Scottish independence: John Major warns over 'Yes' vote

Sir John Major Sir John addressed the Scottish Parliamentary Journalists' Association in Edinburgh

The former prime minister Sir John Major has said Scotland would trade "real influence" for "possible irrelevance" under independence.

Sir John said Scottish government plans to remove nuclear weapons from Scotland in the event of a referendum "Yes" vote would undermine the UK and Nato.

Speaking in Edinburgh, the Conservative also said such a move would not be forgotten by the US.

SNP MSP Stuart Maxwell said Sir John's comments were "woefully out of touch".

Sir John addressed the Scottish Parliamentary Journalists' Association in Edinburgh ahead of the vote on Scotland's future, to be held on 18 September.

'Real influence'

The Scottish government has said an independent Scotland would be able to negotiate EU membership "from within", in an 18-month timescale, but Sir John said entry, "may take years - and may be probable - but is by no means certain".

Sir John said: "And, is it not bizarre for the SNP to campaign to leave one highly successful Union, whilst applying to join another far less successful one that is seen - even by its most ardent advocates - to be in serious need of reform?

"This is even more difficult to understand when you consider that there have always been Scottish voices around the Cabinet table at Westminster - and at the top of our public services.

"By contrast, Scotland - as a mere 1% of the population of the EU - will be guaranteed no senior roles at all.

"The Scottish nationalists are campaigning to replace real influence, living, current, day-to-day influence in the United Kingdom with possible irrelevance in much wider European Union. This makes absolutely no sense whatsoever for Scotland."

Sir John added: "When the SNP threaten to expel Trident from Faslane, they not only undermine the UK, but Nato as well.

"America would not forgive - nor forget - this, and yet the separatists assume membership of Nato is almost a given."

Bannockburn anniversary

Sir John was also critical of the Scottish government's choice of referendum date, in the year marking the 700th anniversary of the Battle of Bannockburn.

Start Quote

John Major is perfectly entitled to his view, but his comments are woefully out of touch”

End Quote Stewart Maxwell MSP SNP

He added: "We have fought wars together more often, and more recently, than we have fought against one another.

"We were at war centuries ago, which is - if I may be brutally frank - why I find it rather sad that the Scottish National Party chose the anniversary of Bannockburn for the vote - presumably to maximise the opportunity for any anti-English sentiment that may exist."

Sir John said he was no longer in politics and was speaking for himself, but added that, like anyone from England, had a stake in campaigning to keep the United Kingdom together.

SNP MSP Stewart Maxwell said: "John Major is perfectly entitled to his view, but his comments are woefully out of touch.

"He was wrong about a Scottish Parliament in the 1990s, and he is wrong about an independent Scotland now.

"He also, unwittingly, makes the case for independence himself by pointing out that the Tories rule Scotland with just one MP out of 59.

"But John Major is just about the last person the 'No' campaign will have wanted to see entering the debate here, given his track record in ensuring a Tory wipe-out in Scotland in 1997."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 10:21: Your Pictures - Get Involved

    Two volunteers at the Highland Folk Museum in Newtonmore shelter from the rain as peat smoke drifts out through the thatch.

    newtonmore folk museum

    The picture was taken by Neil MacNeill from Edinburgh. Send us your photographs and we will use the best.

     
  2.  
    10:12: Red dye 'robber' charged

    A man has been arrested following an armed robbery at an Edinburgh bank which was thought to have left the thief covered in red security dye.

    A four-figure sum was taken during the incident at a branch of RBS in Craigentinny on 13 October.

    A 32-year-old man is expected to appear at Edinburgh Sheriff Court later.

     
  3.  
    10:07: Analysis - Celtic vs Astra

    Read Tom English's take on Celtic's victory over Romanian champions Astra.

    Craig Gordon
     
  4.  
    10:01: Take tax to the max

    Labour should support the devolution of full income tax powers to Scotland, a think tank has said.

    The Red Paper Collective, whose members include Labour MSPs Neil Findlay and Elaine Smith, argued the party's current proposals do not go far enough.

    Money in Scotland

    Labour has backed giving the Scottish Parliament control of three-quarters of basic rate income tax.

    Former Prime Minister Gordon Brown has argued that full tax powers would weaken Scottish Labour at Westminster.

     
  5.  
    09:53: It's bin too long...

    Scottish Borders Council's meeting next Thursday will consider re-instating garden waste collection bins.

    Green bin with leaves sticking out

    They were scrapped 10 months ago, but the council's petitions committee has unanimously agreed to revisit the issue, following a plea from ex-Hawick councillor Andrew Farquhar.

    He had handed in a petition signed by more than 8,000 people, addressing the committee from a green bin which he was using as a symbolic lectern.

     
  6.  
    09:44: Piracy row Scot 'struggling'

    A Scottish man trapped in India by a dispute over anti-piracy operations has said he is struggling to support himself.

    Speaking exclusively to BBC Alba's An La programme, Billy Irving said the British authorities had provided little practical support.

    Billy Irving

    He is on bail but unable to leave India.

    The Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) said it could provide advice but not financial assistance.

     
  7.  
    09:38: BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    CalMac possible delays between Ullapool and Stornoway due to adverse weather on Saturday 25 October.

    Keep an eye on whether your CalMac sailing is running on time here, and keep on eye on hold ups in your area on the BBC Travel site.

     
  8.  
    09:34: Online abuse on the increase

    There has been a big increase in the number of young people contacting a charity about online sexual abuse.

    Model using a laptop computer

    The NSPCC's Childline service says the UK figure has more than doubled in the past year.

    In Scotland, more than 500 young people called the charity looking for help and advice.

     
  9.  
    text 80295 09:23: Drink-drive limit - Your Views

    Hector, Fife: As someone who enjoys one beer with a meal, I feel that this new drink limit will be a further death knell to pubs and restaurants.

    Marie, Uddingston: I'm a 1 drink chancer. I say zero tolerance. Sad but inevitable.

    Tom, Motherwell: I am against drink driving. Can we also remove the bars from both Scottish and UK Parliaments to prevent politicians drinking while on duty and making poor decisions on the future of the country!

     
  10.  
    09:16: Douglas Fraser Business and economy editor, Scotland

    STV applies for local TV licences in Aberdeen, Dundee and Ayr, working with local universities/colleges. Already got Glasgow TV, Edinburgh from Jan.

    Camera in studio
     
  11.  
    09:09: Brazil shooting victim 'was Scottish'

    A man shot dead in Brazil during a robbery is believed to be a 39-year-old Scot named Jason Richard Stevens.

    The BBC's Hugo Bachega told Good Morning Scotland: "He was at a bar when two robbers entered the place. One of them was armed, and witnesses that were quoted by local media say that Jason Richard Stevens went to talk to one of the robbers. It seems that the robber was surprised by how tall he was and shot him dead.

    "He died when he was being taken to hospital."

    Mr Bachega added that according to local media, Mr Stevens is a 39-year-old Scot who was an English teacher in Brazil and had been in the South American country for 13 years.

     
  12.  
    09:02: Public sector worker assaults

    Violence against public sector workers in Scotland, including parking attendants, health service staff and council employees, rose again last year.

    Hospital people

    The total number of recorded incidents was over 37,000 - more than 100 attacks a day.

    But Unison says this may be the tip of the iceberg as many more are never reported, and some organisations do not keep proper statistics.

    The Scottish government says all workers should be safe as they do their jobs.

     
  13.  
    08:52: What the papers say...

    The Scotsman reports that a row has broken out over the long-term viability of Scotland's oil reserves.

    Papers composite

    The Scottish Sun writes that a grandmother has been killed after being kicked by her horse. The Scottish Daily Mail reports that a soldier based in Scotland has been questioned by UK and US police on suspicion that he was travelling to fight jihadists in Syria and Iraq.

    Read our full review of today's papers here.

     
  14.  
    08:48: Morning Call

    Coming up on Morning Call, there will be a discussion over the drink-drive plans and sexual consent. Listen live from 08:50 and get involved by texting 80295 or emailing us.

     
  15.  
    08:43: MacAskill's future

    Kenny MacAskill was also asked about his own future as Justice Secretary.

    With Nicola Sturgeon about to become Scotland's new First Minister, there has been speculation over what role Mr MacAskill would have.

    He said: "That is a matter for the incoming First Minister. I will be happy to serve in whatever capacity, whether that's in a ministerial capacity or elsewhere."

     
  16.  
    08:36: Limit different in England

    If the drink-drive plans come into law, it would mean the legal limit in Scotland would be lower than that in England.

    Drink driving

    On Good Morning Scotland, when asked about why a joint approach with the Westminster government on the issue was not agreed, Mr MacAskill said: "We did seek that, but it was the United Kingdom government that decided not to lower the limit despite, I think, a great deal of public support for it being lowered down there."

     
  17.  
    08:30: 'Broad support' for drink-drive plans

    Kenny MacAskill said the plans to change the drink-drive limit have "broad support".

    The Justice Secretary added: "The support comes not just from the police and law enforcement. It comes from those involved in road safety."

    Asked why the government didn't simply apply a zero tolerance approach, Mr MacAskill said: "There are reasons why individuals may have alcohol in their system. It is also quite clear at the 50 (mg) limit, that is when impairment begins to kick in."

     
  18.  
    08:28: Scottish football gossip

    Celtic are planning to raid Alex McLeish's new side Genk for Senegal international Kara Mbodj.

    dave king

    South Africa-based businessman Dave King is convinced he can still achieve his dream of saving Rangers.

    Newcastle United owner Mike Ashley snubbed King's pleas to meet for takeover talks.

    And Dundee United duo Paul Paton and Mark Wilson face a battle to save their careers after being embroiled in the fracas involving Celtic goalkeeper Lucasz Zaluska.

    It's another day of Scottish football gossip and you can read it here.

     
  19.  
    08:25: Drink-drive changes 'will save lives'

    The Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill has said the Scottish government's plan to reduce the country's drink-drive limit in time for Christmas "will help save lives".

    kenny macaskill

    Mr MacAskill told Good Morning Scotland: "There is clear evidence it will save lives - approximately 20 lives at least.

    "The latest estimates show that approximately one in 10 deaths on Scottish roads involve drivers who are over the legal limit. If you have alcohol in your bloodstream, you are three times as likely to be involved in a fatal car crash.

    "This is about protecting lives of drivers."

     
  20.  
    08:19: MacAskill on drink-drive limit

    Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill is speaking on BBC Scotland's Good Morning Scotland about plans to reduce the drink-drive limit in time for Christmas.

     
  21.  
    08:17: BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    All lanes now open following an accident at Newhouse Junction 6 on the eastbound M8, but congestion back to the Showcase junction.

    Glasgow bound M74 - just after J1A - accident blocking lane 3. Police are at scene and traffic is slow on approach, tailing back to at least Cambuslang Road Junction 2.

    Glasgow's Southside - traffic lights are out of action on Queen's Drive at Victoria Road.

    And in Torphichen, West Lothian, a fuel spillage on A801, both ways at A706 Avon Gorge, means the road is partially blocked.

     
  22.  
    08:13: Deila's delight

    Manager Ronny Deila was delighted to see Stefan Scepovic finally get off the mark as Celtic beat Astra Giurgiu 2-1 in the Europa League.

    stefan scepovic

    The Serbian striker, signed in the summer, missed a host of great chances before he opened the scoring with a second-half header to break his duck.

    "I'm happy for him that he gets the goal," Deila told BBC Scotland.

    "I kept him on the pitch because he was getting chances and I know what a goalscorer he is."

     
  23.  
    08:12: Salmond heading south?

    Alex Salmond has said he has not made up his mind whether or not to stand for a Westminster seat at the next general election.

    alex salmond

    The outgoing Scottish first minister was asked on the BBC's Question Time programme if he would consider becoming an MP again.

    Mr Salmond said he had "absolutely decisively" not made up his mind, but agreed that the door was not closed.

    He served as an SNP MP between 1987 and 2010 for Banff and Buchan.

     
  24.  
    08:03: Drink-drive limit cut by Christmas

    The Scottish government is to reduce the country's drink-drive limit in time for Christmas.

    breath test

    Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill has taken steps which, if approved by the Scottish Parliament, would mean a new limit being introduced on 5 December.

    Under the plans, Scotland's blood alcohol limit would be cut from 80mg to 50mg in every 100ml of blood.

    It would mean the legal limit in Scotland would be lower than that south of the border.

     
  25.  
    08:02: Paul McLaren BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and a warm welcome to Friday's instalment of Scotland Live as we offer you a comprehensive round-up of news, sport, travel and weather between now and 18:00.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • FutureThe future is now

    Get the latest updates and biggest ideas from BBC Future’s World-Changing Ideas Summit

Programmes

  • The smartphone that answers backClick Watch

    Smartphones get smarter – the prototypes that talk and say ouch when you drop them

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.