Scottish Tories square up at party conference


In Manchester for the Tory conference - and there are some fascinating sights to witness.

Murdo Fraser, Ruth Davidson, Jackson Carlaw and Margaret Mitchell The four leadership candidates went head-to-head at the Tory conference

For example, they have a remarkable form of light transit across the city. Runs on rails, overhead power cables. They call it "the trams".

Any possibility that could translate to Scotland?

And, politically, there was an intriguing event at lunchtime as the four contenders for the Scottish Conservative leadership sought to persuade and cajole.

One of the four, Margaret Mitchell, stressed more than once that they were not participating in a "beauty contest" - which caused the others to grin uncomfortably and fix their hair.

So, if not a pageant of pulchritude, what is this contest?

Self-evidently, an election, a keenly contested election. But, as today's hustings confirmed, this is also a quasi-referendum: on the very future of the party in Scotland.

That is because one of the candidates, Murdo Fraser, has proposed that the current party should transform into an entirely new centre-right outfit.

Every question from the floor focused upon this prospect: supportively, sceptically or antagonistically.

Which is entirely right.

There is little point in the candidates spotlighting the fine detail of housing policy while the party confronts a fundamental choice about the very nature of its existence and its pitch to the electorate in Scotland.

Start Quote

Murdo Fraser appeared to suggest he had had to bite his tongue at points during the past few years when he noted that he had remained utterly loyal as Annabel Goldie's deputy, despite occasional private differences.”

End Quote

The essential case was debated at the Manchester hustings.

Mr Fraser argued the Tories could not get a hearing at all in Scotland - because they were not seen as representing Scottish interests, as having a Scottish identity.

His rivals dissented from this, arguing that improved organisation, enhanced communication and hard work to re-engage with the voters could counter this negative tendency.

Tried all that, says Mr Fraser: didn't work, won't work now. Hence, the fundamental choice that is now presenting itself to the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party.

A referendum, then - but not a straightforward one. A multi-option referendum, if you like, in that there are three candidates who oppose Mr Fraser's plan.

Of those, it is generally presumed that Ruth Davidson is the frontrunner - and she performed well, with light touches of self-deprecating humour.

But Jackson Carlaw will have done himself no harm at all with a feisty show, majoring on his experience and dog-whistle appeals to basic Conservative attitudes.

Mr Carlaw argued the Tories risk making themselves look intrinsically foolish by concentrating upon internal strategy and structures while Scotland prepares for a full-blown referendum of another kind: upon independence.

Mr Fraser contested that by arguing that the Tories were going absolutely nowhere as things stood. They must transform or head towards oblivion.

His team believe that, if he wins the election, he will have the momentum - and Westminster compliance - to ensure that he can complete the transition to a new Scottish party which would take the Tory whip in the Commons.

Against that, Ms Davidson pointed to the Conservative party in Wales, which has regained ground.

She argued that a fresh approach, allied to restructured organisation, could repeat that performance in Scotland.

David Mundell Scotland's sole Tory MP David Mundell is not happy about Murdo Fraser's plan

(As an aside, my BBC Wales colleagues tell me that there was warm applause at a Welsh fringe when the Wales Office Minister David Jones criticised the plan to rename and rebrand the party in Scotland.)

Margaret Mitchell characterised herself as the arch-Unionist, opposed to the new tax powers for Holyrood in the Scotland Bill.

In the audience, the Scotland Office Minister David Mundell greeted that with a thin smile.

Other interesting cameo points.

Sections of the audience did not appear to like it when Margaret Mitchell directly spotlighted Ruth Davidson's limited experience. There was sporadic grumbling, although only sporadic.

Murdo Fraser appeared to suggest he had had to bite his tongue at points during the past few years when he noted that he had remained utterly loyal as Annabel Goldie's deputy, despite occasional private differences.

But, of course, this Tory "referendum" will be decided not in Manchester, not at the party hustings around Scotland - but in a postal ballot of the members.

And that will be conducted via the alternative vote.

Party members will rank the candidates in order of preference. The least popular candidate drops out, with their first preference votes reallocated according to second preference.

That process is repeated until an overall winner emerges.

It is generally thought Murdo Fraser, as the experienced, incumbent deputy leader, would have won comfortably - if he had kept quiet about his radical reform thinking.

Team Fraser argue that it is to his credit that he has been frank and upfront about his views on the party - and his proposed solution.

But will he still win when second, third and possibly fourth preferences are redistributed - when, by definition, those votes will initially have gone to candidates who dislike his reform plan?

Can he convince enough switchers to back him?

We will know on 4th November.

Brian Taylor Article written by Brian Taylor Brian Taylor Political editor, Scotland

Past, present and future

Tony Blair once met a voter during one of his election campaigns. He started listing the achievements his government had generated for the people. "Aye, we know all that," chipped in the voter, "What are you going to do next?"

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 69.

    # 68,

    You must be much younger than I am. I have no interest whatever in Thatcher.

    I want an Independent Scotland. The politics of our new nation will take care of itself. My own vote will count just the same.

  • rate this

    Comment number 68.

    64 ginger and 67 baldy
    probably a misprint - Did you mean "sleepy and depraved" ?
    So baldy, heathite tories actually exist ? Wow! I thought they
    had all expired from terminal sulking after maggie took over.

    Sorry guys but I don't see any of the Unionist parties taking over
    from the SNP post independence. It will be 2030 when Nicola retires
    after 2 terms so who knows that far ahead.

  • rate this

    Comment number 67.

    # 64,

    Yeah. I know sorry ! I complained to the Beeb over the recent election coverage. No response. Unfair to have a go at you.

    I want to hear any debate on the independent future. My first vote was in 1978 for the SNP. This is my mantra. Get ourselves free and then argue the toss. I suspect that I may be a Heathite Tory. I don't know.

    Will never know until we are independent !

  • rate this

    Comment number 66.

    Its a fascinating contest.

    It's like watching 4 bald (folically challanged?) people fighting over a comb. Why anyone of them would want to publicly associate themselves with a party in such a retrograde position in Scottish politics is quite beyond me.

  • rate this

    Comment number 65.

    61 baldy
    Don't expect the SNP to fade away after independence.
    Remember who/what is left in Holyrood outside of the SNP
    group............. ? Yup. nothing worth voting for.


Comments 5 of 69


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC


  • Former al-Qaeda double agent Aimen DeanHARDtalk Watch

    Islamic State is about revenge says former al-Qaeda member turned spy Aimen Dean

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.