Alder Hey Children's Hospital safety fears revealed in report

Alder Hey Children's Hospital Safety concerns emerged about the hospital operating theatres

Related Stories

A leaked report into safety fears at Liverpool's Alder Hey Children's Hospital has uncovered "safety shortcuts" in operating theatres.

The internal review, passed to Channel 4 News, revealed a "pressurised" staff with a "mistrust of management" feeling they work in a "hostile environment".

It said "urgent action" was needed by the hospital trust.

Chief executive Louise Shepherd has written an open letter stating there were "no incidents of patient harm".

The review, prepared by director of nursing Gill Core, was presented last month.

'Absence of toys'

Her report identified shortcuts to safety processes that have created high risk activity, limited reporting of incidents and "a belief senior management and the board are aware of the working conditions and condone it".

Scrubs suits used in operating theatres were described as "shabby and mismatched."

The report continues: "Some individuals have reported that the working environment is hostile and there are numerous examples of staff feeling pressurised to undertake activities they do not believe are safe."

The units are not welcoming or child-friendly, it states, and there is "a total absence of toys".

The report added: "The perception of mistrust of management and the board is such that there is a widespread feeling of hopelessness that change will ever be achieved.

"It is immediately apparent that responses from theatre staff have centred on a desire to deliver the best possible service and the highest standard of care to patients."

'Increased demand'

But the review also says: "Staff have adopted some high risk practices in order to avoid cancellations; whilst safe outcomes have been maintained, the level of risk is such that urgent action needs to be implemented to avoid an adverse outcome or serious incident."

Following the leaking of the report, the hospital said it was already making changes and was "very proud" of staff.

Ms Shepherd said it had a deep commitment to ensuring "the very best quality of care".

Trust chairman Sir David Henshaw said it was facing "significant challenges which include an increasing demand for services".

"Over the past year we have undertaken a range of measures to address these and make changes within the department."

He said there were now new protocols around staffing, equipment checklists had been strengthened and new scrub suits and toys bought.

The Care Quality Commission (CQC) made an unannounced inspection last month after being directly approached by theatre staff. Its report will be published soon.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



11 °C 6 °C

BBC Local Live

    NEWS on the hour 14:59: BBC Radio Merseyside

    In our bulletin at 15:00:

    • A Merseyside man who made tens of thousands of pounds selling fake custom-made licence plates has escaped a jail sentence
    • The Green Party leader Natalie Bennett has been in Liverpool to launch her party's campaign for next month's European elections
    • Daniel Sturridge remains a big doubt for Liverpool's game at Norwich on Sunday
    Altogether now 14:48:

    The Farm and The Christians will headline a concert at the finish line of the inaugural Liverpool marathon and half marathon on Sunday, 25 May.

    Race director, Rob Griffiths said: "We look forward to bringing Echo Arena to life with epic performances by The Farm and The Christians along with other local bands."

    The Farm the and now
    Police unable to find shopper 14:44:

    Earlier, North West Motorway Police tweeted about reports of an older woman with a shopping trolley on the M62 junction 5 to 6 at Bowring Park. They have been unable to find the woman.

    Green leader with Roger 14:36: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    Green Party leader Natalie Bennett has some interesting things to say about energy production when she was a guest on my show: "We are utterly opposed to fracking," she told me.

    Natalie Bennett

    "One of the reasons why people have to pay such high energy bills is that we have the poorest housing stock in Europe."

    If you missed our interview you can listen again.

    Wood has torn bicep 14:27: Phil Kinsella, BBC Radio Merseyside Sport

    Ahead of this weekend's Super League programme, Warrington coach Tony Smith has told the BBC that prop Paul Wood has a torn bicep, while versatile forward Grix dislocated a shoulder against Hull KR last time out,

    Smith says both players could be out of action for around 10 weeks.

    And full-back Matthew Russell has been given a new four-year contract by Warrington. Russell joined the Wolves on a two-year deal last October.

    coming up 14:20: Billy Butler BBC Radio Merseyside

    The 2012 semi-finalist of Britain's Got Talent Callum Oakley joins us today to tell us about his solo tour starting at the Floral Pavilion on 2 May.

    The 18-year-old comedian has been gigging since the age of 14 and caught the eye of Little Britain star David Walliams, who said he was a star of the future.

    Night view 14:14:

    YO! Liverpool tweets: Liverpool's Anglican Cathedral by YO! Liverpool Flickr member Pete Titchen. Worlds longest & fifth-largest cathedral.

    Liverpool Cathedral
    News on the hour 13:57: BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 14:00 include:

    • The Green Party leader Natalie Bennett has been in Liverpool to launch her party's campaign for next month's European elections
    • An ambitious plan to turn the Churchill Way flyover into an urban park has moved a step closer
    • Liverpool Coroner's court will move from the city's St George's Hall if councillors approve plans next week
    Coroner's court could move 13:46:

    Councillors are recommending that Liverpool Coroner's court is moved from St George's Hall to the former Community Justice Centre in Kirkdale.

    St George's Hall tiled floor

    The proposal is partly a result of the hall's growing success as a venue for a wide range of events including weddings, parties, corporate events and music recitals, which is starting to impact on the coroner's service, Liverpool City Council said.

    A report to the council's Cabinet meeting on Friday is recommending the move.

    Easter Egg-citement 13:27:

    Merseyside Police tweets: Police gave children and staff at Alder Hey Children's Hospital two and a half thousand Easter eggs.

    Police with Easter eggs
    Green leader with Roger 13:10:

    The Green party leader Natalie Bennett is on Roger Phillip's show on BBC Radio Merseyside now.

    Natalie Bennett
    Rogers Live 13:04:

    Liverpool FC tweets: Watch Brendan Rodgers' pre-Norwich City press conference live on LFCTV GO from 1.30pm BST

    Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers
    News on the hour 12:56: BBC Radio Merseyside

    The headlines at 13:00 include:

    • Cheshire police are advising women on nights out to stay with their friends and take extra care after they arrested a man over an alleged sex assault
    • A leading disability charity's urging operators of the country's tourist attractions to make them more accessible
    • The company behind the return of the giant puppets to the streets of Liverpool in the summer's looking for people to be a part of the show itself
    Coming up 12:47: Roger Johnson Presenter, North West Tonight

    On North West Today at 13:30, the Giants are coming back to Liverpool - and the organisers want members of the public to be a part of the show.

    The Queen is in the region today, giving out Maundy Money in Blackburn: it's the first time she's visited the town's Cathedral. And we'll find out what the latest losses for the Co-Op Group might mean for thousands of jobs here.

    St Luke's working group set up 12:41: Claire Hamilton Political reporter, BBC Radio Merseyside

    Last night's full meeting of Liverpool city council confirmed what Mayor Joe Anderson told us earlier this month: A working group will be set up to look at the future of St Luke's and decide on the best way to secure its future. Watch this space!

    St Luke's Church
    Everton Ladies' draw 12:36: Phil Kinsella, BBC Radio Merseyside Sport

    Everton Ladies started their women's super league season with a draw last night, they drew 0-0 in their opening game away at Birmingham

    Tonight, reigning WSL champions Liverpool Ladies begin their defence of the title with a home game against the newly formed Manchester City Ladies

    The match takes place at the Select Security Services stadium In Widnes and kicks off at 19:45.

    Disabled access 12:30: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    A report by charity Vitalise has criticised top tourist attractions for their lack of disabled access. While some on Merseyside have ranked highly others could do better. You don't have to be disabled, it can be tough for the elderly to get around some places. What are your experiences? Get in touch via email, Facebook or Twitter.

    Slow on viaduct 12:21:

    There's very slow traffic in both directions on the M6 in Cheshire on the Thelwall viaduct, between junction 20, the Lymm interchange and junction 21, for Woolston. The delays are due to roadworks in the area.

    More travel news here.

    In the army now 12:15: Simon Moffatt Reporter, BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been meeting some of the more than 300 army cadets from across the country who're taking part in a parade and musical demonstration at Altcar training camp in Formby.

    Army cadets

    It's the 10th year it's been held there and is part of a week-long series of events.

    News on the hour 11:58: BBC Radio Merseyside

    The main headlines at 12:00:

    • The South Korean coastguard has suggested it is possible some people could still be alive trapped in air-pockets inside the ferry which sank 24 hours ago
    • Cheshire police are advising women on nights out to stay with their friends and take extra care after they arrested a man over an alleged sex assault
    • A new report finds some tourist attractions are failing visitors with disabilities
    How MPs get name checked 11:48:

    There can't be a much better feeling as a backbench MP than being namechecked (in a good way) during a high-profile Commons occasion.

    The Queen tends not to get involved in such detailed matters when opening Parliament, so the next best thing would be a pat on the back from the chancellor during the Budget.

    Body thought to be missing student 11:41: BBC News

    A body found in the River Mersey in Liverpool is believed to be that of a missing Leeds student, according to West Yorkshire Police.

    Aamir Qudeer, 21, was last seen in Liverpool on 26 February, after he had been reported missing from Bradford.

    Coming up 11:36: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    Also, would we work better if we had a four-day weekend? Work is important, but so is fun. In a world of mobile phones and drones, people are right to wonder why they are still working so hard. The past century saw huge technological advances and yet there hasn't been a corresponding increase in leisure time: people are working as hard as ever.

    The Easter break lasts for four days; couldn't every weekend be like this?

    And The Catholic Church in England and Wales has turned down a request by church members for the results of a survey on sexual ethics, commissioned by Pope Francis, to be made public.

    Our Religious Affairs Correspondent Robert Piggott has been to Liverpool to meet Catholics who've struggled with what they say are outdated rules.

    coming up 11:33: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    Today, I'm looking at pensions as pensioners may be given estimates of how long they have left to live to help them manage their savings, according to the Pensions minister.

    Steve Webb says people often "underestimate how long they're going to live" and this advice would help them decide how much they need to be saving. He's promised that the plans would not be "crass and insensitive" .

    But do you want someone to tell you when you're going to die?

    Two men arrested 11:17:

    Cheshire Police tweets: 2 males arrested from the Widnes area earlier on suspicion of going equipped to steal (FCC) -

    NEWS on the hour 10:57: BBC Radio Merseyside

    The main headlines at 11:00:

    • The Co-op Group has announced the worst results in its 150-year history
    • A Runcorn man's been arrested by detectives investigating a serious sexual assault in the town
    • An ambitious plan to turn one of Liverpool's concrete eyesores into an urban park are moving a step closer
    Walton sextuplets 10:44: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    Like me I'm sure lots of you will have followed the lives of the Walton sextuplets on TV - they were the world's first surviving sextuplets.

    Walton sextuplets

    We've watched them grow up in a number of documentaries, the picture below is from a BBC one in 2001, and the latest programme on tonight sees the girls turn 30.

    I've been chatting to their parents Janet and Graham. Get in touch via Facebook, Twitter or email us at

    Anfield expansion 10:34: Liverpool Echo

    Liverpool FC chairman Tom Werner believes another "important step" has been taken towards expanding Anfield after a legal agreement was signed with Liverpool City Council and Your Housing Group.

    Shankley gates at Anfield

    The 'heads of terms' document paves the way for the proposed £260million scheme to regenerate the Anfield area.

    Band camp 10:27:

    North West of England and the Isle of Man Reserve Forces tweets: @bbcmerseyside reporting live from the Cadet Force Band Camp at Altcar Training Camp 0825hrs @CadetForceBands #cfb #inspiretoachieve

    If you missed it you can listen again on BBC Radio Merseyside.

    What do you think? 10:21:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    NEWS on the hour 09:59: BBC Radio Merseyside

    The main headlines at 10:00:

    • A Runcorn man's been arrested by detectives investigating a serious sexual assault in the town
    • The company behind the return of the giant puppets to the streets of Liverpool in the summer is looking for people to be a part of the show
    • Everton boss Roberto Martinez says he remains encouraged about his side's chances of securing a top-four finish despite the 3-2 home defeat to Crystal Palace
    Youth music 09:55: Jerry Chester BBC News, North West

    Really proud of my daughter who's part of the National Youth Orchestra - they're playing their first ever concert in Liverpool tonight at the Philharmonic Hall.

    Tilly Chester on a bus

    Tilly Chester tweets: On the coach on the way to the first @NYOGB concert in liverpool :-)

    New cycle storage 09:39: St Helens Star
    Latest updates
    • Serious sex assault: Man arrested in Runcorn
    • Concrete eyesore: Urban parks plan
    • Listen: BBC Radio Merseyside
    Puppet Pals 09:29:

    The company behind a giant puppet event in Liverpool marking 100 years since World War One have started to "recruit an army" of locals for the show.

    There are 120 roles up for grabs, which Royal De Luxe said are open to "physically fit" adults.

    Volunteers for the Liverpool Pals

    They'll be part of the show dedicated to the WW1 Liverpool Pals battalions.

    Woman on motorway 09:21:

    NW Motorway Police tweets: Merseyside NWMPG blue-lighting to reports of an older female with a shopping trolley on the M62 J5-J6 Bowring Park.

    Best buildings 09:15:

    Four Merseyside buildings are up for an award from the Royal Institute of British Architects.

    The contenders are the Carmelite Monastery in West Derby, the new Everyman Theatre, Liverpool Central Library (below), and the Enterprise South Liverpool Academy in Garston.

    Liverpool Central Library

    The awards are announced tonight - what would be your nomination for the best building? Email us at

    Different songs fit 09:04: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    It's funny how two totally different songs can fit together really well! Even after the Beatles had split, they could still be part of each other's music. Earlier, I slowed down Imagine by John Lennon and overlaid it with Wings' Band On The Run.

    NEWS on the hour 08:58: BBC Radio Merseyside

    The main headlines at 09:00:

    • A Runcorn man's been arrested by detectives investigating a serious sexual assault in the town
    • An attack in north Liverpool has left a man with a number of injuries - thought to have been caused by a knife
    • Roberto Martinez insists Everton won't change their approach for the final four games of the season despite their Champions League hopes taking a dent last night
    Sex assault arrest 08:53: BBC Radio Merseyside

    A Runcorn man's been arrested by detectives investigating a serious sexual assault in the town.

    The alleged attack happened near Irwell Lane two weeks ago and the victim was a 26-year-old woman.

    Cheshire police are advising women on nights out to stay with their friends and be conscious of who is walking near to them.

    Everton defeated 08:46:

    Everton handed the initiative back to Arsenal in the race for fourth as their seven-match winning streak ended with a damaging defeat to Crystal Palace.

    Jason Puncheon and Scott Dann

    Defeat means they remain fifth, a point behind the Gunners, with four matches remaining.

    Good morning 08:27: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Good morning! Almost Easter! Working on the pension story today, as we may be given estimates for our date of death so we know how much to save for old age. Would you want to know?

    Also, The Farm and The Christians are named as the headline acts for Liverpool's first Rock n Roll marathon next month.

    Heart start 08:21: Liverpool Echo

    The roll-out of life-saving defibrillators to every school in Wirral is set to begin today.

    The machines will be installed thanks to a donation from the Wirral Schools' Forum, working with Wirral Council and the Oliver King Foundation.

    Travel 08:11:

    BBC Travel News reports Okell Drive in Halewood is closed in both directions between the Church Road junction and the Harrier Drive junction, because of accident investigation work.

    Rather cloudy 08:10:

    BBC Weather says It'll be a rather cloudy day with some patchy rain and drizzle at times, especially in the morning. This afternoon it'll get drier and brighter.

    Good morning all 08:00:

    It's Jerry Chester here with Thursday's news, sport, travel and weather updates for Merseyside. If you'd like to share your comments or pictures, send them to or tweet us at @bbcmerseyside



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ChildMovie magic

    What do the similarities in children's movies reveal about cinema - and us?


  • A motorised skateboadThe Travel Show Watch

    The motorised skateboard which can reach speeds of 17mph (27 km/h) and other travel technology

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.