NHS reforms: Clegg says bill 'better' despite defeat

Nick Clegg and Baroness Williams Nick Clegg had urged members to back Baroness Williams' motion supporting the NHS changes

Related Stories

Nick Clegg has said he remains committed to seeing through changes to the NHS despite being defeated by Lib Dem party members over the issue.

The Lib Dem leader told the party's spring conference that reforms to the health service in England were "highly controversial" but his party had made them "better" and put "patients first".

He was speaking after activists in Gateshead failed to back government concessions secured by the Lib Dems.

They opposed them by 317 votes to 270.

Mr Clegg has argued his party has secured major revisions to the Health and Social Care Bill and it should now become law.

But party activists rejected the proposed changes championed by Mr Clegg, including safeguards on the role of the private sector and the extent of competition in the health service.

'Strong weapon'

Party members voted to delete the section of a motion put forward by Lib Dem peer Baroness Williams expressing support for the government's NHS concessions - effectively signalling their opposition to the bill as a whole.

Start Quote

The health bill was stopped in its tracks and rewritten”

End Quote Nick Clegg Lib Dem leader

The decision is not binding on the government, but BBC correspondent Norman Smith said it was a major setback for the Lib Dem leadership.

While the deputy PM intended to see the changes through in the face of significant political and medical opposition, our correspondent said it would put Lib Dem peers in a tricky position about whether to continue supporting the bill when it returns to the House of Lords next week.

One prominent Lib Dem critic of the bill, Dr Charles West, told the BBC that the vote would "empower" Lib Dem MPs and peers to reject the bill completely.

"This bill was never in the coalition agreement," he said.

"Nick Clegg has now got a very strong weapon in his negotiations with David Cameron. So we've actually empowered Nick Clegg, we've empowered our MPs and peers, and we've empowered Liberal Democrats."

'Better bill'


The NHS bill is in its final stages but Nick Clegg came to Gateshead and told his party to move on.

The deputy prime minister presented it as virtually done and dusted. Look forward he urged them, "rip off the rear view mirror".

But some still wanted to fight.

At 9am this morning the hall was packed. A sign of how serious they were. Detractors dominated.

There were some supporters, although one was heckled when he claimed significant changes to the bill proved coalition government was working.

When they voted a clear majority refused to support the bill.

It will not change government policy but - on the face of it - it is a problem for Nick Clegg.

His party officially doesn't support the plan as it stands.

Another view is that it could help the coalition's junior partner as he seeks to selectively distance himself from the Conservatives.

The flaw in that analysis though is that he supported these reforms from the outset.

In his keynote speech to the two-day conference, Mr Clegg did not mention the defeat directly but acknowledged the issue was "highly controversial and difficult".

But he said Lib Dems in Parliament had significantly improved the government's proposals.

"Because this is a coalition government, the health bill was stopped in its tracks and rewritten," he said.

"Because this is a coalition competition will be the servant of health care, not the master because this is a coalition government. Because it is a coalition government, this is a bill for patients not profits. It is not a Liberal Democrat health bill but it is a better bill because of the Liberal Democrats, a better bill because of you."

A host of groups representing medical professionals have called for the bill - under which GPs and other clinicians will be given much more responsibility for spending the budget in England - to be axed.

However, ministers have said changes to the way care is commissioned are needed to address the rising costs of drugs and an ageing population, and before Sunday's vote had suggested they would not accept any further major changes.

'More to do'

The party leadership believed that it had seen off a potential rebellion on Saturday when activists chose to debate Baroness Williams' more supportive motion on the health service rather than one urging the party to reject the bill entirely.

Start Quote

Nick Clegg should listen to the country, listen to his members and tell the Conservatives to drop this bill”

End Quote Harriet Harman Labour deputy leader

But after the defeat, Lib Dem MP Andrew George urged the government to "reflect" on the views of Lib Dem members and take action.

"The bill needs to be withdrawn...and to start with a blank sheet of paper," he said.

Health Minister Paul Burstow, who is a Lib Dem MP, said there had been major changes already to the proposed legislation ensuring patients' interests came first and services remained integrated. But he acknowledged the government still had "more to do" to convince critics of its proposals.

"Conference made up its mind yesterday not to adopt a 'kill the bill' strategy. We had a debate today about concerns conference still has about this bill and that is understandable.

"That is why we listen very carefully to those concerns and why we are continuing to make improvements to this legislation."

'Listen to country'

But Labour said Mr Clegg was passing up an opportunity to "break away" from the Conservatives over the issue.

"Nick Clegg can tell his party to be proud of what they've achieved all he likes - the only people with a reason to be pleased that the Lib Dems are in government are the Conservatives," said the party's deputy leader Harriet Harman.

"Nick Clegg should listen to the country, listen to his members and tell the Conservatives to drop this bill."

In his keynote speech, Mr Clegg also pledged to do more to reduce the tax burden for the lowest-paid, saying next week's Budget must have "fairness" at his heart.

The UK's economic recovery would be "long and hard", he argued, but the Lib Dems and their Conservative coalition partners were determined to help those facing tough times.


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 296.

    Most objections seem to come from misinformation, at times outright lies, and from vested interests.

    Most support seems to come from misinformation, at times outright lies and from vested interests.

    Only if we are given the full, complete and unabridged picture can we really decide what is right.

  • rate this

    Comment number 264.

    Yes I have read the bill, and the majority of people I see disagreeing with it are those that work in the NHS who do not like any change whatsoever. It does a balancing act which is necessary given the recent and continuing recession by reducing administration costs in a realistic way and at the same time being more geared toward the patient, after all - the NHS is a public service, correct?

  • rate this

    Comment number 232.

    I don’t know what to think, have just read a breakdown of the bill and the removal of 20,000 top heavy managers I think is a good thing, but I do truly worry with the private sector involvement.

    Still think that the Lib-dems will be history come the next election though.

  • rate this

    Comment number 230.

    The bill is a shambles. We have almost certainly the most efficient and improving health service in the western world. Despite misrepresentation, the majority of health professionals, who do not have large private practices, are against it. Certainly improvement and innovation need to continue but as many have said this should be done by evolution, not a blind faith in competition and markets.

  • rate this

    Comment number 107.

    This bill was always going to go through. As a student midwife I'm seriously concerned about what this bill is going to do to maternity services in the NHS, and community-based services especially, but I think it's a lost battle, they're determined to push this through. It's sad to think that the government is putting its own interests before the opinions of the people it governs.


Comments 5 of 9


More UK Politics stories


Features & Analysis

  • Cartoon of women chatting on the metroChat wagon

    The interesting things you hear in a women-only carriage

  • Replica of a cargo boxSpecial delivery

    The man who posted himself to the other side of the world

  • Music scoreFinal score Watch

    Goodbye to NYC's last classical sheet music shop

  • Former Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton checks her Blackberry from a desk inside a C-17 military plane upon her departure from Malta, in the Mediterranean Sea, bound for Tripoli, Libya'Emailgate'

    Hillary gets a taste of scrutiny that lies ahead

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Best in show

    BBC Autos takes a look at 10 of the most eye-catching new cars at the 2015 Geneva motor show


  • A cyborg cockroachClick Watch

    The cyborg cockroach – why has a computer been attached to this insect’s nervous system?

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.