Hillsborough disaster: Bells rung to mark anniversary

The crowd at Anfield fell silent to mark the moment the match was halted

Bells have been rung 96 times across Merseyside to mark the 25th anniversary of the Hillsborough disaster.

The bells of Liverpool's Anglican Cathedral, Liverpool Town Hall and churches in Merseyside rang at 15:06 BST during a one-minute silence.

It marked the moment Liverpool's FA Cup semi-final at the Sheffield ground was halted on 15 April 1989 after a crush that led to the deaths of 96 fans.

An annual memorial service was held at Anfield stadium.

Seats left empty

Campaigner Margaret Aspinall, chair of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, and other families of victims were clapped as they arrived for the service.

96 seats with scarves draped over them A seat was left empty and draped with a football scarf for each Liverpool fan who died

Fans, players and club officials also gathered in the ground. Ninety-six seats, which were draped in scarves, were left empty.

The service began with the singing of the hymn, Abide With Me, which is synonymous with the FA Cup and has been sung at every final since 1927. It was also recorded as part of a charity single in memory of the victims in 1989.

A ring of lights called the Band of Life, with each light inscribed with the name of a victim, was lit as the names of those who died were read out by the Reverend Kelvin Bolton, the Reverend David Smith and Father Stephen Maloney.

The Band of Life As each name was read out, a light was lit on the Band of Life sculpture

A minute's silence followed, which Rev Bolton ended with the words "a time never to forget".

Taking the first reading, Everton manager Roberto Martinez said he was was only 15 when the disaster happened and that "as a family, we couldn't believe the pain and horror".

He said he was there representing his club, adding that "Everton remembers - we always will".

The service was also screened at Everton's ground, Goodison Park, for fans to pay their respects.

Roberto Martinez, Steven Gerrard, Daniel Agger, Luis Suarez, Daniel Sturridge, Kenny Dalglish, Ian Rush and others Everton manager Roberto Martinez (top left) sat among Liverpool players past and present

Martinez was followed by Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers, who said that while "you don't struggle for inspiration [at] this great football club, the single biggest source for me is when I arrive each match day and see the Hillsborough memorial".

Speaking to the families of the victims, Rodgers said they had "all stood for 25 years together [and] the love for the people you lost inspires me every day as manager".

"I really do feel inadequate in your company. You will never walk alone."

Standing ovations

Many aspects of today's service felt the same as the service did five years ago for the 20th anniversary.

The 96 names were recited then, as now. The Kop was full then, as it was today.

But in every other sense, today's service was different.

When Andy Burnham spoke in 2009, he was heckled by a lone cry of "Justice for the 96", which spread throughout the Kop.

This year when he spoke, it was to a very different reception - applause filled the stadium.

With new inquests under way, the justice process is ongoing.

This year's commemorations were tinged with a feeling of hope and optimism for the future.

Leigh MP Andy Burnham, who had been booed at a Hillsborough memorial service in 2009 while delivering a speech as Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport, thanked the families of the victims.

In a speech which saw several standing ovations for the people he mentioned, including campaigner Anne Williams who died shortly after the memorial service last April, he said he had asked his mother what he should speak about.

He said she "told me to wish you all the best for the league and to say how fitting it would be if you won it in this of all years".

He also praised former Liverpool manager Kenny Dalglish for his work with the families over the last 25 years, adding, "what leadership, what loyalty he has shown on your behalf".

Trevor Hicks, the president of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, said the 25 years since the disaster had been "a very long road".

'Spirit of 96'

Mr Hicks, who lost two daughters at Hillsborough, thanked Liverpool Football Club for their support and the Hillsborough Independent Panel.

Trevor Hicks, father: "The families of the 96 - we did it... we made it all happen"

"The spirit of the 96 burns in our hearts and drives us on," he said.

He also paid tribute to the families of the victims, who he said had "made it all happen".

"We stood together. We pulled, we pushed, we refused to lie down, we refused to go away, which is something that annoyed an awful lot of people."

His words were echoed by Mrs Aspinall, whose son died at the Sheffield stadium.

She said the families had been "fighting for 25 years".

"No matter how much dirt they tried to throw at us, Liverpudlians, Scousers, we don't lie down and take it."

Their speeches were followed by a rendition of You'll Never Walk Alone, led by the singer Gerry Marsden, during which 96 balloons were released.

The service ended with the crowd singing You'll Never Walk Alone

In Sheffield, the city's cathedral held a two-minute silence at 15:07 BST.

At the Hillsborough ground, a short service and a wreath-laying ceremony also took place at the memorial garden and the stadium was opened to allow people to lay flowers and remember those who died at the match against Nottingham Forest.

A minute's silence was observed at Old Market Square in Nottingham for the victims.

Hillsborough memorial service A memorial service was held at the monument at Hillsborough

Scarves from every club in the top four divisions were laid on the pitch to create a number 96 at Anfield as a "sign of unity" for the service, a spokesman for Liverpool said.

Liverpool mayor Joe Anderson said the city "will never forget those who died at Hillsborough, and this is a day for us to unite and remember each and every supporter and the friends and families left behind".

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

Tuesday's events follow a weekend of tributes to the 96 fans, which saw wreaths left at Anfield's and Hillsborough's memorials to those who died and football matches in leagues across England kick-off seven minutes late.

The commemorations come as fresh inquests into the deaths of the fans are held in Warrington. The inquests have been adjourned until 22 April.

They were ordered after the original accidental death inquest verdicts were quashed in 2012 following an independent report.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



Min. Night 4 °C

BBC Local Live

    18:00: Good night

    That's all for Local Live for the night. The service returns at 08:00 on Tuesday. You can still reach the team by emailing merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk

    17:54: Coming up on North West Tonight Roger Johnson Presenter, North West Tonight

    An inquest in Liverpool had heard that doctors and social workers could not have predicted that a mentally ill man would kill his mother.

    Leslie Gadsby stabbed Edna Gadsby to death in 2010. He's now serving a sentence for manslaughter at a secure hospital.

    Watch more on BBC One at 18:30.

    17:48: Tranmere setback Mike Hughes BBC Radio Merseyside Sport

    There was another setback for Tranmere Rovers at the weekend, as they lost 2-1 to Southend United.

    Micky Adams

    Manager Micky Adams said: "I think that perhaps the effects of not having won for an enormous amount of time in the league is adding to the pressure on [the team's] shoulders."

    17:38: Accident on M6

    There are reports of a three-car accident and lane closure on the M6 northbound between Junction 20 (Lymm Interchange) and Junction 21 (Woolston).

    17:35: Soldier's chart hopes Chester Chronicle

    A soldier from Chester hopes his band can use military muscle to defy the odds by claiming number one chart spot this Christmas.

    17:30: Chester train accident report Chris Long BBC News

    A train's safety sand was released too late to deal with leaves and oily rails and stop it hitting a Chester Station platform, a report has found.

    Train crashes into barrier

    The Virgin train, travelling from London Euston to Chester, hit a barrier after pulling in to the station in November 2013.

    The Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB) found its emergency sanding equipment was used when it was too close to the platform. No-one was injured in the crash.

    17:25: Runcorn rape appeal

    Detectives are trying to help trace a couple who helped a rape victim who was attacked 24 years ago in Runcorn.

    The teenager, who was 15 at the time, was attacked at a house in Halton Road.

    She managed to escape and flag down a passing car. A couple in their early 20s took her home and the young woman helped her to the door as she wanted to tell her parents.

    However, the victim made her leave as she didn't want her parents to know. Anyone who can help should contact Cheshire Police on 101.

    17:11: Elderly man dies in fire Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    An 88-year-old man has died in a fire at a house in St. Helens.

    Fire crews were called to the blaze on Samuel Street, St. Helens, at about 11:30 on Friday and realised someone was inside.

    The man's body was found in the living room. An inquest will be held to establish the exact cause of death.

    17:01: Everton 'must keep up hard work' Mike Hughes BBC Radio Merseyside Sport

    Seven games unbeaten now for Everton after the 2-1 victory against West Ham at the weekend.

    Leon Osman

    They're ninth in the Premier League table but only two points off fourth place.

    Saturday's match winner Leon Osman, said: "I think we've been building momentum for a number of weeks. We had three wins and three draws before the international break."

    16:56: News on the hour Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    A young pub worker in Widnes has been dragged into a field, and had a gun pointed at him by robbers.

    They were targeting a venue on Queensbury Way just after midnight last night.

    16:45: Road closure Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    Drivers are being urged to avoid Robins Lane in St. Helens as contractors work to tackle a gas leak.

    The road has been closed near the Bowling Green pub.

    Traffic is being diverted away from Robins Lane at Marina Drive and the New Street mini roundabout.

    16:38: Anti-terror briefings Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Shopping centres, sports stadiums and cinemas across Merseyside are being briefed on how best to spot possible terrorists over Christmas.

    16:28: What do you think? Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live from our base in Liverpool to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    16:19: Clearer and colder Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter

    Turning cloudy across the north of the region, with one or two spots of rain possible and some hill fog in the north.

    BBC Weather

    However, it will stay clearer and colder across Cheshire, with frost and patchy fog in places.

    16:09: Liverpool's struggle for form Mike Hughes BBC Radio Merseyside Sport

    After their fourth defeat in a row, Liverpool are really struggling to find their form.

    Yesterday's 2-1 defeat at Crystal Palace means they've slipped down to 12th in the Premier League table.

    They play Ludogorets in the Champions League in Bulgaria on Wednesday.

    Mother 'loved' killer son 16:04: Paul Burnell BBC News

    A woman who was killed by her mentally ill son, "never lost her love" for him, a coroner said.

    Leslie Gadsby

    Liverpool Coroner Andre Rebello recorded a verdict of unlawful killing on Edna Gadsby, 70, who was stabbed by her son Leslie in March 2010.

    Gadsby, 39, spent more than two years in a secure unit after killing his father, Arthur, with a hammer in 2004.

    15:59: News on the hour Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    A young pub worker in Widnes has been dragged into a field, and had a gun pointed at him by robbers.

    They were targeting a venue on Queensbury Way just after midnight last night.

    15:50: Armed gang raid pub Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    A pub worker was threatened with a gun and tied up by an armed gang during a raid on a Widnes pub.

    Police said three men grabbed a member of staff at the Observatory pub on Queensbury Way, Widnes, just after midnight.

    He was taken to a nearby field and threatened, before being forced to take the gang to the safe so they could steal some cash. They then tied him up and fled.

    15:37: Coming up on drive Paul Salt BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'll be speaking to the son of a Wirral soldier, who's campaigning for his late father to be recognised for his bravery more than 30 years after his death.

    Cpl Stewart McLaughlin from Wallasey died in the Falklands War in 1982.

    You can listen to BBC Radio Merseyside from 16:00.

    15:28: Oil on line caused crash Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Investigators have concluded a train crashed into barriers at Chester station because of leaves and oil on the line.

    Train crashes into barrier

    A report also says the driver didn't use the emergency equipment in time in November last year.

    The Virgin service partially derailed when it hit the buffers at the end of the platform.

    15:18: Fire service marked in show Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    School children across Cheshire will perform a story of how the fire service evolved over the years.

    Heroes with Grimy Faces show

    Heroes with Grimy Faces at Chester Cathedral will use the cause and consequence of fire incidents over the decades to highlight fire safety issues.

    It will be performed by children from Warrington, Culcheth, Ellesmere Port, Macclesfield and Runcorn on Tuesday.

    15:00: News on the hour Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    An inquest's heard doctors could not have predicted a mentally ill Liverpool man would kill his mother, despite killing his father six years before.

    Leslie Gadsby stabbed Edna to death in 2010.

    14:48: Vital roof work continues Runcorn & Widnes Weekly News

    Work has progressed on the second stage of a vital roof restoration project at the oldest church in Widnes.

    14:42: Tunnel facelift Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    The Mersey Tunnels are used by 25m vehicles each year, and now one of them is to benefit from an £8m investment.

    Wallasey Tunnel

    The Kingsway - or Wallasey - Tunnel is to be rewired and lighting will be replaced for the first time in its 40-year history.

    The project will be funded by money set aside from the Mersey Tunnel Toll.

    14:25: Winter carousel

    This vivid carousel in Liverpool city centre is part of Liverpool One's winter celebrations.


    Do you have a picture you'd like to share? Email merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk.

    14:11: Remembering Edward Rushton

    A city-wide exhibition in Liverpool is paying homage to an 18th Century blind poet and slavery abolitionist.

    A mural of Edward Rushton

    But who is Edward Rushton and why is he being remembered?

    13:59: News on the hour Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    An inquest has heard doctors and social workers could not have predicted that a mentally ill Liverpool man would kill his mother.

    Leslie Gadsby, from Stoneycroft, stabbed his mother Edna to death in 2010 - six years after he killed his father with a hammer.

    13:45: Wonderful listeners Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Toy Appeal. A month before Christmas and you donate sackfuls every day. Wonderful listeners.

    toy appeal
    13:35: Accident closes by-pass

    Upton by-pass is closed in both directions between Greasby Road and Royden Road because of an accident near the cricket club.

    13:24: Coming up on North West Today Roger Johnson Presenter, North West Tonight

    Coming up in the programme, an inquest hears how doctors and social workers could not have predicted a mentally ill man would kill his own mother.

    Leslie Gadsby stabbed his mother Edna to death in 2010. He also killed his own father in 2004, but was released from a secure mental hospital after two years.

    Watch BBC North West Today on BBC One at 13:30.

    13:17: Is Kim right? Will Batchelor, BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm standing in for Roger Phillips today and asking is Kim Cattrall right to get involved in the row over green spaces in Liverpool?

    That`s the phone in this lunchtime until 2. You can call me on 0151 709 9333.

    13:10: Edna Gadsby inquest Andy Gill BBC North West Tonight

    I'm at the inquest of Edna Gadsby at Liverpool coroner's court, who was killed by her son in 2010.

    Her son Leslie was conditionally discharged from a secure hospital in 2006 after an appeal to a mental health tribunal.

    It concluded that his mother was unlawfully killed. Watch more on BBC North West Today on BBC One at 13:30.

    12:59: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    TV star Kim Cattrall has hit back at the Mayor of Liverpool after he criticised her for backing a campaign to save Sefton Park Meadows.

    The Sex and the City actor has called the council's decision to sell off some of the area to housing developers an encroachment "on the people's land."

    12:50: Bridge early warning system Warrington Guardian

    A software development company has launched a rival early warning system to alert motorists of the imminent opening of the swing bridges in Latchford, Stockton Heath and Walton.

    12:40: Star's right to opinion BBC Radio Merseyside

    tweets: NEWS: @KimCattrall tells @joeforliverpool "I don't live or work in "Hollywood" I'm a NY actor Liverpool born & bred I've right to my opinion

    12:30: Mayor hits out at Cattrall Bronwyn Jones BBC North West

    Liverpool Mayor Joe Anderson has hit back at comments from Sex and the City star Kim Cattrall criticising plans to sell Sefton Park Meadows.

    The Liverpool-born actor said developing the area next to the park would "encroach on the people's land".

    12:20: Great being on air

    Yellow Door Artists tweets: Great being on @bbcmerseyside with @dreamStHelens this morning about the work we're doing in #StHelens for @vaengland

    Helen Jones and team
    12:12: Indecent exposures in Chester

    Police are appealing for help after two indecent exposure incidents in Chester over the weekend.

    The first was at 19:30 on Saturday in Westminster Park playing fields as a 52-year-old woman walked near to the cafe.

    The second occurred on Blacon Point Road, Blacon, Chester, early on Sunday.

    11:58: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    There's fresh hope for the family of a Wirral soldier, who are campaigning for him to be recognised for his bravery more than thirty years after his death.

    Cpl Stewart McLaughlin from Wallasey died in the Falklands War in 1982.

    11:43: Edna Gadsby inquest Andy Gill BBC North West Tonight

    tweets: At #Liverpool Coroner's Ct for inquest into death of Edna Gadsby who was killed by her mentally ill son Leslie in 2010. @BBCNWT 1.30

    11:32: What do you think? Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live from our base in Liverpool to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    11:20: Mayor criticises Cattrall Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    Liverpool Mayor Joe Anderson said Kim Cattrall's comments about Sefton Park are "out of context and ill-informed".

    The actress, who lived in Liverpool as a child, supported protests over plans to build homes there.

    Mr Anderson said: "It's all very well for a Hollywood superstar to shout from the sidelines, but what does she really know of the issues that Liverpool faces?

    "I'd be interested to hear what Kim Cattrall has to say on care packages for the elderly and disabled adults, mental health provision, crumbling schools or repairing our roads, for example?"

    11:11: Officer misconduct charges Liverpool Echo
    11:00: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A war of words has broken out between Liverpool's Mayor and Sex and the City star Kim Cattrall after she backed a campaign to save Sefton Park Meadows.

    10:45: NHS workers on strike Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    These NHS workers formed a picket line in Liverpool city centre this morning.

    NHS picket line in Liverpool

    It's the second four-hour strike staff in England and Northern Ireland have held as part of a pay dispute.

    They are protesting about the decision not to implement a 1% rise for all staff recommended by a pay review body.

    10:31: Reds' hopes 'unrealistic' BBC Sport

    Former Manchester United and Everton player Phil Neville says that qualification for the Europa League is Liverpool's best hope for the season.

    Former Manchester United and Everton player Phil Neville

    The Reds, who lost 3-1 to Crystal Palace on Sunday, have finished between sixth and eighth place in four of the last five Premier League campaigns.

    10:21: Girl, nine, hit by car Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    A nine-year-old girl was hit by a car in Walton this morning.

    She was injured along with an 18-year-old man at the junction of Scarisbrick Road and Walton Hall Avenue just after 08:30.

    The girl was taken to Alder Hey to be treated for non-serious injuries.

    10:08: Train delays

    There are delays of up to half an hour on Virgin trains services between London Euston and Liverpool Lime Street, due to a signalling problem at Stafford.

    09:57: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool's Mayor has criticised TV star Kim Cattrall after she backed a campaign to save Sefton Park Meadows.

    The Sex and the City actress was in the city over the weekend and posed for photos at the site where new homes will be built.

    09:50: Bellew's next move Phil Kinsella, BBC Radio Merseyside

    After beating Nathan Cleverly in their grudge fight at the weekend, it is being claimed today Tony Bellew's next move will not be a world title bout but a switch to Hollywood.

    Nathan Cleverly's (R) defeat against Tony Bellew (L) was his second loss in 30 professional fights

    Reports suggest the Liverpool boxer, pictured on the right with his rival, has landed a major role in the Rocky spin-off Creed.

    The film will chronicle the boxing career of Apollo Creed's grandson and will be filmed in Las Vegas.

    09:40: Cyclist injured in crash Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    A cyclist is critically ill after he crashed into a parked van in north Liverpool last night.

    The 28-year-old was on his way home from work when the incident happened on Breck Road, Walton, at 21:45.

    09:31: Guitar fails to sell Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    The guitar played by John Lennon when the Beatles recorded Paperback Writer has failed to sell at auction.

    John Lennon

    It was expected to go for as much as £600,000, but failed to reach the £400,000 reserve on Sunday.

    09:21: Rodgers accepts blame BBC Sport

    Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers has accepted full responsibility for his team's stuttering run of form.

    Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers

    Last season's runners-up slumped to a third straight Premier League defeat at Crystal Palace, losing 3-1.

    09:14: Sun up at Otterspool

    This stunning sunrise was captured in Otterspool by Sean Robertson this morning.


    We love to see your pictures from around the region, and you can send them in on email, Facebook or Twitter.

    09:07: Lanterns for Erick Jimmy McCracken BBC Radio Merseyside

    I was in Fazakerley on Saturday when hundreds of people gathered at Field Lane Park to remember Erick Maina.


    The 15-year-old was found dead at his home last week. The event raised money for Marie Curie cancer research.

    08:58: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Merseyside's chief constable wants surveillance powers for police to be updated so they can keep up with criminals and terrorists who use the internet to avoid detection.

    Sir Jon Murphy is outlining his views in a debate at Liverpool John Moores University later on the Surveillance Society.

    08:51: Picket line at Arrowe Park Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm at Arrowe Park Hospital where a four-hour strike is underway. I've been speaking to a midwife who is also a union rep.

    picket line at Arrowe Park Hospital
    08:39: Kim Cattrall's park plea Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Actress Kim Cattrall used a visit to Liverpool over the weekend to back a campaign to save Sefton Park Meadows.

    Kim Cattrall in Sefton Park

    High-quality housing is to be built in the area but the city council's come under fire from green campaigners for selling off the area near Park Avenue.

    08:29: Bus lanes reinstated Tom Mullen BBC News Online

    Four bus lanes in Liverpool have been reinstated after a suspension lasting more than a year.

    Bus on bus lane in Liverpool

    The lanes, all in the city centre, will be the only routes to remain in use after Liverpool City Council decided not to use the others.

    08:14: Oldest hockey player claim Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    A man from Merseyside believes he may have set a world record for the oldest hockey player.

    Robert Adams

    Robert Adams, 84, played a full 70 minutes for West Derby Hockey Club's third team against Golborne in the North West Hockey League on Saturday.

    08:07: Fine and sunny Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter

    A cold and crisp start, with frost and perhaps some fog for a time.

    BBC Weather grab

    A fine day will follow with plenty of sunshine and light winds. Temperatures falling sharply after dusk, although cloud increasing across Cumbria later. Check the forecast near you.

    08:00: Good morning Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    Hello and welcome to the start of the week. I'm here with all your news, sport, travel and weather updates from across Merseyside today. If you'd like to get in touch, you can contact me on email, Facebook and Twitter.



Elsewhere on the BBC


  • Ebola patients in Sierra LeoneHARDtalk Watch

    Dr Geraldine O'Hara recalls the horrors of working on the Ebola frontline in Sierra Leone

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.