Horden shootings: IPCC highlights Durham Police failings

(Left to right) Susan McGoldrick, Alison Turnbull, Tanya Turnbull (Left to right) Susan McGoldrick, 47, Alison Turnbull, 44 and Tanya Turnbull, 24, were killed

Related Stories

An inquiry has found "unacceptable" and "inexcusable" failings in how Durham Police dealt with a man who shot dead three family members and then himself.

Michael Atherton, 42, shot his partner Susan McGoldrick; Alison Turnbull, her daughter Tanya then himself after a row at his Horden home on New Year's Day.

Atherton legally owned six weapons, including three shotguns.

But the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) said his violent past had not been properly investigated.

While the IPCC said it found no evidence to warrant criminal or disciplinary action against any member of Durham Police, it said the force knew of "a number of incidents" which "should have cast doubt" on Atherton's suitability to hold firearms.

Michael Atherton Atherton had a history of domestic and drink-related violence

Durham Police said that since the shootings it had carried out a full review of policy and procedures.

A copy of the IPCC report, seen by the BBC's Inside Out, revealed Atherton was given three police warnings between 2007 and 2008, because of incidents of domestic violence and claims he threatened to "blow his head off" while drunk.

The force was also aware of several domestic violence and drink-related incidents dating back to 2002, the IPCC said - although Atherton only ever received a caution.

The report said Durham Police failed to properly scrutinise Atherton's 2006 application for a shotgun certificate and an application for a firearms licence two years later in 2008. It concluded that decisions were taken with only "partial facts".

Start Quote

The IPCC concluded that no criminal or misconduct action should be taken against any member of Durham Constabulary involved in this decision-making, and we concur with this finding”

End Quote Michael Banks Deputy chief constable of Durham

It has described the failure of senior staff to follow up on concerns voiced about Atherton's emotional state by subordinates as "unacceptable" and concluded the resulting lack of consideration given to the "welfare of the family and wider public" was "inexcusable".

The report highlighted Durham Police's assessment of Atherton for his first shotgun certificate in 2006, in which a member of staff added a handwritten post-it note to his file which read: "4 domestics - last one 24/4/04 - was cautioned for assault. Still resides with partner & son & daughter. Would like to refuse - have we sufficient info - refuse re public safety."

But the recommendation was overruled by two more senior members of the Firearms Licensing Unit, who, the report said, feared the force would lose any subsequent appeal by Atherton as he had never been convicted of an offence.

The IPCC said further opportunities to reassess Atherton were missed when he applied for a firearms licence in 2008, which allowed him to own more powerful weapons.

Shortly after being granted the firearms licence his weapons were seized after a further domestic incident at Atherton's home.

Full inquest

But the IPCC found it "unacceptable" and "inconceivable" that they were returned without Atherton or his family being formally interviewed by licensing staff.

Alison Turnbull's son Bobby, who has seen a copy of the report, said he was angered by its findings.

Mr Turnbull, who has started a campaign urging tougher restrictions on the issuing of gun licences, said: "The police had a number of opportunities to refuse the licences. If people did their jobs in the first place lives would never have been taken."

Durham's deputy chief constable Michael Banks said: "We continue to extend our sympathies to the families of those who died in Horden on the night of January 1, 2012.

The family recall the night the three woman were shot dead before Atherton turned the gun on himself

"We are aware that the IPCC has updated the victims' families on the outcome of their investigation into firearms licensing decision-making in the case of Michael Atherton, and supplied them with their report.

"We've been informed by the IPCC that it is their recommendation that there are no criminal or misconduct cases to answer for any member of Durham Constabulary.

"The report into the investigation will not be made public until HM Coroner holds a full inquest into the deaths. This is not likely to be before the spring of next year.

"We feel that at this stage it is entirely appropriate that members of staff who made decisions within relevant guidance are not identified, as it is the coroner who addresses issues of anonymity.

"Since the tragic events in January, we have carried out a full review of policy and procedures. It would be wholly inappropriate to comment further."

Watch more on this story on Inside Out North East and Cumbria on BBC One at 19:30 GMT on Monday, 19 November, 2012.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tees



21 °C 14 °C

BBC Local Live

    Girl's brain tumour returns 10:21: The Gazette Newspaper

    Teesside parents Sally and Wayne Hodgson say inspirational four-year-old Ruby will need surgery again after a tumour returned for the third time.

    Cheryl lands fourth solo No1 10:10:

    Cheryl Cole has landed the fourth solo number one of her career, becoming only the third British female in chart history to achieve the feat.

    The Heaton-born singer's success with Crazy Stupid Love puts her alongside Geri Halliwell and Rita Ora.

    Cheryl Cole

    Cheryl said: "It feels great to be back but even more special to have achieved my fourth number one. So exciting!"

    News on the hour 09:59:

    The top local headlines at 10:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: A care home company which took Newcastle City Council to court over the fees it pays them has won its case.
    • BBC Tees: Nearly 900 people have been killed or injured on the roads of Teesside and County Durham in the last four years in accidents caused by distracted drivers.
    Crash death biker was father-to-be 09:48: Newcastle Chronicle

    The pregnant partner of a motorcyclist who died in a road crash has vowed never to let her unborn baby forget its dad.

    'Emergency passports available' 09:36:

    Regarding strike action at passport offices, including one in Durham, the Home Office said in a statement: "We have contingency plans in place to ensure that during any industrial action passport offices will maintain a service to the public and keep any inconvenience to a minimum."

    "All HM Passport Office customer service centre counters will remain open and we will be able to issue passports for those in emergency situations, with urgent travel needs."

    MH17 crash 'a war crime' 09:25: BREAKING NEWS

    The downing of Malaysian plane MH17 in east Ukraine may constitute a "war crime", UN human rights chief Navi Pillay says.

    The crash killed Newcastle United fans Liam Sweeney and John Alder, who were on their way to watch the club's pre-season tour of New Zealand.

    Passport office to remain open 09:20:

    The Home Office says all its passport offices, including the one in Durham, will continue to deliver a service today despite strike action taking place.

    The Passport Office

    Members of the PCS union are walking out in a dispute over workload and staffing levels.

    Rubbish apology 09:09:

    Durham County Council tweets: Apologies to anyone whose bin wasn't emptied on Friday. We're still catching up on the backlog and will be back to empty them today.

    News on the hour 08:58:

    The top local headlines at 09:00 include:

    Top headlines
    Record numbers at air show 08:46: Alfie Joey BBC Newcastle

    Almost a million people turned up at the Sunderland International Air Show at the weekend - a record for the event.

    The Red Arrows perform over the seafront at Seaburn

    The team at BBC Newcastle had a brilliant time covering it and you can hear some of the highlights this morning on Alfie and Charlie.

    Bridging the gap 08:35: Jonathan Swingler BBC Tees

    This bridge between Middlesbrough and Stockton is going to close for six weeks to be painted red and silver. There's more on BBC Tees and you can listen live here.

    Tees Newport Bridge
    Missing woman found safe 08:21:

    A woman from Stockton who went missing last week has turned up safe and well.

    Jennifer O'Neil

    Jennifer O'Neil had last been seen on Thursday, but made contact with police late last night.

    Another sunny day ahead 08:09: Kay Crewdson BBC Weather

    Most places will be dry with a fair amount of sunshine. There may be the odd shower, but these should be brief and mainly light. It'll feel quite warm, with temperatures slightly above average. Coastal areas may feel a touch cooler, because of an onshore breeze.

    Kay Crewdson

    The maximum temperature will be 23C (73F). Check the forecast near you.

    Good morning 08:00: Robert Cooper BBC News Online

    Welcome to BBC Local Live on this sunny morning. I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • EscaladeBling's the thing

    The ostentatious Cadillac Escalade cruises into 2015 with fuel-gulping gusto


  • A sun bearThe Travel Show Watch

    The Borneo sanctuary coming to rescue of the world’s smallest bear

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.