Erena Wilson Kew Gardens death: Branch fall 'an accident'

Family handout photo of Erena Wilson Erena Wilson suffered fatal head injuries when a large branch fell on her at Kew Gardens

Related Stories

The death of a woman who was fatally injured when a large branch fell on her at Kew Gardens, south-west London, was an accident, an inquest jury has found.

Erena Wilson, 31, from Hanwell, west London, was walking through the Royal Botanical Gardens when the branch crashed down on her in September 2012.

The accounts manager was attending a three-year-old's birthday party when the "freak accident" took place, West London Coroner's Court heard.

Ms Wilson died from head injuries.

'Ghastly accident'

Returning a conclusion of accidental death, the foreman said the jury found "there is insufficient evidence to establish the cause of the branch failure".

Assistant Coroner Elizabeth Pygott said the death was a "ghastly accident" but she would not be making a Prevention of Future Deaths report.

The inquest heard it was pure "fluke" that Ms Wilson's friend Tess Marshall and her daughter Ruby, who was celebrating her birthday, were not hurt as they were all walking along a main path when the large Cedar of Lebanon branch came crashing down.

Kew Gardens The inquest heard that Kew Gardens failed to put up signs warning of the danger

Giving evidence Ms Marshall said she ran after hearing a "crack like lightning" and saw the thick branch which "blocked out the sky" fall. Her daughter had run ahead moments earlier.

When she turned she saw New Zealand-born Ms Wilson lying face-down with blood coming out of her mouth and ears. She suffered severe head injuries, including fractures, bruising on her left side and scalp and an extensive brain injury.

During the inquest John McLinden QC, representing Ms Wilson's family, said it had been raining heavily hours before the incident, which could lead to "summer branch drop", particularly after long dry spells.

Kew Gardens had failed to put up warning signs because it had deemed the risk as minimal, and the lawyer also questioned why trees had not been fenced off.

But Patrick Blakesley, a lawyer representing Kew, said it was a "terrible freak accident", adding that in more than 50 years, some 66 million people had visited the gardens and only one other person had been killed by a tree.

'Unlikely and unforeseeable'

The inquest also heard from Tony Kirkham, head of arboretum at Kew, who said the "branch deluge was triggered by a wind squall" with gusts of up to 30mph.

He dismissed suggestions that summer branch drop caused the accident, saying it had been the wettest summer since records began, and that warning signs would have been an over-reaction.

Jeremy Barrell, a tree expert called by Ms Wilson's family, disagreed and dubbed Kew's system of tree inspection "a shambles". The death could have been avoided if the tree, which dated back to 1730, had been pruned, he said.

In a statement on behalf of Ms Wilson's parents, Chris Wilson and Elizabeth Shelley, called for more research to "raise public awareness of the deadliness of summer branch drop".

They said: "The loss of our darling daughter, Erena, shattered us as a family.

"If one death can be prevented and one family saved from having to go through this, then some good will have come from this tragedy."

After the inquest Richard Barley, director of horticulture at Kew, said: "The jury has found that there was no identifiable cause of branch failure from this tree that caused this tragic accident."

He added that it would be "inappropriate to place warning signs because it is such an unlikely thing to happen and it is so unforeseeable".

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

14 °C 9 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    10:59: News on the hour

    Scotland Yard says it's making progress in recruiting and promoting more officers from ethnic minorities after the London Assembly called on it to do more to better reflect the city it serves.

    Listen live to BBC London 94.9 to find out more at 11:00.

     
  2.  
    10:52: George III 'eccentric' drawing uncovered

    An eccentric architectural plan thought to have been drawn by George III during his period of "madness" has been discovered at the British Library.

    George III's drawing George III's drawing is described as 'rather savage'

    The diagram of a building was drawn in ink over a pencil outline "in a rather savage way", according to experts.

     
  3.  
    10:43: Christmas workers

    For walking tour guide Mary Tucker, Christmas Day is one of the busiest days of the year.

    Mary Tucker Mary Tucker will lead five walks in central London on Christmas Day

    She will will be leading no fewer than five two-hour Charles Dickens Christmas Day Walks in central London. Are you working on Christmas Day? Let us know what you'll be doing.

     
  4.  
    10:31: Whitehall v town hall Mark Easton Home editor

    The swirling wind of anti-politics that has swept across the Westminster parliament in recent times stems from a conviction that the politicians sitting on warm green leather in the House of Commons are oblivious to the harsh realities of ordinary life.

    It is that sense of a London elite, out of touch with the real world, that has encouraged politicians of all stripes to talk of the importance of localism.

     
  5.  
    10:22: Spurs win 4-0 Andy Rowley BBC London 94.9

    Tottenham will play Sheffield United in the semi-finals of the Capital One Cup after a comprehensive 4-0 win over Newcastle at White Hart Lane.

     
  6.  
    10:10: Councils braced for funding cuts

    London councils are to learn later how much money they will have next year to spend on local services such as waste collection and road maintenance.

    The Local Government Association has warned services would "buckle under the strain" of more cuts.

     
  7.  
    09:56: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    More than 1.6 million children are now eating free school meals, including more than 90% of children in inner London who became eligible for them in September.

    Listen to BBC London 94.9 to find out more

     
  8.  
    09:45: Harlequins sign Australia lock BBC Sport

    Harlequins have announced Australia lock James Horwill will join the Premiership club following the conclusion of the 2015 World Cup.

    James Horwill James Horwill captained Australia against the British & Irish Lions in 2013

    The 29-year-old will arrive on a three-year deal from Queensland Reds.

     
  9.  
    09:36: Met diversity

    The Met must do more to ensure its workforce better reflects London's cultural diversity according to a report by the London Assembly.

    In 2013, 11% of officers were from a black, Asian or minority ethnic background, compared with around 40% of the capital's population.

     
  10.  
    09:28: Have your say Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  11.  
    09:17: 'World leading' research

    The Research Excellence Framework has released a ranking of universities whose proportion of research submitted is "world leading", and a London institution has come top:

    1. London School of Economics - 49.9%
    2. Oxford - 48.1%
    3. Cambridge - 46.8%
    4. Imperial College London - 46.4%
    5. University College London - 42.6%
     
  12.  
    09:11: London overtaking Oxbridge domination Sean Coughlan Education correspondent

    London universities are breaking up the traditional dominance of Oxford and Cambridge, according to official figures on research excellence.

    UCL

    The London School of Economics has the highest proportion of "world-leading" research among UK universities.

     
  13.  
    08:58: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    A new report's called on the Met Police to do more to ensure its workforce better reflects the city it serves.

    To find out more, listen live. at 09:00.

     
  14.  
    08:48: Chelsea beat Liverpool Andy Rowley BBC London 94.9

    Chelsea will meet Liverpool in the last four after they ran out 3-1 winners at Bournemouth thanks to two goals from Raheem Sterling.

     
  15.  
    08:40: Vanessa Feltz BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Councils will be told later this morning how much they'll be allowed to spend in the coming year. The annual local government settlement is being announced, when town halls find out how much Whitehall cash they'll get.

    What would you spend it on? Join the discussion with Vanessa from 09:00.

     
  16.  
    08:29: In the papers

    London stories in the nationals today include:

    • The Independent cites Kensal Rise library as an example of the threat to libraries across London.
    • The Telegraph reports Met Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe said a Sydney-style siege was foiled in London.
    Independent front cover
     
  17.  
    08:21: World Cup venue Andy Rowley BBC London 94.9

    Marylebone Cricket Club has announced Lord's has been chosen to host the 2017 ICC Women's World Cup Final and the 2019 ICC Cricket World Cup Final.

     
  18.  
    08:15: 12th cyclist killed switched transport London Evening Standard Newspaper

    reports an engineer killed when he was knocked off his bicycle on the way to work had given up riding motorcycles because he believed they were "too dangerous".

     
  19.  
    08:11: Train delays BBC Travel London

    There are delays on Abellio Greater Anglia between Seven Sisters and Liverpool Street because of a signalling problem.

     
  20.  
    08:05: Cloudy and mild

    It will be cloudy and mild with some patchy light rain or drizzle in places becoming more widespread during the afternoon. Highs of 14C (57F). This is the outlook for 15:00 today

    Weather map for 15:00
     
  21.  
    08:00: Good morning Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Good morning, I'll be guiding you through BBC Local Live today until 18:00. Please get in touch with your comments and photos by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • HobbitHobbit review

    Nicholas Barber asks whether The Battle of the Five Armies is worthwhile or unnecessary

Programmes

  • An ECG (electrocardiogram)Click Watch

    The wearable technology which could allow you to pay for goods with your heartbeat

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.