitted kicking PC Blakelock whereas they claimed Mr Jacobs had stabbed him.

A third witness, a cousin of Mr Brown and known as "Q", was identified in 2009. He came to the Old Bailey and spun a yarn of what he saw which at times was fantastical.

He suggested he had seen two Rolls Royces on the estate the day before the riots - one silver and one gold - where black men had passed what looked like sawn-off shotguns from one Rolls to the other.

But he placed the murder scene on another part of the estate. His testimony sometimes mirrored that of his relative, although bizarrely he denied Mr Brown was his cousin.

Nicholas Jacobs The prosecution said Nicholas Jacobs had stabbed PC Blakelock as he was on the ground

Q was often incoherent and had serious lapses of memory. He has a long history of alcohol and drug abuse, which at times, listening to his evidence seemed to have impaired his rational bearing. He was a man who sounded like someone 20 years older or one who is seriously ill.

Police investigations

  • The first one was held after the murder where three men were found guilty
  • Their convictions were quashed by the Court of Appeal in 1991
  • In 1992-93, a second investigation was launched, but police struggled to get witness accounts because people did not want to make themselves liable to prosecution
  • The police and CPS decided to pursue those who they believed had weapons as suspects and regard unarmed attackers who punched and kicked as witnesses
  • The case was reopened in 2000 following a review of unsolved murders

His certainty on one fact alone, that Mr Jacobs was guilty, defied the uncertainty and inconsistency on a whole raft of other facts.

He was also evidentially inconsistent with other key witnesses to the crime, in particular the police officers.

A very inconsistent fresh witness he turned out to be.

The fourth strand of evidence was a poem written by Mr Jacobs in 1988 while he was serving a sentence for affray arising out of the riots.

In it he appeared to admit his involvement in the crime but perhaps this was too ambiguous. It could have been the rantings of a mixed-up deluded young man who had clearly chosen the wrong path in life. An attempt at boasting, making himself bigger than he was perhaps?

The final evidence presented by the prosecution was a brief exchange of words with an arresting officer when Mr Jacobs was suspected of being involved in a burglary in 2000.

He was alleged to have said "you don't want to mess with me I did Keith Blakelock". Nevertheless, the officer failed to report this conversation to a senior officer at the time and only provided a statement 12 years after the event. Was this too inconclusive for the jury perhaps?

Broadwater Farm Estate He was killed during a riot on the Broadwater Farm Estate
PC Blakelock's widow Elizabeth, with her sons (left to right) Lee, Kevin and Mark His family have had to go through numerous trials and hearings but as yet no-one is in jail for his murder

Listening to the evidence there was always a strong possibility that there would be some reasonable doubt with all or some of these evidential strands.

I suspect little or any of this will assuage or bring comfort to PC Blakelock's widow Elizabeth or his three sons Mark, Kevin and Lee.

The harsh reality is people will only be convicted on sound evidence and this jury - which often asked penetrating questions whilst they were hearing the evidence - was not convinced it was.

We must never forget this terrible deed, but we must also never forget the circumstances which led to it - a serious injury to mother Cherry Groce in Brixton which left her paralysed and then the death of Cynthia Jarrett when police, against their own rules, entered her home without warning.

Protesters outside Old Bailey Protests have been held outside the court supporting the defendant

The Met Police only "privately" apologised for the former serious injury in March this year. It has never apologised to the Jarrett family.

I was there that fateful night of the riots as I helped pull my future brother-in-law out from the midst of the conflagration.

There have surely been great strides made since then in building relations between police and community.

But the local borough commander in Haringey, Ch Supt Victor Olisa, told me "more still needs to be done to engage and maintain a constructive dialogue with the local community".

The media also has a responsibility to help remove the stigma from a community that current residents say no longer deserves it.

As for those that did murder PC Keith Blakelock, they must live with their conscience and before they meet their maker, they will have to reckon with what was on any scale an unjustified act of evil.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

22 °C 14 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Sainsbury's poster error 14:09:

    A poster encouraging Sainsbury's workers to get customers to spend more was put up in a store window in error.

    The Sainsbury's poster

    The sign, urging staff to get people to spend an extra 50p, appeared in Stratford, east London on Monday.

     
  2.  
    News on the hour 13:56: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    One in seven three-year-olds in London has tooth decay, according to the first ever survey of children in that age group.

    We'll have more on that story in the news at 14:00.

     
  3.  
    House prices 13:49:

    Prices in London are 31% above those reached at the last peak of the market in 2007 according to latest figures, according to BBC Business.

    Although the average house price across the UK has fallen to £188,374, in London it's £401,072.

     
  4.  
    PM praises Boris 13:39:

    David Cameron's insisted he's "delighted" at the prospect of Boris Johnson becoming an MP again next year - even though some have tipped the mayor to replace him as Tory leader.

    David Cameron and Boris Johnson

    The prime minister's dismissed suggestions that he's worried about the mayor's potential return to parliament if he wins in Uxbridge and South Ruislip.

    Mr Johnson's due to speak at the Tory conference at about midday and you can catch full coverage via BBC Politics.

     
  5.  
    Bus station to close 13:27:

    West Croydon bus station is to close until 2016 during a multi-million-pound refurbishment, reports Croydon Guardian.

    No buses will stop at the station, which is used by about eight million passengers a year, from Saturday.

     
  6.  
    Coming up 13:15: BBC London News

    On BBC One at 13:30, find out what Boris Johnson has been saying at the Conservative conference as politics correspondent Tim Donovan is live in Birmingham.

    And Alex Bushill investigates reports that over the past seven months Olympic House tenants have had to endure leaking water on every floor.

     
  7.  
    London from above 13:04:

    MPS helicopters tweets: Looking good as the sun burnt through earlier @StPaulsLondon

    Aerial shot of St Paul's
     
  8.  
    News on the hour 12:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On the 1300 bulletin: London Mayor Boris Johnson say's the city's fortunes remain critical to the rest of the country.

     
  9.  
    Lambeth Station reopens 12:52:

    Lambeth Station has reopened after it was closed due to a faulty train. The rest of the line is now operating a good service.

    BBC Travel has the latest on the Tube.

     
  10.  
    Woman rescued from fire 12:43:

    Firefighters rescued a woman from a maisonette in Battersea this morning after she was a woken by a smoke alarm.

    Watch Manager Mark Nunan, who was at the scene, said: "The fire was on the stairs and the upper landing and all the carpet and clothing on the landing were alight."

    He said they told the woman to stay in her bedroom while they put the fire out before leading her to safety.

     
  11.  
    Afternoon weather 12:33:

    Mostly dry with sunny or bright spells, but the odd isolated light shower is possible in places.

    Hyde Park

    It will feel warm, as temperatures rise above the seasonal average in light winds. Highs of 22C (72F).

     
  12.  
    Bakerloo Line extension 12:20:

    Paolo from north London emails: "2030s & no funding in place: looks like the pre-electoral stunt of the Mayor and his party."

    What do you think about the plans to extend the Bakerloo Line to Lewisham and Hayes and possibly as far as Bromley?

    Send your comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCLondonNews.

     
  13.  
    Painting seen in new light 12:08:

    Did you go and see the sold-out Leonardo Da Vinci exhibition at the National Gallery?

    If so, you may have seen the The Lady with an Ermine, which a scientist has now revealed a major new discovery about the painting.

    Lady with an Ermine painting

    Engineer Pascal Cotte has now shown the artist painted one portrait without the ermine and two with different versions of the fur.

     
  14.  
    News on the hour 11:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the 1200 bulletin, the deputy head of a school in Essex has been found dead, a day after police began an investigation into allegations that he secretly took indecent images of children.

    Essex Police say Martin Goldberg had hundreds of images of teenage boys undressing in changing rooms.

     
  15.  
    Bakerloo Line down 11:51:

    Bakerloo Line tweets: No service btwn Piccadilly Circus and Elephant & Castle while we fix a faulty train at Lambeth North. Good service on the rest of the line.

     
  16.  
    Mayor's former deputy joins UKIP 11:39:

    Richard Barnes, who was Boris Johnson's deputy between 2008-12 and was Tory leader on the London Assembly, has explained why he defected to UKIP.

    He says there's a "disconnect" between the main parties and Westminster.

     
  17.  
    Busker plucked from obscurity 11:29:

    A busker will perform at one of London's most prestigious venues after being plucked from obscurity by an award-winning poet when she was spotted playing in the street.

    Griselda Sanderson with her Nyckelharpa

    Griselda Sanderson with her Nyckelharpa, a traditional 16-string Swedish instrument, will play at the Queen Elizabeth Hall on the South Bank.

    Alice Oswald has asked her to play as part of her performance at London Literature Festival.

     
  18.  
    Have your say 11:13: Rebecca Cafe BBC News

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  19.  
    News on the hour 11:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Doctors' leaders have criticised the prime minister's plans to provide seven days a week access to GPs.

    David Cameron says if the Tories win next year's election they'll spend £400m to ensure everyone has access to a doctor between 0800 and 2000 every day.

    Find out what the British Medical Association's concerns are in the 1100 bulletin.

     
  20.  
    Could VR help build better cities? 10:53:

    Architects have traditionally used physical models of proposed buildings to demonstrate to planners and members of the public how a project will look when it is completed.

    A computer simulation showing a planned station upgrade in Hong Kong

    But some are now using a combination of simulations and augmented reality to find out how buildings will influence behaviour.

     
  21.  
    In the papers 10:42:

    Landowners have promised to take court action in removing an illegal encampment of up to 30 eastern-European migrants from a woodland area, reports This Is Local London.

     
  22.  
    Combat online stalking call 10:27:

    Labour MP Stella Creasy has called for more action to combat online stalking after a man who bombarded her with abuse on Twitter was jailed for 18 weeks.

    Stella Creasy

    Peter Nunn, from Bristol, targeted the politician when she campaigned for a picture of the author Jane Austen to go on the £10 note.

    Ms Creasy told BBC Radio 4's Today programme the experience had been "terrifying" and the police and the Crown Prosecution Service needed to better understand the risks involved.

     
  23.  
    Mayor's former deputy joins UKIP 10:19:

    Boris Johnson's former deputy London mayor, Richard Barnes, has defected from the Conservative Party to UKIP.

    The news comes just hours ahead of Mr Johnson's speech to the Conservative Party conference.

    BBC Politics has the latest.

     
  24.  
    News on the hour 09:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The world has lost half its wildlife in the past 40 years, according to a report from the World Wide Fund for Nature and the Zoological Society of London.

    The Living Planet index says populations of mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians and fish have declined by an average of 52%.

    The 10:00 bulletin has reaction from the chief executive of the WWF.

     
  25.  
    Mayor: Only Tories 'serious' over EU 09:46:

    London Mayor Boris Johnson has urged the "great Conservative family" to unite to defeat Labour at the next general election and to guarantee a referendum on Europe.

    Speaking in the wake of a second Tory defection to UKIP, the mayor of London said only the Conservatives could "sort out" the UK's relationship with the EU.

     
  26.  
    'Half of stillbirths could be prevented' 09:31:

    More than half of stillbirths in the UK could be prevented if the NHS implemented additional scans, a leading obstetrician has told Panorama.

    Prof Nicolaides offers Doppler scans to all women three times during their pregnancies

    Each year, more than 3,000 babies are stillborn in the UK, one of the worst rates in the developed world.

    Prof Kypros Nicolaides, from London's King's College Hospital, says offering all women Doppler scans, which measure blood flow between the placenta and foetus, could save 1,500 babies a year.

     
  27.  
    Quiz an MP 09:19: Vanessa Feltz Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    This morning on BBC London 94.9 I'm being joined in the studio by Jim Fitzpatrick, Labour MP for Poplar and Limehouse.

    Jim will be taking your questions so call 020 722 42000.

     
  28.  
    Bakerloo Line extension 09:05: Tom Edwards Transport correspondent, London

    On the Bakerloo Line extension it's very, very early days - there's no planning permission or funding and we're talking 2030.

    Proposed Bakerloo extension
     
  29.  
    News on the hour 08:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the 0900 bulletin: More than 2,700 people were trafficked in the UK; almost 500 were in London.

    Chloe Setter, from the charity ECPAT which campaigns to stop child trafficking, says some of the cases she's seen have been horrific.

     
  30.  
    Bakerloo Line extension 08:49:

    A public consultation begins today into plans to extend the Bakerloo Line to Lewisham and Hayes, and possibly as far as Bromley.

    There are two potential routes - one via the Old Kent Road and the other via Camberwell and Peckham.

    It would cost up to £3bn and London Mayor Boris Johnson says it is vital to help south London grow as the population continues to rise.

     
  31.  
    Chelsea to 'risk' Costa 08:37:

    Chelsea manager Jose Mourinho says he will "risk" starting striker Diego Costa in tonight's Champions League Group G match away to Sporting Lisbon.

    Chelsea forward Diego Costa
     
  32.  
    Top headlines
     
  33.  
    Travel 08:25: Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    On the trains, there are 10 min delays to Southern services at London Bridge due to a signalling problem.

    On the roads, Creek Road in Greenwich is closed westbound due to emergency gas repairs for the next week causing long delays around Greenwich, Blackheath and Blackwall.

    And the M23 is very slow southbound from J8 M25 to J9 Gatwick because of roadworks.

    For the latest disruption information go to our travel page or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel.

     
  34.  
    Park searched for Alice 08:16:

    The hunt for missing schoolgirl Alice Gross has moved to a National Trust-owned estate near to where she was last seen more than a month ago.

    Alice Gross

    Scotland Yard officers are combing Osterley Park, in west London, for the first time.

    The park is about two miles (3.2km) from the spot near the Grand Union Canal where Alice, 14, was last seen.

     
  35.  
    Dull start, brighter later 08:05:

    Many places will have a dull start, with some mist and low cloud. This will gradually clear through this morning, leaving sunny spells and the risk of an isolated shower.

    It will feel warm as temperatures rise above the seasonal average in light winds, reaching highs of 22C (72F).

     
  36.  
    Good morning 08:00: Rebecca Cafe BBC News

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or Tweet @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • FilmsOnes to watch

    BBC Culture picks nine top films coming out next month

Programmes

  • A computer simulation showing a planned station upgrade in Hong KongClick Watch

    Simulated world - how architects are using virtual and augmented reality to transform our cities

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.