Scottish referendum: Think tank says post-independent army would struggle

The King's Own Scottish Borderers The think tank has questioned how a Scotland-only army would cope

An independent Scotland would have a limited defence force which would struggle to recruit and retain personnel, a report has suggested.

Think tank The Scotland Institute has produced what it claimed was a "comprehensive review".

SNP defence spokesman Angus Robertson said independence would protect defence jobs and stop "Whitehall making bad decisions on our behalf".

Voters in Scotland are going to be asked to decide on independence.

On 18 September next year, the electorate will say "yes" or "no" to the question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

Start Quote

I cannot see how slicing up a competent and well established military will aid either the United Kingdom or an independent Scotland”

End Quote Major-General Andrew Mackay Defence report chairman

Think tanks, experts and lobbyists, as well as the UK and Scottish governments, have been producing their own reports on the impact of independence.

This latest one, titled Defence and Security in an Independent Scotland, had input from armed forces personnel, defence academics, former secretaries of defence and senior officials from Nato, UK MOD and the EU.

It was chaired by Major-General Andrew Mackay who commanded a Task Force in Afghanistan and served in the army for 27 years.

In the report's foreword, he said: "I cannot see how slicing up a competent and well established military will aid either the United Kingdom or an independent Scotland.

"Indeed, I see very real risks to the people of Scotland, be it from the loss of jobs and the local economic impact that the inevitable removal of the Faslane naval base would bring, the huge costs necessary to start building the armed forces from afresh, the loss of access to sensitive intelligence materials and the inevitable dilution in the quality and number of the armed forces of this small island, which to date have had such a profound effect upon the course of world events."

The report suggested that after independence Scotland would be more vulnerable to terrorist and cyber attack because it would need time to establish an intelligence body capable of dealing with these threats.

Limited functions

It insisted that post-Yes Scotland would not be either "cheaper or easier to defend".

Start Quote

To have serious credibility, this report must also outline Scotland's vast defence assets, as an independent Scotland would of course not be starting from scratch”

End Quote Angus Robertson SNP defence spokesman

The authors believed what would result would be a "very small military force, able to perform a limited number of niche functions such as protecting Scotland's fisheries and oil refineries".

It also judged that an independent Scotland would find it difficult to maintain an air force "of any consequence" and would possess a "truncated navy stripped of submarine forces".

However, Nationalist MP Mr Robertson hit back saying that there would be better defence decisions in Scotland post independence.

He was critical of the UK government's move in recent years to close bases, disband units and scrap "vital" capabilities like maritime patrol.

Mr Robertson added: "To have serious credibility, this report must also outline Scotland's vast defence assets, as an independent Scotland would of course not be starting from scratch - but the key difference is that after independence, Scotland would decide how to spend all of the money it contributes to defence.

"A sovereign Scotland can therefore increase spending on conventional defence in Scotland while making savings from Trident. An annual defence and security budget of £2.5bn would be around £500m more than is currently spent by the UK government in Scotland - but £1bn less than Scots taxpayers currently contribute to the UK's defence policy.

"Normal democratic countries make their own defence decisions - our best future is to make the right decisions for Scotland and we will be able to do that with independence."

Defence and Security in an Independent Scotland

Contributors Role

Major-General Andrew Douglas Mackay CBE

Chairman of panel

Dr Azeem Ibrahim

Executive chairman of The Scotland Institute

Simon Smith

Senior research fellow, The Scotland Institute

Prof Mark Webber

Head of the School of Government and Society, University of Birmingham

Prof Sir Hew Strachan

Fellow, All Souls College Oxford University

Prof Brian Holden Reid

Professor of Military Institutions, Department of War Studies, Kings College, London

Lord Browne of Ladyton

Former secretary of state for defence

Lord Reid of Cardowan

Former secretary of state for defence

Sir Malcolm Rifkind

Former secretary of state for defence

Lord Robertson

Former secretary general Nato

Angus Robertson MP

SNP's spokesman on foreign affairs and defence

Luke Skipper

SNP defence spokesman

General Sir John George Reith

Former Nato deputy supreme allied commander, Europe

Air Commodore Gordon Moulds

Former British forces commander

General Prof Sir Paul Newton

Former commander and director of Strategy and Security Institute, Exeter University

Lieutenant General Sir Alistair Stuart Hastings Kirwin

Adjutant-General to the Forces, 2003 to 2005

Lieutenant Colonel Stuart Crawford

Royal Tank Regiment and former SNP parliamentary candidate

Prof Malcolm Chalmers

Director Royal United Services Institute for Defence and security Studies

Prof Paul Cornish

Professor of strategic studies, University of Exeter

Prof John Deni

Research professor Joint, Interagency, Intergovernmental and Multinational (JIIM)

Dr Rob Dover

Senior lecturer international relations, Loughborough University

Dr David Dunn

Head of the department of political science and and international studies, University of Birmingham

Prof Tim Edmunds

Professor of international security, University of Bristol

Dr Colin Fleming

Leverhulme early career fellow, University

Prof John Gearson

Professor Department of War Studies, King's College London

Prof Anthony King

Professor, University of Exeter

Dr MJ Williams

Reader international relations, Royal Holloway, University of London

Major Sir Edward Mountain

Former commander and adjutant career planning UK Armed Forces

Prof Mikkel Vedby Rasmussen

Centre for Military Studies, University of Copenhagen, Denmark

Prof Keith Hartley

Emeritus professor of defence economics, University of York

Prof Trevor Taylor

Emeritus professor of defence and security, Cranfield Unviersity

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • KnucklesGood or bad?

    For many it can be very satisfying to 'crack' the bones in your hand, but is it bad for you?


  • BatteriesClick Watch

    More power to your phone - the lithium-ion batteries that could last twice as long

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.