Wear-Tyne derby: Could football call time on early kick-offs?

Police control crowds in Newcastle Trouble flared in Newcastle city centre in April

Related Stories

This weekend Sunderland play Newcastle United for the first time since more than 100 fans were arrested after trouble following a game last season. Like that fixture, Sunday's match will kick off earlier than many fans would like, but do early starts still prevent violence?

April's Tyne-Wear derby at St James' Park will be remembered for events both on and off the pitch.

Sunderland won on Tyneside for the first time in almost 13 years and the aftermath of the game is still making its way through the courts.

Several Newcastle fans received prison sentences, including one man who was jailed for a year after he admitted punching a police horse, and two 12-year-old boys are now among the youngest in the country to have football banning orders.

It came as some surprise to fans, then, when Sunday's match between the fierce rivals was originally scheduled for 16:00 GMT by Sky Sports, but no one connected to either club was shocked when the kick-off was brought forward to 13:30 for safety reasons.

Early kick-offs are unpopular with fans attending games and some have questioned whether they still serve their purpose of reducing drinking time.

'Little correlation'

Kevin Miles from the Football Supporters' Federation said he was "yet to be convinced" the measure was still relevant.

"The fact is that once you give agencies like the police additional powers of this kind, they'll be very reluctant to relinquish them," he said.

"From what I can see there appears to be little correlation between the time a game starts and the numbers of arrests made, especially at derby games.

"The last Tyne-Wear derby was an early kick-off, yet the number of arrests was among the highest ever. Added to that was the fact the less than 10% of those arrested had actually attended the game."

A town divided

Sunderland and Newcastle fans

Rival fans at the Stadium of Light will be kept largely out of view of each other due to the configuration of the ground and carefully-planned travel arrangements.

But a little over 10 miles from Newcastle and only eight away from Sunderland, the town of South Shields will be split down the middle.

Tickets will be required just to get standing room in some pubs as supporters gather to watch the match on television.

Ross Gregory, sports editor of the Shields Gazette, said the town was "literally 50/50".

"As much as you might think there'd be lots of trouble, I can't think of a time when we've had a major disturbance before or after a derby match," he said.

"Certain pubs are black and white, others are red and white and the rest just sit on the fence."

Home Office statistics released this month revealed more Newcastle fans had been arrested than any other club during the 2012-13 season, with the figure vastly inflated by the trouble following Sunderland's 3-0 win on Tyneside in April.

The figures showed football arrests had risen by 4% but the number of fans held for alcohol-related issues was down from 800 to 549 year-on-year.

Geoff Pearson from Liverpool University has researched the impact of alcohol restrictions on football crowds and found fans observed in a study would go to "extraordinary lengths" to overcome "practical and legal measures".

He said early kick-offs did reduce the alcohol consumed, although perhaps not as much as police forces would like.

"Fans will start earlier, but if you have a 17:30 kick-off, fans belonging to that drinking sub-culture are going to drink for about five hours before the game, whereas if you had a midday kick-off, they're not going to be drinking for as long.

"They might start at 10:00 maybe, but they're not going to be consuming the same amount.

"What does happen is that over the course of the day an early kick-off means there's going to be more drinking time in total."

Mr Pearson said early kick-offs could lead to volatile situations for "same city derbies" where fans would mix long after the game

'Get tanked up'

Fans on either side of the Wear-Tyne divide point to relaxed licensing laws as an example of why the measure may now have less of an impact than in the past.

Gary Stephens, a former chairman of Sunderland's fan liaison group, believes early kick-offs should be scrapped.

"They absolutely do not work", he said. "As far as drinking goes, you can't stop it. Pubs can open whenever they want, now that we've got 24 hour drinking. But even if they didn't, people can simply go to the supermarket, get tanked up and still cause trouble."

Of its 384 licensed premises, Sunderland Council said 67 were able to serve alcohol before 11:00 BST.

It has rejected one temporary application to serve from 08:00 BST on Sunday after objections from police.

Barry Rogerson at Newcastle Magistrates' Court Barry Rogerson punched a police horse after April's derby at St James' Park

Northumbria Police's operations commander for Sunday's game Ch Supt Steve Neill said "public safety and the welfare of fans" was the "absolute priority".

"We sometimes seek earlier kick-off times for the derby to reduce the length of time people have to consume alcohol and to help prevent the likelihood of crime and disorder," he said.

Mark Jensen, editor of Newcastle fanzine The Mag, said he had not found any football fan that had "anything to say" for early kick-offs.

"It's crazy in this day and age that a crowd of around 50,000 can be inconvenienced just because of the risk a small minority might cause trouble.

"When there's so much money in football and the police have CCTV and all their other resources it does seem mad that you can't have a match after a certain time.

"Police will always play the public order card but after the match at St James' Park in April that seems to have been blown out of the water."

Ch Supt Neill said the police priority was for "supporters to be able to enjoy the game".

He will join fans of both clubs in hoping Sunday's talking points are generated purely on the field.

More on This Story

Related Stories

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tyne & Wear

Weather

Newcastle upon Tyne

17 °C 11 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Stockton MP to talk devolution 11:33: Mark Denten Political Correspondent, BBC North East & Cumbria

    The Conservative MP for Stockton South, James Wharton, is among 20 backbenchers meeting the Prime Minister David Cameron over devolution today.

    David Cameron is hosting a summit of senior Conservative MPs at Chequers to discuss plans to limit the Commons voting rights of Scottish MPs.

     
  2.  
    Striker Wyke to return 11:20:

    Hartlepool United manager Colin Cooper says Charlie Wyke is close to extending his loan deal with the club.

    The striker, who is on loan from Boro, is their top scorer so far this season, but he missed Saturdays 2-0 defeat at Plymouth due to a head injury.

    Cooper is confident the youngster will be back at the club this week.

     
  3.  
    A load of rubbish 11:09: Chris Jackson Presenter, Inside Out North East & Cumbria

    We've discovered the number of illegal tips being closed down has doubled in two years. But people living close to dodgy operators say the authorities have been too slow to act.

    Inside Out graphic

    We uncovered cases where the waste is buried or stored in huge rotting stockpiles - leaving fire risks and local residents having to suffer foul smells and vermin infestation.

    Join me at 19:30 tonight on BBC One to find out more.

     
  4.  
    News on the hour 10:58:

    The top local headlines at 11:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: A County Durham dog owner has been seriously injured after being mauled by his own American bulldogs.
    • BBC Tees: Stockton's Conservative MP has told BBC Tees it's important that any constitutional change for Scotland doesn't damage the North East economy.
     
  5.  
    Man charged with attempted murder 10:51:

    A man has been charged with attempted murder following a stabbing at a house in North Tyneside.

    A 21-year-old man suffered serious injuries in the attack, which happened at about 04:30 at an address in Saint Andrews Court in Benton, on 29 August.

    He was taken to hospital in a critical but stable condition. Police said he was now recovering from his injuries. A 21-year-old man of Hollington Close, Longbenton, will appear before North Tyneside Magistrates' later.

     
  6.  
    Boro eased to victory 10:41:

    Boro boss Aitor Karanka said sending the fans home happy is the most important thing after Middlesbrough eased to a 4-0 victory over Brentford.

    "It was a difficult game against a kind of team who will make it hard for you. They are dangerous opponents. Even at half-time when we were winning I told the players there could be no let-up.

    Albert Adomah beats David Button

    "We sent the fans home happy and that's the most important thing. That's three straight wins and we have to keep going, there's another game on Tuesday and then Saturday. We're always looking ahead."

     
  7.  
    Top headlines
    • Gateshead rape: Man charged
    • Injured dog owner: 'Mauled by dogs'
    • Listen Live: BBC Tees and BBC Newcastle
     
  8.  
    Man charged with rape 10:31:

    A man has been charged with rape and false imprisonment after a woman was attacked at a house in Gateshead last Wednesday.

    The 26-year-old man, from Pelton, Chester-le-Street, was arrested after a joint investigation involving inquiries by Northumbria Police and Durham Constabulary

    He has also been charged with assault, two counts of a breach of a sexual offences prevention order, two counts of witness intimidation, common assault, use of violence to enter premises, criminal damage and sexual assault. He will appear at Gateshead Magistrate's Court later.

     
  9.  
    Dog owner mauled 10:23:

    A dog owner was injured when he was mauled by two of his dogs in a street in County Durham.

    The 47-year-old man was attacked in the street at Priors Grange, High Pittington, and was taken to Newcastle's Royal Victoria Infirmary last night. He has serious but non-life-threatening injuries.

    Both dogs were captured soon after the attack. One of the dogs was destroyed. The other dog was taken to kennels where it will remain until a decision has been taken about its future.

     
  10.  
    Finding unsuitable material 10:09: Jonathan Miles BBC Newcastle

    How internet savvy are you, and would you know what to do if your child or grandchild had a problem?

    If you have children or grandchildren regularly surfing, how confident are you that they won't be able to access unsuitable material?

    We've also got a computer expert, Fevzi Turkalp, to field your questions - Call BBC Newcastle on 0191 232 6565 or join the conversation on Facebook.

     
  11.  
    News on the hour 09:58:

    The top local headlines at 10:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: A man from County Durham is in a "serious condition" after being mauled in the street by his own dogs.
    • BBC Tees: Foodbank volunteers on Teesside say the number of families using their services is continuing to rise.
     
  12.  
    Reignite the debate? 09:52: Mike Parr BBC Tees

    Now that the dust has settled on the Scottish referendum result and with it a promise of extra powers to be granted to Holyrood, what about the devolvement of powers to the North East?

    It's 10 years since we voted against the creation of a regional assembly. Is it time to reignite that debate? Call BBC Tees on 01642 225511 or join the conversation on Facebook.

     
  13.  
    'Bring back ChuckleVision' 09:42: Duncan Leatherdale BBC News Online

    It started with a custard pie and went on to become a 13-year, £25,000 obsession for one 43-year-old man from County Durham.

    And now school caretaker Shaun Hope is taking his interest to a new level by organising a campaign to see children's comedy duo the Chuckle Brothers return to the small screen.

    Shaun Hope

    Mr Hope, from Willington, first met the pair in 2001, when he volunteered to go up on stage. Read the full story.

     
  14.  
    'We had tremendous resolve' 09:31:

    Newcastle United manager Alan Pardew said he was proud of his team after a 2-2 draw against Hull.

    He said: "We had some big chances and then we make one mistake and it got punished, and an unbelievable goal out of nothing puts us in a big hole. But we had tremendous resolve. The players have had to play under enormous pressure and I'm very proud of them.

    Newcastle fans and Alan Pardew

    "I have to say 80% of the crowd were terrific. They took a view of 'let's see what happens'. We do have some fans who are a little bit more radical than that and they wanted to make their presence felt and you have to accept that as a manager."

     
  15.  
    Burglar spared jail 09:20: The Gazette Newspaper

    A model who became a heroin addict and a burglar after she fell 80 feet from a hotel balcony has been given the chance to rebuild her life by a judge.

     
  16.  
    Sunderland 'need to improve' 09:09:

    Sunderland manager Gus Poyet was pleased his side kept a clean sheet during the 0-0 draw against Burnley on Saturday.

    He said: "I don't think it was a special game or a good game for us. The one who scores the goal wins the game. The good thing today was the clean sheet. For the first time we get a clean sheet. We need to improve though for sure.

    George Boyd and Santiago Vergini

    "Overall, we played OK. Just OK. But OK in the Premier League is not enough - you need to be better."

     
  17.  
    News on the hour 08:59:

    The top local headlines at 09:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: The lawyer acting for a Northumberland man, who spent six months in an Indian jail on firearms charges, will make another attempt to have his passport returned today.
    • BBC Tees: Air pollution across the BBC Tees area contributes to more than 500 deaths every year according to official figures.
     
  18.  
    Durham's win 'tense' affair 08:52:

    England all-rounder Ben Stokes admitted it had been "tense the whole way through" after helping Durham lift the One-Day Cup at Lord's.

    The 23-year-old took two wickets and hit an unbeaten 38 as they clinched a three-wicket win over Warwickshire.

    Durham celebrate victory

    "I love coming back to play for Durham. I am absolutely thrilled that we've won another title. I just tried to stay as calm as possible and tried to make sure I was there at the end," said Stokes.

     
  19.  
    Balls injures reporter during football 08:41:

    Ed Balls left an opponent from the North East with a bloodied eye in the annual party conference football match between Labour and political journalists.

    The shadow chancellor clashed with the Northern Echo's Rob Merrick in the game at Manchester City's Etihad complex.

    The pair were contesting a 50-50 ball on the edge of the journalists' penalty area when an elbow from Mr Balls left a cut under Mr Merrick's right eye.

    Rob Merrick

    The reporter left the pitch for medical treatment with his shirt covered in blood.

     
  20.  
    Pollution hot spots 08:30: Cara Thorpe BBC Newcastle

    About 1,200 people in our region could be dying prematurely every year due to air pollution.

    There are 15 areas that have been identified as pollution hot-spots in the area, including parts of Tyneside and Durham.

    A recent report from Public Health England suggested poor air quality mostly caused by vehicle fumes could be to blame.

     
  21.  
    Pleasant after chilly start 08:20: Lisa Gallagher Weather Presenter, BBC Look North

    Today will be a fine and dry day with some good sunny spells. After a chilly start it will feel quite pleasant in the sunshine and light winds by the afternoon.

    Weather forecast

    Maximum Temperature: 18C (64F). Check today's forecast near you.

     
  22.  
    Two-car accident on A19 08:09:

    The A19 in New Herrington has a lane closed on the entry slip road and there's very slow traffic northbound at Herrington Interchange because of an accident involving two cars in the roadworks area.

    The A67 in High Coniscliffe is closed between the Ulnaby Lane junction and the B6275 junction because of a landslip and roadworks. There's a diversion in operation via B6275, B6279 Staindrop Road, B6280 Carmel Rd North and A67 Coniscliffe Road. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

     
  23.  
    Good morning 08:00: Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Welcome to BBC Local Live. I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • GeoguessrWhere in the world...?

    Think you are a geography expert? Test your knowledge with BBC Travel’s interactive game

Programmes

  • StudentsClick Watch

    Could a new social network help tailor lessons to students’ needs and spot when they fall behind?

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.