Scotland's future: Your 10 independence questions

With less than a year to go until the Scottish independence referendum, there are many questions about what a "Yes" vote might mean.

  • For more on the Scottish independence referendum go to the BBC's Scotland's Future page.

BBC news website readers have been telling us the kind of things they want answered ahead of the poll on 18 September 2014.

Here are 10 of the most frequently asked questions........

1. Alex O'Brien asks: "I recently renewed two UK passports for my wife and I. Will I require a new one if the vote is 'Yes'?

The Scottish government intends to bring in a separate Scottish passport under independence, but says Scots would be free either to retain their British passport, or hold both.

Finding the answers

The Scottish government says it will answer "all your questions" when it publishes its vision for independence on 26 November.

That said, UK Home Secretary Theresa May says the Westminster government may not allow Scottish dual citizenship, adding that the issue will be considered along with SNP policy on citizenship, and membership of the EU.

Current UK Border Agency policy states that British subjects can keep their British passport, as long as the country in which they want to hold another passport (which in this case would be an independent Scotland) allows dual nationality.

2. Iain Morrison asks: "What is envisaged as the national anthem for a new independent Scotland? As someone born of Scots parents in England, I am proud of my Scottish inheritance but I feel that the lyrics of the current anthem 'Flower of Scotland' are far too nationalistic."

Scotland does not currently have its own official national anthem, but it seems certain that, under independence, the nation would seek to adopt one.

Want to know more?

The SNP-run Scottish government has already been outlining what it wants to happen in the event of independence. So, what do we already know about the Nationalist vision?

God Save the Queen is the national anthem for the whole United Kingdom, but tunes such as Flower of Scotland and Scotland the Brave have long been used as an unofficial Scots anthems, especially at sporting events.

There have been numerous suggestions over the years to find Scotland's national song, from adopting one of the above to coming up with a brand new one - although the SNP's policy of retaining the Monarch under independence means God Save the Queen could still have its place.

3. Jim Green asks: "What will be the proportion of votes needed to favour independence for the result to be declared a 'Yes'?"

The result of the independence referendum will be decided by a simple majority.

That means a "Yes" vote of "50% plus one" would be enough to gain independence.

There is no turnout requirement for next year's vote - unlike the 1979 devolution referendum, in which the "Yes" vote had to exceed 40% of the total electorate.

4. Geoff Parry asks: "Assuming a 'Yes' vote for separation in 2014, would Scots be able to vote in a UK election if that were held between the date of the referendum and the date in 2016 when the' Yes' vote would take effect?"

If the September 2014 referendum returns a "Yes" vote, the SNP says it would take 18 months to prepare for full independence - that's March 2016.

Differing views

The UK government has been publishing a series of papers on why it believes the Union should remain intact.

The next UK election, due to happen in May 2015, would come in the middle of that - but Scotland would still then be a member of the UK, so it is likely Scots would still be able to vote for their local MP.

However, in the event of a "Yes" vote, the question is - would anyone stand for election to one of Scotland's 59 Westminster seats, in the knowledge they faced redundancy the following year?

5. Len Loullis asks: "If Scotland attains independence, will it still be a member of the EU?"

Nobody has seriously suggested that an independent Scotland cannot or would not be a European Union member - the argument has centred around how long it might take.

SNP thinking in the past few years has gone from saying membership would be "automatic" to a position that Scotland, having been part of EU member state Britain, would negotiate its position "from within".

Scottish Finance Secretary John Swinney is confident there would be enough time in the 18-month window for the process to be completed, but opponents have said such talks could be lengthy and very complicated.

6. Anne MacDonald asks: "I work in the NHS and am close to retirement age. What will happen to state pensions in an independent Scotland? And, does Alex Salmond propose to keep age changes in the state pension?"

The Scottish government says benefits, tax credits and state pensions would continue to be paid from the first day of independence, with the same level of protection that currently exists.

Scotland's future: Viewpoints

The BBC news website has been publishing a number of webcasts on the Scottish independence debate. They can be found on our Scotland's Future website.

Pensions expert David Davison, from actuarial firm Spence & Partners, says the challenge would be the transition of schemes from one administration to another.

On the policy front, the SNP - if it became the party of government in an independent Scotland - says that, from 2016, new pensioners would get £160 a week, making them £1.10 better off than those in the rest of the UK. It has also pledged to set up a commission looking at what level the state pension age should be.

7. Gary Woolton asks: "What would happen to in Scotland? As no longer part of the UK would Scottish-based business, individuals using addresses still be entitled to use them or would a new domain be set up? What would the cost to business be if this was the case"?

Plans for an optional .scot domain have been accepted by the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), following a campaign by not-for-profit company Dot Scot Registry and have passed the initial evaluation process. This means the domain could be ready to go live in January 2015, regardless of the referendum result.

All domains are administered by UK registry Nominet, which says the domain names they manage are not currently subject to any geographic restrictions. Therefore the status of registrants and prospective registrants should not be affected by Scotland becoming an independent country.

Nominet has consulted on proposals that, post-independence, Scottish companies wishing to keep or apply for a .uk domain would have to nominate a UK address of service to which legal papers could be served.

8. Lorrie Godwin asks: "Will Scotland have a second chamber and if so will it be elected?"

Scottish devolution was seen as a chance to do things differently from Westminster and its single-chamber setup, backed up by Holyrood's cross-party committees, is regarded as a system which works well and is not likely to change.

The campaigners

Both sides of the Scottish independence debate have well established campaigns with well established websites - Yes Scotland is for independence and Better Together is pro-Union.

There has been some support for a second chamber - from nationalist-leaning commentator Michael Fry for one - but the SNP's continued dominance in Scottish politics would keep it off the agenda, given the party's opposition to the UK House of Lords.

Apart from anything else, the Scottish Parliament may need to build an extension to make it happen.

9. Derek McAllister asks: "What percentage of the UK national debt will be transferred to an independent Scotland?"

This would have to be negotiated, but the SNP has touted a figure of £92bn, based on population, while they also argue Scotland's share of the national debt should be lessened because of the high contribution to the UK's coffers by oil and gas from Scotland's shores.

The National Institute of Economic and Social Research says Scotland's debt could be 86% of national income- significantly lower than the 101% calculated for the rest of the UK.

There is also an argument that, with no track record of servicing debt, the new independent nation of Scotland could face a higher borrowing cost - between 0.72% and 1.65% above UK borrowing costs for 10-year debt.

10. Ian Thompson asks: "Would the UK still be called the UK after Scottish independence? Wales is not a kingdom, neither is Northern Ireland. Would the UK just refer to its other title of Great Britain?"

It could be assumed the term "UK" might continue to stand for England, Wales and Northern Ireland, given it is a term people know and that the Union of the Scottish and English crowns would continue under independence.

The term UK is not synonymous with Great Britain.

Britain refers to England, Wales and Scotland, while the UK also includes Northern Ireland. Therefore, using the title Great Britain to refer to the Union of England, Wales and Northern Ireland would be incorrect as it would include Scotland, which in the event of independence would no longer be part of this union, and exclude Northern Ireland which would remain part of the Union.

Technically speaking Northern Ireland is a province and Wales although formerly a principality, was officially reclassified as a country in January 2012 by the International Organisation for Standards (ISO).

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories


Scotland Live

    Warm and sunny 14:26: Judith Ralston BBC Weather presenter

    It will be sunny and warm this afternoon for most of Scotland. Some patchy haar will continue to affect parts of the east coast and there will be a little more in the way of cloud towards the west coast in places.

    Temperatures will climb to a very warm 24C or 25C across the mainland, around around 18C to 20C for the Western and Northern Isles.

    You can watch a full weather forecast here.

    Man electrocuted on rail line 14:05:

    A man has died after being electrocuted on a railway line in Edinburgh.

    The Edinburgh to Glasgow Central line was closed from 08:50 until 10:20, affecting hundreds of commuters travelling to West Lothian, Shotts and Carstairs.

    Haymarket station

    The man's body was found on the line, west of Haymarket. His death is not being treated as suspicious by the British transport Police.

    Commuters were still able to travel on the Glasgow Queen Street line.

    BBC Scotland Live - Your views 13:55: Bryan Quinn BBC Scotland News

    What do you think of BBC Scotland Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    We've introduced the minute-by-minute commentary to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place.

    Tell us what you think.

    Countryside life 13:39:

    Images have been released from a photography contest which explores what the traditional way of life means to crofters.

    Registers of Scotland has announced the winners of its "Click Your Croft" photography competition.

    Registers of Scotland

    Run in association with the Scottish Crofting Federation and the Crofting Commission, the contest set out to explore what this traditional way of life means to crofters in 2014.

    You can see a selection of the images here.

    River of fortunes 13:15:

    As Glasgow makes the final preparations for its Commonwealth Games, BBC special correspondent Allan Little took a journey along the River Clyde to chart the city's reinvention.

    The River Clyde

    Read Allan's thoughtful piece here.

    Coming up at 13:30 13:07: Jackie Bird BBC Scotland presenter

    On this lunchtime's Reporting Scotland, I'll have the latest on how Glasgow is creating business links with Commonwealth countries ahead of the Games, and we'll be live from a street party in the city's east end.

    You can watch the programme live here.

    Starring role for baton 12:48:

    The Queen's Baton Relay makes a special appearance in tonight's River City.

    River City's Molly with the baton

    As you'll see tonight on BBC One Scotland at 20:00, resident gossip Molly takes her role as baton bearer pretty seriously...

    Tam's readathon 12:43: Via Twitter Pauline McLean BBC Scotland

    Day 39 and @tamdeanburn is still on his feet for his marathon reading of all Julia donaldson's books @culture2014

    Tough draw for Scots 12:31:

    Hopes are high for Scottish badminton duo Imogen Bankier and Kirsty Gilmour to grab a medal at Glasgow 2014, but they've been handed a tough draw in the women's doubles event.

    Kirsty Gilmour and Imogen Bankier

    In a mouth-watering first round match, Bankier and Gilmour are up against English fourth seeds Gabby Adcock and Lauren Smith.

    Elsewhere, in the badminton team event, Scotland have been placed in Group C alongside New Zealand, Guernsey and Seychelles.

    Swan attacks force kayak ban 12:17:

    Edinburgh Leisure has been forced to cancel water sports at one of its venues because a swan has been attacking people.

    Craiglockhart pond

    Kayaking has been banned on Craiglockhart pond after the bird became aggressive while protecting its cygnets.

    Police appeal after assault 12:11:

    A young woman has been assaulted near Fearn in Easter Ross.

    The incident happened at about 13:00 on Monday near Rhynie Farm, about a mile from Fearn.

    Police appeal generic

    Police want to trace a man described as in his 30s, 5ft 10in tall, of slim build and wearing dark trousers and a white top.

    Games guide 12:05: BBC Sport Scotland

    tweets: With just 1 day to go until the @Glasgow2014 Opening Ceremony, here's a day-by-day guide to the Games

    Never miss a Beatt 11:57: John Beattie BBC Scotland

    On today's show, we'll be looking at the grieving process in light of the Malaysian Airlines plane crash in Ukraine - how can you grieve for a family member if there is no body to bury? Text us your views to 80295.

    Also, are Commonwealth Games are only for Glasgow's benefit or will they help Scotland as a whole?

    You can listen to the show live here.

    John Beattie Cycling diary

    You'll also be able to read the latest entry to my daily cycling diary, experiencing the sights and sounds of Glasgow as the Games get under way.

    Horsing around 11:38:

    Jack Alston sent us this stunning shot of two horses - and thousands of midges - as the sun sets on New Lanark.


    You can tweet us your pictures using #ScotlandLive or email them here.

    Baton ballet 11:27:

    Perhaps the most elegant moment in the entire 39-day relay so far came a few minutes ago when when dancers from Scottish Ballet, which is headquartered in Glasgow's south side, took the baton.

    Scottish Ballet dancers with the baton
    Carers face allegations 11:21:

    Two Aberdeen social care workers have been accused of failing in their care of young people.

    The allegations will be heard at Scottish Social Services Council misconduct hearings in Dundee next week.

    The cases against the two workers include several alleged incidents of both physical and verbal abuse towards people in their care between January 2012 and July 2013.

    Swim warning 11:13:

    A warning about swimming in open water has been issued after two young girls had to be rescued after getting into difficulties in the Solway Firth.

    Solway Firth

    The girls - aged 12 and 16 - got into difficulties near Rockcliffe on Monday afternoon and were pulled to safety by members of the Kippford Inshore Lifeboat.

    The not so long walk to Celtic Park 11:07: Via Twitter Games Travel 2014

    tweets: Got a ticket for the Opening Ceremony tomorrow? Why not walk or cycle? Signage showing the way from city centre

    Biker dies in Fife 11:02:

    Police are appealing for witnesses after a motorbike rider died following a collision with a camper van and a car in Fife.

    The accident happened on the A919 St Michael's to Leuchars Road at about 17:00 on Monday.

    Police said the accident involved a Yamaha motorbike, a Volvo car and a camper van.

    Your photos 10:57:

    Valerie Pegler from Livingston sent us this close-up shot of a bee she took while enjoying a walk along the Borders Abbey Way from Kelso to Jedburgh.

    Valerie Pegler

    Send us your photos via email or on Twitter using #scotlandlive and we'll feature the best ones online.

    Latest updates
    How would the UK fare without Scotland? 10:47:

    If Scotland votes for independence on 18 September, what would it actually mean for the rest of the UK? Read our latest analysis of how land, population, the economy and political representation would be affected if Scotland cuts loose.

    pair of scissors
    Slateford body find 10:43: Via Twitter Edinburgh Evening News

    tweets: Police called after body found beside Slateford railway track.

    Read the full story here.

    Wiggins critical of velodrome 10:36:

    Sir Bradley Wiggins has said his fellow knight Sir Chris Hoy deserves more prominence in the Glasgow velodrome named after him.

    Bradley Wiggins

    The former Tour de france champion branded the Commonwealth venue "a bit corporate", and said he would be "a bit p***** off" he were Sir Chris.

    Do you agree with Sir Bradley? And which sports star do you think should have a venue named after them? Tweet us #ScotlandLive, email us here or text us on 80295.

    Salmond speech 10:34: James Cook Scotland Correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: Alex Salmond speaking in splendid surroundings at Commonwealth business conference in Glasgow Uni. #Glasgow2014biz

    Salmond speech
    Saints in for Forster? 10:27:

    The transfer market looks set to heat up with reports of English Premiership team Southampton preparing a £7.5m bid for Celtic's goalkeeper Fraser Forster. However, the bid is believed to fall short of the Parkhead club's valuation of the player.

    Fraser Forster Celtic

    Elsewhere, Motherwell say they are confident of European progress while Rangers midfielder Lewis Macleod says he can make himself a first-team regular after beating a mystery illness which sidelined him last season.

    Read the rest of our Scottish football gossip here.

    Planes, trains and automobiles 10:16: Laura Pettigrew BBC Scotland news website

    As tens of thousands of people prepare to descend upon Commonwealth Games venues across Glasgow and beyond, organisers have been putting huge effort into encouraging people to plan their journeys.

    Glasgow transport

    Read my new guide to making sure you get your travel plans right.

    Science funding for Glasgow 10:05:

    Chancellor George Osborne will announce £18m of funding for life sciences and a new centre for business on a visits to Glasgow later today.

    George Osborne

    Mr Osborne will tell political and business leaders at the Commonwealth Games Business Conference that it could help create 30,000 jobs.

    Russia - Your views 09:57: Via SMS

    Gordon, in Falkirk: I wonder if the gentleman wanting nothing at all to happen to Russia would be saying the same if it were his wife or child blasted from the sky.

    Mags: There isn't much chance of Europe doing anything as they are too dependant on Russia's oil and gas. Germany need their gas so nothing will happen.

    Des Swan on the Isle of Bute: Europe & the USA are hypocrites. They killed thousands of innocent people in Iraq & Afganistan & now want to drag us into another war that CAN'T be won.

    Morning Call's lines are still open - call 0500 92 95 00 or text 80295.

    You can listen live to the debate here.

    Go Gordon! 09:48:

    Scotland manager Gordon Strachan has completed his run with the baton. The 57-year-old, who won 50 caps for his country, ran into Hampden before completing a lap of the new athletics track inside the stadium.

    Gordon Strachan QBR

    You can watch live footage and text commentary from the relay on the dedicated BBC Queen's Baton Relay site.

    Making the news 09:44:

    The aftermath of the Malaysian Airways crash continues to dominate several of Scotland's newspapers with the Scotsman and Scottish Daily Mail leading with new developments on the story.

    Claims of a £3bn bank fixing scandal makes the front page of the Herald, while the Scottish Sun runs with a story about problems behind the scenes of the Commonwealth Games.

    Newspaper review 22 July

    Read more about the stories making the front pages in our daily newspaper review.

    More rail disruption 09:34: Via Twitter ScotRail

    tweets: Owing to emergency services dealing with an incident btwn Edinburgh/Glasgow Ctrl srvcs btwn Edinburgh/Glasgow Ctl via Shotts are disrupted

    Rail delays 09:30: Via Twitter TransPennine Express

    tweets: INFO: Due to a person struck by a train near #Haymarket services in this area may be delayed or cancelled at short notice

    Today's weather 09:27: Judith Ralston BBC Weather presenter

    It'll be a dry day with spells of warm sunshine. The odd mist or fog patch inland will clear quickly this morning, with haar affecting eastern coastal areas. This will burn off allowing the sun to come through, although the odd patch may linger along the east coast.

    Temperatures will soar to a very warm 23C to 26C across the mainland and around 19C or 20C for the Western and Northern Isles. The odd light shower may develop along the west coast later in the day.

    You can watch a full weather forecast here.

    Morning Call 09:20: BBC Radio Scotland

    This morning, Kaye Adams asks: what should Europe do about Russia? European leaders will meet today to discuss possible measures and Britain is leading the call for tough economic sanctions. Is that the way to go?

    And why have complaints against health workers trebled in recent years? Is it cause for concern?

    Tell us what you think by calling 0500 92 95 00, texting 80295 or emailing. The lines are open now.

    You can listen live to the debate here.

    Queen's Baton Relay 09:12:

    It's Day 39, and the baton is almost home! Today it will tour Glasgow's south side, culminating in a special event in Queen's Park at around 18:00. Here's a map and some rough timings for the day:

    Baton Glasgow route

    08:55 Mount Florida 09:20 Toryglen 09:50 Polmadie 10:05 Govanhill 10:25 Gorbals 10:40 Eglinton Toll 10:45 Pollokshields 12:30 Bellahouston

    13:15 Govan 14:55 Cardonald 15:25 Crookston 15:35 Pollok 15:45 Mosspark 16:00 Bellahouston 16:55 Dumbreck 17:20 Langside

    17:30 Shawlands 17:45 Strathbungo 17:55 Mount Florida 18:05 Queen's Park

    Grimmy at the Quay 09:05:

    It's been an early start to BBC At The Quay this morning with BBC Radio 1's Nick Grimshaw presenting his breakfast show live from the site. Early bird music fans were treated to a special live performance from Ella Eyre.

    BBC Live at The Quay

    Find out more about the BBC At The Quay festival here.

    Welcome 09:00: Marianne Taylor BBC Scotland news

    Good morning and welcome to BBC Scotland Live, your minute-by-minute guide to the latest news, sport, travel and weather across the country.

    You can get in touch using Twitter #BBCScotlandLive, by email or by text on 80295.



  • Games lane sign, bus, cars and journey times signGames ready?

    Planes, trains and automobiles - how to get to Glasgow 2014

  • ScissorsWithout Scotland?

    How might things change for the rest of the UK?

  • Diagrams showing bowler and batsmanAnyone for Vigoro?

    The bizarre Edwardian attempt to merge tennis and cricket

  • Payton McKinnonKilling heat

    Why so many American children die in hot cars

  • Dr Mahinder Watsa Dr Sex

    The wisecracking 90-year-old whose agony column is a cult hit

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Kyoto.Falling for Kyoto

    Acclaimed writer Pico Iyer describes an enchanting first stroll through the city


  • (File photo) Usain BoltClick Watch

    Challenging the world's fastest man to a virtual race over 40m – can you keep up?

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.