Calls to government departments 'too expensive', say MPs

Man making phone call MPs are unhappy about how much the public are having to pay and average waiting times

Related Stories

More than 100 million calls by the public to government departments were charged at a premium rate, costing people an estimated £56m, MPs said.

The Public Accounts Committee report found a third of Whitehall numbers used by the public last year were higher-rate, including those for victim support, benefit and tax enquiries.

Labour MP Margaret Hodge said their continued use was "not acceptable".

The government acknowledged a "more consistent" approach was needed.

According to the cross-party committee, which has been looking into the issue, of the 208 million calls made to government departments in 2012/13, about 63% were made to higher-rate numbers.

Target 'poorest'

Half of the lines in Whitehall which charge premium rates "serve the poorest" in society, it said, and there ought to be "low-cost alternatives" for vulnerable people.

There was also criticism that calls to government departments took too long to answer.

"Customers of government services should be able to contact those services easily and cheaply," Mrs Hodge, who chairs the committee, said.

MPs taking evidence from civil servants on the issue in September

"Charging customers higher rates by making them use 0845 or other high-rate numbers is not acceptable, especially when the customers are often vulnerable people.

"Customers spent an estimated £56m on calls using higher rate numbers, from the lines run by the Department for Work and Pensions, to helplines for victim support and the Bereavement Service and the inquiries and complaints line of the Student Loans Company."

According to the communications regulator Ofcom, 0843 and 0844 calls cost between 1p and 13p a minute from landlines and, typically, between 15p and 41p a minute from mobile phones.

Calls to 0845 numbers cost between 1p and 10.5p a minute from landlines, and from 12p to 41p from mobiles while for 0870 codes, the rates are 2p to 10p and 21p to 41p.

The Department for Work and Pensions, which gets more than a 100 million calls from the public a year, has said it will offer a choice between 0845 and 0345 numbers to enable callers to choose the line which is cheaper for them.

Waiting times

Appearing before the committee in September, head of the Cabinet Office Richard Heaton said his officials would work on guidance and principles for Whitehall departments to ensure people were not "ripped off".


Ofcom is planning to reduce the categories of numbers used in an effort to make prices clearer. Its suggestions are:

01, 02 and 03: Geographic rates

07: Mobile rates

0800: Free from landlines

0843/4/5 and 0871/2/3: Business rate, lower cost

090/091/098: Premium rate, higher cost.

In its report, the committee also said calls to government departments took too long to answer, with callers to Revenue and Customs in the first quarter of 2013 having to wait an average of seven minutes.

According to the committee, Revenue and Customs only answered 16% of calls made to its tax credit helpline on July 31, the deadline day for notifying change of circumstances.

Mrs Hodge said the performance of some departments was "astonishingly bad".

"Callers must be informed of the costs involved in calling a particular number. Costs to callers can be even higher when they are left waiting to speak to someone," she added.

"The industry benchmark is to answer 80% of calls in 20 seconds but most departments do not have such a target and their performance falls wide of accepted industry standards."

'Bumper bill'

The Cabinet Office said many people now preferred to use the internet to access government services.

"We agree that it is inappropriate for vulnerable people to pay high charges for accessing vital public services and we are clear that a more consistent approach is needed," a spokesman said.

"The Cabinet Office now runs a cross-departmental group to consider customer telephone lines. This group has made good progress in drafting guidance on prefix number selection and establishing best practice.

"We will publish this guidance and have a standing remit to ensure it is kept up to date."

Consumer group Which? called on all public bodies and companies to provide either freephone or local rate numbers for their customer service and complaints lines.

"It is ridiculous that people face a bumper bill to call a public body, especially when they have to wait on hold," said its executive director Richard Lloyd.

"The Cabinet Office must now act fast to ensure the government and public bodies lead by example and put an end to costly calls."


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 110.

    As per other posts here, avoid calling and email Gov, or use something like Gov.UK website to find your answer (if it's not specifically about you I mean, as in seeking info). If people want calls answered more quickly, ask the Gov to employ more staff - oh hang on, that'll cost too... I used to work in Gov, but now back in private sector. I'd had enough of constant team reductions!

  • rate this

    Comment number 109.

    HYS about energy pricing please!!!

  • rate this

    Comment number 108.

    When STD codes meant that we paid either local or national rates there may have been some justification, but nowadays most phone packages include "free minutes" to STD codes.

    There is no justification for any 08 codes to public bodies. Even my local council use it. Just another rip off devised by the managers to boost revenue.

  • rate this

    Comment number 107.

    I'm not too sure what to make of this, but for those who say 'Calls to Government should be free', nothing is ever 'free' in this respect. If the caller doesn't pay for their call, then someone else will have to fund it - i.e. the taxpayer. It's the same when people say 'the Government should pay for xyz' - again, that means us. It would be better if calls were answered more quickly by Gov depts.

  • rate this

    Comment number 106.

    Government is too expensive , full stop
    Too few in the public sector with real world experience and with heads well and truly up their nether regions


Comments 5 of 110


More UK Politics stories



Elsewhere on the BBC


  • A prosthetic legClick Watch

    How motion capture technology is being used to design bespoke prosthetics

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.