Hillsborough Wikipedia changes inquiry 'challenging'

Hillsborough memorial Ninety-six Liverpool football fans died after a crush at the Hillsborough stadium in 1989

Identifying who made offensive changes to a Wikipedia page about the Hillsborough disaster "may prove challenging", ministers have said.

The government said a full inquiry led by Cabinet Office Permanent Secretary Richard Heaton was under way.

It came after the Liverpool Echo said Whitehall computers on a secure government network were used.

The Cabinet Office said the "sickening" changes were "in complete contravention of the Civil Service Code".

'All relevant material'

A Cabinet Office statement said "important stakeholders" including the Hillsborough Family Support Group, the Hillsborough Justice Campaign and the All Party Parliamentary Group on the Hillsborough Disaster would be kept updated of developments.

How the source was uncovered

Liverpool Echo front page
  • Wikipedia allows any web user to make changes to its pages, but this leaves a trace through the user's internet protocol (IP) address
  • Changes are monitored by Wikipedia, but internet trolls have been known to post insulting material, which is usually swiftly removed
  • Liverpool Echo reporter Oliver Duggan discovered that insults posted on the website's Hillsborough Disaster page had been made using computers within the government's internal intranet
  • He confirmed this after referring to a list of 34 IP addresses used by the government released by former minister Angela Eagle in 2008

A spokesman said Andy Burnham MP, who "has a deserved status as an expert on the disaster", would be given the chance to "view all relevant material from the very outset so that he can assure himself all steps have been taken".

The statement said: "The amendments made to Wikipedia are sickening. The behaviour is in complete contravention of the Civil Service Code. It is entirely unacceptable.

"At this time, we have no reason to suspect that the Hillsborough edits involve any particular department, nor more than one or two individuals in 2009 and 2012.

"As the first incident happened five years ago and there are hundreds of thousands of people on the government's network, it may prove challenging to identify who was involved, but we are exhausting every option."

Mr Burnham said it was "sickening and appalling to think that people in government are aiming this kind of abuse at the Liverpool supporters - particularly the victims and survivors of that tragedy".

He said that "a full and proper inquiry [to] find the name of the individual or individuals responsible" needed to happen, adding that they must then be "held accountable - nothing else will do".

Mr Burnham, during his time as Culture, Media and Sport Secretary, was instrumental in a campaign to have classified documents about the disaster released, which led to the formation of the Hillsborough Independent Panel.

Liverpool anthem

Oliver Duggan, the Liverpool Echo reporter who broke the story, said the paper used a list of 34 internet protocol (IP) addresses for Whitehall computers.

These were released in 2008 by Angela Eagle MP following a parliamentary question to "match up" the addresses with those used to edit the Wikipedia page about the disaster.

The newspaper said the alterations to the page included the Liverpool anthem You'll Never Walk Alone being altered to You'll Never Walk Again and the phrase "Blame Liverpool Fans" being added to a paragraph.

line break
Wikipedia edit for Hillsborough disaster page on 15 April 2009 A Wikipedia edit on the 20th anniversary of the disaster added the words 'Blame Liverpool Fans'
line break

Steve Rotheram, the MP for Liverpool Walton, echoed Mr Burnham's remarks and said he and a group of Merseyside MPs would be writing to the government to ask that any inquiry "be swift".

Sheila Coleman, spokeswoman for the Hillsborough Justice Campaign, said the group would be talking to its legal team about "how to proceed".

Ms Eagle, the MP for Wallasey, said the claims were "pretty shocking" and were "another problem for [the families] having to deal with the grief".

Entries in Wikipedia, an online encyclopaedia, can be edited by anyone with access to the internet.

Jon Davies, chief executive of Wikimedia UK, said it was "appalled by such vandalism".

Ninety-six Liverpool football fans died after a crush at an FA Cup semi-final at the Sheffield ground on 15 April 1989.

New inquests, which are ongoing, were ordered after fresh evidence revealed by the Hillsborough Independent Panel led to the original inquest verdicts being quashed.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



15 °C 11 °C

BBC Local Live

    News on the hour 15:03: Lucinda Moore BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Home Secretary has said she's going to cap the amount of money retired police officers can claim for legal representation at the Hillsborough Inquests.

    Listen live at BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Lib Dems back safe standing stadiums 14:56: BBC Sport

    The Liberal Democrats want to change the law and allow Premier League and Championship clubs to introduce safe standing at stadiums.

    The Liberal Democrats have put forward plans for fans to be allowed to stand at top-flight football matches.

    The party has confirmed it plans to make the pledge as part of its 2015 General Election manifesto.

    Martinez cools down 14:47:

    Everton FC tweets: Roberto Martinez takes the #IceBucketChallenge and nominates Bill Kenwright, Martin Tyler and his PA Sue Palmer.

    On air 14:35: Billy Butler BBC Radio Merseyside

    Band TJ & Murphy play live for us today ahead of their gig this evening. Listen live at BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Grayson Perry protest 14:25:

    Disabled artists in Leeds are going up against Grayson Perry by staging their own exhibition in protest against the venue for his show in the city.

    Grayson Perry's The Vanity of Small Differences

    Perry's The Vanity of Small Differences - which has been on show in Liverpool - is on display at Temple Newsam House, but the venue is not fully accessible.

    So eight disabled artists are putting on their own rival textiles exhibition.

    Medical for £16m Balotelli 14:08: BBC Sport

    AC Milan striker Mario Balotelli is flying to England for a medical as talks continue over his proposed £16m move to Liverpool.

    With a fee agreed, the Reds are set to offer 24-year-old Balotelli nearly £120,000 a week to move to Anfield.

    The deal will not be done in time for the Italian to make his debut against former club Manchester City on Monday.

    News on the hour 13:59: Lucinda Moore BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Home Secretary has revealed she's going to cap the amount of money retired police officers can claim for legal representation at the Hillsborough Inquests.

    Coming up 13:41: BBC Radio Merseyside

    It's Will Bachelor today sitting in for Roger Phillips - and he is talking about the crisis in Iraq and Mario Balotelli's planned move to Liverpool and can there be safe standing at football stadiums?

    Give me a call on 0151 7099333 and listen live to BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Coming up 13:21: BBC North West Tonight

    We will bring you the latest on the sentencing of a couple over a counterfeit alcohol scam in St Helens where more than 800 bottle of counterfeit booze were seized from White House Pub - some not fit for human consumption.

    Watch more on BBC One at 13:30.

    Stage set at Sefton 13:07: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    Here's a picture of the stage for the Liverpool International Music Festival's Summer Jam which kicks off tonight at Sefton Park.

    Sefton Park

    Thousands are expected over the next three days for the free event.

    I spoke to Ian Broudie earlier and he says he cant wait to perform with the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra with whom he played a well-received concert in April.

    News on the hour 12:57: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    There are reports this lunchtime that Liverpool have agreed personal terms with Mario Balotelli's agent and the striker's now on a plane heading for Merseyside.

    Listen live to the bulletin on BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Rhys Jones' mum: 'No lessons learnt' 12:36: Liverpool Echo

    The mum of murdered schoolboy Rhys Jones says she doesn't think any lessons have been learnt since he died on the seventh anniversary of his death.

    Balotelli: 'Great asset' 12:22:

    BBC Radio 1 and 1Xtra DJ Charlie Sloth thinks new signing Mario Balotelli could bring some "explosive" action to the pitch and become a "great asset" to the team.

    Mario Balotelli

    The self-proclaimed "massive Liverpool fan" said: "Mario Balotelli is constantly getting a bad rep in the press, but we don't look at the positive things he's done."

    What do you think about the signing? Please send us your comments via email, Facebook or Twitter.

    Fees top £5m 12:09: Liverpool Echo

    Legal fees for former police officers being represented at the Hillsborough inquests have topped £5m, it emerged today.

    News on the hour 11:58: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool will resume talks with Mario Balotelli's representatives over the terms of his proposed £16m move from AC Milan.

    Listen live to the bulletin on BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Lineker on Match of the Day at 50 11:46:

    Ex Everton player, pundit and presenter Gary Lineker says Match of the Day - which celebrates its 50th birthday - is "more than a TV show, it is a national institution".

    Gary Lineker on the Match of the Day set in 2000

    He said the programme has played an amazing part in his whole life. Tell us what MOTD means to you on email, Facebook or Twitter.

    A5038 roadworks 11:35:

    There is one lane closed on the A5038 Southport Road in Bootle between the Mons traffic lights and the Oxford Road junction because of roadworks.

    Hunt for attempted robber of bookies 11:30:

    Merseyside Police tweet: Detectives in Edge Hill are appealing for witnesses following an attempted robbery at a bookmakers on Wednesday.

    At around 11.45am, police were called to William Hill on Durning Road to reports of a masked man entering the premises attempting to demand cash.

    Salt on the rocks 11:14: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    Beatles promoter Sam Leech told me some great stories this morning.

    Sam Leach (bottom) with John Lennon (top) and George Harrison

    He talked about being sacked for being the world's worst drummer, how Stuart Sutcliffe didn't speak to him for a week when he plugged his guitar in during a gig and how he put salt in John Lennon's whisky.

    Listen again to BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Oil spill on A41 11:04: BBC Radio Merseyside

    There are hazardous driving conditions on the A41 New Chester Road at M53 junction 5 at Eastham due to an oil spillage.

    News on the hour 10:59: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Opponents of Tranmere Rovers proposal to sell training fields to fund a new facility in Leasowe have told us the fight's not over even though Wirral council's approved the plans.

    Get the full story at 11:00 on BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Must go destinations 10:51: via Facebook

    Helen Jones who is sitting in for Sean Styles is asking for your must go destinations as fans flock to Liverpool for the Beatles festival.

    Donna Jackson has posted on facebook: "Round the corner from Mendips is St Peter's Church Hall, where John and Paul first met.

    "It's open for Beatle Week today, tomorrow and Monday. Please come and say hello!"

    Coming up 10:43: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm standing in for Sean Styles this morning and on day three of the International Beatleweek Festival I am talking to Beatles promoter Sam Leach.

    Listen live to BBC Radio Merseyside.

    M62 and A5080 delays 10:33:

    BBC Travel says one lane is closed on the A5080 Bowring Park Road at the M62 junction 4 in Liverpool between the Rocket junction and the A5058 Queens Drive Wavertree because of an accident involving two cars.

    Rick Astley on Mr Smith's demolition 10:20: Warrington Guardian

    Eighties crooner Rick Astley has criticised the likely demolition of Mr Smith's which he called a 'special venue'.

    Rick Astley
    Top headlines
    International Beatleweek Festival 10:06:

    Fab Four fans from across the globe are in Liverpool for International Beatleweek Festival.

    The Beatles

    There are bands from over 20 countries in the city for the event - and fans from more than 40 countries.

    Fans include a party of Australians who've also visited Hamburg as part of a pilgrimage to mark the 50th anniversary of the group's tour Down Under.

    Are you part of it? I'd love to see your pictures so please send us your photos from International Beatleweek Festival via email, Facebook or Twitter.

    News on the hour 09:58: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Four men are being questioned about two robberies in under half an hour on Merseyside last night.

    The first happened at the co-op shop on Warrington Road in Rainhill 19:05. Then there was a report of another 25 minutes later in Maghull's Bargain Booze on Liverpool Road.

    Listen live to the bulletin on BBC Radio Merseyside.

    On air 09:40: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    We're talking to Ian Broudie of the Lightning Seeds about playing with the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra at Sefton Park later.

    Ian Broudie

    Listen live on BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Gazza in hospital 09:29: Liverpool Echo

    Former England and Everton FC star Paul Gascoigne was being treated in hospital today as he faces being made homeless following another drinking binge.

    Paul Gascoigne
    Liverpool International Music Festival facts 09:17:
    • The LIMF started last summer replacing the popular but increasingly costly Mathew Street festival
    • This year's free extravaganza features 150 live acts from over 20 countries over two weeks
    • The three-day Summer Jam at Sefton Park features five stages
    • Boy George, Ian Brodie and the Lightning See, Tim Burgess, Kid Creole and The Farm are amongst the LIMF line-up
    Coming up 09:06: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    We're getting all the build up ahead of the start of the Liverpool International Music Festival at Sefton Park.

    Yaw  Owusu LIMF music curator

    We're speaking to Yaw Owusu the music curator as well as Ian Broudie from the Lighhtning Seeds who is playing the park with the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra.

    Listen live on BBC Radio Merseyside

    News on the hour 08:58: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Liverpool International Music Festival arrives in Sefton Park later where five stages have been constructed for the weekend.

    More than 150 live acts will play across the city over the next two weeks.

    Listen live to bulletins on BBC Radio Merseyside.

    B5194 closed 08:39:

    The B5194 Stockbridge Lane in Huyton-With-Roby is closed in both directions between the M57 junction and the Park Way junction because of resurfacing work.

    From Suarez to Balotelli 08:28: BBC Sport

    After selling one of the most controversial players in the history of English football for £75m, you could forgive the powers-that-be at Liverpool for playing it safe for a while.

    Mario Balotelli and Luis Suarez

    Instead, the Reds are seeking to replace Luis Suarez with Mario Balotelli - a man once dubbed "unmanageable" by Jose Mourinho who tried to do just that when they were at Inter Milan together.


    Liverpool's International Music Festival starts tonight with a star studded concert at St George's Hall.

    Boy George

    Steve Levine's Assembly Point Sessions will see Boy George, Bernard Butler and Tim Burgess taking to the stage alongside some new up and coming artists.

    There will also be 120 acts playing at Sefton Park for over the bank holiday weekend.

    Sunny spells 08:06:

    BBC Weather says it is mostly dry and fine today, with frequent sunny spells, although isolated showers remain possible throughout. Feeling cool, especially when exposed to the fresh north westerly breeze.

    BBC Weather forecast

    Let's hope the sun holds out for the Liverpool International Music Festival which starts in Sefton Park later.

    News on the hour 08:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Four men are being questioned about two robberies in under half an hour on Merseyside last night.

    The first happened at the co-op shop on Warrington Road in Rainhill at 19:05. Then there was a report of another 25 minutes later in Maghull's Bargain Booze on Liverpool Road.

    Listen live to the bulletin on BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Good morning 08:00: Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    Hello! I'm here to bring you all the news, sport, weather and travel news across Merseyside and get you in the mood for the weekend.

    Please get involved by tweeting us, emailing us, or posting on our Facebook page.



Elsewhere on BBC News

  • bikeWheels of change

    Ten new bikes that are reinventing the humble two-wheeler for the 21st Century


  • Hitch-hiking robot HitchBOTClick Watch

    Hitch-hiking robot HitchBOT completes a 6,000km (3,700-mile) trip plus other tech news

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.