Douglas Carswell: Reaction as Tory MP defects to UKIP

Douglas Carswell

Related Stories

Conservative MP Douglas Carswell has defected to UKIP, saying leaders of his former party are "not serious about real change in Europe".

He said Tory leaders planned to renegotiate Britain's position in the Europe "just enough" so voters would choose to stay in the EU at the referendum promised by David Cameron.

And Mr Carswell said "everything that they're doing" was being done to win the election - so the party's policy amounted to "change so that everything can stay the same".

But what have others made of his comments?

Prime Minister David Cameron

"It's obviously deeply regrettable when things happen like this, when people behave in this way, but it's also in my view counter-productive. If you want a referendum on Britain's future in the EU - whether we should stay or go - the only way you can get that is to have a Conservative government after the next election. That is what until very recently Douglas Carswell himself was saying."

UKIP leader Nigel Farage

"I'm delighted that Douglas Carswell has joined us. He's been a very clear and principled politician ever since he went into Westminster. But I think to not just defect to UKIP but to be noble enough to say 'let's put this to a by-election' is one of the most remarkable things I've seen in my political lifetime."

Labour leader Ed Miliband on Twitter

"Douglas Carswell's defection is not just a blow to David Cameron. It shows the Tory party is too divided to stand up for hard-working families."

Dr Matthew Goodwin of Nottingham University

"We mapped all constituencies according to how favourable they were to UKIP based on the types of voters that were in those seats. Clacton is the most favourable seat for UKIP in the country. The only thing that was preventing us as academics from pointing this seat out was in fact Douglas Carswell's large majority, which is 28%... I do not think he will struggle at all to win election under the UKIP banner."

Mick Page, Conservative leader of Tendring District Council, which covers Clacton (Mr Carswell's constituency)

"That's come as a shock - a bolt from the blue. We always thought he was a Conservative very much against Europe but we thought he would work within the party to achieve his aims. As far as I'm aware the Conservative Association had no warning of this."

Tendring District Council's Labour leader, Ivan Henderson

"He's seen the vote increasing for UKIP, seen the possibility he could lose his seat and panicked. Douglas has always been a maverick in terms of his party but this is an opportunistic move because he's seen it slipping away from him.

Conservative Party spokesman

"This is a regrettable and frankly counter-productive decision... the only way to get a referendum on the EU is to return a majority Conservative government. The Conservative Party will contest the forthcoming by-election vigorously to make sure the people in Clacton have a strong Conservative voice in this parliament and the next."

Labour's shadow Cabinet Office minister Michael Dugher

"Douglas Carswell's defection is a hammer blow to David Cameron. Confidence in David Cameron is collapsing inside a Conservative Party which is divided and running scared of UKIP. David Cameron's weak leadership has seen him abandon the centre ground, repeatedly trying to pander to his own right-wing backbenchers rather than concentrate on the needs of the country."

BBC political editor Nick Robinson

"This is a body blow to [David Cameron]. I'm told that he had absolutely no warning of this, that the first the Conservative Party knew about the defection was when they saw it at that UKIP news conference. And the reason it's a body blow is not because Mr Carswell is a household name, not because one UKIP MP will change the dynamics of the House of Commons, but because it changes the narrative of politics and also because it will fuel fear in the Tory ranks."

Conservative MP Mark Pritchard

"The only party that's going to be able to deliver a referendum after the next general election is the Conservative Party, and that's why I will be remaining a member of the Conservative Party... The fact is that this is no surprise. Douglas has been flirting with UKIP for some time now."

Sir Bob Russell, Lib Dem MP for neighbouring Colchester

"He's so far to the right of the Conservative Party that I've wondered for a long time how he could remain a Conservative. This is a huge embarrassment for the Conservative Party, although when David Cameron refers to wide-eyed fruitcakes, you've only got to look at Douglas Carswell to see the kind of person he was talking about."

Labour MP Tom Watson

"So @douglascarswell defects to UKIP. He's eccentric and maverick, I disagree with him on nearly everything but can't help admiring him."

Conservative MP Bernard Jenkin

"He'll regret this because, bluntly, the more Conservative voters defect to UKIP, the more likely it becomes that Ed Miliband becomes prime minister and we get plunged further and further into the European Union, we don't have any kind of renegotiation and we certainly don't have a referendum. Is that what Douglas Carswell really wants?"

Conservative MP Nigel Evans, speaking in a video posted on Facebook

"Douglas, I think that you are wrong. You are principled but completely wrong. You and I both wish to ensure the British public have their say in 2017 on an in/out Europe referendum. The only way that is going to happen is if there is a majority Conservative government in 2015. What you have done today is a huge distraction. It's very expensive and totally unnecessary."

More on This Story

Related Stories

More UK Politics stories


Politics Live

    @Kevin_Maguire Kevin Maguire, Daily Mirror associate editor

    tweets: TV election debates are important in principle. If we adopt a written constitution, put them in alongside secret ballots and spending caps

    07:15: Campbell on TV debates BBC Radio 4 Today

    Alastair Campbell, Tony Blair's former director of communications, says David Cameron's decision to only take part in one TV debate is "democratically wrong and morally cowardly". He says Mr Cameron should be honest about why he doesn't want to take part - "he just doesn't want to do them", Mr Campbell says.

    07:11: One-on-one debate? Ross Hawkins Political correspondent, BBC News

    Is it possible for a "one-on-one" debate to go ahead with just one person? Labour thinks so, our political correspondent reports. The party will insist the plan is credible and could lead to Ed Miliband taking part in a debate with a presenter.

    "If that were to happen, David Cameron would be pursued by a man in a chicken costume throughout the campaign, I'm certain of that", our correspondent adds.

    07:06: Telegraph on debates The Daily Telegraph

    The Telegraph has penned an editorial which says the televised discussions are good for democracy. The paper argues the debates would "inject some much-needed spontaneity and excitement into the stage-managed, safety-first election campaigning". The piece says broadcasters now need to work together to make sure "some sort of debate" does take place.

    Norman Smith BBC Assistant Political Editor

    tweets: Labour say Ed Miliband will still take part in Ch4//Sky head to head debate without the PM

    @NickyMorgan01 Nicky Morgan, minister for women

    tweets: Looking forward to today's #CWIB2015. Bringing together ambitious business women for masterclasses and mentoring. #womensday

    06:55: 'Move Parliament to Manchester' The Guardian

    Earlier this week, we reported Commons Speaker John Bercow saying the Houses of Parliament may have to be "abandoned" within 20 years without extensive repair work. There have been a number of suggestions on possible alternatives. Today, Simon Jenkins writes in the Guardian that Parliament should be moved to Manchester, arguing it would be good for democracy.

    06:51: Broadcasters 'pressing ahead' Norman Smith BBC Assistant Political Editor

    "Talking to some of those involved last night, my impression at the moment, is the broadcasters are intent on toughing this one out... They do not think that one 90-minute debate involving eight parties in the next fortnight or so is acceptable. They do not think it is acceptable one party should have the power to veto what goes ahead. As things stand they are intent on pressing ahead with the debates as currently scheduled."

    06:42: Cameron's debate plans Norman Smith BBC Assistant Political Editor

    Our correspondent has been analysing last night's big debate news.

    The effect is to swing a huge wrecking ball in the direction of the broadcasters' plans for these TV debates, he says. It may demolish all hopes for a debate to be held, or may leave one "paltry" 90-minute debate later this month.

    The clear view of Downing Street is that this is the fault of broadcasters, who they accuse of coming forward with proposals without consultation, to a timetable that was never going to be acceptable, and of failing to get the parties to get together for meaningful negotiations, our correspondent says.

    06:39: TV debate reaction

    There is plenty of reaction around to Downing Street's one-debate proposal. Including this, which leaves little doubt as to where the Huffington Post stands on the issue.

    06:30: Scotland Ashcroft poll

    In other political news you may have missed from last night, a poll suggested the SNP could win Gordon Brown's seat - Kircaldy and Cowdenbeath - at the election in May. The poll by Lord Ashcroft also suggested Charles Kennedy, the former Liberal Democrat leader, could also lose his seat to the nationalists. It's the latest polling which suggests the SNP could make significant gains on 7 May.

    06:25: The papers
    Daily Telegraph front page - 05/03/15

    Downing Street's announcement that the prime minister will only take part in one TV debate ahead of the election features in several papers, with The Daily Telegraph describing it as an "ultimatum" to broadcasters. The BBC's Alex Kleiderman has the full round-up of the nationals here.

    06:20: Child benefit changes? BBC Newsnight BBC Two, 22:30

    The BBC has learned the Conservatives are considering limiting child benefit to three children. As Newsnight reported last night, the Treasury has "softened" to the idea, which could save an estimated £300m a year.

    06:15: Debate bombshell

    In case you missed it, there was a significant development last night on the TV leaders debates, after Downing Street wrote to broadcasters to make a "final offer" of only one debate with seven, possibly eight, leaders. Other parties criticised the PM, accusing him of "acting like a chicken" and the broadcasters have said they will respond to the proposal in due course. Expect more reaction on this story this morning.

    06:10: Good morning

    Hello and welcome to a fresh Thursday's political coverage. Nick Eardley and Matthew Davis will bring you all the action, reaction and analysis in text and you'll be able to watch and listen to all the main BBC political programmes, from Today and Breakfast through to Newsnight and Today in Parliament. Don't forget you can get in touch by emailing or via social media @bbcpolitics. Here's how Wednesday unfolded.



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Best in show

    BBC Autos takes a look at 10 of the most eye-catching new cars at the 2015 Geneva motor show


  • Kinetic sculpture violinClick Watch

    The "kinetic sculpture" that can replicate digital files and play them on a violin

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.