Alder Hey Children's Hospital safety fears revealed in report

Alder Hey Children's Hospital Safety concerns emerged about the hospital operating theatres

Related Stories

A leaked report into safety fears at Liverpool's Alder Hey Children's Hospital has uncovered "safety shortcuts" in operating theatres.

The internal review, passed to Channel 4 News, revealed a "pressurised" staff with a "mistrust of management" feeling they work in a "hostile environment".

It said "urgent action" was needed by the hospital trust.

Chief executive Louise Shepherd has written an open letter stating there were "no incidents of patient harm".

The review, prepared by director of nursing Gill Core, was presented last month.

'Absence of toys'

Her report identified shortcuts to safety processes that have created high risk activity, limited reporting of incidents and "a belief senior management and the board are aware of the working conditions and condone it".

Scrubs suits used in operating theatres were described as "shabby and mismatched."

The report continues: "Some individuals have reported that the working environment is hostile and there are numerous examples of staff feeling pressurised to undertake activities they do not believe are safe."

The units are not welcoming or child-friendly, it states, and there is "a total absence of toys".

The report added: "The perception of mistrust of management and the board is such that there is a widespread feeling of hopelessness that change will ever be achieved.

"It is immediately apparent that responses from theatre staff have centred on a desire to deliver the best possible service and the highest standard of care to patients."

'Increased demand'

But the review also says: "Staff have adopted some high risk practices in order to avoid cancellations; whilst safe outcomes have been maintained, the level of risk is such that urgent action needs to be implemented to avoid an adverse outcome or serious incident."

Following the leaking of the report, the hospital said it was already making changes and was "very proud" of staff.

Ms Shepherd said it had a deep commitment to ensuring "the very best quality of care".

Trust chairman Sir David Henshaw said it was facing "significant challenges which include an increasing demand for services".

"Over the past year we have undertaken a range of measures to address these and make changes within the department."

He said there were now new protocols around staffing, equipment checklists had been strengthened and new scrub suits and toys bought.

The Care Quality Commission (CQC) made an unannounced inspection last month after being directly approached by theatre staff. Its report will be published soon.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



24 °C 17 °C

BBC Local Live

    News on the hour 14:59: Graham Whyte BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 15:00 include:

    • The Trojan Horse inquiry says there was "an aggressive Islamist agenda" to impose hardline Muslim views in some Birmingham schools
    • A retired South Yorkshire Police inspector denies he is 'pushing the SYP line' at the new Hillsborough inquests
    • The widow of former spy Alexander Litvinenko, says she's "relieved and delighted" a public inquiry is to be held into his death
    Coming up on Billy Butler 14:44:

    BBC Radio Merseyside's Billy Butler tweets: The Virginia Luthiers (pictured) and @midgeure1 feature on the programme today (14:00 - 16:00)!

    The Virginia Luthiers
    Slow traffic on M57 14:25:

    BBC Travel is reporting slow traffic on M57 northbound between J6, A506 (Kirkby) and J7 M58.

    New bishop to be confirmed 14:16:

    The new Bishop of Liverpool, the Rt Revd Paul Bayes will be confirmed by the Archbishop of York at a special service at York Minster tomorrow.

    Rt Revd Paul Bayes

    Following the ceremony, Bishop Paul will have the spiritual jurisdiction over the Diocese of Liverpool.

    He will be installed at Liverpool Cathedral on November 15th.

    News on the hour 14:00: BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 14:00 include:

    • The Trojan Horse inquiry says there was "an aggressive Islamist agenda" to impose hardline Muslim views in some Birmingham schools
    • The Independent Police Complaints Commission has raised concerns about the way officers are using tasers
    • Merseyside's police commissioner is warning more government cuts to the force`s budget will have a devastating impact
    Harrison tree killed by beetles 13:53:

    A pine tree planted in 2004 in memory of former Beatle George Harrison in a Los Angeles park has died after being infested by beetles.

    George Harrison

    The sapling was planted in the city's Griffith Park near the observatory.

    Harrison, who died in 2001, spent his final days in LA and was a keen gardener.

    Grand’mère meets Grandma 13:43:

    Liverpool's Lord Mayor, Councillor Erica Kemp is to meet up with another giant matriarch tomorrow morning.

    Grandmother Giant sleeping

    Councillor Kemp will visit St Georges Hall to have a peek at the sleeping French Grandmother giant who arrives as part of this year's 'Memories of August 1914' event.

    Staff, patients and carers from Alder Hey will also be getting a first look at the magical old lady before she wakes from her sleep.

    Happy Birthday Dirk! 13:29:

    Former Liverpool player Dirk Kuyt is celebrating his 34th birthday today.

    Dirk Kuyt

    The Dutch striker - now with Turkish side Fenerbahçe - scored 71 goals in almost 300 appearances for the Reds, including that 2011 hat-trick against Man United.

    Adored by Reds fans, his tireless running in every game earned him the nickname 'The Duracell Bunny'.

    Coming up on North West Today 13:20: Stuart Flinders

    The Giants are coming! The mammoth marionettes return to Liverpool with the arrival of the Grandmother at St George's Hall tomorrow.

    Grandmother Giant

    We're looking ahead to the spectacular event in North West Today at 13:30 on BBC One. Watch again on iPlayer

    News on the hour 13:00: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 13:00 include:

    • The Trojan Horse inquiry says there was "an aggressive Islamist agenda" to impose hardline Muslim views in some Birmingham schools
    • There are fresh concerns about the security of the wreckage of Flight MH17 shot down in Ukraine last week
    • There's a warning that Merseyside Police could lose another 400 officers in the next round of cuts
    Why do you love the Giants? 12:51: Owen Walker BBC Local Live

    What do you love about the giants?

    Sea Odyssey

    They're arriving in Liverpool tomorrow and we want to know what you're looking forward to most about their visit.

    Get in touch via email, Twitter or Facebook.

    Rocking out in Liverpool 12:31: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    Award-winning smash hit musical 'Rock of Ages' is the latest show to come to Liverpool's Empire Theatre.

    Think 80s classic rock, big hair, tight jeans and air guitar.

    Sean Styles

    Earlier I spoke Noel Sullivan who plays Drew, and Cordelia Farnworth, who plays Sherrie Christian. Listen to the interview on iPlayer soon.

    Drug gang jailed 12:15: Liverpool Echo

    A gang which tried to sneak £1m of cocaine into Britain hidden in tins of a Caribbean vegetable were today behind bars.

    News on the hour 11:59: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 12:00 include:

    • A spokesman for the officials at the site of the Malaysia Airlines Crash in Ukraine says parts of the wreckage have been changed since they first saw it
    • Schools will be given resources to teach children about female genital mutilation
    • Remploy, which used to run a factory in Birkenhead employing disabled people, is to be partly privatised
    Coming up 11:51: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'll be talking to Cindy Butts, who's a commissioner with the Independent Police Complaints Commission, about the increased use of Tasers by police officers.

    The police watchdog has raised concerns about the appropriate use of Tasers and whether officers have had the correct training.

    We'll also have all the latest from Gaza and events surrounding flight MH17.

    Litherland incident 11:42:

    Merseyside Police are trying to trace a white car after an incident in Litherland yesterday afternoon.

    Two men were seen threatening another man before pushing him into a white car on Longfield Road which then drove off.

    Police say the men appeared to know one another.

    Liverpool go second in WSL 11:29:

    Liverpool have climbed to second place in the Women's Super League table after a 3-1 victory at Bristol Academy.

    Liverpool midfielder Katrin Omarsdottir

    You can see all the highlights of the Woman's Super League on the BBC Sport website.

    Witness appeal launched 11:17: Wirral Globe

    Detectives are appealing for witnesses to an assault outside a Wirral pub that left a 56-year-old man with head injuries.

    Giants are set to arrive 11:06: Owen Walker BBC Local Live

    We're really looking forward to the giants arrival in Liverpool tomorrow.

    Grandmother giant

    The Grandmother will be the first giant to go on show to the public as she sleeps in St George's Hall.

    Find out more about the whole event Giant Spectacular website.

    News on the hour 10:59: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 11:00 include:

    • Schools will be given resources to teach children about female genital mutilation
    • A train carrying the bodies of most of the victims of the Malaysia Airlines crash in Ukraine has arrived in the city of Kharkiv - which is controlled by the government
    • The police watchdog says it's concerned too many officers are using tasers just to cause people pain
    Brian Epstein statue 10:49:

    The organisers of a campaign to erect a statue of Beatles manager Brian Epstein hope sales of a specially written song will help raise the money needed.

    Brian Epstein

    Supporters say his importance to the 60s music scene and his management of the Beatles deserves to be formally recognised.

    Gibson returns? 10:36:

    The BBC Sport Gossip Column says midfielder Darron Gibson, 26, is expected to end his nine-month spell on the sidelines when Everton face Tranmere Rovers in a friendly today.

    Darron Gibson

    You can read the full story in the Liverpool Echo.

    Funny eBay description 10:22: Liverpool Echo

    An eBay seller seemingly from Liverpool has gone to hilarious lengths to try and shift his Citroen C3.

    Coming up 10:10: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    Noel Sullivan joins me in the studio to chat about Rock of Ages which is on at the Liverpool Empire this week.

    Also, as Prince George celebrates his first birthday we're talking about your memorable milestones. First kiss, first day school, wedding or maybe first holiday abroad?

    Let me know yours via email, Twitter or Facebook.

    News on the hour 09:59: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 10:00 include:

    Stairwell death 'unexplained' 09:44:

    A man has died after being found in the stairwell of a block of flats in Falkland Street.

    Merseyside Police are treating the death as unexplained and have launched an investigation.

    They're appealing for a man and woman who found the collapsed man and called an ambulance to come forward.

    A very special day 09:31: Jimmy McCracken BBC Radio Merseyside

    This morning I've been to Snelly's old school, All Saints Primary School in Anfield, to meet the choir who are in for a very special day today.

    All Saints Primary School Choir

    They're off to a recording studio to record a special song to raise money for a statue of Brian Epstein.

    No arrests in crash investigation 09:20: Warrington Guardian

    There has yet to be any arrests made in the police investigation into a fatal road accident that saw an Orford father-to-be killed 12 hours before his baby was born.

    Children of prisoners 09:10:

    A Liverpool-based charity's calling for more government funding to help children whose parents have gone to jail.


    Statistics show they're three times more likely than their peers to become offenders and develop mental health issues.

    Lorna Brooks, a specialist practitioner at Person Shaped Support in Liverpool, told BBC Radio Merseyside the children of prisoners are "often treated quite badly by society for things they haven't done."

    Top headlines
    • Police: More cuts will be 'devastating'
    • Fatal: Stairwell death investigated
    • Listen: BBC Radio Merseyside
    News on the hour 08:59: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 09:00 include:

    • A Liverpool-based charity's calling for more government funding to help children whose parents are in jail
    • Palestinian officials say Israeli aircraft have hit more than 70 targets in the Gaza Strip overnight
    • Parents who fail to stop their daughters suffering female genital mutilation will face prosecution under laws being unveiled by David Cameron
    How well do you know St Helens? 08:57: St Helens Star

    How many people in Eccleston have a degree? What proportion of people in Parr are Christian? Take this quiz and test your knowledge of your area.

    Just one more sleep! 08:48:

    Giant Spectacular tweets: @BBCNWT not long to go now just one more sleep! Looking forward to welcoming you tomorrow #giantsarecoming

    Borini to 'fight for Liverpool place' 08:34:

    The BBC Sport Gossip Column says Liverpool have accepted a £14m offer from Sunderland for striker Fabio Borini but the 23-year-old is set to reject the move and fight for his place at Anfield.

    Fabio Borini

    You can read the full story in the Newcastle Chronicle.

    'Blown away' by the Giants 08:24: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    Yesterday, I had the chance to go and see a sneak preview of the Giants.

    Little Girl Giant

    I can tell you I was blown away. I'm not going give you any details but I reckon it's going to be even better than last time.

    The Chair of Merseytravel, Cllr Liam Robertson, reckons the event is going to be huge. He said people should "prepare and plan" how they're going to get around as there will be significant changes to public transport.

    Queuing traffic on M62 08:15:

    BBC Travel reports: Queuing traffic earlier on M62 eastbound between J7, A57 (Rainhill Stoops) and J8 Burtonwood Road, because of an earlier accident.

    Warm and sunny 08:07: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC North West Today

    It will be a cloudy and even misty start to the day for some but this should all burn back relatively quickly to leave behind another warm and sunny day.

    Weather graphic on 22.07.2014

    Patchy cloud will develop in the afternoon but it will still feel hot with highs of 26C (79F).

    News on the hour 08:00: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 08:00 include:

    • A Merseyside charity's urging the government to give more help to children whose parents are in prison
    • Rebels in eastern Ukraine have handed over two flight-data recorders from the MH17 plane to Malaysian experts
    • Detectives in Liverpool are investigating the death of a man found at the bottom of a stairwell
    Good morning 08:00: Owen Walker BBC Local Live

    I'm here with today's news, sport, travel and weather updates for Merseyside.

    If you'd like me to feature your comments or pictures, send them to or tweet us at @bbcmerseyside.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Kyoto.Falling for Kyoto

    Acclaimed writer Pico Iyer describes an enchanting first stroll through the city


  • (File photo) Usain BoltClick Watch

    Challenging the world's fastest man to a virtual race over 40m – can you keep up?

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.