'Serious failures' in death of baby in Northamptonshire

Baby holding adult's thumb. DO NOT REUSE A child protection plan was "completely toothless", the review found

Related Stories

A four-week-old baby who died was failed by professionals who should have been protecting her, a serious case review has found.

Assessments of "Maisie" were not "robust enough" and those working on the case were "insufficiently curious".

She died of natural causes in 2012 and had been sleeping with her drug addict parents on a mattress on the floor.

Local Safeguarding Children Board Northamptonshire (LSCBN) said agencies had "failed to protect" the girl.

Maisie, not her real name, had been made subject to a child protection plan over concerns that she may be neglected, and her parents Natalie and Karl, also not their real names, were deemed at risk.

Karl, 32, had been to prison in 2001 for causing grievous bodily harm to his six-year-old stepson.

Blood around mouth

Eighteen-year-old Natalie had a troubled past and both she and Karl abused drugs and alcohol, the review said.

Kevin Crompton Kevin Crompton said professionals had failed Maisie

Maisie had been born prematurely in April 2012 and when she left hospital should have stayed with her mother at her grandmother's house, which was deemed the best place by authorities.

But the serious case review found Maisie and Natalie stayed at Karl's flat.

She was found lifeless by Natalie in their bed in May, with blood around her mouth and nose.

Timeline of failings

  • January 2012: A hospital midwife completes an "early alert risk form", which is seen by other health colleagues. She sees a very drunk, swearing Karl with pregnant Natalie. She flags up Natalie's use of street drugs, her learning difficulties, late booking for maternity care, previous depression, and the fact she was known to social services as a vulnerable child. LSCBN said these concerns "should have triggered a higher level of intervention".
  • February 2012: At a scan, the baby appears small and Natalie claims she has not drunk alcohol for six months. The midwife makes a referral to Adult and Children's Services two weeks later, on 28 February. LSCBN said the midwife described the concerns as "low risk", which may have been an "over-optimistic view given the high level of risk factors".
  • March 2012: A meeting is held, leading to a child protection inquiry being carried out. LSCBN said Karl's violent past does not appear to have been flagged up or known at this stage.
  • April 2012: A social worker attends the "tidy" flat. LSCBN said it was "disappointing the social worker did not carry out any unannounced visits", or see the parents singly. Maisie is born on 5 April, up to four weeks early, and is discharged on 10 April to live with Natalie at her grandparent's house. LSCBN described this as a "completely toothless" plan because her grandparents were not told what to do if this was not carried out. A social worker who takes the family home from hospital takes them to Karl's flat. Karl's previous violence is treated as historic even though it includes an attack on a child.
  • May 2012: A police officer in the street is worried Maisie is not warm enough and her mother is dishevelled. He records his observations but does not tell social services.

A post-mortem examination failed to ascertain the cause of death, although co-sleeping with her parents on a mattress on the floor was a "contributory factory".

Maisie had severe nappy rash, the flat was dirty and untidy and there was evidence of drugs use.

She and her parents had not been seen by a social worker for 10 days.

'Serious failures'

The review points out that it is impossible to say whether Maisie's death could have been predicted or prevented but states professionals had not been curious enough and had been "over optimistic" about the difficulties of the case.

It was found that there were some occasions where agencies could have considered the protection of the child and carried out a full assessment of the risks.

Information was not shared as openly as it should have been.

Kevin Crompton, chairman of LSCBN, said: "We failed to protect this child by allowing her to remain in conditions that represented a risk to her safety.

"There were serious failures in practice which should not happen.

"I urge every professional in the county involved with safeguarding to read this report and reflect on whether it would happen on their shift."

Natalie and Karl were arrested on suspicion of neglect, but the case was dropped.

'Pieced together jigsaw'

The review comes just months after a damning report into Northamptonshire's children's services by Ofsted.

It said services were inadequate, the lowest rating possible.

Catherine Boardman Councillor Catherine Boardman said a new team was in place since Maisie's death

The service is now six months into a two-year improvement programme.

Councillor Catherine Boardman, cabinet member for children and education, said it "could have and should have" given Maisie better care, support and protection.

"We should have pieced together the pieces of the jigsaw that would have showed us the extent of her vulnerability.

"We should have supported her mother better because we knew she had her own vulnerabilities that impacted her ability to look after her child.

"Every time we came into contact with the family, we should have asked ourselves if we were doing our best for Maisie."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Northampton



Min. Night 1 °C

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Best in show

    BBC Autos takes a look at 10 of the most eye-catching new cars at the 2015 Geneva motor show


  • Kinetic sculpture violinClick Watch

    The "kinetic sculpture" that can replicate digital files and play them on a violin

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.