Scottish independence: Could Scotland afford better childcare?

What are the issues at the heart of the childcare debate in Scotland? What does the Scottish government propose in the event of independence and what do the major political parties have to say on the issue? And could Scotland afford an improved childcare system? The BBC's Marianne Taylor examines these key questions.

line break
How much does childcare cost?

Childcare policy is devolved to Holyrood. All three and four-year-olds in Scotland are entitled to 12.5 hours per week of free childcare, increasing to 15 hours in August, and extended to vulnerable two-year-olds. In the rest of the UK, state-funded childcare is between 10 and 15 hours a week. Some parents can claim working tax credits from the UK government to help with the costs. Working parents on low incomes can receive up to 70% of their childcare charges up to a maximum of £175 per week for one child and £300 per week for two or more children.

Childcare in Scotland

27%

Family income spent on childcare in Scotland

5%

Family income spent on childcare in Sweden

  • 50% Families relying on grandparents to help with childcare

  • 79% Councils saying they do not have sufficient childcare

  • £1,032 Annual shortfall, per child, in council-funded places at private nurseries

PA

Average weekly childcare costs, 2014 (£)

Region/nation Nursery 25 hours (under 2) Nursery 25 hours (2 and over) Childminder 25 hours (under 2) Childminder (2 and over) After-school club 15 hours

Source: Family and Childcare Trust

Scotland

106.04

102.06

95.59

96.84

49.54

England

110.95

106.19

100.74

101.51

48.40

Wales

103.17

102.28

94.24

94.24

45.98

Britain average

109.89

105.52

99.77

100.52

48.19

line break
Is there anything wrong with the current system?
Children reading books

Parents and childcare experts say the system is expensive, complex and inflexible.

Jackie Brock, chief executive of Children in Scotland, said it was based on parents' ability to pay "and the market's ability to provide and run a business".

The National Day Nurseries Association, which represents private, independent and voluntary facilities, said it was "financially unsustainable", with 92% of nurseries reporting a loss on the "free" places provided by the government. The association said most nurseries had no choice but to pass the extra costs on to parents.

And according to research published by the Family and Childcare Trust in 2013, 40% of local authorities in Scotland do not know if they can provide sufficient childcare for working parents, meaning provision is a postcode lottery that varies from council to council.

line break
What's the SNP's plan if Scotland votes 'Yes' to independence?

Childcare proposals for an independent Scotland

30

Free hours childcare per week for 3, 4 and some 2-year-olds

£4,660

Maximum saving per child per year

  • 212,000 Families better off

  • 35,000 Childcare jobs created

  • £700m Policy cost per year

Thinkstock

Under the Scottish government's proposals, state-funded provision would be doubled to 1,140 hours - equivalent to primary school hours - for all three, four and vulnerable two-year-olds by the end of the first independent parliament. This would be extended to all children over the age of one by the end of the second parliament.

First Minister Alex Salmond says the policy would eventually save an estimated 212,000 families up to £4,600 per year, per child, and create up to 35,000 jobs in the childcare sector.

line break
Is there an appetite for more free childcare?
Pregnant woman at keyboard

A report in 2013 by Save the Children found the high cost of childcare led to 25% of low-paid parents giving up their jobs, while a quarter of non-working mothers with pre-school children mentioned affordability of childcare as their main reason for not getting a job. A recent survey by the website Mumsnet found that two-thirds of mothers said the cost of childcare was an obstacle to them working more hours.

line break
Could Scotland afford a better childcare system?
Baby sleeping

First Minister Alex Salmond believes improving childcare would benefit the economy in an independent Scotland by encouraging more women into work. They in turn would pay tax and help increase economic output.

The Scottish government's White Paper says the childcare plan would initially be funded by savings made from no longer contributing to the UK nuclear weapon and scrapping the UK government's planned married couples tax allowance.

Mr Salmond insisted that his "transformational shift" could only happen under independence.

Economist Prof Donald Mackay backed Mr Salmond's stance, saying "no financially responsible Scottish government would dare to implement the childcare proposals under the fixed block grant funding of devolution, unless they were prepared to take an axe to existing programmes". However, economist Jo Armstrong, professor of public policy at Glasgow University's Adam Smith Institute, said more financial scrutiny was needed.

line break
We know the SNP plan, but what of the other main parties?
Children playing in play park

Labour: The party's education spokeswoman, Kezia Dugdale, said if Labour was in power at Westminster it would extend free childcare for three and four-year-olds to 25 hours a week for working parents, paid for by a levy on banks.

She added; "Labour would also guarantee parents wraparound childcare - access to breakfast clubs or homework clubs - from 08:00 to 18:00 in primary schools. Money would be provided for Scotland, but it would be up to the government there to decide whether to spend it in the same way as England."

Scottish Conservatives: Liz Smith, Tory education spokeswoman, said her party would increase nursery provision, "particularly to disadvantaged youngsters", and was committed to improving the "flexibility and quality of care". She added: "In the 2011 manifesto we made a commitment to ensuring that every three and four and vulnerable two-year-olds would receive 12.5 hours of nursery care per week and stated we would look to go beyond this when finances allowed."

Also the coalition government at Westminster, which includes the Tories and the Lib Dems, announced in March plans to offer families a new childcare subsidy worth up to £2,000 per child.

Scottish Liberal Democrats: The party's education spokesman Liam McArthur said it was important to do more to give "more children in Scotland the best start in life".

He added: "The strength of devolution is that countries within the UK can share the best ideas and benefit from different policy approaches at local, national and UK levels. For example, the UK coalition government's major new childcare voucher scheme will help around 210,000 families in Scotland, saving the typical working family with two children up to £2,400."

More on This Story

Scotland Decides

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    10:29: Ryanair confirms Prestwick routes David Miller BBC Scotland transport correspondent

    Ryanair has confirmed it's to continue flying from Prestwick Airport next summer.

    The budget airline revealed in July that it was transferring several key routes from Prestwick to Glasgow Airport. That led to speculation about the future of passenger services at the Ayrshire terminal.

    Ryanair will operate a total of 44 weekly return flights from Prestwick next summer, and 57 return flights from Glasgow.

     
  2.  
    10:26: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    An accident on the A96 Westbound in Moray between B9015 Mosstodloch and B9103 Lhanbryde has been cleared and traffic has returned to normal.

     
  3.  
    10:22: Man proposes to his girlfriend at Braehead

    A Glasgow man proposed to his partner at a popular shopping centre in the city.

    Tony Moore managed to persuade bosses at Braehead Shopping Centre to show a video of his proposal on a big screen, before he got down on one knee and popped the question.

    Read the full story in the Daily Record.

     
  4.  
    10:10: Managerial casualty

    Ross County have sacked manager Derek Adams and his father George, who was director of football at the club.

    Derek Adams

    In a statement, the club said that the parties "have come to an agreement".

    Adams led County to the 2010 Scottish Cup final during his first spell in charge of the club, and to promotion to the top flight in his second.

    Coach Steve Ferguson and captain Richie Brittain will look after the first team for Saturday's Premiership game at Hamilton Academical.

    County are without a point after four league matches this season.

     
  5.  
    10:05: Cancer sufferers need more help

    Three-quarters of cancer patients who are clinically depressed do not get the psychological therapy they need, according to research in the Lancet.

    Charities say the current situation is "heartbreaking".

    depressed man

    People often wrongly assume that major depression is part of a natural reaction to cancer - but this is much more than transient sadness, the Edinburgh and Oxford university researchers have concluded.

     
  6.  
    10:00: Morning Call - Get Involved

    What would you like to ask Douglas Alexander of the Better Together campaign before you cast your vote in the referendum?

    Louise White and Douglas Alexander

    Call 0500 92 95 00 or text 80295 with your questions.

    You can listen live to the debate here.

     
  7.  
    BBC Scotland Live - Your Views

    What do you think of BBC Scotland Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    We've introduced the rolling text service to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place.

    Tell us what you think here.

     
  8.  
    Text using 80295 Referendum - Your Views

    Andrew, ex-pat in County Durham: It's intriguing me as to what will make the difference in the vote outcome - is it just one vote? If so, why aren't the two sides using this as a strong point in getting their voters into the booths? Also - where will the vote be announce and whom will announce it?

     
  9.  
    09:49: Squirrel leprosy danger

    Scotland's red squirrels are facing a new threat from a form of leprosy, according to scientists in Edinburgh.

    Red squirrel

    Six cases caused by a bacteria similar to Mycobacterium lepromatosis have been confirmed in squirrels in Dumfries and Galloway and the Moray Firth since 2006.

     
  10.  
    09:41: Page turner

    Edinburgh author Alexander McCall Smith has been shortlisted for the Scottish Children's Book Awards.

    McCall Smith's Precious and the Mystery of the Missing Lion is in the younger readers' section.

    Scottish Book Awards

    One of the other shortlisted authors is Alex McCall, a 20-year-old screenwriting and filmmaking student at University of the West of Scotland in Ayr, who will be hoping to win with his work Attack of the Giant Robot Chickens.

     
  11.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 09:28: Your Photos

    Reader Karen Brown sent us this stunning image of Glen Affric near the village of Cannich in the Highlands.

    Glen Affric

    You can send in your own photographs via email or twitter using #ScotlandLive

     
  12.  
    Text using 80295 Referendum - Get Involved

    Stephen, Ayr: In the event of a No vote can we, the British people, claim back all the money wasted on this needless campaign?

    Derick, Monifieth: If we're 'Better Together,' why aren't better together now?

     
  13.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 09:00: Where do we go if it's No? - Get Involved

    There has been plenty of talk about how things will change if there is a "Yes" vote in the Scottish referendum on 18 September.

    But what about if Scotland says "No"?

    BBC News political correspondent Tim Reid says it will be far from "business as usual".

    What do you think? Tell us by texting 80295, via email or at #ScotlandLive.

     
  14.  
    Text using 80295 Referendum - Your Views

    Chris, Dunoon: What happens to the Barnett Formula?

    Anonymous: If we are 'Better Together' why have food banks quadrupled? Why is there an increase in people in poverty with health problems due to malnutrition?

     
  15.  
    08:46: 'I'm your biggest fan'

    The mum of a five-year-old boy who wrote an "amazing" fan letter to Scottish Commonwealth swimming champion Ross Murdoch says he will be "over the moon" to meet his hero.

    Brian Fitzpatrick's note reached the swimmer despite being addressed simply to "Ross Murdoch, Commonwealth Champion, Balloch".

    Brian Fitzpatrick and Ross Murdoch

    The 200m Breaststroke gold medal winner asked Twitter users to help him get back in touch with the youngster.

    Brian's parents, who live in Dumbarton, got in touch after the appeal was retweeted more than 1,300 times.

    Ross now plans to meet Brian and show him where he trains.

    Brian's mother, Claire, said: "He loves swimming and is very excited at the prospect of meeting Ross.

    "To start with, I had no idea Brian was writing to Ross. He started school last week and I just thought he was doodling when he asked me 'Mum, how do you spell, I am your biggest fan?'"

     
  16.  
    08:38: What the papers say

    The Scottish independence debate continues to dominate the front pages ahead of the 18 September vote.

    Newspapers 28 August

    The Scottish Sun leads with a story claiming that senior Conservatives confident of a "No" vote have planned a champagne bash after the poll.

    Elsewhere, The Scotsman claims that Scottish Secretary Alistair Carmichael would leave his UK government post in the event of a "Yes" vote.

    You can read more in our daily newspaper review.

     
  17.  
    Text using 80295 Referendum - Get Involved

    Duncan in the hills: If Scotland votes No this must mean an end to international football and rugby. International comes from Latin, "between nations". Voting No means you deny that we have a status as a nation.

    Anonymous: My question is exactly what extra powers will Scotland be offered?

    Robert from Larkhall: I want to ask that if the Scottish economy is withdrawn from the Bank of England wouldn't there be another banking collapse?

     
  18.  
    08:22: Pro-independence drive

    More than 200 business figures have signed an open letter backing Scottish independence.

    Stagecoach chairman Sir Brian Souter and Clyde Blowers boss Jim McColl are among signatories who say independence is in Scotland's economic interest.

    It comes a day after a similar letter from 130 pro-UK business leaders said the case for independence had not been made.

    The pro-independence letter has been published in The Herald newspaper.

     
  19.  
    08:16: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    In Glasgow, delays on the M74 around Rutherglen and congestion on the M8 heading eastbound at around Junction 28 Glasgow Airport, and Junction 27 Arkleston.

    Surface water on the M80 Northbound between Junction 4A Low Wood and Junction 5 Auchenkilns is also causing delays.

     
  20.  
    08:10: New York, New York...

    Andy Murray will aim to avoid the cramp he suffered in his first round win at the US Open, when he faces German qualifier Matthias Bachinger.

    Murray's second-round match at Flushing Meadows will open the late session on Arthur Ashe Stadium in the Big Apple.

    Andy Murray

    "I didn't feel unbelievably nervous before my first match (against Robin Haase)," Murray told BBC Sport.

    "I wasn't putting too much pressure on myself either - no-one really has any expectations of me here anyway.

    "I don't feel any different but I'm happy I'm still in the tournament. I could easily be on my way home."

    The Scot will take centre stage from 00:00 on Friday.

     
  21.  
    08:05: Morning Call Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    On Morning Call we are giving you the chance to put your questions to the politicians at the heart of the referendum campaign. Tomorrow it's the First Minister Alex Salmond, but today it's the turn of Shadow Foreign Secretary Douglas Alexander.

    Louise White Morning Call

    So what question do you want to ask Douglas Alexander of the Better Together campaign before you cast your vote?

    Tell us what you think by calling 0500 92 95 00, texting 80295 or via email. The lines are open now.

    You can listen live to the debate here.

     
  22.  
    Weather Update Judith Ralston BBC Weather presenter

    Rain sweeping north becoming confined to Orkney. Shetland staying dry with sunshine. Dry for a time before showers develop mainly in south. A lot of dry, sunny weather in the north pm. Temps ranging from 15C n/e coast with some mist here. 18/19 for most, 21C Inv & Moray.

     
  23.  
    08:01: Economy Boost

    The UK is "an economy of opportunity" which supports one million Scottish jobs, David Cameron is to tell business leaders.

    The prime minister will address the CBI conference later, calling the UK one of the "most successful single markets".

    Prime Minister David Cameron

    The speech takes place in the final weeks of the referendum campaign.

    Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond challenged Mr Cameron to name a single job-creating power certain to come after a "No" vote.

     
  24.  
    08:00: Rise and Shine... Thomas McGuigan BBC Sport

    Good morning and a warm welcome from the Scotland Live team as we provide our rolling live text service of news, sport, weather and travel from across the country between now and 6pm.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Child museumChild's play

    Should children be allowed to run wild in museums? BBC Culture investigates

Programmes

  • Going through ice across the Northwest PassageThe Travel Show Watch

    Navigating the treacherous Northwest Passage through ice and Arctic storms

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.