Hillsborough police officer 'raised stadium access concerns'

The Hillsborough disaster Ninety-six fans died as a result of the crush at the 1989 FA Cup semi-final

A South Yorkshire police officer raised concerns about access at the Hillsborough stadium three years before a fatal crush developed at the ground.

At new inquests into the tragedy, former superintendent Terence Stuart was shown a police memo highlighting problems over access to the ground.

Mr Stuart had helped draft a letter to Sheffield City Council giving the stadium "a clean bill of health".

He said he had not seen the memo before but it merited "very serious action".

The memo was written in June 1986 by Insp Clive Calvert to the head of the force's F Division, Ch Supt Brian Mole.

Insp Calvert was the police force's liaison officer with Sheffield Wednesday at the time and attended meetings of the officer working party, the committee which oversaw the club's safety certificate.

'Absolutely stunning'

In the memo, he "highlighted various topics" which had been raised with the football club "with very little success".

It said: "One of the greatest problems we have is access to the ground, particularly at the Leppings Lane end.

"The redesigned turnstiles do not give anything like the access to the ground, either on the Leppings Lane Terraces or in the West Stand, needed by away fans.

"On occasions last season when large numbers attended we had away supporters who were justifiably irate because of the inefficiency of the system, which was turned on the police and could have resulted in public disorder."

The Leppings Lane end of Hillsborough was where all of the Liverpool fans that died as a result of the crush on 15 April 1989 had accessed the ground.

Mr Stuart said he found the document "absolutely stunning".

"Surely the chief superintendent of that division should have brought it to the attention of the officers who were meeting regularly for this and ensured that it got some attention," he said.

"Why it hasn't I've not got a clue but it should have had.

"It should have been brought to the attention of all the people that attended the safety of Sports Grounds meetings.

"That's what we are there for, so it should go to that."

'Clean bill of health'

Mr Stuart was involved in drafting a reply to Sheffield City Council after the authority, in November 1986, asked for the police force's opinion on Hillsborough, in relation to the Safety of Sports Grounds Act 1975.

He told the jury he could not recall the letter but accepted that he had not heard Insp Calvert's views on the access into the ground before it was sent.

Referring to the memo, Jonathan Hough QC, junior counsel to the inquests, said: "It may be suggested in a properly run system, when asked to produce a document of this kind giving a clean bill of health to the stadium, from your point of view, you should have spoken to Inspector Calvert."

Mr Stuart said: "Well, I should, providing I know what he is doing."

Fiona Barton QC, representing South Yorkshire Police, showed documents to the jury which appeared to show the force consulting with the club about some concerns.

One of them illustrated how Sheffield Wednesday's engineers were asked to investigate the turnstiles at Leppings Lane, but could not find a solution.

She said: "The '86 memo from Calvert has given rise to discussions about the adequacy and efficacy of the turnstiles.

"Concerns that had been raised by the police had been taken to the club and looked at by the surveyors who came up with no answer."

Mr Stuart replied: "That appears to be the case."

After seeing those documents, Mr Hough asked Mr Stuart: "The fact remains Mr Calvert raised a concern about the turnstile access, nothing was done about it, but a clean bill of health was still given?"

Mr Stuart replied: "Yes."

The new inquests in Warrington are being held to investigate how 96 Liverpool fans died as a result of the Hillsborough disaster.

The hearing continues.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool

Weather

Liverpool

27 °C 17 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    hot in the city 14:06:

    Earlier, we asked you for your tips about cooling down.

    On Twitter, Andy Lyon says: Ice lolly

     
  2.  
    news on the hour 14:04: Graham Whyte BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our headlines at 14:00 include:

    • An Elvis Presley impersonator from Southport who downloaded and distributed indecent images of children has been jailed for a year
    • A report has criticised Scotland Yard for keeping information about the campaigns run by the bereaved families of 18 people
    • The Hillsborough inquests has heard ambulance staff at the ground on the day of the disaster could have gone into the stadium on foot
     
  3.  
    Giant typo 13:49: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    I spotted this sign in a car park. Spot the typographical errors in the dates and wording!

    Q Car park
     
  4.  
    Strange things in Albert Dock 13:36:

    Giant Spectacular tweets: Strange things have been going on @theAlbertDock today - there is magic in air! Have you spotted #suprises #giants

    Albert Dock and Giants car
     
  5.  
    Newlyweds' extra guest 13:25: Jimmy McCracken BBC Radio Merseyside

    Newlyweds Carys Evans and Stuart Turner (pictured) had a special extra guest at their wedding at St George's Hall today - Grandmother Giant.

    newlyweds and Giant

    You can just about see her head beneath the balcony as she lies in state until 19:00. My report's on Drive from 16:00.

     
  6.  
    Major changes to transport 13:16:

    Merseytravel tweets: There will be major changes to public transport for #Giants pls plan ahead & check for changes bit.ly/MTGiants

     
  7.  
    hot in the city 13:10: via Facebook

    Earlier, we asked how you plan to keep cool as temperatures on Merseyside are expected to reach 27C today.

    Jane Cullen Greenwood says: keep hats on plenty high factor cream, for kiddies, plenty of drinks, either beach, baths, paddling pool, an yeah Ice lollies/ Ice cream mmm Crosby, Waterloo, Otterspool, all beautiful places xxx

    Fran Stellman says: Splash

     
  8.  
    Elvis impersonator jailed 13:05: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    A 53-year-old Elvis impersonator from Southport who downloaded and distributed images of children has been jailed for 12 months at Liverpool Crown Court.

    Louis Fella, from Birkdale, Southport admitted possessing and distributing hundreds of pornographic images of children, some of them grade four and five, the most serious.

     
  9.  
    news on the hour 12:59: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our headlines at 13:00 include:

     
  10.  
    on air 12:50: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm speaking to American solider and author Brian Turner who is in Liverpool to tell his story of the war in Iraq.

    And do you think cabbies in Liverpool should wear a shirt and a tie to give a good first impression of the city to visitors? There will be many thousands of visitors descending this weekend because of the Giants.

    Of course if there's anything you want to talk about call me 0151 709 9333 or contact me via email, Facebook or Twitter.

     
  11.  
    Why I love the Giants 12:46: Helen Carter BBC Local Live

    I love this picture of Grandmother Giant for two reasons - the crowd and the view of the splendid interior of St George's Hall.

    Grandmother Giant

    Do you have a picture of the Giants you'd like to share? Email us, Tweet us or send a message on Facebook.

     
  12.  
    Teen rescued from mud 12:35: Wirral Globe

    A teenager stuck chest deep in mud near Crosby shore was rescued by a Wirral lifeboat crew.

     
  13.  
    Looking at Liverpool pals 12:25:

    Royal de Luxe's Liverpool Giants production, Memories of August 1914, will commemorate the outbreak of World War One and its effect on the city.

    Liverpool Pals

    The conflict saw 5,000 Liverpool men sign up to serve their country, 2,800 of whom died in the war.

    The men formed the Liverpool Pals battalions and were recruited by Lord Derby to answer Lord Kitchener's appeal for voluntary recruits.

     
  14.  
    QUEUES FOR GRANDMA GIANT 12:18: Jimmy McCracken BBC Radio Merseyside

    Queues are building up again outside Liverpool's St George's Hall to see Grandmother Giant ahead of this weekend's Memories of August 1914 show. The heat of the city is not deterring people.

    Queues at St George's Hall

    About 20,000 people saw Grandmother giant's first day asleep in Liverpool ahead of a World War One event. She is on show today until 19:00.

     
  15.  
    MISSING SNAKE FOUND 12:13:

    The missing Skelmersdale snake has been found safe and well in its owners home, Lancashire Police has confirmed.

    A boa constrictor

    An 8ft (2.4m) snake, believed to be a boa constrictor, was reported on the loose on Tuesday morning.

     
  16.  
    NEWS ON THE HOUR 11:58: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our headlines at 12:00 include:

    • An Algerian passenger plane has gone missing while flying over Africa
    • It's claimed a dog that mauled its owner to death in Liverpool had been reported to Environmental Health officers before the killing
    • A report on how undercover officers spied on bereaved families campaigning for justice for loved ones is to be published shortly
     
  17.  
    Lord Mayor's special visitor 11:55:

    Liverpool Council tweets: Lord Mayor @CllrEricaKemp meets a very special visitor @SGHLpool #giants pic.twitter.com/romvjZxkKI

    giant and mayor
     
  18.  
    Passenger changes at Lime Street 11:49:

    Network Rail emails to say from tomorrow until Sunday, Liverpool Lime Street station will be employing a two directional system in and out of the station between 15:00 - 00:45.

    Exiting the station will be via Lord Nelson Street only and access will be via Skelhorne Street only, where there will be a queuing system in operation. Passengers should allow for extra time to board their train and check with Network Rail staff on duty for assistance.

     
  19.  
    LOWE QUALIFIES FOR SWIMMING FINAL 11:39: BBC Sport

    Birkenhead swimmer Danielle Lowe (pictured) has qualified for tonight's 400 metres individual medley final.

    Danielle Lowe

    The 19-year-old came third in her heat with a time of 04.48.1 giving her a seventh-best qualifying time.

    The final takes place at 19:07 tonight.

     
  20.  
    hot in the city 11:34: Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    It's cracking the flags today and we want to know how you're keeping cool? With temperatures in Merseyside hotting up to 27C we want to hear how you're getting respite from the heat and sun.

    Sunshine at Crosby Beach

    As I look at this picture of Crosby beach, I'm thinking of using it as an excuse for ice cream!

    Send your tips via email, Facebook or Twitter and we'll share the best online.

     
  21.  
    House where woman mauled 11:28: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm at the house in Old Swan where police say a 43-year-old woman was killed by her Staffordshire Bull Terrier.

    House in Old Swan where woman mauled
     
  22.  
    More on Giant crowds 11:23:

    About 20,000 people saw Grandmother Giant's first day asleep in Liverpool ahead of a World War One event.

    Grandmother Giant

    Crowds queued for more than an hour to see the 25ft (7.5m) marionette at St George's Hall.

    The grandmother figure, one of three giants who will appear in the Memories of August 1914 show, will be on show in the hall until 19:00. She begins her walk around the city tomorrow.

     
  23.  
    What do you think? 11:16:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  24.  
    More on Tuebrook shooting 11:10:

    A 16-year-old is shot in the leg and five people, including the victim, arrested on suspicion of possessing a firearm.

    Rockhouse Street, Liverpool

    The shooting took place in Rockhouse Street, Tuebrook, at about 23.10.

    The victim was taken to hospital with a leg wound but his injuries are not thought to be life-threatening.

     
  25.  
    Rise in drownings off coast 11:02: Wirral Globe
  26.  
    NEWS ON THE HOUR 10:57: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our headlines at 11:00 include:

    • It's claimed a dog that mauled its owner to death in Liverpool, had been reported to Environmental Health officers before the killing
    • Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond says Britain's gravely concerned by the heavy level of civilian casualties in Gaza
    • A teenager in Liverpool's been arrested, after he got shot in the leg
     
  27.  
    Accident between van and lorry 10:49:

    BBC Travel News reports one lane is closed and there's queuing traffic on the Knowsley Expressway southbound in Tarbock Green between Tarbock Island and the Speke Road junction because of an accident involving a lorry and a van.

     
  28.  
    Epic Giants 10:44: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    Claire McColgan, Liverpool City Council's Director of Culture, told me there won't be a dry eye in the city for the Giants event in the city to commemorate World War One.

    Grandmother

    "The epic-ness of the Giants cannot be underestimated," she said. "The stories the Grandmother tells are incredible. It will make peoples' hearts bleed."

    Listen to the Giants extravaganza on BBC Radio Merseyside.

     
  29.  
    murder appeal 10:37:

    Merseyside Police is offering a £20,000 reward for information of the murder of 58-year-old James Stanton (pictured) on the eighth anniversary of his death.

    James Stanton

    He was shot at work at Aintree Commercial Vehicles on Ormskirk Road, Aintree, on 24 July 2006.

    Detectives believe two men were responsible for his death and they fled the scene in a blue Toyota Avensis stolen from Sefton Street, Liverpool, two months earlier.

     
  30.  
    LIVERPOOL'S BORINI INJURED 10:28: BBC Sport

    Striker Fabio Borini suffered a shoulder injury as Liverpool lost to Roma in a pre-season friendly.

    Fabio Borini

    Borini, who spent last season on loan at Sunderland, went off in the first half.

    A fee of £14m had been agreed for his permanent return to Wearside, but that move could now be in doubt.

     
  31.  
    LIFE OF A LILLIPUTIAN 10:22: Chris Long BBC News

    As spectacular as the Giants show in Liverpool promises to be, organisers say it would be nothing without its army of "Lilliputians", the people who animate the huge marionettes.

    Liliputians

    Some are members of the Royal de Luxe street theatre company, but many are volunteers.

    Colin Bordley from Wallasey, who helped animate the diver giant in 2012's Sea Odyssey show has told BBC News Online nothing can prepare you for the amount of physical exertion involved.

     
  32.  
    GIANTS SELFIE 10:15: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been to see Grandmother Giant at St George's Hall.

    Sean Styles with grandma giant

    Here's my "serious selfie". Well, I had to be quiet! I'm asking you for your best and worst queuing stories as 20,000 people queued yesterday to see her and similar numbers are expected today.

    Get in touch on 0151 709 9333 or via Facebook.

     
  33.  
    NEWS ON THE HOUR 10:00: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our headlines at 10:00 include:

    • Organisers of the Giants spectacular in Liverpool say visitors can't fail to be moved by the performance
    • The Israeli prime minister says it's a travesty of justice that Israel's offensive in Gaza has been condemned by the UN
    • A teenager in Liverpool's been arrested, after he got shot in the leg
     
  34.  
    Giants explain war vision 09:50: Jerry Chester BBC News, North West

    The Liverpool Giants will not just be delighting crowds with their majestic grace - they will also be explaining how one man's vision changed the city forever when war broke out a century ago.

    Edward Stanley

    Edward George Villiers Stanley, the 17th Earl of Derby, (pictured) was a lover of Liverpool and a patriotic man, so much so that Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother, would one day call him the "king of Lancashire".

    A former Grenadier Guard and Conservative MP, he served as Liverpool's Lord Mayor in 1911, was president of the city's chamber of commerce and chancellor of the university.

     
  35.  
    woman killed by dog 09:42:

    A 43-year-old woman was mauled to death by her Staffordshire bull terrier, Merseyside Police has said.

    Macqueen Street, Old Swan in Liverpool

    Louise Caygill's body was found in a flat in Macqueen Street, Old Swan (pictured) in Liverpool on Sunday.

     
  36.  
    Going to see the Giants? 09:38: Jimmy McCracken BBC Radio Merseyside

    I met Jean-Luc Courcoult yesterday, the man who has brought the Giants to Liverpool.

    Jean Luc Courcoult

    I wonder who I will see today? Let me know if you're at St George's Hall by emailing, Tweeting or contacting us on Facebook.

     
  37.  
    Campaign to save building 09:24: Warrington Guardian
  38.  
    GIANTS FEVER 09:15: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    I don't want to spoil the surprise for the people of Liverpool with the Giants, but I have to tell you I have never seen anything like it - it'll be massive!

    'Sleeping' giant in Liverpool

    I was given a sneak peek of the rehearsals with Claire McColgan, Liverpool City Council's director of culture.

    I loved the Giants two years ago; it was magical but this will be even bigger and better. I'm off to get two more memory cards for my camera!

    Listen to all the build up on BBC Radio Merseyside.

     
  39.  
    M56 CRASH 09:06:

    BBC Travel News reports two lanes are closed on the M56 eastbound between junction 7 at Bowdon and junction 6 at Hale Four Seasons roundabout because of an accident involving three cars.

    Congestion is tailing back to junction 9 at the Lymm Interchange.

     
  40.  
    top headlines
     
  41.  
    news on the hour 08:59: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our headlines at 09:00 include:

    • Organisers of the return of the Giants spectacular to Liverpool believe visitors will leave wanting more
    • Five people have been arrested after a teenager was shot in Liverpool last night
    • Households which have their electricity cut off in bad weather are to get more compensation
     
  42.  
    COMING UP 08:48: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been speaking about inspirational teenager Malala Yousafzai (pictured) who was shot by the Taliban and is a guest speaker at World Merit Day in Liverpool later.

    Malala Yousafzai

    I've also been speaking to Chris Arnold who set up World Merit - a scheme to encourage young people to recognise their potential and make a difference.

    Send us your photos or comments on email, Facebook or Twitter.

     
  43.  
    Beer stolen from microbrewery 08:37: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been at Norton Brewery at Norton Priorty, where hundreds of bottles of beer have been stolen from a microbrewery run by adults with learning difficulties (pictured).

    Norton Brewery

    They are working round the clock to fulfil orders for farmer's markets and customers over the next few weeks.

     
  44.  
    Teenager shot in Tuebrook 08:30:

    A teenager was shot in Tuebrook last night and five people have been arrested.

    Police were called to Rockhouse Street at 23:10 and found a 16-year-old had been shot in the leg. His injuries are not life-threatening.

    Two men, aged 20 and 34, a 38-year-old woman and two 16-year-old boys have been arrested on suspicion of possession of a firearm, including the person who was injured.

     
  45.  
    GIANT TURN OUT FOR GIANTS 08:18:

    They queued all day and into the early hours and official figures suggest 20,000 people visited St George's Hall in Liverpool yesterday to catch their first glimpse of Grandmother Giant.

    Grandmother giant

    It's all part of the World War One commemoration Memories of August 1914, and along with The Little Girl and Xolo the dog, Grandmother Giant is set to take over the streets of Liverpool on Friday.

    Did you go? Please feel free to send me your pictures and snippets of news via email, Facebook, or by tweeting us @bbcmerseyside.

     
  46.  
    Accident involving cyclist and lorry 08:11:

    BBC Travel News says: Speke Road in Speke is partially blocked and there's queuing traffic in both directions at the Knowsley Expressway junction, because of an accident involving a cyclist and a lorry.

     
  47.  
    ANOTHER FINE DAY 08:07:

    BBC Weather says after a warm and sunny start it will be another fine and dry summer's day across the region. There will be long sunny periods throughout the afternoon, allowing temperatures to become very warm.

    BBC Weather
     
  48.  
    NEWS ON THE HOUR 08:05: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our headlines at 08:00 included:

    • Organisers of the return of the Giants spectacular to Liverpool believe visitors will leave wanting more
    • As Israel continues its offensive against militants in Gaza, the UN says Palestinian civilians there face an increasingly desperate plight
    • The number of people who lost their lives on the UK coast has reached a four-year high, according to the RNLI
     
  49.  
    GOOD MORNING 08:00: Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    I'll be bringing you all the day's news, sport and weather updates from around the region on another gorgeous day in Liverpool as excitement mounts over the Giants.

    Please feel free to send me your pictures and snippets of news via email, Facebook, or by tweeting us @bbcmerseyside.

     

Features

  • Shinji Mikamo's father's watchTime peace

    The story of the watch that survived Hiroshima


  • Northern League supporters at the party's annual meeting in 2011Padania?

    Eight places in Europe that also want independence


  • scottie dogShow-stealers

    How Scottie dogs became a symbol of Scotland


  • Hamas rally in the West Bank village of Yatta, 2006Hamas hopes

    Why the Palestinian group won't back down yet


Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Arash AF8Naughty Brits

    From scrappy upstarts to legendary brands, six speed demons that hail from the UK

Programmes

  • A man taking a selfie with friendsClick Watch

    The apps to help you with selfies, plus other websites and apps reviewed

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.