Councils 'not obliged' to provide weekly bin collection

 
Rubbish collection More than half of councils now collect domestic rubbish once a fortnight

Related Stories

The government has admitted it cannot force councils in England to provide weekly bin collections.

Communities Secretary Eric Pickles had hoped to include the measure in a new waste strategy but it was watered down following a row with officials at Defra, the BBC understands.

The strategy says collections should happen "more frequently" but it is up to councils to offer "local solutions".

Labour said the result was "another broken promise" by the government.

But Mr Pickles insisted the strategy would provide better value for money for householders.

Better service

He said: "Families pay £120 a month in council tax. Both Whitehall and the town hall need to raise their game to deliver more frequent and better rubbish and recycling collections in return."

ANALYSIS

A return to weekly bin collections has been a popular Tory theme.

But ministers now seem to accept they can't make councils do it.

Over half of local authorities in England now run some form of fortnightly scheme.

Most have invested heavily and say they won't go back.

Behind the scenes there has been a battle going on in recent days.

I understand Eric Pickles was pushing until the last minute to get a stronger commitment on weekly collections into the waste review.

But it contains no firm measures or incentives for councils to act.

Ministers say the objective remains but it's not clear how or whether it can be achieved.

Downing Street said the government understood that "people have a reasonable expectation that their bins are collected on a weekly basis" but although ministers "had a view" about the frequency of collections "ultimately councils are accountable to their local electorate".

The BBC understands that once councils told ministers the £100m a year cost of reintroducing weekly bin collections would have to be met by central government, the idea was effectively shelved.

More than half of councils now collect domestic rubbish once a fortnight. Some authorities say weekly collections work best, while others argue that the "alternate weekly collection" of different types of waste is the most effective way to increase recycling.

'Curry claim'

In 2008, Mr Pickles told the Tory party conference that weekly collections would "be back" if the party gained power and a "decent" refuse service was "vital" to help "protect the local environment and public health". As recently as January, he said the issue needed to be sorted out.

Amid a barrage of criticism from Labour MPs in the Commons, Environment Secretary Caroline Spelman denied there had been a U-turn, saying the government was "fulfilling the provisions regarding waste" set out in the coalition agreement.

She also said £100m in additional funding would be made available to councils to remove the most noxious food waste once a week.

But Shadow Environment Minister Jamie Reed said the Conservatives had promised the public that weekly bin collections would be reinstated.

Fortnightly bin collections help recycling rates claims council spokesman Richard Kemp

"Before the election, the Secretary of State (Mr Pickles) said - to much acclaim among his own party - that it was a basic right for every Englishman and woman to be able to put the remnants of their tikka chicken masala without having to wait two weeks for it to be collected," he said.

"Perhaps he can explain why it is the government's position has changed."

Friends of the Earth said weekly collections resulted in less recycling and the government should focus instead on halving black bag waste over the next ten years.

Fly tipping

As part of the new strategy, councils' rights to fine people up to £1,000 for minor domestic waste offences are to be scrapped. But there will be sanctions for the most serious rule-breakers, such as fly-tippers.

Householders currently can be punished for such actions as leaving dustbin lids open and using the wrong bin.

The best and worst recyclers in England

Rank Area Recycled

Source: Defra - 2009/10 figures

1.

South West

47.5%

2.

South East

45.5%

3.

London

44.6%

4.

Eastern

41.1%

5.

West Midlands

40.1%

6.

East Midlands

38.2%

7.

Yorks and Humber

38.1%

8.

North West

35.7%

9.

North East

32.2%

The government is to remove most of those powers from English councils but town halls will be able to issue fixed-penalty notices of between £75 and £100 to people who allow rubbish to pile up, or those who fly-tip.

Ms Spelman said the government's emphasis must be on ideas to enable households and businesses to be smarter with their waste.

There will be a ban on wood going to landfill from homes or industry - with it being burned for energy instead - while ministers intend to work with the hospitality industry to try to reduce food waste and with the toy industry to cut excessive packaging.

The Local Government Association, which speaks on behalf of more than 400 councils in England and Wales, welcomed the latter move, saying efforts were needed to reduce such waste "at source".

"Allowing councils to identify and work with people who misunderstand or make mistakes when sorting their rubbish is important," it added. "As a last resort councils also need effective, proportionate powers to take action against households or businesses which persistently or wilfully damage the local environment."

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +44

    Comment number 59.

    We need to reduce waste. We have our bin collected every 2 weeks and it's not always full. We don't have recyclcing collected as we live in 'a community of less than 300 people' so we go to the centre with a car load once a fortnight.We recycle everything we can but, more importantly we buy things without too much packaging, and if I think something is overpackaged, I leave packing at the shop!

  • rate this
    -10

    Comment number 49.

    How about a compromise? Collect refuse at least weekly during the warmer weather, reverting if necessary to fortnightly during the winter. If councils moan about the cost, then they should think about the cost in lawsuits if even one case of Weil's disease or similar is proved to be due to rats attracted by uncollected garbage.

  • rate this
    -4

    Comment number 43.

    With weekly collection of food waste and general recycling it's not a health/smell problem. But the small landfill wheely bin is often overflowing with non-recyclable packaging etc.since it is only emptied once a fortnight. The rain and bird/rat-proof kitchen and garden storage areas for multiple recyclable items has swallowed too much of our small, 2-bed bungalow for comfort.

  • rate this
    +39

    Comment number 29.

    I'm with Tim Eggins and others - our fortnightly general waste bin is never more than half full. I can only assume people with overflowing bins either don't recycle enough, or don't recycle at all.

  • rate this
    +39

    Comment number 27.

    We are a family of 4 and only put our waste bin out once every 4 weeks.Mystified why other families bins are overflowing every 2 weeks.
    We shouldnt go back to weekly collections for households as it would only benefit the lazy. Councils should follow the lead of Windsor and Maidenhead, they operate some sort of reward scheme for people who reduce their waste.

 

Comments 5 of 6

 

More UK Politics stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • SkatesCity-dweller's dream

    These motorised roller skates allow you to cruise to work - without breaking a sweat

Programmes

  • A digger operated via an Oculus Rift and a controllerClick Watch

    Why controlling a heavy digger with a virtual reality helmet might improve safety

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.