Edinburgh, Fife & East Scotland

Review of David Gilroy's murder conviction closed

David Gilroy Image copyright PA
Image caption David Gilroy was sentenced to life in prison for murdering Suzanne Pilley

A review of the case of David Gilroy, who was convicted of murdering Suzanne Pilley in 2012, has been closed.

Ms Pilley, 38, disappeared on her way to work in central Edinburgh in May 2010 but her body has never been found.

Gilroy asked for his case to be considered by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission, claiming he had suffered a miscarriage of justice.

The commission said it has now completed its review and the case has been closed.

Gilroy could ask for a subsequent review of the case by the commission but only if, for example, new evidence came to light.

His family have issued a statement saying they are "shocked" at the decision to closed the case.

He was sentenced to life in prison after being found guilty of her murder in March 2012, but he continued to protest his innocence.

Image copyright PA
Image caption Suzanne Pilley's body has never been found.

Ms Pilley, who had previously had an affair with married Gilroy, had set off on her usual journey to work in Edinburgh city centre but never arrived.

The jury in Gilroy's trial heard he was driven by jealousy, maintained a front of normality and embarked on a series of acts to cover up his crime.

He took Ms Pilley's body to a secret grave, believed to be in remote Argyll.

When Gilroy later appealed his conviction it was rejected and he failed in a bid to have his case looked at by the UK Supreme Court.

The Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission announced its review of the case in January 2015.

It was set up to investigate possible miscarriages of justice. Only a small number are referred back to the High Court.

A statement from Gilroy's family said: "We are shocked not just at the decision but also at what seems to us to be many instances where the commission's analysis has fallen far short of a full and fair investigation into the detail of the application which David, supported by us, made to them in November 2014.

"We will now consider what else we can do to support David in his quest to clear his name in the hope that a fresh inquiry will take place which may stand some chance of uncovering the truth."

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites