Mesh implants victims give 'heartbreaking' evidence to MSPs

Olive McIlroy and Elaine Holmes at the Scottish Parliament Olive McIlroy, centre, and Elaine Holmes, who have both received surgical mesh implants, giving their 'heartbreaking' evidence to the the Scottish Parliament

Related Stories

Women who suffered "life-changing side effects" after receiving surgical implants have given evidence to a committee of MSPs.

The Scottish Mesh Survivors campaign urged the Scottish government to suspend all such implant surgery pending a safety inquiry.

Health Secretary Alex Neil said he was hoping to discuss the matter with the medicines regulator.

He added that action was being taken to make GPs more aware of the issue.

About 1,500 women in Scotland receive transvaginal mesh implants every year, usually to treat a prolapsed bladder and relieve incontinence, often as a result of childbirth.

However, some have been left in constant pain after the implants hardened, and have been told they can never have sex again.

Convenor of the petitions committee David Stewart called on the Scottish government to act.

Mr Neil said he had written to the chairman of the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) seeking an "urgent meeting to discuss on-going concerns over the use of transvaginal mesh implants".

He added: "It is extremely upsetting to hear the accounts of women who have experienced unimaginable suffering as a result of having this procedure.

From Democracy Live: Olive McIlroy, centre, told MSPS all mesh implant surgery should be suspended in Scotland, pending a safety inquiry

"I personally met with some of the women affected and I am clear that no-one else should have to go through the suffering they have experienced.

"It is imperative that we have expert opinion of the full implications of the use of mesh implants and I think it is of paramount importance that we can be in a position to reassure women all across Scotland that this issue is being treated with the severity it deserves."

Hundreds of claims are due before the Scottish courts within the next year, with cases already under way in the US and Canada, where the authorities have issued warnings to hospitals.

Start Quote

One of the big problems has been that the women were not given proper advice before they got the operations”

End Quote Olive McIlroy Scottish Mesh Survivors

An expert group set up by the Scottish government to look at the issue met for the first time in February.

It is developing a revised information leaflet for use in the NHS in Scotland, which will be given to women in advance of undergoing the procedure.

However, Olive McIlroy from Scottish Mesh Survivors said she wanted ministers to go further.

She said: "In a nutshell, we are asking for mesh implant surgery to be suspended pending a safety inquiry, for reporting of adverse incidents to be mandatory for doctors - currently only 12 have reported cases to the MHRA despite more than 300 women undergoing repeated operations.

"[We] want an implant register to act as an early warning system as the current system is clearly not working.

"The women have been working on new consent forms which will contain all the complications. One of the big problems has been that the women were not given proper advice before they got the operations.

"They weren't told the life changing side effects and they were not offered alternatives. We have some of the world's top docs writing to Health Secretary Alex Neil asking him to stop mesh in our hospitals."

'Compelling petition'

Following the committee meeting, convener Mr Stewart said: "This is one of the most compelling petitions we have had before us.

"We heard moving and indeed heartbreaking evidence from the petitioners and the committee was united in its determination to address the issue.

"We will ask the Cabinet Secretary to give evidence at our next meeting as there must be action and there must be action now."

More on This Story

Related Stories

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

More Scotland stories



Elsewhere on the BBC

  • MoviesWhat to watch

    BBC Culture picks eight top movies coming out in September


  • Man dancingClick Watch

    Searching for the DNA of dance music – the quest to find the perfect party anthem

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.