Scottish independence: 'Retain welfare set-up for transitional period'

UK in coins The Scottish government has welcomed the report on the delivery of welfare in an independent Scotland

The administration of pensions and benefits in an independent Scotland should be shared with the rest of the UK for a transitional period, according to a welfare working group.

The Scottish government, which commissioned the group's report, welcomed the proposal.

But it wants the ability to reverse policies, like the housing benefit cuts which critics dubbed the "bedroom tax".

The Scotland Office said leaving the UK but keeping UK welfare "didn't add up".

The Expert Working Group on Welfare was set up by the Scottish government in January 2013 to look at the costs and delivery of welfare should there be a yes vote in the 2014 independence referendum.

Its report said the Scottish and UK governments have "a strong common interest in working together, to support each other in maintaining the delivery of benefit payments during an agreed period of transition".

A large proportion of welfare payments are processed in Scotland.

The working group said Scotland delivers almost all parts of the current UK benefits system to people living in Scotland from locations within Scotland. However, many services to claimants in England also come from Scotland.


There are more than 10,000 people employed by the UK government's department for work and pensions in Scotland.

They don't all administer pensions and benefits, but many of those that do are servicing claimants all over Britain (Northern Ireland has its own set-up).

There are two major pensions centres in Scotland - Dundee and Motherwell.

Together they handle about a fifth of all British state pensions and about a quarter of all pension credit claims.

That means that there are millions of people in England and Wales whose welfare payments are processed from Scotland.

There are also many benefits paid to Scottish claimants that are handled by processing centres in other parts of Britain.

The point is that the existing set-up is integrated, complex and potentially tricky to unpick.

That is why the Scottish government is keen to accept its expert group's recommendation that an independent Scotland should keep sharing the welfare delivery system with the rest of the UK for a transitional period.

It's a way of reassuring people that after independence they would receive pensions and benefits in the same way as they did before.

Of course, this would have to be agreed with the rest of the UK. But Scottish ministers think a deal would be forthcoming because of the volume of work that Scottish centres carry out for other parts of Britain.

The UK government says the key issue is not delivery but affordability in the longer term.

It argues that Scotland would be better off funding pensions and benefits for a growing elderly population from a UK wide tax base, rather than from revenues generated only in Scotland.

The report stated: "Scotland provides a wide range of services to England. Some of these services are significant... and involve a claimant count measured in millions rather than thousands."

It said: "Immediately separating these services would present serious risks to the continuity of payments to people in both Scotland and England and so a challenge for both an independent Scottish government and a UK government representing the interests of the remaining parts of the United Kingdom."

The working group said the Scottish government's preliminary forecasts on the costs of benefit spending in Scotland through to 2017-18 were "reasonable", given the information available to it.

However, it recommended that, in the event of a yes vote, the Scottish government should build its capacity to forecast benefit spending and to assess the impact of changes to the system on individuals and households.

The report also went on to consider evidence taken from various organisations, individuals and communities with a close interest in the current system.

It then presented some possibilities for changes to the benefits system which it said could be considered in an independent Scotland.

The report said: "It is clear to us, however, that there is a very strong appetite across Scotland for a wider conversation about the principles and policies, opportunities and choices, which governments in an independent Scotland might wish to pursue."

Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon welcomed the findings and published an initial response to the report.

She said: "People want to know that benefits - including pensions - will be delivered seamlessly from the point of independence. I therefore welcome the report's finding that almost all benefit payments to people in Scotland - including all pensions - are administered from locations within Scotland.

"In other words, the infrastructure of our welfare system already exists in Scotland.

"The report also makes the point that millions of people in England receive benefits that are administered from within Scotland. In light of that, I tend to agree with the group that a transitional period of shared administration would make sense."

New group

However, Ms Sturgeon said the Scottish government would only accept the sharing of services if that would not prevent it from reversing welfare policies it opposed, including changes to housing benefits.

She added: "I am very clear that a transitional period of shared administration would only be in Scotland's interests if it allows us, from day one of independence, to address the inequities of the current system and work towards a system that better reflects Scotland's needs and circumstances."

Start Quote

The Scottish government seem to have their heart set on the impossible. ”

End Quote Michael Moore MP Scottish Secretary

Scottish Secretary Michael Moore said it was not credible for Scotland to leave the UK family, keep the welfare system, but change welfare policies.

He said he was also disappointed that the Scottish government had not given more details about how it would deliver its policy of a fully separate welfare system in the longer term.

He said: "It seems that time and again we wait for the Scottish government to unveil one of their main building blocks of an independent Scotland only for questions to emerge where answers should be.

"The Scottish government seem to have their heart set on the impossible. They want to leave the UK and keep the UK welfare system. But they only want to keep the UK welfare system if they can insist upon immediate policy changes.

"I think most people in Scotland will regard this as a self-defeating contortion.

He added: "It is deeply disappointing that the Scottish government has passed up on another opportunity to spell out what sort of welfare system an independent Scotland would have and how it would be funded."

The UK government has also made available a document outlining what is says are facts and analysis about independence and welfare.

The deputy first minister has announced that a new group will now look at the medium and longer-term options for reform of the welfare system in an independent Scotland.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • TravelAround the world

    BBC Travel takes a look at the most striking images from the past seven days


  • A bicycle with a Copenhagen WheelClick Watch

    The wheel giving push bikes an extra boost by turning them into smart electric hybrids

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.