Scottish independence: The currency debate, claim by claim

Money Currency in an independent Scotland has become the central issue of the referendum debate

The issue of what currency an independent Scotland would use has become the key battleground of the referendum debate.

The Scottish government is in favour of a sterling zone, saying it would be in the interests of both Scotland and the UK to continue to formally share the pound if the former votes for independence, ensuring stability for both states.

UK chancellor George Osborne has said the UK would not enter into a currency union with Scotland if it voted 'Yes' in September's referendum, claiming such a union would be against the economic interests of England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

Mr Osborne's statement was the UK government's strongest intervention in the debate yet, and his position was supported by both Labour and the Liberal Democrats.

First Minister Alex Salmond countered Mr Osborne's claims in a speech to pro-independence business leaders in Aberdeen on Monday, which he said had "deconstructed" the case against a currency union.

So what are Mr Osborne's key arguments and how has Mr Salmond sought to counter them?

Claim: Trade with Scotland is important to the UK, but the overall proportion is small
Alex Salmond Alex Salmond defended a currency union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK during a speech to business leaders in Aberdeen

George Osborne: "I'm the first to say that our deeply integrated businesses and their suppliers are compelling reasons for keeping the UK together - 70% of Scottish trade is with the rest of the UK. That is a massive proportion.

"And trade with Scotland is important to the rest of the UK - but at only 10% of the total trade, it is a much smaller proportion. These trade figures don't make the unanswerable case for a shared currency that the Scottish government assume."

Alex Salmond: "I am publishing an estimate of the transactions costs he would potentially impose on businesses in the rest of the UK. They run to many hundreds of millions of pounds. My submission is that this charge - let us call it the George tax - would be impossible to sell to English business.

"In fact if you remove oil and gas from the equation, Scotland is one of the very few countries in the world with which England has a balance of trade surplus."

Claim: An independent Scotland would be a foreign country
George Osborne In a speech opposing a currency union between Scotland and the rest of the UK, George Osborne said an independent Scotland would be a foreign country

George Osborne: "When the nationalists say 'the pound is as much ours as the rest of the UK's', are they really saying that an independent Scotland could insist that taxpayers in a nation it has just voted to leave had to continue to back the currency of this new foreign country . . . consider the circumstances of this foreign country when setting their interest rates, stand behind the banks of this foreign country as a lender of last resort or stand behind its foreign government when it needed public spending support.

"That is patently absurd."

Alex Salmond: "For Scots, whether independent or not, the rest of the UK will never be 'foreign'. Indeed the Government of Ireland Act of 1948, negotiated after infinitely more difficult circumstances than we have, specifically states that Ireland is not to be regarded as a 'foreign country'.

"And so despite the Chancellor's campaign rhetoric I don't believe his 'foreigner' language represents any significant view in Scotland or indeed England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

Claim: The pound belongs to the UK
pound coin Scotland would walk away from the pound if it leaves the Union, according to chancellor George Osborne

George Osborne: "There's no legal reason why the rest of the UK would need to share its currency with Scotland, as the Treasury's publication clearly shows. If Scotland walks away from the UK, it walks away from the UK pound.

An accompanying Treasury paper said there was no legal basis for Scotland to assert a "share" of the pound or the Bank of England, because the UK would be the "continuing state" in international law.

Alex Salmond: "If there is no legal basis for Scotland having a share of the public assets of the Bank of England, then there is equally no legal basis for Scotland accepting a share of the public liability of the national debt.

"As Professor Christine Bell of Edinburgh University wrote, legally under international law the position is clear: if the remainder UK keeps the name and status of the UK under international law, it keeps its liabilities for the debt. The UK took out the debt, and legally it owes the money. Scotland cannot therefore 'default'.

"We are willing, despite the legal position, to accept a share of liabilities on the basis that there is also a share of the assets - one of which is the Bank of England which holds almost one third of the UK debt."

Claim: Scotland's financial sector is too big for a workable currency union
Bank of england The Bank of England is a joint UK asset, according to First Minister Alex Salmond

George Osborne: "The rest of the UK would be tying its currency to a country with a big financial sector, capable of inflicting huge damage on it."

An accompanying treasury paper estimated Scotland's financial sector was 25% of the UK's total.

Alex Salmond: "HMRC estimated Scotland's share of the Bank Levy (effectively a charge on the balance sheets of banks) to be 7.3% of the UK total - smaller than Scotland's share of UK GDP - not the near 25% which the Treasury has estimated and on which the Chancellor's remarks are based.

"This Treasury achieved its inflation of the Scottish financial sector by simply allocating London based assets to Scotland."

Claim: A currency union means the rest of the UK would have to bail Scotland out during difficult times, such as oil market volatility
Oil rig The chancellor said a currency union could be put at risk by volatility in the oil markets

George Osborne: "The continuing UK would be almost 10 times the size of the Scottish economy, so this would be a totally one-sided deal where UK taxpayers would have to transfer money to an independent Scotland in times of economic stress with limited prospect of any transfers the other way.

"Consider for example the impact of a substantial fall in the oil price - something we've seen several times over the last 30 years. As part of the UK, Scotland is insulated from the impacts that this would have on tax revenues."

Alex Salmond: "They would not. In fact, the Fiscal Commission Working Group recommended a stabilisation fund to address this very point. The fund would mean money will be built up when the oil price is high to smooth out price fluctuations if the oil price was low.

"The Chancellor cited between 2008 and 2009 when oil prices fell as his example. In fact in both years with oil prices low and oil prices high Scotland's finances were healthier than the UK - in 2008-09 by a lot and in 2009-10 by a little.

Claim 6: Scotland would have to cede sovereignty to join a currency union with the UK
holyrood The parliament of an independent Scotland would have to cede some sovereignty in the event of a currency union

George Osborne: "Look at the direction the euro is heading in - supervision and consent to member budgets, deficit controls, debt reduction rules.

"In a crucial sense, Scotland would have less independence than it has now - because spending and tax decisions would still have to be agreed by the parliament in Westminster, but now there would be no longer any Scottish MPs in that parliament or Scottish members of the cabinet.

"And the citizens of the rest of the UK would have to concede at least some sovereignty and supervision of our own budget to a foreign country - something we've fiercely resisted up to now and would in the future."

Alex Salmond: The Fiscal Commission did recommend a fiscal sustainability agreement with overall objectives for ensuring that net debt and government borrowing do not diverge significantly.

"These would be sensible rules that any country, whether in or out of a currency union, would seek to adhere to. Such an agreement would allow control over fiscal levers, employment policy, competition policy and a range of other policies which would in turn boost economic resilience."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    13:15: Airport using Google glasses

    Staff at Edinburgh Airport are using Google Glass headsets to help them deal with customer inquiries.

    Google glass glasses

    The smart glasses display digital information in the user's field of vision and can take photos and video.

    Airport staff are trying out the wearable technology until December to provide flight information, translations and answer questions about the city.

     
  2.  
    13:01: 'Left wing FM'

    The Scottish Daily Mail's political editor Alan Roden tweets: @RuthDavidsonMSP warns that @NicolaSturgeon will be "the most left-wing First Minister Scotland has ever known."

     
  3.  
    12:55: More Davidson Tim Reid Political correspondent, BBC News

    Speaking in Birmingham, Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson says the Tories proved they were not too "toxic" to take part in the referendum campaign.

    "We have blown that myth out of the water," she says.

     
  4.  
    12:53: Davidson speech Tim Reid Political correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: Another standing ovation for Ruth Davidson at Scottish Tory fringe.

     
  5.  
    12:46: Firearms to be 'less visible'

    Firearms carried by police officers in Scotland are expected to be covered with a new type of holster to make them less visible to the public.

    Police Scotland

    Senior Police Scotland officers said trained officers should still be able to routinely carry the weapons, but their visibility should be reduced.

    The policy on the carrying of firearms has proven controversial. The recommendation has been sent to Chief Constable Sir Stephen House for his agreement.

     
  6.  
    12:38: £1m funding for vision loss

    Scientists in Scotland have been given a £1.1m grant to develop new laser technology aimed at detecting early vision loss.

    Eye with Age related macular degeneration

    The funding given by Innovate UK will support work by Strathclyde and Kent Universities, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde and Dunfermline-based firm Optos. Clinical trials of the new technology are due to be completed by early 2017.

    If they are successful, a further £9m will be invested to develop a fully-licensed new medical device by the end of 2018.

     
  7.  
    12:30: Douglas Fraser Business and economy editor, Scotland

    tweets: #indyref was about the heart, EU Brexit is about pragmatism, says @David_Cameron.

     
  8.  
    12:22: Grangemouth road open

    Bo'ness Road, in Grangemouth, has now reopened.

    A spokesperson for Ineos said, "We detected a leak of butane gas from a small vessel that was brought quickly under control.

    "All personnel are accounted for and the incident team has stood down."

     
  9.  
    12:17: Incident over Steven Godden BBC Scotland

    The incident at Grangemouth is over and emergency services have been stood down.

    The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service say the on-site Ineos fire team dealt with a small butane leak on one of their vessels.

     
  10.  
    12:09: Scotland squad announced

    The SFA tweets: Here is the Scotland squad for the @EuroQualifiers vs and @pzpn_pl

    Squad list

    See the official squad here.

     
  11.  
    11:59: Pauline McLean BBC Scotland

    Carnegie caskets attracting international attention. Irish and Russian consuls in today. American ambassador was here yesterday.

    Tune in to Reporting Scotland later today for more.

     
  12.  
  13.  
    11:42: Grangemouth gas leak

    Roads have been closed as emergency services deal with a suspected gas leak at the Grangemouth industrial complex.

    The leak, thought to be butane gas, is not believed to pose a wider risk to people living nearby.

    Police Scotland say no one has been injured in the incident.

     
  14.  
    11:33: Views sought from indyref groups

    The man leading the commission on more devolved powers for Scotland has written to campaigners on both sides of the independence debate.

    Lord Smith

    Lord Smith said he wanted submissions from new groups that came to the fore during the referendum campaign.

    The five main political parties are already represented on the commission. Lord Smith also wants to hear from civic institutions and the public.

    Groups have until 17:00 on Friday 31 October to submit their views.

     
  15.  
    11:29: Costly court delays The Courier

    tweets: Taxpayers to foot bill for Dundee Sheriff Court delays.

    Read the full story here.

     
  16.  
    11:18: Rare violin theft

    A violin valued at £17,000 has been stolen from Glasgow's West End over the weekend.

    The rare Cain and Mann instrument and Charles Bazin bow were taken from a parked car in Beaconsfield Road, Kelvinside.

    Police said the owner of the "specialist" violin is a professional musician.

     
  17.  
    11:08: Elgin stabbing The Press and Journal

    tweets: Two teenagers suffer stab wounds in Elgin fight.

    Read the full story here.

     
  18.  
    10:49: Cancer treatment wait

    The NHS in Scotland is still failing to treat people diagnosed with suspected cancer within two months, although performance has improved since March.

    Waiting

    Scottish government targets state that 95% of patients with an urgent referral should be treated within 62 days.

    Between April and June, 93% of patients started treatment within this timeframe. In March, the figure was 92%.

     
  19.  
    10:40: Brent Alpha container safe

    The oil company Shell says a container which fell into the sea from one of its North Sea platforms has been lowered onto the sea bed.

    Brent Alpha

    It was initially being held 20ft below the water, still attached to the crane, but there were concerns that it could damage existing pipes.

    The accident happened when the container was being manoeuvred onto a ship from the Brent Alpha installation on Sunday when the crane being used developed a mechanical fault.

    Shell says the container will eventually be removed but has been placed at a depth of 140 metres to keep it safe.

    All but essential personnel have been removed from the platform.

     
  20.  
    10:36: Cameron: 'Heartbreak' over Scotland

    David Cameron has said he cares "a thousand times more strongly" about keeping the UK together than about the country staying in the European Union.

    David Cameron

    Speaking on Radio 4's Today programme, the prime minister said that, had Scotland left the UK, it would have caused him "heartbreak".

    He also told the programme that the topic of Europe had been a "great cause of unity" among Tories attending the party's annual conference in Birmingham.

     
  21.  
    @Daily_Record 10:28: Restaurant raid Daily Record

    tweets: Armed gang hold Chinese restaurant owner and family hostage while robbing their home.

    Read the full story here.

     
  22.  
    10:19: Oil industry 'must cut costs'

    The oil and gas industry must do more to cut costs even if it means more job losses, it has been claimed.

    Oil platform

    Industry body Oil and Gas UK's annual economic report said operating costs were 60% higher than three years ago while oil prices were falling.

    There have already been substantial layoffs at companies this year.

    Shell UK announced 250 onshore jobs cuts from its North Sea operation in Aberdeen in August, after Chevron announced 225 losses in July.

     
  23.  
    10:13: Scotland squad announcement

    Scotland resume their attempt to qualify for Euro 2016 next month when they play Georgia and Poland in Group D.

    Gordon Strachan will name his squad for the double header later at Hampden.

    Ikechi Anya celebrates his goal against Germany with Scotland team-mate Steven Naismith

    Earlier this month, Scotland ran world champions Germany mighty close in their Euro 2016 opener, losing 2-1 in a pulsating opening Euro 2016 qualifier in Dortmund.

    Ikechi Anya was on target for the Scots.

     
  24.  
    10:04: Record Trade for Gretna

    A retail village on the border at Gretna is expanding on the back of record trade figures.

    Gretna Gateway Outlet Village

    Work on a 19,000 square foot extension starts next month, creating about 50 additional jobs.

    A spokesman for Gretna Gateway Village said August was the busiest month in its 15-year-history, with cross-border Commonwealth Games traffic a contributory factor.

     
  25.  
    Text 80295 10:02: Cancer treatment - Your views

    Anthony in Dumfries: I think Linda is right to choose to stop treatment. Some people can be heartbroken watching their loved ones continually suffer as they go through a treatment process that will not cure their illness and will take away precious quality time with their family and friends.

    Fiona: Why is it morally wrong to discontinue treatments that are essentially man-made? Aren't we already playing as God, seems to me nature's saying your time's up but medicine says no! Why is it selfish to allow death with dignity in this way and to make the best of the remaining time being used to the full, not making yourself sick, delaying the inevitable?

     
  26.  
    09:50: Cancer treatment Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    On Morning Call now: Have you or your family had to make difficult choices about how to deal with cancer?

    Morning Call
     
  27.  
    Text 80295 09:45: Sex education - Your views

    Derek, Glasgow: It's not sex education now, it's Relationships, Sexual Health & Parenthood. Lanarkshire have updated their materials for regular and ASN schools in last few years, not all schools engage with it. Also, classes like Talk2 Glasgow educate parents to talk to their kids.

    Anon: Would any adult say now that they wish they had less sex education? No adult, including parents, have the right to censor information to children and you can'tt leave it up to parents and hope for the best. It is every 16-year-old's human right to have been taught about sex, relationships and what is and isn't acceptable.

     
  28.  
    09:36: Increase in human trafficking

    Fifty five potential victims of human trafficking were identified in Scotland last year, according to a National Crime Agency report.

    Women walking on street

    Almost a third (30%) of them experienced sexual exploitation. Romania was the most common country of origin, with nine cases in Scotland.

    This year is the first time the UK figures have been broken down by area.

     
  29.  
    Text 80295 09:25: Sex education - Your Views

    Jeff, Airdrie: I'm a parent and absolutely agree sex education should be compulsory. However, it should focus on this being an adult behaviour, and reinforce the importance of childhood and try to turn against the fashion of growing up too quickly an children engaging in adult behaviour. Kids do need to know the facts about sexual issues, as playground talk is what spreads myths and untruths, confusing kids.

    Geoff, Penicuik: When I was at secondary school in the early 60's, the girls in my class were taken for sex education while the boys were given dental hygiene.

     
  30.  
    09:18: Minaj high note for Glasgow...

    Starships hit-maker Nicki Minaj is to host the 20th MTV European Music Awards in Glasgow in November.

    Nicki Manaj

    The singer will also perform during the ceremony at the Hydro Arena.

    Katy Perry leads the nominations and is up for seven awards including best female, pop act, video and live act.

    She's going up against Ariana Grande, who has six nominations for the awards, while 5 Seconds of Summer and Pharrell Williams have five each - one more than One Direction.

     
  31.  
    Text 80295 09:05: Sex education - Your Views

    Fiona: Sex education should not be enshrined in law. Patents are responsible for their child's education as per Education Scotland Act. It's not for Government to dictate what is and isn't taught. No one knows a child better than their parents.

    Heather, Edin: Sex education etc should maybe be taught in secondary schools but definitely not in primary schools. Primary school kids should be playing and enjoying their wee short childhoods. There is more to life than sex.

     
  32.  
    @pressjournal 08:54: Aberdeen death The Press and Journal

    tweets: Man believed to have been stabbed as police investigate Aberdeen death. http://bit.ly/1vsR2KN

    Read the full story here.

     
  33.  
    08:48: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    M8 leaving Glasgow - stop-start from 8 Baillieston to 5 Harthill - then further eastbound queues from 4 Whitburn to 1 Hermiston Gait. The A904 Queensferry to Newton Road remains partially blocked following an accident - delays both ways.

     
  34.  
    08:44: Morning Call Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    Today, we want to hear your views on sex education. Should it be compulsory in all of Scotland's schools?

    And, with actress Lynda Bellingham choosing to stop chemotherapy so she can spend one last Christmas with her family, we're asking if there's a right time to stop cancer treatment?

    Call us on 0500 92 95 00 or text 80295.

    You can listen live to the programme here.

     
  35.  
    08:38: How's the weather looking today? BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    Hi Kawser here. Bright in the East, once mist clears, then dry and sunny at 18-20C. Rain and stronger winds in the West, becoming patchier as spreads eastwards. 15-16C.

     
  36.  
    08:34: Today's papers

    The Scotsman, The Herald and Daily Record all focus on Chancellor George Osborne's announcement that benefits are to be frozen for two years, should the Tories win next year's General Election.

    Newspaper composite

    The Daily Record dubs the announcement "The Tory war on poor".

    The Scottish Sun, meanwhile, focuses on the arrest of boxer Scott Harrison, as he awaits extradition to Spain.

    Read our paper round-up here.

     
  37.  
    08:25: Wind farm proposal

    A proposed wind farm project near Loch Rannoch which has drawn a number of objections is to be discussed in the Scottish parliament.

    Plans were submitted to the government for 24 turbines on the Talladh-a-Bheithe estate, near Rannoch Moor.

    Hillwalkers, Scottish Natural Heritage and the John Muir Trust have all voiced opposition to the plans.

    However, the developer said the "carefully balanced project" was drawn up with community feedback in mind.

     
  38.  
    08:19: Hibs floor Rangers

    Three goals in 14 first-half minutes earned Hibernian victory over Rangers in last night's Championship clash at Ibrox.

    Hibs travelled to Glasgow second-bottom of the table but Alan Stubbs's men secured a 3-1 win.

    Hibs' Jordon Forster celebrates at Ibrox

    "The players deserve all the credit," Stubbs said. "When you find yourself in a 3-0 lead, you think 'what's going on?' But the lads took their chances on the counter and were really positive."

    Rangers boss Ally McCoist lamented his side's defensive mistakes but stressed that - sitting six points behind league leaders Hearts - the title race will be "a marathon" and not a sprint.

     
  39.  
    08:08: Tinkers' Heart plea

    MSPs are to be asked to back a campaign to protect a stone heart which has been central to the culture of travelling people in Scotland for centuries.

    The Tinkers' Heart is a pattern of quartz stones which was laid at an Argyll cross-roads in the 1700s.

    Generations of Scottish Travellers have used it as a wedding place and for children to be blessed.

    The Tinkers' Heart

    Holyrood's public petitions committee will be urged to back a campaign to preserve it.

    The committee will be addressed by Jess Smith, an author and campaigner for the rights and recognition of travelling people and their culture.

     
  40.  
    08:02: Economic boost

    The Scottish economy is continuing to recover with performance at pre-recession levels, according to a survey.

    The Bank of Scotland business monitor found turnover trends and expectations comparable with those of 2007.

    Bank notes

    It said a "surge" in economic activity last year was maintained, suggesting the recovery will continue into 2015.

    Of the firms surveyed, 49% reported that turnover had increased over the three months to August.

     
  41.  
    08:00: Welcome Thomas McGuigan BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and welcome to Scotland Live. We'll be here until 18:00 with news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the country.

    Keep in touch on Twitter @BBCScotlandNews using #ScotlandLive, via email or text 80295.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • FilmsOnes to watch

    BBC Culture picks nine top films coming out next month

Programmes

  • A computer simulation showing a planned station upgrade in Hong KongClick Watch

    Simulated world - how architects are using virtual and augmented reality to transform our cities

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.