Audit Commission 'fulfilled goals', says watchdog chief

Cash The Audit Commission for Local Authorities in England and Wales was established in 1983

Related Stories

The chairman of England's public spending watchdog has defended its work, saying it had "more than fulfilled" the goals set out for it.

Michael O'Higgins made the defence following an announcement on Friday that the Audit Commission would close.

Communities Secretary Eric Pickles said the move would save £50m a year.

Mr Pickles said: "Rather than being a watchdog that champions taxpayers' interests, it has become the creature of the Whitehall state."

The commission's 2,000 employees received an e-mail from management on Friday. A source told the BBC it came "completely out of the blue".

Local Government Minister Bob Neill said: "I very much regret the way this has been handled by the Audit Commission who just sent out an e-mail which I think is quite disgraceful.

"I would have got my staff together and said 'let's talk through this'."

'Significant successes'

Mr O'Higgins said he "regretted" the decision and listed the "significant successes" the commission has had.

Mr O'Higgins said: "The Audit Commission was set up by a Conservative secretary of state in 1983, and I believe we have more than fulfilled Michael Heseltine's ambitions when he set it up.

"In 1985-86 the commission led the investigation of the rate-capping rebellion which resulted in 32 Lambeth councillors and 47 Liverpool councillors being surcharged and banned from office.

Eric Pickles said scrapping the commission would save £50m a year

"The gerrymandering 'homes for votes' scandal at Westminster Council was uncovered by the Audit Commission.

"In 2010 the commission carried out a corporate governance inspection of Doncaster Council in the light of 'serious concerns about the council's performance and the threat to public confidence caused by recent events', being the brutal attack on two boys by two brothers in Edlington.

"Recently over £200m of fraud has been detected through the National Fraud Initiative."

However Mr O'Higgins acknowledged "it is of course the absolute right of the secretary of state and Parliament to change the arrangements around the architecture of government, including abolishing the commission."

Mr Neill said the coalition government would strengthen the powers of local ombudsmen and that councils were now urged to publish online all expenditure above £500.

Mr Pickles said the commission's research functions would stop and councils would be able to ask private companies to carry out audits. There would also be a "new audit framework" for local health services.

He said he wanted to see the commission's auditing function become independent of government and compete for business from the public and private sector.


The Audit Commission is a body that has been responsible for checking how councils, and some health organisations, spend taxpayers' money.

There have over the last few weeks been some quite bad tempered tussles between the Audit Commission and the new coalition government.

But the fact that it is to be scrapped has come completely out of the blue.

The Communities Secretary Eric Pickles' belief is that bringing in the private sector will increase the amount of competition and drive down costs.

Sources I've spoken to believe the Audit Commission can do the job more cheaply than big private accounting firms.

What is clear is that 2,000 staff at the Audit Commission will lose their jobs - at any rate in their present form.

He said: "The corporate centre of the Audit Commission has lost its way. Rather than being a watchdog that champions taxpayers' interests, it has become the creature of the Whitehall state.

"We need to redress this balance. Audit should remain to ensure taxpayers' money is properly spent, but this can be done in a competitive environment, drawing on professional audit expertise across the country."

Asked about job losses, he said: "In terms of people working for the Audit Commission, almost certainly we are looking for them to be able to continue in another form."

In a statement, Labour's shadow communities secretary John Denham said the move meant taxpayers would have "no coherent information" about how much value for money their local services provided.

He said: "The Audit Commission doesn't just look at the cost but at the quality.

"Without the function of the Audit Commission there will be no-one to step in when a council is failing, as Doncaster was recently.

"This move by the government shows they are only interested in the cost of everything and the value of nothing."

Earlier, Clive Betts, Labour, chairman of the Communities and Local Government Select Committee, suggested to BBC Radio 4's PM programme there might be a "political motive" behind the move - saying there were "quite a few Labour people" including former councillors on the body.

The watchdog has offices in London, Bristol, Leicester, Solihull, Stevenage, Bolton, Gateshead, Leeds and Exeter.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More UK Politics stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Need for speed

    Audi unveils its fastest production car ever - ahead of its Geneva debut


  • A robot holding a table legClick Watch

    The robots who build flat-pack furniture - teaching machines to work collaboratively

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.