Erena Wilson Kew Gardens death: Branch fall 'an accident'

Family handout photo of Erena Wilson Erena Wilson suffered fatal head injuries when a large branch fell on her at Kew Gardens

Related Stories

The death of a woman who was fatally injured when a large branch fell on her at Kew Gardens, south-west London, was an accident, an inquest jury has found.

Erena Wilson, 31, from Hanwell, west London, was walking through the Royal Botanical Gardens when the branch crashed down on her in September 2012.

The accounts manager was attending a three-year-old's birthday party when the "freak accident" took place, West London Coroner's Court heard.

Ms Wilson died from head injuries.

'Ghastly accident'

Returning a conclusion of accidental death, the foreman said the jury found "there is insufficient evidence to establish the cause of the branch failure".

Assistant Coroner Elizabeth Pygott said the death was a "ghastly accident" but she would not be making a Prevention of Future Deaths report.

The inquest heard it was pure "fluke" that Ms Wilson's friend Tess Marshall and her daughter Ruby, who was celebrating her birthday, were not hurt as they were all walking along a main path when the large Cedar of Lebanon branch came crashing down.

Kew Gardens The inquest heard that Kew Gardens failed to put up signs warning of the danger

Giving evidence Ms Marshall said she ran after hearing a "crack like lightning" and saw the thick branch which "blocked out the sky" fall. Her daughter had run ahead moments earlier.

When she turned she saw New Zealand-born Ms Wilson lying face-down with blood coming out of her mouth and ears. She suffered severe head injuries, including fractures, bruising on her left side and scalp and an extensive brain injury.

During the inquest John McLinden QC, representing Ms Wilson's family, said it had been raining heavily hours before the incident, which could lead to "summer branch drop", particularly after long dry spells.

Kew Gardens had failed to put up warning signs because it had deemed the risk as minimal, and the lawyer also questioned why trees had not been fenced off.

But Patrick Blakesley, a lawyer representing Kew, said it was a "terrible freak accident", adding that in more than 50 years, some 66 million people had visited the gardens and only one other person had been killed by a tree.

'Unlikely and unforeseeable'

The inquest also heard from Tony Kirkham, head of arboretum at Kew, who said the "branch deluge was triggered by a wind squall" with gusts of up to 30mph.

He dismissed suggestions that summer branch drop caused the accident, saying it had been the wettest summer since records began, and that warning signs would have been an over-reaction.

Jeremy Barrell, a tree expert called by Ms Wilson's family, disagreed and dubbed Kew's system of tree inspection "a shambles". The death could have been avoided if the tree, which dated back to 1730, had been pruned, he said.

In a statement on behalf of Ms Wilson's parents, Chris Wilson and Elizabeth Shelley, called for more research to "raise public awareness of the deadliness of summer branch drop".

They said: "The loss of our darling daughter, Erena, shattered us as a family.

"If one death can be prevented and one family saved from having to go through this, then some good will have come from this tragedy."

After the inquest Richard Barley, director of horticulture at Kew, said: "The jury has found that there was no identifiable cause of branch failure from this tree that caused this tragic accident."

He added that it would be "inappropriate to place warning signs because it is such an unlikely thing to happen and it is so unforeseeable".

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

25 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Lunchtime news 13:10: Sonja Jessup Presenter, BBC London News

    On BBC London News from 13:30, we'll be live at Transport for London HQ as figures reveal which tube stations will lose the most staff under plans to close ticket offices.

     
  2.  
    News on the hour 13:00:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 13:00:

    Police searching for the missing 14-year-old, Alice Gross, say they're treating a man with a murder conviction as a suspect in her disappearance.

     
  3.  
    Digital speed cameras by 2016 12:50:

    Speed cameras in London are to be upgraded, with drivers being warned to watch their average speed.

    Speed camera

    Hundreds of traditional "wet film" speed cameras are being replaced with digital cameras, while cameras at traffic lights are also being replaced, with work expected to be completed by October 2016.

     
  4.  
    Vintage car boot sale returns 12:41:

    The Classic Car Boot Sale returns to London this weekend at the Olympic Park, offering vintage fashion traded from classic cars.

    Classic Car Boot Sale

    More than 100 traders are due at the boot sale on Saturday and Sunday, which also features music from Swing Patrol, free film screenings and the London debut of the Mobile Museum of Obsolete Technology.

     
  5.  
    On air this afternoon 12:28: Robert Elms Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    On BBC London 94.9 till 15:00, I'll be talking to film critic Jason Solomons about the latest batch of new movies including Riot Club, Woody Allen's Magic in the Moonlight, Walking Among Tombstones with Liam Neeson and Grand Piano starring Elijah Wood.

     
  6.  
    'At risk' theatres revealed 12:15:

    Two London theatres are among 33 venues throughout the country listed as "at risk" from decay, closure or irreversible change, according to the Theatres Trust.

    Theatres Trust 'at risk' theatres list

    The Secombe Theatre and Charles Cryer Studio Theatre, both in Sutton, are among three new additions to the list.

     
  7.  
    News on the hour 12:00:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 12:00:

    • Police searching for missing teenager Alice Gross name Latvian builder Arnis Zalkalns as a suspect, and appeal for information on the red bike he was seen riding on the same route as the teen in west London
     
  8.  
    Murder arrest in Duffy stabbing 11:53:

    Police have arrested a 48-year-old man on suspicion of murdering 26-year-old Leighann Duffy.

    Leighann Duffy

    Ms Duffy was found with stab wounds to her arm and neck at a residential property in Walthamstow on 1 September and died two days later in hospital.

     
  9.  
    Warhol's cookie jars 11:43:

    The Barbican is to host the first major exhibition in the UK of the personal collections of post-war and contemporary artists.

    Cookie jars previously owned by Andy Warhol Andy Warhol's collection of cookie jars are among the exhibits

    Magnificent Obsessions: The Artist as Collector will feature personal effects from artists including Damien Hirst, Andy Warhol and Sir Peter Blake.

     
  10.  
    Tube cut claims 'nonsense' 11:32:

    Phil Hufton, London Underground's Chief Operating Officer, said it was "nonsense" to suggest plans to change staffing at Tube stations would not benefit stations, after the London Assembly Labour Group said the proposals would mean a staff cut of over 50% at some stations.

    A London Underground Tube train

    Hufton added: "Under our proposals there will be more staff visible and available to help our passengers and keep them safe and secure as they will be brought out from behind glass windows and back offices to work where people need them - within ticket halls, and on concourses and platforms."

     
  11.  
    Tube staff cuts 'beggar belief' 11:20:

    London Underground passengers are "getting less for more" on the Tube as fares rise while staff numbers are cut, said Val Shawcross, Labour's London Assembly transport spokesperson.

    London Underground escalator at Swiss Cottage

    She said: "It beggars belief that with tube fares due to rise by 2.5% in January, Boris Johnson has the nerve to cut front line staffing levels at stations by an average of 16% across London."

     
  12.  
    Feedback 11:10:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  13.  
    News on the hour 11:00:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 11:00:

    • Police name Arnis Zalkalns as a suspect in the disappearance of teenager Alice Gross, and reveal he was imprisoned for murder in his home country Latvia in the 1990s
     
  14.  
    Tube station reform: Staff 'more visible' 10:47:

    Phil Hufton, London Underground's Chief Operating Officer, said the detail of proposed changes to staffing on the Tube could change as consultation continues, following claims from the London Assembly Labour Group that up to 58% of station workers would go.

    London Underground sign at Westminster

    He added: "Every station will remain staffed at all times whilst the service is running and there will be even more visible staff available to help customers including those with disabilities."

     
  15.  
    Tube staff cuts: 'Worst affected' 10:32:

    Planned staff cuts at London Underground stations will lead to a loss of up to 58% of workers at some Tube stations, according to the London Assembly Labour group, with these six stations losing the highest proportions of staff:

    • Barons Court (District and Piccadilly Lines)
    • Edgware (Northern Line)
    • Finchley Central (Northern Line)
    • Kilburn (Jubilee Line)
    • Dagenham Heathway (District Line)
    • Parsons Green (District Line)
     
  16.  
    Alice Gross: Police hunt suspect's bike 10:22:

    Police have appealed for the public's help in tracking down the red mountain bike seen ridden by Arnis Zalkalns, who has been named as a suspect in the case of missing teenager Alice Gross.

    CCTV of Arnis Zalkalns

    Zalkalns was seen on CCTV riding his bike along a route in west London that was used about 15 minutes earlier by the missing teenager.

     
  17.  
    Alice Gross: Suspect 'could pose risk to public' 10:13:

    Police searching for suspect Arnis Zalkalns in the case of missing teenager Alice Gross say he may pose a risk to the public.

     
  18.  
    Alice Gross: Suspect 'in UK since 2007' 10:09:

    Arnis Zalkalns, who is wanted as a suspect in the case of missing teenager Alice Gross, has been in the UK since 2007, and has a partner and young child living in Ealing, police said.

    Officers have received more than 100 calls to the Find Alice investigation after an appeal on BBC Crimewatch earlier this week.

     
  19.  
    Alice Gross: Arnis Zalkalns 'not wanted man' 10:03:

    Arnis Zalkalns, who police are searching for in relation to the missing teenager Alice Gross, was not a wanted man in his home country Latvia after serving seven years in prison for murder, and was not on UK records, said the Met.

    Missing teenager Alice Gross

    Latvian authorities told the Met about Zalkalns' murder conviction "in the last few days", said a police spokesman.

     
  20.  
    News on the hour 10:00:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 10:00

    • Police are treating Latvian Arnis Zalkalns as a suspect in the disappearance of teenager Alice Gross, revealing that he had been convicted of murder in his homeland in the 1990s
     
  21.  
    Alice Gross: Wanted man missing 09:51:

    Arnis Zalkalns has not been since Wednesday 3 September and was reported reported missing from his home in Ealing by his partner two days later.

    A police spokesman appealed for information on his whereabouts, saying: "I want anyone who may have seen him after that date, or who may have helped him by giving him money or somewhere to stay, to call and speak to us."

     
  22.  
    Alice Gross: Wanted man convicted of Latvia murder 09:47:

    Arnis Zalkalns, who is being hunted by police in connection with the disappearance of Alice Gross, was convicted of murder in Latvia in the late 1990s and served seven years in prison, said police.

    Arnis Zalkalns

    He was arrested in London in 2009 for indecently assaulting a girl but no further action was taken.

     
  23.  
    Alice Gross: Zalkalns disappearance 'out of character' 09:43:

    Since Arnis Zalkalns was last seen at his home in Ealing on the evening of Wednesday, 3 September he has not accessed his bank account or used his mobile phone and his passport was left at his house, said police.

    Friends and family of Arnis have told police that his disappearance is completely out of character, and they are very concerned for him.

     
  24.  
    Alice Gross: Man caught on CCTV 09:41:

    Detectives trying to find 14-year-old Alice Gross are treating 41-year-old Arnis Zalkalns as a suspect, and say he was seen on CCTV cycling along Brentford Lock at 16:00hrs about 15 minutes after Alice walked that route.

    Alice Gross
     
  25.  
    Alice Gross BREAKING NEWS

    Police have said the man they are searching for in relation to the case of missing teenager Alice Gross, Arnis Zalkalns, is being treated as a suspect in her disappearance.

    A reward of £20,000 is being offered for anyone with information that leads to the discovery of the teenager.

     
  26.  
    Tube cuts 'mean 16% staff drop' 09:21:

    Cuts to staff on the London Underground will lead to 588 frontline workers losing their jobs, with some stations losing up to 58% of their staff, according to analysis from the London Assembly Labour Group.

    London Underground

    Val Shawcross, the Labour Group transport spokesperson, said current proposals would mean station staff being cut by an average of almost 16% from January 2015.

     
  27.  
    London Bridge disruption 09:11: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    There have been delays and cancellations on Southeastern and Thameslink trains through London Bridge because of a signal failure.

    For the latest travel updates on twitter, follow @BBCTravelAlert

     
  28.  
    News on the hour 09:00:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 09:00:

    • Police searching for the missing west London teenager Alice Gross will release more information at a news conference this morning, to mark three weeks since she disappeared.
     
  29.  
    Chelsea's Costa in injury warning 08:56:

    Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho suggested Diego Costa is not ready to start more than one game a week after using him as a substitute in the Champions League draw with Schalke last night.

    Chelsea striker Diego Costa

    Striker Costa came on in the 74th minute as Chelsea drew 1-1 in their Champions League Group G opener, but is still suffering from a hamstring strain he suffered playing for Spain on 4 September.

     
  30.  
    Top headlines
  31.  
    On air 08:43: Vanessa Feltz Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    On BBC London 94.49 at 09:00, a government advisor on racism has told the BBC that Islamic State extremism and the child sex abuse scandal in Rotherham have led to a right wing backlash against British Muslims.

     
  32.  
    Ebola nurse travels to US 08:30:

    A British nurse who recovered from Ebola has travelled to the US to donate blood to try to save the life of another victim of the virus.

    Will Pooley

    Will Pooley, 29, was discharged from the Royal Free Hospital in north-west London two weeks ago where he received treatment in a special isolation unit.

     
  33.  
    Two charged over Battersea shooting 08:20:

    Two men have been charged with murder after a man was shot in south London.

    Sebastian Hyman-Knight, 21, was found by police on Tennyson Street in Battersea, late on the night of 11 September.

     
  34.  
    Tube delays 08:15: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    On the Tube, there are severe delays on the Bakerloo Line because of earlier signal problems.

    For more travel news, visit BBC London's travel website.

     
  35.  
    Sunny spells 08:08:

    Mist, fog and low cloud at first will quickly thin and break to leave long spells of sunshine from mid morning.

    Further spells of sunshine are expected this afternoon but a few sharp showers are expected to develop. Maximum temperature: 24C (75F).

     
  36.  
    08:00: Matthew Bell BBC News, London

    Good morning. I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • SpiderWeb of wonder

    BBC Earth takes a unique journey inside the body of a giant tarantula

Programmes

  • A person taking a photo of fireworks on a smartphoneClick Watch

    A look at the latest gadgets which could make it easier to take the perfect night-time picture

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.