Wear-Tyne derby: Could football call time on early kick-offs?

Police control crowds in Newcastle Trouble flared in Newcastle city centre in April

Related Stories

This weekend Sunderland play Newcastle United for the first time since more than 100 fans were arrested after trouble following a game last season. Like that fixture, Sunday's match will kick off earlier than many fans would like, but do early starts still prevent violence?

April's Tyne-Wear derby at St James' Park will be remembered for events both on and off the pitch.

Sunderland won on Tyneside for the first time in almost 13 years and the aftermath of the game is still making its way through the courts.

Several Newcastle fans received prison sentences, including one man who was jailed for a year after he admitted punching a police horse, and two 12-year-old boys are now among the youngest in the country to have football banning orders.

It came as some surprise to fans, then, when Sunday's match between the fierce rivals was originally scheduled for 16:00 GMT by Sky Sports, but no one connected to either club was shocked when the kick-off was brought forward to 13:30 for safety reasons.

Early kick-offs are unpopular with fans attending games and some have questioned whether they still serve their purpose of reducing drinking time.

'Little correlation'

Kevin Miles from the Football Supporters' Federation said he was "yet to be convinced" the measure was still relevant.

"The fact is that once you give agencies like the police additional powers of this kind, they'll be very reluctant to relinquish them," he said.

"From what I can see there appears to be little correlation between the time a game starts and the numbers of arrests made, especially at derby games.

"The last Tyne-Wear derby was an early kick-off, yet the number of arrests was among the highest ever. Added to that was the fact the less than 10% of those arrested had actually attended the game."

A town divided

Sunderland and Newcastle fans

Rival fans at the Stadium of Light will be kept largely out of view of each other due to the configuration of the ground and carefully-planned travel arrangements.

But a little over 10 miles from Newcastle and only eight away from Sunderland, the town of South Shields will be split down the middle.

Tickets will be required just to get standing room in some pubs as supporters gather to watch the match on television.

Ross Gregory, sports editor of the Shields Gazette, said the town was "literally 50/50".

"As much as you might think there'd be lots of trouble, I can't think of a time when we've had a major disturbance before or after a derby match," he said.

"Certain pubs are black and white, others are red and white and the rest just sit on the fence."

Home Office statistics released this month revealed more Newcastle fans had been arrested than any other club during the 2012-13 season, with the figure vastly inflated by the trouble following Sunderland's 3-0 win on Tyneside in April.

The figures showed football arrests had risen by 4% but the number of fans held for alcohol-related issues was down from 800 to 549 year-on-year.

Geoff Pearson from Liverpool University has researched the impact of alcohol restrictions on football crowds and found fans observed in a study would go to "extraordinary lengths" to overcome "practical and legal measures".

He said early kick-offs did reduce the alcohol consumed, although perhaps not as much as police forces would like.

"Fans will start earlier, but if you have a 17:30 kick-off, fans belonging to that drinking sub-culture are going to drink for about five hours before the game, whereas if you had a midday kick-off, they're not going to be drinking for as long.

"They might start at 10:00 maybe, but they're not going to be consuming the same amount.

"What does happen is that over the course of the day an early kick-off means there's going to be more drinking time in total."

Mr Pearson said early kick-offs could lead to volatile situations for "same city derbies" where fans would mix long after the game

'Get tanked up'

Fans on either side of the Wear-Tyne divide point to relaxed licensing laws as an example of why the measure may now have less of an impact than in the past.

Gary Stephens, a former chairman of Sunderland's fan liaison group, believes early kick-offs should be scrapped.

"They absolutely do not work", he said. "As far as drinking goes, you can't stop it. Pubs can open whenever they want, now that we've got 24 hour drinking. But even if they didn't, people can simply go to the supermarket, get tanked up and still cause trouble."

Of its 384 licensed premises, Sunderland Council said 67 were able to serve alcohol before 11:00 BST.

It has rejected one temporary application to serve from 08:00 BST on Sunday after objections from police.

Barry Rogerson at Newcastle Magistrates' Court Barry Rogerson punched a police horse after April's derby at St James' Park

Northumbria Police's operations commander for Sunday's game Ch Supt Steve Neill said "public safety and the welfare of fans" was the "absolute priority".

"We sometimes seek earlier kick-off times for the derby to reduce the length of time people have to consume alcohol and to help prevent the likelihood of crime and disorder," he said.

Mark Jensen, editor of Newcastle fanzine The Mag, said he had not found any football fan that had "anything to say" for early kick-offs.

"It's crazy in this day and age that a crowd of around 50,000 can be inconvenienced just because of the risk a small minority might cause trouble.

"When there's so much money in football and the police have CCTV and all their other resources it does seem mad that you can't have a match after a certain time.

"Police will always play the public order card but after the match at St James' Park in April that seems to have been blown out of the water."

Ch Supt Neill said the police priority was for "supporters to be able to enjoy the game".

He will join fans of both clubs in hoping Sunday's talking points are generated purely on the field.

More on This Story

Related Stories

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tyne & Wear


Newcastle upon Tyne

Min. Night 10 °C

BBC Local Live

    Good evening 18:00: Kristie Kinghorn BBC News Online

    That's all today from BBC Local Live in the North East. We'll be back again from 08:00 on Thursday with the latest news, sport, weather and travel. But before we go, a nice little tale to leave you with.

    Paddington Bear has made a visit to the Great North Children's Hospital in Newcastle to help raise vital funds for charity.

    Cameron Howe meets Paddington Bear during his visit to the Great North Children's Hospital

    He visited the young patients yesterday to raise awareness of charity Action Medical Research, which helps save and change the lives of thousands of sick babies and children. The marmalade-loving bear met Cameron Howe from Bishop Auckland during the trip.

    Coming up later 17:58: BBC Look North

    On the programme tonight: Rape crisis workers welcome plans to re-investigate 11 alleged sex attacks previously discounted by the police.

    And three decades on we remember the siege of Easington - one of the most bitter battles of the year-long miners' strike. Watch BBC One at 18:30 or catch up here.

    Road network plans under fire 17:54: The Journal Newspaper

    The biggest transport shake-up in decades is an attempt to pedestrianise key parts of Newcastle city centre, councillors claim.

    Dozens of roads and junctions could be redeveloped if multimillion-pound plans plans outlined in a new document approved by the city council cabinet ultimately go-ahead.

    Light rain to spread 17:48:

    Hopefully any showers will clear giving clear spells, but becoming cloudy overnight with outbreaks of mainly light rain spreading from the west later in the night, and winds turning southwesterly. It's going to feel cool.

    Weather tonight
    The pioneers behind the wall 17:40:

    An exhibition stretching the length of Hadrian's Wall is going on display.

    Wall Face: Portraits of people who revealed Hadrian's Wall, celebrates the archaeologists and antiquarians who contributed to the wall's survival, including the story of John Hodgson.

    John Hodgson by Edward Scriven (L) and William Hutton by James Basire (R)

    Through careful study of inscriptions, the clergyman and antiquarian concluded the wall was built by the Emperor Hadrian and not by Emperor Severus, which had previously been thought. It was many years before this was generally accepted.

    The exhibition is on display at 11 sites until 9 November.

    Sharing the blossom 17:26:

    Gilbert Johnston from East Boldon sent us this photo of a red admiral and a peacock butterfly sharing the same Buddleia.

    Butterflies on Buddleia

    If you'd like us to feature your comments and pictures then send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.

    Son's anger at war medal theft 17:10: Newcastle Chronicle

    The victim of a burglary which saw his dead dad's war medals stolen is appealing for their return.

    Roger Howell's home in Hexham was targeted by thieves while the 73-year-old was on a week-long holiday. Raiders took World War Two medals belonging to Roger's father, Bob, who served with the Royal Army Service Corp.

    News on the hour 16:58:

    The top local headlines at 12:00 include:

    • BBC Tees: Businesses in Northallerton say they're hoping a reduction in parking charges will increase trade in the town.
    • BBC Newcastle: Jon Harle and Anne Leuchars have a round-up of the day's news.
    Tiote 'not going on the cheap' 16:47:

    Reports say Newcastle United midfielder Cheick Tiote is not available at a knock-down price.

    Papers in from Russia have suggested Lokomotiv Moscow have opened talks with the Magpies in an effort to sign the 28-year-old Ivory Coast international.

    Cheick Tiote
    Bus diversion in Sunderland 16:30:

    Go North East tweets: #56 is currently diverting via Ferryboat Lane and A19 in both directions due to an incident. Apologies for the inconvenience this has caused

    A1 in Northumberland cleared 16:20:

    The A1 in Morpeth is now clear following an earlier accident involving a motorbike, a car and a lorry. There's more on BBC Travel News.

    News on the hour 15:59:

    The top local headlines at 16:00 include:

    Bit of a breeze 15:51:

    Jim Jones sent us this photo of Blyth beach in the early morning sunshine. He said the lovely cloud formations and a bit of a breeze made it the ideal weather for dog walkers.

    Blyth beach

    If you'd like us to feature your comments and pictures then send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.

    Cheryl joins Ice Bucket Challenge 15:38:

    Cheryl Fernandez-Versini has accepted Simon Cowell's challenge and has posted a video of herself taking part in the Ice Bucket Challenge on her Instagram account. The pop star squealed as the water was poured over her and said: "I hope you're happy."

    Cheryl Fernandez-Versini

    She challenged One Direction singer Liam Payne, Piers Morgan and fellow Girls Aloud star Nicola Roberts to get in on the action, which is to raise money for charity. Earlier BBC Newcastle's Jonathan Miles and Look North presenter Colin Briggs had a go.

    Window ledge teen safe 15:24: Northern Echo Newspaper

    A teenager who earlier appeared on a hotel window ledge in Darlington town centre has been led to safety.

    Fire crews tackle straw fire 15:13:

    County Durham & Darlington Fire & Rescue Service tweets: 1148-Crew from Bishop Auckland used beaters to extinguish 100 square metres of straw on fire in the Leeholme area

    News on the hour 14:58:

    The top local headlines at 15:00 include:

    Town centre cordoned off 14:45: Northern Echo Newspaper

    Police have cordoned off part of Darlington town centre after a youth appeared on a hotel window ledge.

    The faces behind Hadrian’s Wall 14:35:

    The pioneers who have helped protect and record Hadrian's Wall for centuries are being celebrated in an exhibition stretching the length of the site.

    Built in the years AD 122-30 by order of the Emperor Hadrian, it took about 15,000 men six years to build the Roman frontier defensive structure.

    Hadrian's Wall - Housesteads crags

    For the first time, the stories of the archaeologists and antiquarians who contributed to the wall's survival will be on display at 11 sites, including the Great North Museum in Newcastle.

    Man injured in serious assault 14:21:

    A dog walker in Stockton was assaulted by a blade-wielding robber.

    The victim, 34, was walking his dog at the rear of St John's Close on Queens Park at about 22:30 yesterday when a man approached him and demanded he hand over his phone.

    He was then assaulted with a bladed weapon, leaving him with serious injuries to his buttocks and arm.

    News on the hour 13:54:

    The top local headlines at 14:00 include:

    Pizza delivery 'robbery' arrest 13:45:

    Police investigating reports that a 24-year-old pizza delivery driver had been assaulted and robbed of £100 by three youths in Grangetown on Friday say that they are now not looking for anyone in connection with the report.

    Cleveland Police say a 24-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of theft and is currently in police custody.

    New arrivals at allotment 13:33:

    Lee Hargreave sent us this photo of his five-day-old chicks at his allotment in Sunderland.


    If you'd like us to feature your comments and pictures then send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.

    Minor delays on Metro 13:21:

    There's minor delays on the Metro between Shiremoor and St James due to earlier overhead line problems. Get more on the revamped BBC Travel News website.

    Lifeguard cuts 'gobsmacking' 13:10: Hartlepool Mail Newspaper

    The mum of a young boy who drowned after Hartlepool's lifeguards were withdrawn says she is "gobsmacked" at council proposals to axe the service again due to budget cuts.

    News on the hour 12:57:

    The top local headlines at 13:00 include:

    A1 closed in Northumberland 12:45:

    The A1 in Morpeth is closed and there's queuing traffic northbound between the Morpeth North turn off and the Longhorsley junction because of an accident involving a motorbike, a car and a lorry. There's more on BBC Travel News.

    Your photos: Sunny North Tyneside 12:31:

    Alan Thompson sent us this photo of a sunny day at St Mary's Lighthouse in Whitley Bay.

    St Mary's Lighthouse

    If you'd like us to feature your comments and pictures then send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.

    Give us your feedback 12:20:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    Sunderland Aquatic Centre pool shut 12:07: Sunderland Echo Newspaper

    The main pool at Sunderland's swimming centre is closed after a problem with the pumps.

    A reduced swimming programme is being held in the diving pool after a fault with the pumps that heat and treat the water meant it had to close to the public last Wednesday. Council bosses said it is hoped it will be open as normal by next Thursday.

    News on the hour 11:56:

    The top local headlines at 12:00 include:

    Mr Briggs' icy moment 11:44:

    Here is BBC Look North's Colin Briggs being soaked in cold water to raise money for Children in Need.

    Colin was nominated by BBC Newcastle's Jonathan Miles to take part in the Ice Bucket Challenge - the latest internet craze which involves people pouring cold water over themselves and posting their videos online.

    Colin Briggs and Jonathan Miles

    Colin nominated former Look North cameraman Darren Reichard who now lives in Melbourne as he is "not close enough" to make his life a misery.

    Get all the sporting action 11:32:

    The football season has begun and you can keep up to date with all the latest transfer news and gossip, reaction to the start of the season for Sunderland, Newcastle, Boro and Hartlepool, plus much more with BBC Sport's Sportsday Live.

    bbc sport
    Woman found in park 'critical' 11:19: The Shields Gazette Newspaper

    A woman who was found collapsed in a park in South Shields is in a critical condition.

    Police were called to Readhead Park in Sunderland Road at about 10:30 yesterday, after a passer-by found the woman, who is in her mid-50s. She was taken to South Tyneside District Hospital. Her condition is described as "critical but stable".

    Missing Redcar girl appeal 11:10:

    A 16-year-old girl has gone missing on Teesside. Hannah Rose Brown was last seen by her family in Hayling Grove, Redcar, yesterday evening.

    Hannah Rose Brown

    She is white, about 4ft 10in, of medium build with shoulder length brown hair and brown eyes. She was wearing a white vest top, brown cardigan, blue jeans and red canvas shoes.

    It is believed Hannah may still be in the Redcar area. Call 101 with information.

    News on the hour 10:59:
    Jonathan's Ice Bucket Challenge 10:50:

    Here is the moment BBC Newcastle's Jonathan Miles took part in the latest internet craze, the Ice Bucket Challenge.

    Jonathan Miles and Colin Briggs

    BBC Look North's Colin Briggs soaked Jonathan in cold water for Children in Need. Involving people pouring cold water over themselves and posting their videos online, celebrities have also taken the plunge to raise money for motor neurone disease.

    Police to re-examine 'no crime' rape claims 10:40:

    Northumbria Police says 15 officers involved in rape claims feared to have been incorrectly recorded as a "no crime" have been moved to other duties.

    Police and Crime Commissioner Vera Baird said: "If cases like this are not properly investigated, they are very serious indeed.

    "A senior investigating officer has been put to look into how they were dealt with and also all of the cases will be reopened to be investigated."

    Missing boys: Seven people bailed 10:26:

    Police investigating the disappearance of three brothers from Sunderland - who were found last week - say all seven people arrested in connection with the case have been released on bail.

    No charges have been brought and inquiries are continuing.

    An icy moment for presenters 10:17: BBC Newcastle

    Our presenters have taken part in the latest internet craze - the Ice Bucket Challenge.

    Involving people pouring cold water over themselves and posting their videos online, well-known names from Cristiano Ronaldo and Lady Gaga to Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg have taken the plunge to raise money for charity.

    Jonathan Miles and Colin Briggs

    Here is BBC Newcastle's Jonathan Miles and BBC Look North's Colin Briggs before the drenching. Listen live in a few minutes for their reactions!

    Maddison 'could be tempted' 10:06:

    Gateshead boss Gary Mills on Marcus Maddison: "I want to keep him. We're ambitious and need players like that to help us get out of this league."

    "If league clubs come in for him, he's possibly going to be tempted - but it's got to be right for us."

    Marcus Maddison
    News on the hour 09:58:
    Post office robbery charge 09:54:

    A man has been charged following a robbery at a post office in Gateshead. The incident happened at about 09:10 yesterday in Durham Road, Birtley.

    Terrence Mackell, 26, of no fixed address, has been charged with robbery and will appear at Gateshead Magistrates' Court later.

    A man 26, and a woman, 24, arrested on suspicion of robbery have been released with no further action, police said.

    Tell us your views 09:44:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    Boro boss hails Kike 09:32:

    Boro boss Aitor Karanka says goalscorer Kike is "very important" for the team following Middlesbrough's 2-1 win over Bolton Wanderers .

    Kike scored the winning goal as Boro came from behind to leave Bolton still searching for a first Championship win.

    Karanka said: "He's [Kike] very important and the other lads know that when we work and create a chance, he's going to be there and he's going to score. We have to now keep going in the same way and keep working."

    'Right Direction' for Tyneside artist 09:21:

    A teenager from South Tyneside who dropped out of college is becoming an artist to the stars.

    Emilia Apreda, 18, from Whitburn, was commissioned by One Direction's Zayn Malik to draw a picture of him and his fiancee Perrie Edwards from Little Mix for her 21st birthday.

    Emilia Apreda

    Emilia has also had her artwork of Taylor Swift signed by the star herself.

    Sex attack suspect 'no longer on Teesside' 09:10: The Gazette Newspaper

    A man being hunted in connection with a brutal sex attack is no longer on Teesside, Cleveland Police believe.

    Cezar Florea is wanted on suspicion of attempted rape following an attack on the A66 flyover near Lytton Street, in North Ormesby, on 7 June.

    Cezar Florea
    News on the hour 08:57:

    The top local headlines at 09:00 include:

    Boro beat Bolton 08:45:

    Kike scored as Middlesbrough came from behind to leave Bolton Wanderers still searching for their first Championship win.

    Bolton v Middlesbrough

    With two wins out of three, Boro are up to eighth in the early-season table after their 2-1 victory.

    The best places to live 08:35: The Daily Telegraph

    Northumberland and Stockton have ranked fourth and sixth in the best places to live in England and Wales.

    The Telegraph has constructed an index using data on average weekly incomes, crime rates, health, home ownership and economic activity.

    Map of England and Wales

    Nowhere in London made the top 10 due to low levels of home ownership and high crime.

    As it happened
    • News, sport and weather for 20 Aug
    • Join us again from 08:00 on Thursday
    • Listen Live: BBC Tees and BBC Newcastle
    Spells of sunshine 08:25:

    Today will see a chilly start, mostly dry and fine with spells of sunshine.

    Lisa Gallagher

    Scattered showers will develop this afternoon. Highs of 17C (63F).

    Minor delays on the roads 08:14:

    There's very few traffic delays on the roads this morning. There are reports of slow traffic on the A1 southbound in Newcastle between Blaydon and the Dunston interchange because of a broken down vehicle.

    In Redcar, the A1085 Trunk Road in Grangetown is busy but moving eastbound at the West Gate roundabout junction. Get the traffic for Tyne and Wear and Teesside.

    'No crime' rape inquiries reopened 08:06:

    A number of rape claims are to be re-examined over fears they have been incorrectly recorded as a "no crime".

    Vera Baird, Northumbria Police and Crime Commissioner

    Northumbria Police said 33 rapes this year have been listed as "no crime" - when people subsequently inform officers no offence took place - but 11 are to be reinvestigated.

    Here more on this from Northumbria Police and Crime Commissioner Vera Baird live on BBC Newcastle in the next couple of minutes.

    Good morning 08:00: Kristie Kinghorn BBC News Online

    Welcome to BBC Local Live. I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments and pictures then send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.



Elsewhere on BBC News

  • Pulling a pint in MauritiusThe beer hunter

    One man's quest to bring artisan beer to the island of Mauritius


  • Traffic lightsClick Watch

    From hacking cars to traffic lights - behind the scenes at a cyber-security conference

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.