Scottish independence: 'Yes' vote means leaving pound, says Osborne

 

Chancellor George Osborne said the pound was not an asset to be divided up, during a speech in Edinburgh

UK Chancellor George Osborne has said a vote for Scottish independence would mean walking away from the pound.

His statement came after the senior civil servant at the Treasury, Sir Nicholas Macpherson, said currency unions were "fraught with difficulty".

Mr Osborne was backed by Labour and the Liberal Democrats.

Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond said the Westminster parties were trying to "bully" voters ahead of the 18 September independence referendum.

The Scottish government has argued that keeping the pound and the services of the Bank of England as part of a currency union under independence made sense for both Scotland and the rest of the UK.

But Mr Osborne said there was "no legal reason" why the rest of the UK would want to share sterling with an independent Scotland.

Start Quote

What's really striking is the publication of the normally private advice of the top Treasury mandarin Sir Nicholas Macpherson”

End Quote

The chancellor, Labour shadow chancellor Ed Balls and Lib Dem Chief Secretary to the Treasury Danny Alexander said they could not recommend such a plan.

Speaking in Edinburgh, Mr Osborne said: "The pound isn't an asset to be divided up between two countries after a break-up like a CD collection.

The instinct of the Scottish National Party may well be to dismiss the head of the Treasury's unambiguous advice to the Chancellor that he should not enter into currency union with an independent Scotland as the public-school and Oxford establishment closing ranks to save the union.

But the letter from Sir Nick Macpherson (Eton and Balliol) to George Osborne (St Paul's and Magdalen) is a significant constitutional event.

It is unusual for the permanent secretary to the Treasury to write a public letter on any issue at all, let alone one as momentous as whether institutional arrangements should be put in place so that an autonomous Scotland could have an influence on monetary and financial-regulation policy while continuing to use the pound.

The relevant issue for Mr Salmond is only to a limited extent whether Macpherson and the Treasury are right or wrong that monetary union with an autonomous Scotland would be contrary to the interests of a still-united England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

"If Scotland walks away from the UK, it walks away from the UK pound."

He went on: "There's no legal reason why the rest of the UK would need to share its currency with Scotland.

"So when the Nationalists say the pound is as much ours as the rest of the UK's, are they really saying that an independent Scotland could insist that taxpayers in a nation it had just voted to leave had to continue to back the currency of this new, foreign country?"

Mr Osborne added: "The UK is growing faster than any other advanced economy in Europe, and within the Union, Scotland is growing faster than the rest."

"Nothing could be more damaging to economic security here in Scotland than dividing our United Kingdom."

The chancellor's speech came as he published the Treasury's latest currency analysis paper, which said:

  • The UK's successful union with its shared monetary policy and risk would be lost in an independent Scotland.
  • Countries with more direct control over monetary policy can better cope with severe economic problems.
  • An independent Scotland would be more exposed to risks from the "volatile" energy and finance industries.
  • The eurozone crisis had shown that agreed fiscal rules are not enough to ensure a stable currency union.
  • There is no rule or principle in international law requiring the continuing UK to formally share its currency with an independent Scotland.

And in a highly unusual move, the chancellor also published civil service advice from Sir Nicholas, the Treasury's permanent secretary, who stated:

  • "Currency unions between sovereign states are fraught with difficulty. They require extraordinary commitment, and a genuine desire to see closer union between the peoples involved."
  • "What worries me about the Scottish government's putative currency union is that it would take place against the background of a weakening union between the two countries, running counter to the direction of travel in the eurozone."
  • "The Scottish Government is still leaving the option open of moving to a different currency option in the longer term. Successful currency unions are based on the near universal belief that they are irreversible. Imagine what would have happened to Greece two years ago if they had said they were contemplating reverting to the Drachma."
  • "Scotland's banking sector is far too big in relation to its national income, which means that there is a very real risk that the continuing UK would end up bearing most of the liquidity and solvency risk which it creates."
  • "If you follow Treasury advice and this week rule out a currency union in the event of Scottish independence, you can expect the Scottish Government to threaten not to take on its share of the United Kingdom's debt. I do not believe this is a credible threat."
George Osborne George Osborne's speech came as he published the latest Treasury analysis on the nature of a currency union in an independent Scotland

Mr Salmond responded: "This is a concerted bid by a Tory-led Westminster establishment to bully and intimidate - but their efforts to claim ownership of sterling will backfire spectacularly in terms of reaction from the people of Scotland, who know that the pound is as much theirs as it is George Osborne's.

Analysis

This feels like a defining moment in the independence referendum campaign.

There will be others but this is arguably the most important so far with the possible exception of the publication of the Scottish government's White Paper.

It set out the case for Scotland to keep using the pound Sterling in a formal currency union with the rest of the UK in the event of independence.

Scottish First Minister, Alex Salmond has repeatedly said this would be in the economic interests of both countries.

Today, his pro-union opponents in all three major UK parties are effectively saying that it would not be and that they will not let it happen.

They hope to seriously undermine the credibility of the nationalists' promise of currency continuity.

The Scottish government hopes referendum voters will see it as an attempt to bluff and bully and that it will backfire.

They are determined not to abandon their preferred currency option for an alternative - using the pound anyway, creating a new Scottish currency or applying to join the Euro - that may seem much riskier.

They have also said that if the rest of the UK is not prepared to share the currency that an independent Scotland would not be obliged to take a share of UK debts.

The stakes in this campaign just got a lot higher.

"Mr Osborne's claims are based on a caricature of a currency union rather than the reality, and his claims, for example on the size of Scotland's banking sector, do not reflect that reality."

The Scottish first minister added: "The reality is that a formal currency union with a shared sterling area is overwhelmingly in the rest of the UK's economic interests following a 'Yes' vote, and the stance of any UK government will be very different the day after a 'Yes' vote to the campaign rhetoric we are hearing now.

"To do otherwise would involve a prospective Westminster chancellor of any party standing on a platform which was not only vastly at odds with majority public opinion across Scotland and the rest of the UK but would seriously damage the economy of the rest of the UK as it would cost their own businesses hundreds of millions of pounds a year, blow a massive hole in their balance of payments and it would leave them having to pick up the entirety of UK debt."

But Mr Alexander said the Treasury had provided "crystal clear" analysis that a currency union would create unacceptable risks both for Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom.

He also called on the Scottish government to set out an alternative currency proposal.

Mr Alexander added: "As a Scot and as Liberal Democrat Chief Secretary to the UK Treasury, on the basis of this analysis, I couldn't recommend a currency union to the people of Scotland and my party couldn't agree to such a proposition for the rest of the UK.

"The SNP continue to pretend that an independent Scotland could continue to share the pound. It couldn't, without agreement."

The Scottish Lib Dem MP said: "This isn't bluff, or bullying, it's a statement of fact."

Start Quote

The dominant parties at Westminster sought to avoid any pre-negotiation - but now they've broken their own rule. We now have one, very important piece of pre-negotiation, by declaring no negotiation at all.”

End Quote

Mr Balls, added: "Alex Salmond is saying to people that you can have independence and keep the pound and the Bank of England - that is not going to happen.

"It would be bad for Scotland, it would place an unacceptable burden on the UK taxpayer, it would repeat the mistakes of the euro area, in fact, worse.

"It won't happen, I wouldn't recommend it. Scotland will not keep the pound if Scotland chooses independence."

It is understood former Chancellor Alistair Darling, who is leading the Better Together campaign to keep the Union, was instrumental in getting the three Westminster parties to agree a joint currency position.

The referendum will see Scots asked the Yes/No question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

 

More on This Story

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 5151.

    At last! In the past few years of the independence debate we have had no answers to our questions no straight talking from politicians. We now know one think about this referendum and that is we will not have the pound in a currency union. I live near the border, will I have to change my money every time I want to go to Carlisle for a meal or a drink?

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 5150.

    5140. Dont believe the Hype

    True but the real news here is that so do SNP politicians. They're still politicians and by definition they are liars and cheats as well. Just like all politicians, you'll believe whatever you want to believe.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 5149.

    Cant help thinking this is a bit like a 16 year old announcing to their parents that they want to leave home and move into a flat without any real idea of how they will pay their way in the world. Then asking the parent to act as guarantor for the rent and bills.

  • rate this
    -2

    Comment number 5148.

    Given that Scotland has contributed more in REAL terms than it has received in recent times AND that it growing faster than the rest of the UK (stated above) surely getting out now is the perfect time?
    For those who say Scotland COULD not use the GBP then I give you this. How can so many countries use USD without formal currency unions with US?
    Scotland could use it's own pound if it has to.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 5147.

    Arguing now about a minor matter like currency is a distraction. The key issue is independence to manage affairs as Scots see fit.
    If Scotland votes for independence, then the relationship with the pound will alter, but that is to be negotiated after the event. Lots of smaller countries manage independent and shared currencies OK. Independence is much bigger than currency.

 

Comments 5 of 5151

 

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    12:58: Meet the Clydesiders

    One of the great successes of Glasgow 2014 has been the Clydesiders, the red and grey volunteer army tasked with keeping the Games running and keeping the spectators smiling.

    Clydesider doing high-five

    BBC Scotland's Laura Pettigrew meets the "warm and friendly" faces of the Games.

     
  2.  
    12:37: Starstruck

    @Team_Scotland tweets: The moment 13 year old Erraid Davies met her fans for the 1st time.

    Erraid Davies
     
  3.  
    New towns 12:24:

    Scotland may need up to eight new towns to help avert a potential housing crisis, a special commission has said.

    Houses

    The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors-led group called for several new communities, which could be new towns or extensions to existing ones.

    The Scottish Housing Commission also said the private rental sector needed to be expanded.

     
  4.  
    Show cancelled 12:14:

    An Israeli show at the Edinburgh Fringe has been cancelled after only one performance following a protest by a pro- Palestinian group.

    The City, a hip-hop opera by a theatre company from Jerusalem which receives funding from the Israeli government, was already the focus of a campaign.

    Demonstration

    Two weeks ago, 50 Scottish artists and writers signed a letter calling for the cancellation of The City.

     
  5.  
    Boxing fan 12:05:

    A man who was watching his brother compete in the Commonwealth Games has been fined for throwing a plastic bottle which struck a child.

    Laith Samardali, 25, from Perth, Australia, admitted throwing the bottle at a man during a boxing event where his brother Jordan was competing.

    The bottle missed the man and hit the seven-year-old boy.

     
  6.  
    Rain warning 11:58:

    The Met Office says we could be in for a soaking on Sunday.

    Met Office webiste

    "A developing low pressure area will move north across Scotland on Sunday. Rainfall totals will be very variable but could well exceed 50 mm in 12-24 hours in places, whilst winds are likely to gust 40-50 mph over some coasts and hills."

     
  7.  
    Dreich

    @strathearnrose tweets: Jamaican athlete not impressed by Scottish weather? Most Scots aren't impressed by the Scottish weather! @usainbolt

     
  8.  
    Travel news 11:45:

    @BBCTravelScot tweets: A74(M) N/B clsd RTC two lorries involved between J19 B725 (Ecclefechan) and J18 B723 (Lockerbie South). Police directing traffic.

     
  9.  
    Cycling 11:38:

    Linda Villumsen of New Zealand takes gold in the women's time trial.

    Linda Villumsen

    Emma Pooley of England takes silver and Australia's Katrin Garfoot takes bronze.

    Katie Archibald of Scotland was in fifth after a brave ride that ran out of steam.

     
  10.  
    Spectators' view 11:27:

    Samantha and Tom from Uddingston sent us this great shot of the athletics at Hampden on Wednesday.

    Hampden

    They say they had perfect seats to watch the likes of Kirani James and Greg Rutherford win gold medals.

     
  11.  
    On her way... 11:15:

    BBC Scotland's Kevin Keane tweets: Scotland's Katie Archibald passing the crossing point near Stepps. Big cheers here. #Glasgow2014

    Katie Archibald in the time trial
     
  12.  
    Celtic suffer heavy defeat 11:08:

    Away from the Games, Celtic suffered a nightmare first-leg defeat in the third round qualifying for the Champions League.

    Celtic defeated in Poland

    The Parkhead side lost 4-1 to Legia Warsaw last night after taking an early lead in Poland.

    Read more and listen to an interview with Celtic manager Ronny Deila here.

     
  13.  
    Bottle fine 11:00:

    A 25-year-old man from Perth, Australia has been fined £400 for throwing a bottle at a man at the Commonwealth Games boxing event.

    Laith Samardali is the brother of Australian boxer Jordan.

    He missed the man and the plastic bottle hit a seven-year-old child.

     
  14.  
    Bolt quotes 10:53:

    The Times has released its transcript of a conversation in which it claimed Usain Bolt made disparaging remarks about the Commonwealth Games.

    Usain Bolt

    The newspaper reported on Wednesday that the Olympic 100m champion said he was not enjoying the Glasgow Games.

    But Bolt described the article as "nonsense" and "lies" on Twitter and later told reporters the Games were "awesome".

     
  15.  
    10:43:

    @millarmind tweets: 14:28 start time today for me. Going to be a proud moment rolling off the start ramp.

     
  16.  
    Yesterday's highlights 10:31:

    BBC Scotland's Andy Burke presents a video round-up of all yesterday's highlights from the Games, including Dan Keating's fantastic silver in the all-round gymnastics, and Guy Learmonth, who ran the race of his life to qualify for the 800m final alongside David Rudisha.

    Guy Learmonth

    Watch the video here.

    You can also read about all yesterday's best bits.

     
  17.  
    Time trial latest 10:29:

    BBC reporter Kevin Keane captured this image of Antri Christoforou of Cyprus.

    Antri Christoforou

    The leading riders in the Games time trial are passing Hogganfield Loch on their way to East Dunbartonshire and North Lanarkshire.

     
  18.  
    They're off! 10:17:

    @BBCSport tweets: Live women's road cycling on @BBCOne next - Olympic medalist Emma Pooley's last race before retirement #Glasgow2014

    Emma Pooley

    Or, if you live to the north and east of Glasgow, you can just get out and watch it.

     
  19.  
    10:07:

    @NetworkRailSCOT tweets: The line at Lenzie has now reopened however residual delays will be experienced until after the morning peak. Sorry for the disruption.

     
  20.  
    Cycle man 09:59:

    @BBCJohnBeattie tweets: Interviewing the man who lent the Malawi team some bikes

    John Beattie

    Catch John on BBC Radio Scotland from 12:00.

     
  21.  
    Legacy? 09:49:

    Glasgow will benefit from the vast amount of money spent hosting the Commonwealth Games - according to Clyde Gateway Regeneration.

    Over £500m pound has been spent on hosting and an entire athlete's village built in the east end - which will be used as housing after the games.

    Especially if you live in Glasgow, how much do expect by way of lasting change?

    Contact us on newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk or tweet using #ScotlandLive.

     
  22.  
    Paper review 09:36:

    BBC Scotland has a guide to this morning's papers.

    Front pages 31 July

    As well as Glasgow 2014 (of course) there are reports on Nato and the Baltic states, and the challenge to the NHS in Scotland of treating an increasing number of older pensioners.

     
  23.  
    Keep smiling 09:27:

    Debbie Paterson sent us this picture of Clydesiders at the hockey arena having fun with the local police.

    Clydesiders and police officers

    We'd love to see your images from Glasgow 2014. Send them to newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk

     
  24.  
    Medal haul 09:18:

    Scotland's Daniel Keatings took silver and Viorel Etko claimed bronze on day seven of Glasgow 2014.

    Medal table

    Keatings finished second in the men's all-around gymnastics final at the Hydro. Etko defeated Malta's Adam Vella to win the wrestling bronze medal in the 61kg.

    Team Scotland is currently in fourth place in the table, with a total of 39 medals. England are top with 105.

     
  25.  
    Australian athlete held by police 09:10:

    An Australian weightlifter who won a bronze medal at the Commonwealth Games has been held by police following an assault on a Welsh athlete.

    Francois Etoundi, 29, is due to appear at Glasgow Sheriff court.

    The alleged assault on the unnamed athlete is said to have taken place at the athletes' village in Glasgow at about 06:00 on Wednesday.

    A Team Wales spokesman said: "We're aware of an incident that occurred involving a member of Team Wales."

     
  26.  
    More rail disruption 08:59:

    Scotrail tweets: services between Glasgow Queen Street and Stirling may be cancelled, delayed or diverted via Cumbernauld at short notice

     
  27.  
    Taking flight 08:57:

    An independent economic group has called for the future expansion of London airports to take Scotland and other parts of the UK into consideration.

    Busy airport

    The Scottish Council for Development and Industry has also lobbied for action to increase long-haul services from Scottish airports.

     
  28.  
    Mapping the route 08:42:

    The cycling time trial is a gruelling course that takes in North Lanarkshire and parts of East Dunbartonshire before heading back to Glasgow.

    Time trial map

    Thousands are expected to line the route - don't forget to send us your pictures as the cylists whizz by. You can tweet them using #ScotlandLive or email them here.

     
  29.  
    Today at the Games 08:29:

    Scottish athletes are in action in plethora of events today.

    Away from David Millar and Katie Archibald in this morning's time trial, individual apparatus finals in the gymnastics start at 15:00, with all-round silver medal winner Dan Keating holding Scottish hopes in the pommel-horse.

    In the athletics, Eilidh Child goes for gold in the 400m hurdles, while para athletes Meggan Dawson-Farrell and Samantha Kinghorn will compete in the T54 1500m.

    Eilidh Child

    Full coverage of every Games event is available on the BBC, across TV, radio and online.

     
  30.  
    08:23: Contact us

    Much of the cycling time trial today can be watched free - if you can find a good vantage point.

    What has been your favourite free event of Glasgow 2014?

    And if you are at the cycling, send us your thoughts and your pictures.

    Text 80295, email newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk or tweet using #ScotlandLive.

     
  31.  
    08:15: Coming up Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    Parcel delivery firms are to be given a "statement of principles" to try to improve things for people in "remote" parts of the UK. I'll be asking: When it comes to deliveries are you being punished by your postcode?

    And more than a dozen family pairings are competing in Glasgow 2014. Has sibling rivalry helped or hindered you in life?

    Morning Call on BBC Radio Scotland starts at 08:50. Phone me on 0500 92 95 00; Text 80295; email morningcallscotland@bbc.co.uk

    Listen live from 08:50.

     
  32.  
    07:58: Train disruption

    @BBCTravelScot tweets: Disruption trains GW Queen St/ Edn Waverley,/GQS and Perth and GQS and Alloa All services through Croy being delayed or disrupted.

     
  33.  
    07:55: Local hero

    Who to cheer on at the cycling time trial?

    David Millar

    A favourite with the crowds is likely to be defending Commonwealth Games champion David Millar.

    Also watch out for England's Alex Dowsett, who won silver at Delhi 2010.

    In the women's race, young Scottish talent Katie Archibald will get her chance to shine.

     
  34.  
    07:40: Wild paths

    More than 120km of paths across Scotland's national parks are set to be renovated thanks to a £3m grant from the Heritage Lottery Fund.

    Highland glen

    Eroded pathways in the Cairngorms and Loch Lomond and the Trossachs are to be restored and upgraded as part of the People and the Mountains project.

     
  35.  
    07:30: Cycling trials

    Major road closures are being made in and around Glasgow ahead of the cycling time trial.

    Cyclist

    The 40km route - 30km for women - starts and ends at Glasgow Green.

    The single loop course takes in a huge swathe of countryside in North Lanarkshire and cuts across East Dunbartonshire before coming back to Glasgow via the city's east end.

     
  36.  
    07:17: Kylie confirmed

    Kylie Minogue will perform alongside Lulu, Deacon Blue and Dougie MacLean at the closing ceremony of Glasgow 2014.

    Kylie

    (OK, it was confirmed yesterday, but who can resist another picture of Kylie?)

     
  37.  
    07:11: Today's weather BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    It'll be cloudy, with rain through the Highlands and Islands drifting north and east.

    A wet start for the south west too, moving east to Lanarkshire but with bright spells later across Tayside, the central belt and Southern Uplands.

    However, expect some hefty showers after lunch with a risk of thunder. Less windy than of late with highs of 17C to 20C.

     
  38.  
    07:01: Sandy Murray BBC Scotland news

    Welcome to BBC Scotland's live coverage of news, sport, weather and travel across the country on Thursday 31 July. It is day eight of the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games and we'll be keeping you up to date on all the Team Scotland action. We're here until 23:00.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ClockMore for less?

    Could spending less time in the office make you perform more efficiently?

Programmes

  • A factory in JapanThe Travel Show Watch

    Factory infatuation – why Japan’s industrial compounds are drawing large crowds at night

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.