Scottish independence: What are the 'No' parties offering instead of independence?

Better Together badges The pro-Union Better Together campaign comprises Labour, the Liberal Democrats and the Conservatives

Ahead of the Scottish independence referendum on 18 September, pro-Union parties have offered voters the prospect of more powers for the Scottish Parliament in the event of a "No" vote.

The three parties - Scottish Labour, the Scottish Conservatives and the Scottish Liberal Democrats - came together in June 2014 to pledge an increase in Holyrood's fiscal powers if Scotland votes against independence.

Be informed

Go to the BBC's Scotland Decides page for analysis, background and explainers.

But there was no joint offer on the specifics of further devolution - each party has its own proposals.

So, what are each party's plans?

line break
Scottish Labour
Johann Lamont Scottish Labour leader Johann Lamont has backed further powers for Scotland's devolved parliament

Scottish Labour's devolution commission has backed increased tax-varying powers and control over some elements of welfare and benefits policy.

It said MSPs should be able to vary tax by up to 15p, giving them the option of restoring the 50p rate for top earners - but there would be no power to cut the upper income tax rate, which currently sits at 45p.

The plan would go further than 2012's Scotland Act, a piece of UK government legislation giving Holyrood the power to vary income tax by 10p from 2016.

The commission also said housing benefit should be devolved to Holyrood, allowing MSPs to scrap the UK government's controversial under occupancy charge, branded the "bedroom tax" by Labour and other critics.

It also proposed devolving the attendance allowance - paid to disabled over-65s - and the work programme, which manages services for the unemployed.

All other pensions and benefits would stay at Westminster, and there would be no powers for Holyrood over corporation tax, national insurance, VAT, capital gains tax or air passenger duty.

line break
Scottish Conservatives
Ruth Davidson Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson said she wanted to strengthen Scottish devolution

Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson has said Scotland should be given full income tax powers, a key recommendation of the party's devolution commission, chaired by Lord Strathclyde.

The commission, which said the income tax plan would see the Scottish Parliament accountable for 40% of the money it spent, also said there was a case for a share of Scottish VAT receipts being assigned to the Scottish Parliament.

It recommended the tax-free personal income tax allowance should remain reserved to Westminster, but, after that, the Scottish Parliament would decide on rates and bands.

And it called for a new, independent Scottish Fiscal Commission to produce Scottish forecasts.

Elsewhere, the Strathclyde report said the Scottish Parliament should get responsibility on welfare issues which relate to devolved areas, such as housing benefits, and attendance allowance.

Launching her successful Scottish Conservative leadership campaign in 2011, Ms Davidson described further powers beyond the Scotland Act as "a line in the sand".

But her stance changed when she announced the commission, saying her party was "committed to a new path" of more Holyrood responsibility.

line break
Scottish Liberal Democrats
Sir Menzies Campbell Sir Menzies Campbell led a commission into the future of Scottish devolution

Under the Liberal Democrats' Scottish "home rule" vision, Holyrood would raise and spend most of its own taxes and borrow on its own terms.

Its commission, chaired by former UK party leader Sir Menzies Campbell, said the Barnett formula - used to work out Treasury funding to the UK's devolved areas - should be replaced with a "needs-based" arrangement.

Oil would continue to be managed at a UK level, as would welfare and pensions, defence and foreign affairs.

Under the plans, the Act of Union between Scotland and England would be scrapped and replaced with a declaration of federalism.

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    On the Waterfront 10:40:

    It was an early start for the BBC At The Quay festival this morning with a special broadcast of Radio 2's Ken Bruce breakfast programme in front of a packed studio audience.

    Our colleagues at BBC Scotland tweeted this great picture of Simple Minds frontman Jim Kerr performing for the show.

    Simple Minds at the BBC

    You can find out more about the BBC At The Quay festival and watch a live stream of the events here.

     
  2.  
    Edinburgh river body identified 10:32:

    A man whose body was recovered from the Water of Leith in Edinburgh has been identified.

    The body of Henry Archibald, 40, was discovered near the Stenhouse Industrial Estate at about 09:30 on Monday.

    Police officers generic

    A bike, thought to belong to Mr Archibald, was found nearby. Police say there are no suspicious circumstances surrounding the death.

     
  3.  
    Miley's Twitter sabbatical 10:24:

    Competitive action at Glasgow 2014 is now less than 24 hours away, with Team Scotland comprising 310 athletes - 168 men and 142 women.

    Hannah Miley

    Swimmer Hannah Miley is first-up for Team Scotland tomorrow at 10:30 in the women's 400m individual medley.

    Miley, from Inverurie, tweeted last night: "Right guys I'm going into social media lock down as of tomorrow [Wednesday] morning so no twitter and facebook for me until I've finished racing!! Hope you enjoy watching the Commonwealth games! Remember to support your team :-)"

     
  4.  
    Flybe expands Aberdeen flights 10:16:

    Flybe has announced it will take over the service between Aberdeen and London City airport.

    British Airways said last month it was pulling out of the route in October.

    Flybe aircraft

    Flybe will operate twice daily flights, by 78-seat Bombardier Q400 aircraft, starting on 27 October.

     
  5.  
    Tigers chase Robertson 10:08:

    Dundee United have rejected an improved £2m-plus offer from Hull City for highly-rated Scotland defender Andrew Robertson. However, Tigers manager Steve Bruce is expected to come back with another offer to secure the 20-year-old's signature.

    Andrew Robertson in action for Dundee united

    Elsewhere, English Premiership side Southampton are set to make an improved second bid for Celtic's Fraser Forster after the first was described as "well below" the Parkhead club's valuation of the English international.

    Read more footie gossip here.

     
  6.  
    Clydeside expressway 10:00: Games travel 2014

    tweets: #GRG driving in Glasgow this morning? No access to Clydeside Expressway from Finnieston Street. Please use alternative routes.

     
  7.  
    Glasgow 2014 - your views 09:52: Via SMS

    Pauline: You'll need to look far and wide for a moanie minnie this day Kay. 15,000 volunteers believe in the Games!

    Willie in Wick: Bring on the Games. I'll be glued to the TV coverage every day and night. The world will be watching not only the Commonwealth, so come on Scotland, you can do it.

    Anonymous: What a waste of money, we can't repair the holes in roads.

     
  8.  
    See the sights... 09:44:

    With Games fever taking hold, unusual sights - and sites - have been popping up all over Glasgow. BBC Scotland's Louise Andrews and Laura Pettigrew have been out and about charting them.

    Murals

    Read all about it here.

     
  9.  
    Deila maintains 100% record 09:37:

    It's not been too shabby a start for new Celtic manager Ronny Deila, whose team cruised past Icelandic side KR Reykjavik and into the third qualifying round of the Champions League last night.

    Celtic manager Ronny Deila

    Doubles from Dutch defender Virgil Van Dijk and Finnish forward Teemu Pukki gave Celtic a 4-0 win on the night, 5-0 on aggregate.

    They'll face the winners of the tie between Irish team St Patrick's and Polish side Legia Warsaw, who meet tonight.

    So, two wins, two clean-sheets and five goals for Deila... happy, Celtic fans? Let us know using #ScotlandLive on Twitter, or by emailing here.

     
  10.  
    Making the news 09:29:

    The opening of Glasgow's Commonwealth Games dominates the front of all Scotland's newspapers.

    Newspapers 23 July

    Each carries its own message of support. "The sun rises on Glasgow's golden Games" is the Herald's headline, while the Daily Record proclaims "Bring it on" next to a striking image of a child with a Saltire painted on her face.

    Read more in our daily newspaper review.

     
  11.  
    Glasgow hotspots 09:22:

    BBC Newsbeat got a tour of Glasgow's hotspots from Games volunteer Katie Kinloch, 19.

    Clydesider 19-year-old Katie Kinloch

    The 15,000 Clyde-siders, as they are known, are key to the success of the Games, helping athletes, officials and visitors make the best of their time in Glasgow.

    Watch Katie's video here.

     
  12.  
    Morning Call 09:08: BBC Radio Scotland

    After seven years of preparation, the moment is finally here as the Commonwealth Games kick off in Glasgow tonight.

    Presenter Kaye Adams asks: Are you excited or can you see it far enough? We also want to hear about the furthest travelled visitor to the Games - how far have you come to get here?

    Lines are open now. Call 0500 92 95 00, text 80295 or email morningcallscotland@bbc.co.uk.

    You can listen live to the debate here.

     
  13.  
    Today's weather 09:03: Judith Ralston BBC Weather presenter

    The recent dry and warm weather will continue across the country. Any morning mist and fog will burn back towards the east coast, where some patches of haar will linger for much of the day, particularly over Orkney and the east of Shetland.

    It'll be another very warm day with temperatures reaching 25C to 27C for many inland areas, with light breezes cooling Dundee and Edinburgh to a high of around 22C.

    The high temperatures may trigger off a few showers late this afternoon and into the early evening, mainly across the northwest Highlands, with possibly the odd one developing over the high ground of central and southern Scotland.

     
  14.  
    Latest updates
  15.  
    Good morning 08:58: Marianne Taylor BBC Scotland news

    Good morning, and welcome to BBC Scotland Live. We'll be here till 17:00, bringing you the latest news, sport, weather and travel from across the country.

    It's a big day for Glasgow and Scotland, with the opening of the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games at Celtic Park just hours away. We'll have all the build-up throughout the day.

    Stay in touch and send us your pictures using Twitter #ScotlandLive, email us at newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk or text to 80295.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • SleepSleep on it

    Is it possible to strengthen your brain's synapses while you slumber?

Programmes

  • (File photo) Usain BoltClick Watch

    Challenging the world's fastest man to a virtual race over 40m – can you keep up?

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.