Scottish independence: Prof Patrick Dunleavy makes £200m start-up claim

Professor Patrick Dunleavy

An independent Scotland would face £200m of immediate start-up costs, it has been claimed.

Prof Patrick Dunleavy gave the figure in a report commissioned by The Sunday Post.

A spokesman for the First Minister said the UK Treasury's previous £2.7bn figure had been "blown out the water".

A UK Treasury spokesperson said the Scottish government was "refusing to come clean" on the cost of independence.

Prof Dunleavy, from the London School of Economics, said an independent Scotland could have to spend between £150m to £200m on new administrative structures to replace existing UK bodies.

Although an independent Scotland could share UK bodies during the transition to independence, it would have to build its own systems by 2021 to the cost of hundreds of millions of pounds, he claimed.

However, he added that a hostile approach from the UK government in post-Yes negotiations could "greatly add" to the cost.

The key points from the paper include:

  • Immediate set up costs of up to £200m to create new versions of existing UK bodies
  • The total would increase if UK ministers take a "hostile stance" in post-Yes negotiations
  • The costs could be offset due to Scotland having a "smaller government machine", spending less on areas such as defence
  • The initial expenditure should be seen as an investment which will save on future running costs
  • The long-run viability of an independent Scotland is "generally high"

Prof Dunleavy's latest work comes after he dismissed the UK Treasury's use of his research to calculate £2.7bn of start-up costs as "ludicrous".

'Utterly demolished'

A spokesperson for the First Minister said Prof Dunleavy's findings "totally vindicate" the Scottish government's position.

He said: "Their figure of £2.7bn has been blown out of the water by Prof Dunleavy.

"The Treasury estimate has been exposed as a total and utter fabrication, and we now demand an immediate retraction.

"The No campaign's arguments have been totally and utterly demolished, and we now need a retraction both from the Treasury and the No side."

He added: "The set-up costs, which Prof Dunleavy estimates at £200m, would be offset against the scope that he has pointed out for efficiencies from better delivery of services."

'Come clean'

However, a Treasury spokesperson said the Scottish government was "refusing to come clean" on the cost of independence.

The spokesperson said: "Prof Dunleavy accepts there may be over a billion pounds in additional costs to Scotland at a time when the economy and our national finances are recovering.

"In addition, independent estimates show that setting up a new tax system is costing £750 million in New Zealand, and research from the Department of Work and Pensions says that a new welfare and pensions IT system alone would cost between £300 million and £400 million.

The spokesperson added: "The Scottish Government has refused to come clean with its own number on the cost of independence and only the UK Government is providing the facts."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    Murdoch wins heat 11:24:

    Commonwealth champion Ross Murdoch has won his heat of the Men's 100m breaststroke following his gold medal in the 200m breaststroke last night.

    Michael Jamieson finished third in the same heat.

    Both men should be in tonight's semi-final at around 20:05.

     
  2.  
    Beattie meets... 11:15: John Beattie BBC Scotland

    tweets: Bumped into the wonderful @matthewcpinsent

     
  3.  
    What a lot of pants 10:58: Graham Fraser BBC Scotland

    Forget all those amazing scenes in the pool last night. Surely the most memorable moment of the Games so far - barring the Scottie dogs of the opening ceremony of course - is the celebration of Gavin Rumgay in the table tennis.

    Gavin Rumgay celebrates in the table tennis

    Are those Team Scotland boxer shorts? Who knows. Some questions are best left unanswered.

     
  4.  
    St Helena to Glasgow 10:51:

    For most of you reading this page, it will take minutes or maybe a few hours to travel to Glasgow.

    So spare a thought for athletes from St Helena - an island in the South Atlantic - who spent 10 days travelling to get to the Games.

    St Helena team

    Watch a video diary of their journey.

     
  5.  
    Prisoner voting - your views 10:45: Via SMS

    Jeff: Prisoners should definitely have the vote. People change and deserve a second chance.

    Knowles in Inverurie: Surely the whole point of going to prison is you loose your rights. Some discouragement. Must be given to help preventing people offend in the first place.

    Gerry McSherry: Prisoners are part of society. Fact. Thus, they MUST have their "right to vote" respected. Otherwise, our society is fatally flawed,non-inclusive and uncivilised. Unionise our incarcerated!

    Stevie in Greenock: No prisoners should get a vote never mind those that commit murder. They bang on about human rights, what a front, wonder if they think about the rights of the victims. The minute you go to prison you lose the right to vote and long may that continue.

     
  6.  
    Exam reform delayed 10:39:

    Dozens of schools across Scotland are delaying the introduction of new Highers in popular school subjects, according to BBC Scotland research.

    New look Highers start in the new school year to tie in with the replacements for Standard Grades.

    Classroom scene

    But a significant number of schools have chosen to delay them for a year in some popular subjects.

     
  7.  
    Mother admits Mikaeel Kular killing 10:30:

    The mother of three-year-old Mikaeel Kular has pleaded guilty to killing her son in Edinburgh in January.

    Mikaeel Kular

    Rosdeep Adekoya had been charged with murder, but admitted the reduced charge of culpable homicide when she appeared at the High Court in Edinburgh.

     
  8.  
    Disappointment for Brownlie 10:28: Heather Dewar BBC Scotland

    Scotland's Caroline Brownlie has missed out on qualification for the womens 10m air pistol event at Barry Buddon.

    Caroline Brownlie

    The 36-year-old from Edinburgh finished 24th out of 28 in this mornings qualifiers. Brownlie had a disappointing first two rounds before improving in the final two. She finished with an overall score of 351-3x.

     
  9.  
    Camera spy 10:25: Louise Sayers BBC Scotland

    Just spotted the BBC's Gary Lineker doing a piece to camera next to the Science Centre.

    Gary Lineker
     
  10.  
    Your pictures 10:11:

    Chris Dwyer from Ullapool sent us this stunning shot of the sun setting along Loch Broom last night.

    Loch Broom

    You can tweet us your pictures using #ScotlandLive or email them here.

     
  11.  
  12.  
    Scots make their mark 10:03:

    BBC Scotland's Andy Burke has created a fantastic video montage of Team Scotland's success on day one.

    Scottish swimmer Ross Murdoch

    Watch it here.

     
  13.  
    Watch again 09:56: Graham Fraser BBC Scotland
  14.  
    Dutchman to leave Celtic? 09:51:

    Speculation surrounding the future of Celtic defender Virgil van Dijk continues.

    Celtic defender Virgil van Dijk

    Read Friday's Scottish gossip round-up.

     
  15.  
    Elderly drinking - your views 09:43: Via SMS

    Stan in Banff: My great grandfather had a nip everynight lived to 94.

    H in Edinburgh: It's more like UNDER 65s who need to cut down. As long as over 65s drink very moderately it is ok although must be moderate so to lower risk of falls.

    Anonymous: Not the over 60s who are carted into A&E every night of the week comatose through alcohol. If people want to drink let them get on with it but don't waste taxpayers money paying for NHS and police to look after them.

     
  16.  
    Which famous Scots can't vote? 09:37:

    They may have strong opinions on the forthcoming independence referendum, but many of Scotland's famous and respected names don't live in the country so won't get a vote.

    Gordon Strachan

    Read about them here.

     
  17.  
    Scotland third in the medal table 09:28:

    After day one of competition, Scotland are third in the medal table thanks to golds from swimmers Hannah Miley and Ross Murdoch and judo stars Kimberley and Louise Renicks.

    Medal table after day one

    There were also silvers for Aileen McGlynn and Louise Haston in tandem sprint cycling, swimmer Michael Jamieson and judo fighter Stephanie Inglis.

    John Buchanan, James Millar and Connie Ramsay (all judo) won bronze medals.

    England top the table with six golds, followed by Australia with five.

     
  18.  
    Scots to watch 09:21:

    Katie Archibald could medal in the women's individual pursuit on the cycling track. The qualifying is at 11:15, with the final at 16:55.

    South Africa's men are in action against Scotland in the hockey competition at 11:00, while Scotland's women will play Malaysia at 16:00.

    Robbie Renwick at Glasgow 2014

    In Netball, Scotland will play Saint Lucia at 17:00.

    Meanwhile, at the pool, Ross Murdoch and Michael Jamieson will be in action again today in the men's 100m breaststroke semi-finals at around 20:05.

    Robbie Renwick (pictured), the men's 200m freestyle Commonwealth champion, is also in action today. Heats begin at 10:30, with the final at 19:25.

    Don't forget, you can catch all the action on the BBC Sport website.

     
  19.  
    Keep the noise up! 09:11: Via Twitter Team Scotland judo player Connie Ramsay

    tweets: Anyone coming to watch judo today, please keep that noise up! It was amazing yesterday! I know yous can do it again! We want to hear yous!

     
  20.  
    Two through, one out 09:05:

    Aberdeen and St Johnstone progressed in the Europa League qualifiers last night, but Motherwell went out.

    Aberdeen players celebrating

    The Dons secured a 2-1 win in the Netherlands to beat Groningen by the same scoreline on aggregate while Saints won a penalty shoot-out against Swiss side FC Luzern. Motherwell went down 5-4 on aggregate against Icelanders UMF Stjarnan after extra-time.

    Spanish side Real Sociedad await Aberdeen in the third qualifying round while St Johnstone will face Spartak Trnava of Slovakia.

     
  21.  
    Where were you? 08:51:

    Everyone's talking about Scotland's golden night at Glasgow 2014. But where were you? Were you lucky enough to be at Tollcross or the SECC? And how did you celebrate?

    Louise and Kimberley Renicks

    Send us your comments and pictures on Twitter using #ScotlandLive, by email or you can text us on 80295.

     
  22.  
    Morning call 08:30: BBC Radio Scotland

    Kaye Adams leads today's debate from 08:50. With figures showing that almost one in five pensioners drinks alcohol at home every day, she'll be asking: should we be telling old people to lay off the booze?

    Elsewhere, judges in the UK's highest court ruled yesterday that prisoners should not be allowed to vote in September's referendum. Do you agree?

    We want to hear from you - call 0500 92 95 00, text 80295 or email morningcallscotland@bbc.co.uk.

     
  23.  
    Fans flocking to Glasgow 08:15:

    More than 100,000 people are expected at Commonwealth Games venues today during the second day of competition.

    Medal events are taking place in track cycling, swimming, weightlifting and judo at venues in Glasgow.

    Fans at Commonwealth Games

    The shooting medal event takes place at the Barry Buddon Centre in Carnoustie.

     
  24.  
    Wickerman gets under way 08:08:

    Thousands of music fans are heading to south west Scotland as the annual Wickerman Festival gets under way.

    Wickerman festival

    The event, at East Kirkcarswell near Dundrennan on Friday and Saturday, will see acts including Dizzee Rascal, Del Amitri, The Feeling and Martha Reeves and the Vandellas perform.

     
  25.  
    Re-live the magic 08:01:

    Bathed in sunshine, the opening day at Glasgow 2014 had many memorable moments.

    Triathlon

    You can re-live some of them here in our picture gallery.

     
  26.  
    Good Morning Scotland 07:52: BBC Radio Scotland

    The nation's morning news programme is on air now with analysis of all the latest national and international developments.

    You can listen live here.

     
  27.  
    RBS expects profits to rise 07:46:

    Royal Bank of Scotland has reported better than expected pre-tax profits of £2.65bn for the first half of the year, up from £1.37bn last year.

    RBS

    The bank said it had set aside much less money for fines and compensation than expected - down to £269m from £2.15bn.

    However, chief executive Ross McEwan warned of "bumps in the road ahead of us."

     
  28.  
    Another big day ahead 07:41:

    Following yesterday's success, there's more Team Scotland action to look forward to in the pool and in track cycling, with Michael Jamieson having the opportunity to put his silver medal disappointment behind him in the 100m breaststroke semi-finals at around 7pm.

    Michael Jamieson disappointed with silver at Commonwealth Games

    Robbie Renwick is also in action in the 200m freestyle, the title he won in Delhi four year ago. Elsewhere, Scots athletes are involved in boxing, badminton and squash.

    Keep across all the action on on the BBC Sport website.

     
  29.  
    Hot and sunny 07:30: BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    A cloudy and misty start around North Sea coasts with some mist also to be found through the central belt, burning back to leave another fine, hot day with plenty of sunshine.

    It's the last day of high temperatures, which could reach 27C or 28C across central and western Scotland at best. Cooler on the east coast and for eastern cities, but still pleasant once the haar moves away.

    For the Northern Isles, the haar lingers, but some good spells of sunshine coming through the west of Orkney where it could reach 23C. A risk of a few afternoon showers across the Highlands, set off by the high temperatures, some of which could be sharp.

    For a full forecast go to the BBC Weather website.

     
  30.  
    Latest updates
  31.  
    Golden night 07:12:

    Day one ended in a goldrush for Team Scotland with gold medals for sisters Kimberley and Louise Renicks in the judo and Hannah Miley and Ross Murdoch in the pool.

    Hannah Miley

    The home team won 10 medals in all, with the prospect of more to come today.

     
  32.  
    Welcome 06:56: Marianne Taylor BBC Scotland news

    Good morning and welcome to BBC Scotland Live. We'll be here until 23:00 bringing you all the latest news, sport, weather and travel from across the country, including all the action and atmosphere from the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games.

    Keep in touch and send us your comments and pics via Twitter using #ScotlandLive, by email or by text on 80295.

     

Features

  • Silhouetted of feetYour pictures

    A selection of your photographs of Scotland sent in between 18 and 25 July


  • Jean-Luc CourcoultJean-Luc and the giants

    The enigmatic Frenchman behind Liverpool's 25ft grandmother


  • NS Savannah, 1962Nuclear dream

    The ship that totally failed to change the world


  • Irvine WelshDeaf ears

    Five famous Scots who can't vote in the Scottish referendum


  • Balloons flying upUp, up and away

    Why the ever rising pound is not all good news


Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Canada.Hidden rail trip

    Canada's tiny, two-car shuttle is a train lover's dream with scenic views

Programmes

  • Leader of Hamas Khaled MeshaalHARDtalk Watch

    BBC exclusive: Hamas leader on the eagerness to end bloodshed in Gaza

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.