Scottish independence: Councils bar 'Yes' and 'No' campaigns from schools

 
A BBC Scotland survey revealed 84% of councils will restrict access to pupils once the purdah period starts on 22 August. BBC Scotland spoke to the country's 32 councils about their policy on referendum debates in schools

The official referendum campaigns are being barred from the majority of schools in Scotland ahead of polling day, BBC research has found.

Twenty-six of the country's 32 councils will restrict access to Yes Scotland and Better Together.

However, most councils said pupils would be able to talk about the referendum in school.

For the first time in the UK, 16 and 17-year-olds in Scotland - the majority of whom attend high school - can vote.

The findings come on the first day of "purdah" which curbs what public bodies can do during election periods.

In the lead up to the referendum on 18 September, governments and local authorities are restricted on what new projects they can announce and legislate on, for fear of influencing the way people vote.

Many councils north of the border are applying those "purdah" rules to referendum debate activities in schools.

What are the policies of Scottish councils?

Authority name Have campaign groups been barred?

SOURCE: Scottish councils

Aberdeen

Yes

Aberdeenshire

No

Dumfries and Galloway

Yes

Dundee

Yes

Glasgow

Yes

Midlothian

Yes

Scottish Borders

Yes

BBC Research: Full breakdown on what Scottish councils said.

In four weeks time, Scotland's electorate will be asked the "Yes/No" question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

The BBC Scotland research found the majority of local authorities had chosen to limit access to campaign groups in the coming weeks, and were strictly adhering to guidelines outlined in the Referendum Act.

Six councils - Aberdeenshire, East Ayrshire, Edinburgh, Orkney, Shetland Islands, and Western Isles - said they would allow the Yes Scotland and Better Together campaigns access to their students during this 28-day period.

Public bodies

Electoral Commission guidelines stipulate what materials may not be published by public bodies, but they do not specifically address whether campaigns can visit schools and interact with pupils ahead of polling day.

A commission spokesman told BBC Scotland it was up to each local authority to decide how to approach the pre-referendum period.

Orkney Council, which has not barred Yes Scotland and Better Together, stressed that any activity on school premises would need to be balanced in the countdown to polling day.

A statement said: "In the interests of even-handedness, both sides of the debate would have to be involved in any such visit.

"This would also have to take place outside class time and would have to be short."

line
What is the purdah period?

By BBC Scotland political editor Brian Taylor

"Political purdah means different things for different people.

"For ministers, in the run-up to an election, it places a curb upon their natural desire to evangelise their undoubted talents to the citizens at public expense.

"For civil servants, it can provide a welcome relief - from the ever helpful advice offered by ministers. A chance to get on with governing the country, free from unwarranted interruption. And, of course, to prepare for the next administration - of whatever political hue.

"More seriously, purdah refers to the specified period prior to an election when governments desist from making announcements designed to impress the people and, thus, win votes for their party."

line

The Better Together campaign questioned the approach by many councils to limit access to schools.

A statement from the group said: "The decision we take on 18 September will determine the future of Scotland's young people, so it's vital that those with the vote get to hear all of the facts and the arguments.

"For young Scots the idea of creating barriers and limiting their opportunities makes no sense."

A spokesman for Yes Scotland said the issue of schools hosting referendum debates was a matter "for local councils to administer".

He added: "Yes Scotland is always happy to accept invitations to debate."

line
What are the issues of the referendum?
Debt graphs

As the people of Scotland weigh up how to vote in the independence referendum, they are asking questions on a range of topics, from welfare to pensions. In a special news website series, we take a look at those major questions and by using statistics, analysis and expert views shining a light on some of the possible answers. Our correspondents have already written about how broadcasting, oil, education, trident and debt fit into the referendum debate.

line

Many councils said that while the two campaigns would not be allowed into schools now, they had attended school debates earlier in the year.

Falkirk Council agreed upon a policy with head teachers that each secondary school should hold a referendum presentation between February and June, attended by two members from each campaign.

Tony McDaid, head of education at South Lanarkshire Council, said: "Over 500 young people from schools throughout South Lanarkshire took part in a debate on independence at Hamilton Town House in June.

"Representatives from the Yes and No campaign pitched their points to the audience of 16 and 17 year olds."

Last year all councils were issued with a joint briefing from key organisations including;

  • The Association of Directors in Education Scotland
  • Education Scotland; the Electoral Commission
  • The Electoral Management Board for Scotland
  • And School Leaders Scotland.

The briefing encouraged councils to ensure young adults were;

  • Registered to vote,
  • Were aware of how to vote on polling day
  • Understood the key referendum issues
  • And were made aware of other online resources.

At the start of 2014, all councils were issued with Education Scotland's Curriculum for Excellence briefing which informed teachers how to promote political literacy ahead of the referendum.

The BBC Scotland research found that five councils - Angus, Dundee, Highland, Moray and North Ayrshire - were placing the heaviest restrictions on their schools during the "purdah" period.

No school debates

In guidance notes issued to its schools, Angus Council stated: "Individual school mock hustings must be held prior to the pre-referendum period and in the course of session 2013 / 2014."

Similarly, a spokesman for Dundee council said: "We have organised a central referendum debate through the Dundee Youth Council which has already been held and all secondary schools were involved.

"We have agreed that there will be no individual school debates over and above this."

The remaining councils stipulated that while school debates were not permissible, general classroom discussion related to the referendum would be allowed.

 

More on This Story

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • Comment number 357.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 356.

    Indoctrination isn't teachers etc. openly stating their views.
    Rather UK press constantly putting down education, Europe, and now Scotland.
    In fact many Yes voters cite UK's press-banker-corporate elite.
    UK's the only EU gov't that allows MPs on corporate payrolls.
    So- worst income gap, education, etc.
    UK elite seem untouchable.
    I don't find that in W. Europe.
    W'minster is past reform.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 355.

    353.Auld Reekie

    What you on man?
    Just how long do you want him to go on for?

    So you are going to help us by absolving us of our share of the national debt created by Westminster governments.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 354.

    349.hengis

    Not keeping up with the news?
    Culturally, London is the most expensive place in all Europe.
    As for living there, many Londoners commute due to horrendous housing costs, and have to pay exorbitant rail fares to a 2nd rate subsidised rail system.

  • rate this
    -2

    Comment number 353.

    @352. Drunken Hobo

    "Whisky, tourism, energy, farming, engineering, ..."

    The only people to talk our great nation down is your party and Project Hate.

    Interesting to see you listed many industries, which as it happens the rUK are the main recipients of our exports! Tourism? Yep, the rUK our biggest guests.

    You wish to give 2 fingers to them and then expert them to be our lender of last resort!

 

Comments 5 of 357

 

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    11:42: Weather update BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    A cloudy afternoon across much of the country with scattered showers, most of them across the West, while eastern Scotland stays drier and brighter with some spells of sunshine.

    It'll be cooler than in recent days, with temperatures reaching 14C in the best of the sunshine, and a brisk west or south-westerly breeze.

    Later this afternoon, winds will strengthen, reaching gale force through the Minches by this evening.

     
  2.  
    Text 80295 11:41: Carrier bag charge - Your Views

    Nikki, Edinburgh: In my honest opinion, all shops should stop supplying bags, forcing people to take their own. Six wee string bags would hold most people's shopping and would cost them virtually nothing.

    Rachel, Kirkcudbright: What about the vast amounts of plastic our groceries are packaged in. This 5p charge is putting the onus on the customer who has no say or control over this excess use of packaging! The manufactures' should be taxed on the waste their products they produce.

    Andrew, Aberdeen: If I'm paying 5p per bag then I'll want better quality bags.

     
  3.  
    11:36: Carrier bag charges John Beattie BBC Scotland

    5p charge for plastic bags comes into force today, anyone out there had to pay for one today?

     
  4.  
    11:34: OAP 'critical' after Edinburgh crash

    A 74-year-old woman is in a critical condition after being hit by a car at traffic lights in Edinburgh.

    Police said the Ford Fiesta struck the woman when the vehicle moved away from the lights at the junction of Charlotte Square and Rose Street at about 19:30 on Sunday.

    Officers were keen to speak to the driver of a green BMW which was also at the traffic lights.

    They appealed for witnesses to contact the police.

     
  5.  
    @TheScotsman 11:30: The Scotsman

    tweets: Average pension pots in Scotland will only give people a "comfortable" retirement income for 5 years, research finds.

    Read the full story here.

     
  6.  
    11:23: Retail therapy

    The number of people passing through shops in Scotland rose last month, with footfall up 2% compared to last September.

    Shopping bags

    Scotland recorded the highest footfall figures of any area of the UK, with out-of-town retail the standout performer.

    Shopper traffic through the high street also rose from previous months but shopping centres were quieter, seeing a slight dip.

    The Scottish Retail Consortium, who released the statistics, says this is because they're dominated by fashion retailers - who suffered from the unusually warm weather last month.

     
  7.  
    11:15: Wrestles in the net... BBC Sport

    You remember the one where Dundee celebrated a goal with a #WWE move? Here it is...

    Jim McAlister and Dundee goalscorer Gary Harkins
    Randy Orton tweet
     
  8.  
    11:03: Tug for broken down cargo ship

    A coastguard tug is attending an incident in the Pentland Firth, five miles north of Dounreay.

    Herakles

    The 95m-long cargo ship broke down after passing through the Firth last night, before drifting back eastwards.

    The ship raised the alarm shortly after 22:00 and the Shetland Coastguard tasked emergency tug 'Herakles' to attend the scene.

     
  9.  
    10:59: Delivering festive cheer

    Royal Mail is launching its Christmas recruitment drive - employing an additional 1,100 temporary staff in Scotland to work from November to early January.

    Christmas cards being sorted in Royal Mail office

    Its parcels business, Parcelforce Worldwide, is also recruiting 2,000 extra people across the UK.

     
  10.  
    10:55: Stormy waters BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Cal Mac - Armadale to Mallaig - Due to the poor weather forecast, all sailings have been restricted for the day.

     
  11.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 10:54: Carrier bag charge - Your Views

    Alan Cameron, Aberdeen: In response to Michael Laurier's comments that the plastic bag charge "denies people, for no real valid reason, their basic human rights"... I can think of a great deal of human rights denials in the world which are of far greater consequence than not getting one of Mr Laurier's Plastic Bags. These bags were almost unknown when I was child, and a 'message bag' just had potatoes, and veg tipped into it. No bags of any kind and that was in the 60's.

     
  12.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 10:53: Is Aberdeen 'dismal' and 'tired'?

    Does Aberdeen deserve the accolade of "most dismal town"?

    David Motion emails: Yes, a city with so much money has no excuses to be so architecturally and culturally deprived. Never have I lived in a city that has so little to offer. Shameful!

     
  13.  
    10:47: Batten down the hatches The Scotsman

    Tweets: Gale force winds are set to cause travel disruption for much of Scotland over the next few days.

    Read the full story here.

     
  14.  
    10:34: Building profits

    The Scottish house builder CALA has announced record profits.

    Builder

    The company made a pre-tax profit of £27m in the year to the end of June - a rise of 117% on the previous year.

    This included what it called a "strong performance" from the English house builder Banner Homes, which it bought in March.

    House sales for the group reached a record level.

     
  15.  
    Text your views to 80295, email newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk, or tweet #ScotlandLive 10:23: Carrier bag charge -Your Views

    Carol, Largs: In Ireland, clothing etc is packed in recyclable paper bags. You're only charged for plastic bags in the supermarkets.

    Lorna, Stirling: I will be paying for a new bag when I buy clothing. This is taking it too far.

    Lee, Perth: I can't believe that people are moaning about a 5p bag! Seriously, if that all you've got to worry about in your life you can afford to pay for a 5p bag.

     
  16.  
    10:07: Textbook planning

    Accommodation for almost 200 students is to be created in Aberdeen to cope with demand.

    Planning permission has been granted for a 196-bed complex with parking for 20 cars and 70 bicycles on Powis Place, near Aberdeen University.

    Image if plan
     
  17.  
    10:00: Kaye Adams tribute to Lynda Bellingham

    BBC Radio Scotland presenter Kaye Adams has paid tribute to actress and presenter Lynda Bellingham, who has died at the age of 66.

    Lynda Bellingham

    Kaye, who worked with Lynda on ITV's "Loose Women", has described her late colleague, who was battling cancer, as "fun, energetic and dynamic".

    "She just made you feel good about yourself, and good about the world. She was a very optimistic, very positive with a wicked sense of humour."

     
  18.  
    Text 80295 09:54: Carrier bag charge - Your Views

    Glyn Evans, Beauly: 5p for a bag won't make much of a difference! Charge 20p a bag up to a maximum of £1 in any one visit. Put the profits into a welfare fund to help the most impoverished and vulnerable children in the country. Admittedly, this creates a slight dilemma between Eco and charity but if these bags were biodegradable and marketed as multi-purpose (refuse bags, small bin liners etc etc) this could make a real difference to the welfare of many people in this country. All it takes is a wee change of mindset. Or is that too socialist for today's capitalist society?

     
  19.  
    09:45: Smoke bombs at Almondvale Edinburgh Evening News

    Tweets: Boy had to be carried from Hibs game after smoke bombs let off.

    Read the full story here.

     
  20.  
    09:43: 'Tired' Aberdeen?

    After Aberdeen was nominated for a Carbuncle Award - which highlights poor architecture and planning - a senior councillor has admitted the city is looking "tired".

    Aberdeen

    The Granite City is in the running for the 'Plook in the Plinth' prize, with Urban Realm describing it as "the place where architecture goes to die".

    Fellow nominees for "most dismal town" include Cumbernauld and Lochgelly.

    Does Aberdeen deserve this dubious honour? Do you have a more apt choice to offer? Get in touch via text using 80295, email here or tweet using #ScotlandLive.

     
  21.  
    Text 80295 09:34: Carrier bag charge - Get Involved

    Elaine: M&S already charge 5p per bag and have been doing it for some time, it would seem, without much complaint. However, if I shop there I make sure I take my own bag which has now become a habit I don't even think about.

    Graham: It's all very well taxing carrier bags but what about the plastic bottles, fast food containers and cans? Just walk about our streets and look along our road network and see the mess. I'm Scottish but we are a dirty bunch. We need a general keep Scotland tidy campaign.

    H, Edinburgh: Yet another thing about the good auld days. Nae carrier bags when I wis wee. Jist get rid o them altogether. People will soon learn quick tae take a bag wi them.

     
  22.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 09:29: Scottish Labour - Your Views

    James Martin, Glasgow: The problem with Labour is that we do not know what they stand for, but know they stand against ANYTHING that any SNP MSP says at Holyrood, or what any Tory says in Westminster. Yet, when Labour complain, they don't provide ideas to fix the problem and expect to be elected, by default, as simply "the other party". I really do think the Labour Party now embodies everything that is seen as wrong in politicians: self-serving, void of ideas and putting party before the people.

     
  23.  
    09:26: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    tweets: CalMac weather warning overnight/tomorrow means Caledonian Isles will return to Brodick this evening to berth. Tomorrow 0700 ex Ardrossan.

     
  24.  
    09:18: Dementia care

    Speaking ahead of the conference on dementia in Glasgow today, health secretary Alex Neil said that Scotland is "leading the way" in care.

    Alex Neil

    However, he accepted that aspects of residence care rated "unsatisfactory" in the mental health commission report.

    "We are monitoring the implementation of these recommendations to make sure that those shortcomings are addressed quickly and comprehensively," said Mr Neil.

     
  25.  
    09:10: Once the referendum dust settles...

    On 19 September, hundreds of thousands of Scots woke up disappointed after the country voted to reject independence.

    Hope over Fear rally

    In the days before Scotland voted, political activity rocketed. In streets in the major cities, "Yes" and "No" campaigners gathered to rally their supporters and get their message across.

    How did it feel to be on the losing side? And where do they go from here?

     
  26.  
    09:01: Scottish Labour leadership Daily Record

    Tweets: Scottish Labour MP Jim Murphy rules out challenging Johann Lamont for the leadership.

    Read the full story here.

     
  27.  
    08:56: Dementia summit

    Scotland's largest dementia conference is taking place in Glasgow today.

    dementia conference

    The four-day event aims to find ways of overcoming the stigma attached to the condition, which affects almost 90,000 people in Scotland.

    Tonight, the Glasgow Declaration - a commitment to promoting the rights of people living with dementia across Europe - will be signed.

     
  28.  
    08:51: Alternative view: Bag charge is 'wrong'

    Not everyone is happy about the plastic bag charge.

    Michael Laurier, director of plastics manufacturer Symphony Environmental, says the new law is wrong.

    "It denies people, for no real valid reason, their basic human rights," he told BBC Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland.

    "It's taking away an everyday product, that people don't use just once. They've already paid for within their shopping bill and getting them to pay for it again.

    "It also forces them to buy more bin liners. When you refer to the Irish experience, the consumption of shopping bags dropped from 90-95% but the sale of bin liners went up 400%."

     
  29.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 08:48: Carrier bag charge - Your Views

    Derek Reilly, Pontypridd: Frustrating charge - when you purchase clothes, no one has large bags. Beware: people will buy knives and not be willing to buy a bag so carry the knives around.

     
  30.  
    08:42: Football gossip

    West Ham manager Sam Allardyce is keeping tabs on Celtic defender Virgil van Dijk, reports the Scottish Sun.

    Celtic defender Virgil Van Dijk Are West Ham keen to 'hammer' out a deal with Celtic for defender Virgil van Dijk?

    This morning's back pages also mark Dave King's anticipated meeting in Glasgow this week with Rangers shareholder Mike Ashley.

    Read the rest of the sporting headlines in our newspaper round-up here.

     
  31.  
    08:37: Bag charge a 'major step forward'

    Calum Duncan, Scottish Programme Manager at the Marine Conservation Society, has welcomed the new 5p charge for single use carrier bags as a "major step forward".

    Plastic bags

    Speaking on Good Morning Scotland he said 750 million 'single use' carriers bags are used every year in Scotland.

    "That's the highest per person than anywhere else in the UK; and that's 150 per person, per year," Mr Duncan added.

    "They're used for only about 20 minutes but the average carrier bag can take over 1,000 years to break down and fragment."

    What do you think about the charge? Text 80295, email us here or tweet using #ScotlandLive.

     
  32.  
    08:30: Tune in... Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    Scottish Labour has found itself in a state of flux following the referendum. There have been rumours of challenges to leader Johann Lamont and former First Ministers Jack McConnell and Henry McLeish have urged the party to rediscover its "sense of purpose".

    Morning Call

    On today's programme I'm asking: has Scottish Labour lost its way? Also, is charging 5p for a carrier bag a waste of time?

    Give us a call on 0500 92 95 00 or text 80295.

    You can listen live to the programme, from 08:50, here.

     
  33.  
    08:24: Today's papers

    The Scottish Daily Mail leads with suggestions that a collapse in support for Scottish Labour could cost it victory at next year's general election.

    Scotland's newspapers

    Meanwhile, The Scottish Sun features the results of an investigation by the paper into the commission paid to online comparison sites.

    Read the rest of our newspaper round-up here.

     
  34.  
    08:16: 'Oh... Vienna'

    Andy Murray came from a set down to beat David Ferrer 5-7 6-2 7-5 in the final of the Vienna Open.

    The victory means the Scot moves ahead of Ferrer in the race to qualify for the World Tour Finals.

    Murray, 27, broke his opponent three times in the final set before holding his nerve to serve out the match and win only his second title of the year.

    Andy Murray following his Vienna Open title

    "It was a good finish to the week," Murray told BBC Radio 5 live after a match that lasted two hours 42 minutes," said the Scot.

    "It was a very long match and both of us were in the locker room struggling, limping around and very stiff and sore so it was a nice one to get through."

     
  35.  
    08:12: Starting salaries

    Starting pay for new recruits has been rising strongly, data on Scotland's labour market shows.

    It found that the numbers available for work had been falling while employers took on more staff.

    The Bank of Scotland survey for September saw weaker growth than in the previous three months.

    The number of vacancies grew, but at the slowest pace for 11 months.

    Glasgow had the highest growth in pay for permanent new recruits, and Dundee had the fastest rise in pay for those on temporary contracts.

     
  36.  
    08:08: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Stop-start at times westbound #A720 Edinburgh City by-pass Gilmerton to Dreghorn - about 5 miles of queuing traffic.

     
  37.  
    Text 80295 08:04: Carrier bag charge - Your Views

    PB, Glasgow: 5p a bag? About time. Next we want £500 a mile for every private car poisoning the air that we breathe!

    Jimmy in Alloa: Come off it guys, a 5p charge on plastic bags means we'll be paying twice the cost. The bags are already costed into the price of the goods we purchase.

     
  38.  
    08:03: How's the weather looking? BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    Morning all, Gillian here. Scattered showers today, mainly in the West; drier & brighter in the East. Temperature between 12-15C. Winds strengthening later.

     
  39.  
    08:00: Carrier bag charge

    A mandatory carrier bag charge has been introduced in Scotland for the first time.

    Shoppers will now have to pay a minimum of 5p per bag, with net proceeds to be donated to good causes.

    Carrier bag

    In May, MSPs voted to bring in the new regulations in an effort to tackle Scotland's litter problem.

    In addition to plastic bags, the fee has also been imposed on single-use carriers made from eco-friendly materials.

    The minimum charge applies to all retailers, not just supermarkets.

    Wales became the first part of the UK to introduce a minimum charge for single-use carrier bags in 2011, followed by Northern Ireland last year.

     
  40.  
    07:59: Welcome Thomas McGuigan BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and a warm welcome from the Scotland Live team. We'll bring you a comprehensive round up of the latest news, sport, travel and weather between now and 18:00.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

Programmes

  • Ade Adepitan at the ColosseumThe Travel Show Watch

    The challenges of providing disabled access at Europe’s leading ancient monuments

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.