Scottish independence: Henry McLeish says 'voting No has become difficult'

Henry McLeish, former Labour First Minister Henry McLeish is a former Labour First Minister of Scotland

Former First Minister Henry McLeish has told the BBC that voting "No" to independence "has become difficult".

Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland's The Big Debate, Mr McLeish insisted he would still vote to maintain the Union.

But he said he was unsure what Scotland would get "when Westminster and the new government meet in 2015".

Former SNP leader Gordon Wilson, who backs independence, claimed "there will be people disappointed with the slowness of change".

There has been speculation that Mr McLeish, who was Labour First Minister from 2000-2001, will declare his support for a "Yes" vote ahead of the 18 September referendum.

Blair McDougall, director of the pro-UK Better Together campaign, tweeted after the programme: "Just heard from impeccable source that Henry McLeish endorsing Yes on Monday. Hardly a surprise but he's entitled to his view."

But Mr McLeish described the claim as "absolute rubbish".

In a BBC referendum webcast in April, Mr McLeish said he "would find it nearly impossible to vote 'Yes'."

'Highly partisan'

Asked on The Big Debate if he still intended to reject independence, Mr McLeish said: "I'm a 'No' voter, but I have been honest enough on public platforms and in a new book that voting 'No' has become difficult.

"The debate is very tribal, the debate is highly partisan. We live in a politic environment so there is nothing surprising about that.

"But on the other hand, what I think we have to make sure of in this debate, whether you're voting 'Yes' or 'No' is to try and maybe understand, all of us, the full implications because there's nothing black and white in the world.

"And what I'm arguing for is, if you vote 'Yes' you get independence, if you vote 'No' there's a bit of a hesitation as to what you get when Westminster and the new government meet in 2015."

Pressed on whether he would consider changing his vote to "Yes", he replied that "at this point" he was still voting "No", but added: "It doesn't mean I won't continue to irritate and annoy my own party and others by putting the issues that matter to Scotland."

He added: "This is a debate about the future of our country, not about the future of any individual party in it."

Gordon Wilson Gordon Wilson is a former leader of the Scottish National Party
'Slow change'

Presenter Gordon Brewer asked Mr Wilson, who has been critical of the SNP's campaign for independence, if he would consider voting "No".

Mr Wilson, who led the SNP from 1979 until 1990, replied: "I wasn't entirely in agreement with many aspects of the campaign, because I didn't think it was strong enough in many ways. Having said it has come into line more with my own views in the last few weeks and I hope that will take us through.

"I look at this in the long term. Maybe it's something to do with age, but we're not looking at Scotland's future in terms of one, two, three years. It's five, ten fifteen, twenty years.

"As I put it, the good ship Scotland will slowly leave the UK dock, and there will be people disappointed with the slowness of change that takes place."

He said he backed independence because the rate of emigration from Scotland in the 20th century "shows that the Union is not delivering for Scotland."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    13:28: Road deaths fall

    The number of people killed and injured on Scotland's roads fell by 10% last year, according to official statistics.

    With 11,498 road casualties reported to police in 2013, this was the lowest level since records began.

    Scotland roads

    The figures released by Transport Scotland showed an increase in recorded fatalities for car drivers, cyclists and motorcyclists.

    However the number of fatalities across all modes of transport fell by 3% to 172.

     
  2.  
    Text 80295 13:15: Scotland's Powers - Get Inolved

    Gordon from Dundee: Acting as an agent for the 3 UK parties, Gordon Brown promised Home Rule, as near to federalism as could be, where one party comprises 85% of the population. Anything less is a betrayal.

    Brian McPherson, Wemyss Bay: Why do all the No voters want extra power for Scotland when they voted to say Scotland couldn't survive without Westminster? If they didn't believe in Scotland on September 18th why do they believe now that we are capable of running our own affairs without Westminster? You voted No so you have to live with what Westminster decided and remember you No voters chose it.

     
  3.  
    Text 80295 13:02: Scotland's Powers - Your Views

    Graeme in Argyll: The SNP are the majority party in the Scottish Parliament so should have the most say in the smith commission. They also form the Scottish government voted in democratically and therefore represent the people of Scotland.

    John, Aberdeen: I eventually voted after being a Yes all the way through. My No doesn't mean no, it means yes to Devo Max and Home Rule. It also means yes to all the vows promised by the three leaders.

     
  4.  
    12:50: Mr Pickles peels off a few layers

    A cat has lost almost half his body weight at the Scottish SPCA's Aberdeenshire centre.

    Stray Mr Pickles was 12kgs when he arrived in July last year.

    Before and after shots of Mr Pickles Mr Pickles eschewed the fish suppers for a healthier lifestyle

    Staff at the Drumoak centre put the cat on a strict diet and exercise regime and he has now reached 6.5kgs.

    "Mr Pickles has been at the centre for over a year now and has become something of a local celebrity," said assistant manager Debbie Innes said.

     
  5.  
    12:46: What's next for Scotland?

    Is there a referendum-shaped hole in your life?

    Yes and No campaign placards adorn a lamp post in sight of the Campsie Fells in Glasgow

    Never fear, you can keep up to date with what's next for Scotland on our new webpage.

    We will have all the latest articles, blogs, analysis and features as the story progresses.

     
  6.  
    Text 80295 12:36: Scotland's Powers - Your Views

    Richard, Edinburgh: Scotland should get what it was promised. Gordon Brown pledged a federal Scotland with everything devolved except defence and foreign affairs.

    Pete, Inverness: There is no mandate for devo max, just a No to independence. There was only one question on the ballot and that should be respected. For further devolution, the parties should outline this in their manifestos and let us vote. It seems that to protect their positions the unionist parties panicked and tried to fiddle the effective question in the independence ballot.

     
  7.  
    12:27: Crack canine case

    Sabes este perro? Do you know this dog with a Spanish microchip found in Airdrie?

    The Scottish SPCA said the female, thought to be a two to three-year-old Estrela mountain dog, was discovered in Deedes Street on 17 October.

    Carmen

    The animal is being cared for at the charity's rescue centre in Hamilton, where staff have named her Carmen.

    Centre manager Peter Fleming said: "Unfortunately Carmen's microchip hasn't been registered in this country and we've been unable to find any contact details for her owner."

     
  8.  
    12:19: Arty EMAs The Evening Times

    Tweets: MTV selfie? Giant logos designed by Glasgow School of Art students to be placed around the city for EMAs.

    Read the full story here.

     
  9.  
    12:08: £5bn deficit claim

    A decline in oil revenues could lead to a £5bn deficit if Scotland gets fiscal autonomy, a think tank says.

    Fiscal Affairs Scotland claimed a move to full responsibility for taxation would mean an increased reliance on oil revenues.

    oil platform

    It published figures showing oil revenues in the first half of the financial year were £1bn lower than in the same period last year.

    Scottish ministers said tax revenues without oil were on a par with the UK.

     
  10.  
    12:00: Never Miss A Beat John Beattie BBC Scotland

    What additional powers should be given to the Scottish government?

    Join us on the programme by listening here and texting 80295.

     
  11.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 11:59: Your Pictures

    Mary Mathieson has sent in this picture of her son Adam finding a conker in Pollok estate in Glasgow.

    Adam Mathieson looking at a conker

    Share your pictures with us by email.

     
  12.  
    11:58: Blind attitudes

    A project aimed at helping young blind and partially sighted people into work has received £500,000 funding from the Big Lottery.

    Partially sighted woman

    Kate Storrow, from RNIB Scotland, spoke to Good Morning Scotland about the importance of employers changing their attitudes towards employing people who are blind or partially sighted.

    The RNIB Scotland's Looking to the Future project will help 140 blind and partially sighted young people in Glasgow, Edinburgh and Aberdeenshire.

     
  13.  
    11:50: World's End murder trial

    The World's End murder trial has heard that one of the teenage victims may have walked into the field where her body was found.

    A soil expert examined debris taken from the feet of Helen Scott, found dead in a wheat field in East Lothian in 1977.

    Christine Eadie and Helen Scott

    Professor Lorna Dawson told the High Court there was strong evidence that Helen Scott had likely stood or walked in the field where her body was discovered.

    Angus Sinclair is charged with raping and murdering Helen and her friend Christine Eadie 37 years ago. He denies all the charges. The trial at the high court in Livingston continues.

     
  14.  
    11:40: Export increase

    The volume of Scottish manufactured export sales grew by 2.8% during the second quarter of 2014, statistics show.

    The figures were lifted by strong performances from the chemicals and engineering sectors.

    Cargo port

    However, there was a slight quarterly fall in figures for the food and drink sector.

    On an annual basis, the overall volume of exports from Scotland increased by 0.5%.

     
  15.  
    11:34: Mark Wotte defiant

    BBC Sport's Kenny Macintyre has all the latest on Mark Wotte, following his decision to stand down as the SFA's Performance Director.

    Over a series of tweets, Kenny said: "Spoken to Mark Wotte 'I am very disappointed with the untrue statements that have been made about me, and the things I have done during my time as Performance Director.

    Mark Wotte

    "'Some people in Scotland are reluctant to change. I have things to say but will take my time to think about my response.'"

    Find out more about the story on Sportsound tonight on Radio Scotland at 18:10.

     
  16.  
    11:16: Green buses

    The Scottish government has allocated £3.7m towards the cost of buying another 83 low carbon emission buses.

    Nine bus operators have been awarded funding through round five of the Scottish Green Bus Fund.

    Lothian Buses

    Fund managers have said performance returns from operators confirm the buses are delivering "significant fuel savings and reduced emissions".

    It will bring the total number of low carbon buses in Scotland's fleet to 209.

     
  17.  
    newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk 11:09: Scotland's powers - Your Views

    James Martin, Glasgow: The most basic power Scotland needs is the power for Holyrood to veto legislation and policies from Westminster which is not favourable to the Scottish people; no matter if a reserved power or not. That lack of control got us into all sorts of messes through Thatcher, poll tax, illegal wars, Bedroom tax, fracking etc.

     
  18.  
    11:05: Cannabis farm The Courier

    Tweets: Former high-earning Perth estate agent jailed for role in running cannabis farm.

    Read the full story here.

     
  19.  
    11:00: All eyes on Vern Cotter

    The BBC's Tom English looks ahead to the Autumn internationals, and how the spotlight will be on new Scotland rugby coach Vern Cotter.

    Scotland head coach Vern Cotter
     
  20.  
    10:49: 'Retain the strength of the UK'

    Duncan Hothersall, an activist for the Better Together campaign, has outlined what he wants from the Smith Commission.

    "Scotland has just voted to retain the strength of the United Kingdom and what that means is Scots want a devolution settlement that retains Westminster's power and strength to deliver things like the Barnett formula," he said.

    "What we need to do is stop talking in phrases like devo max and start talking about empowering people to get input into the decisions and to look at the detail."

     
  21.  
    10:41: 'I've Got The Power..." John Beattie BBC Scotland

    Right, here is today's question; What additional powers should be given to the Scottish government?

     
  22.  
    #ScotlandLive 10:35: Choral Hit? Your Views

    Andrew Scharf, after reading our 10:02 entry, tweets: Mull of Kintyre. Of course, you could always choose "As The Saints Come Marching In".

     
  23.  
    10:32: Zaluska attack Daily Record

    Tweets: Celtic's Lukasz Zaluska tells of shock at being attacked by two rival players on night out.

    Read the full story here.

     
  24.  
    10:30: Wotte, Astra & Souness

    Newspaper speculation abounds over the departure of Mark Wotte as the SFA's Performance Director.

    Kieron Dyer, Graeme Souness and Lee Bowyer

    Celtic's Europa League opponents Astra Giurgiu seem to be having some issues ahead of Thursday's match, while Kieron Dyer has revealed Graeme Souness's novel offer to sort out a spat between the England midfielder and Lee Bowyer.

    Read the rest of the stories making the back pages here.

     
  25.  
    10:25: Revenge Porn

    A new law to tackle revenge pornography is to be introduced in Scotland.

    The BBC understands the Scottish government intends to make it a specific criminal offence to publish explicit images of someone without their consent.

    revenge porn

    New legislation has already been drawn up for England and Wales.

    The Scottish Liberal Democrats have written to Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill urging him to follow suit.

     
  26.  
    10:20: Suspected meningitis case

    A student at Glasgow Kelvin College is being treated in hospital for a suspected case of meningitis.

    The student, who attended the Springburn campus, is said to be responding well to treatment.

    meningitis

    NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde said close contacts of the student have received health advice and treated with antibiotics where appropriate.

    The case comes after two students at Strathclyde University in Glasgow were diagnosed with meningitis last week.

     
  27.  
    10:12: Murray serves notice

    Andy Murray is stepping up his efforts to qualify for next month's tennis end of season tour finals in London.

    Fresh from his win in Vienna, the Scot faces Jurgen Melzer in the first round of the Valencia Open later today and admits competition is fierce at the top of men's tennis.

    Andy Murray

    "I've been a bit inconsistent, especially at the beginning of the year," said Murray. "Also, the rest of the guys around the top of the game have improved, with some big results like Marin Cilic winning the US Open and and Kei Nishikori making his first final.

    "I need to get back to winning more and being more consistent if I want to stay at the top of the game."

     
  28.  
    10:02: Sing-a-long St Andrews hits high note

    The St Andrews Voices Festival, the only festival in the country devoted to vocal and choral music, begins tomorrow.

    The festival offers something for everyone with singing workshops and open air performances with music from Bach to Beyonce.

    The Alleycats

    One of the groups involved in the festival are the award-winning acapella group from the University of St Andrews, The Alleycats.

    Artistic director Sonia Stevenson says St Andrews is the perfect location to test the vocal chords.

    "It's a very cultural place," she added. "St Andrews is a small town but it punches way above its weight in terms of culture."

    Given the chance, which song would you choose at the sing-a-long?

    Text 80295, email here or tweet using #ScotlandLive.

     
  29.  
    09:58: A History of Maps

    A new book has been published exploring Edinburgh's history through maps, some of which have never before appeared in print.

    Edinburgh: Mapping the City brings together 71 maps, including the earliest known map of Edinburgh which was drafted about 1530 by exiled Scottish Lutheran theologian Alexander Allane.

    Edinburgh maps
     
  30.  
    09:30: Cargo ship towed to safety

    A cargo ship which was drifting off Fair Isle overnight is being towed to safety at Lerwick Harbour.

    The Dutch registered freighter Myrte which has nine crew suffered engine failure following a small fire on board.

    A tug from the port of Sullom Voe attached a line to the vessel this morning.

    The Myrte was travelling from Invergordon to Lerwick with a cargo of pipes for the oil industry when she ran into trouble 12 miles south east of Fair Isle.

     
  31.  
    09:22: Devo max

    Speaking on Morning Call about the Smith Commission, Lesley Riddoch said she wanted devo max from the process.

    Ms Riddoch added: "Devolution is not like a bit more milk, or a bit more cream. You don't just get a bit more, a bit less, and it is much the same. There is quite a step change of what gets handed back to Scotland.

    "The proposals currently on the table, particularly from the Tories and Lib Dems to devolve the income tax without oil revenues, that could be a recipe for disaster for Scotland."

     
  32.  
    09:15: Oil revenue John Beattie BBC Scotland

    Scottish oil revenue is down to £1.1bn for the first six months of the year.

     
  33.  
    09:13: Hen Harrier protection

    The RSPB has launched a cross-border five-year programme to protect the future of an endangered bird of prey, the hen harrier.

    Most of the UK breeding population of the birds are found in Orkney, the Hebrides and parts of the western mainland.

    Hen harrier

    Between 2004 and 2010, Scotland's hen harrier population declined by 20%.

    The birds were previously a common sight in the UK's uplands, but persecution by game preservers and skin and egg collectors meant that by 1900 they were almost extinct in the UK.

     
  34.  
    09:03: Obituary - Glenn Gibbons The Scotsman

    In a professional career spanning five decades, Glenn Gibbons forged a reputation as one of Scotland's most independently minded and insightful sports journalists.

    Primarily a football correspondent, he utilised his pugnacious and often acerbic style of writing to telling effect throughout the dramatically different eras of the sport in this country of which he was a colourful chronicler and sharp observer.

    Read the full obituary.

     
  35.  
    Text 80295 09:00: Political powers - Get Involved

    Jon, East Kilbride: The best thing for Scotland would be get rid of the Scottish Parliament and all the defeated SNP never-ever-has-been's and never-ever-will-be's.

    Martin, Bishopton: It has to be maximum devolution. (Devo Max) with 45% voting Yes and at least 10% voting No on the basis of the vow. Federalism, home rule, devo max were terms used by Brown, Alexander, Galloway to persuade people to vote No. Anything less would be an epic let down.

    George in Elgin: Smith Commission - Let's call a halt to any more wind farms trashing our finest landscapes!

     
  36.  
    08:55: Assisted suicide

    Proposals to legalise assisted suicide are "unnecessary, unethical and uncontrollable", according to campaigners opposed to the move.

    Care Not Killing (CNK) has launched an online petition calling on MSPs to reject a bill that would allow people to obtain help in ending their life.

    Nurse and patient holding hands

    The Assisted Suicide Bill is backed by Green MSP Patrick Harvie on behalf of former independent MSP Margo MacDonald.

    Ms MacDonald died in April following a long battle with Parkinson's disease.

     
  37.  
    08:45: Today's papers

    The Scottish Sun and The Daily Record devote their front pages to Celtic keeper Lukasz Zaluska's black eye.

    Meanwhile, the Scottish Daily Mail leads with a story on the poor meals being provided on a tiny budget to Scottish hospital patients.

    Front pages 22 October

    Fancy a full-blown account of what the papers are saying? Read our round-up here.

     
  38.  
    08:44: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    In Dundee, the A972 Kingsway East is clear of that accident at Old Craigie Road.

    In Glasgow, it is very slow at Junction 2A - the Cambuslang Road junction of the Glasgow-bound M74 extension.

    For drivers in Dumbarton, delays of 20 minutes through the roadworks on A82 Stirling Road. At the Whitburn junction of the M8, it's looking stop/start eastbound.

    Ferries are looking much better than yesterday, but Stena Line has cancelled its 11:30 sailing from Cairnryan to Belfast.

     
  39.  
    08:40: Devolution talks Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    What do YOU want for Scotland? #SmithCommission Talking to @LesleyRiddoch on @BBCRadioScot #morningcall 0850

     
  40.  
    08:30: Ebola warning

    A global health expert is warning that the Ebola virus is "very likely" to come to Scotland.

    Dr Devi Sridhar said isolated cases are possible, with Aberdeen one of the places most at risk because of its prominence in the oil and gas industry.

    ebola

    Aberdeen councillor Barney Crockett told Good Morning Scotland: "I think we have to be appropriately concerned, but I don't think we have to make it a pressing worry to us.

    "The health service has made preparations. Our industries are used to having a worldwide approach into looking at a very careful analysis of risk. The two together, people in Scotland should take great heart from that."

     
  41.  
    08:25: Coming up... Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    As the Smith Commission meets to consider more powers for the Scottish Parliament, we're asking what do you want for Scotland?

    Also, with respect to the challenges and dilemmas of looking after someone with dementia: what comes first, care or dignity?

    Louise White

    The lines are open now. 0500 92 95 00 or text 80295.

    You can listen live from 08:50 here.

     
  42.  
    08:17: High Street sales blow

    Scotland's high streets have suffered their poorest sales figures for September since records began.

    Official statistics show total sales dropped by 2.9% compared with September 2013.

    Sale sign on the High Street

    Food sales were down 2.4%, while non-food sales decreased by 3.3% on the previous year.

    Analysts blamed uncertainty over the independence referendum and unseasonably warm weather for people staying away from the shops.

    David Martin, of the Scottish Retail Consortium, said: "September was a challenging month for retailers with a combination of factors contributing to the weakest sales performance since January 1999, excluding Easter distortions."

     
  43.  
    08:10: 'Hail of bullets' VC hero honoured

    A soldier who braved a hail of bullets to rescue wounded comrades during a World War One battle in France is being honoured in his home city of Glasgow.

    Pte Henry May received the Victoria Cross (VC) - the highest award for gallantry - for actions at La Boutillerie on 22 October 1914.

    Private May

    A paving stone in his memory will be unveiled outside the People's Palace.

    Stones are being laid in the home town of every UK soldier awarded the VC as part of World War One centenary events.

    The paving stone in memory of Bridgeton soldier Pte May will be unveiled on Wednesday by the city's Depute Lord Provost Gerry Leonard.

     
  44.  
    08:06: Coming up... Gary Robertson BBC Radio Scotland

    Global health expert says Scottish cases of Ebola "very likely" with Aberdeen one of the places most at risk. #bbcgms 0815

    BBC Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme

    You can listen live to BBC Radio's Good Morning Scotland programme here.

     
  45.  
    08:03: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Glasgow M8: One lane blocked RTC Westbound at J13 M80 (Provan). Lane three (Of three) blocked just before the entry slip. Police en route.

    In Dundee, the A972 Kingsway East partially blocked; accident at Old Craigie Road/Pitkerro Road/Pitkerro Drive/Kingsway East. Police are in attendance.

     
  46.  
    08:02: Bolster political powers

    The Smith Commission, set up to consider more powers for the Scottish Parliament, is to hold its first full meeting later.

    Chairman Lord Smith of Kelvin will meet representatives of Scotland's main political parties at the Green Investment Bank in Edinburgh.

    Scottish Parliament chamber at Holyrood

    The SNP, Labour, the Conservatives, the Lib Dems and the Scottish Green Party have all made devolution proposals.

    The five parties represented in the Scottish Parliament each have two representatives on the commission, which is expected to reach an agreement by 30 November.

    Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats, who campaigned against independence, have all promised further powers for Scotland in areas including taxation, the economy and employment.

     
  47.  
    08:00: Welcome Thomas McGuigan BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and welcome to Wednesday's edition of Scotland Live, as we bring you a comprehensive round-up of news, sport, travel and weather from now until 18:00.

     

Features

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • FutureThe future is now

    Get the latest updates and biggest ideas from BBC Future’s World-Changing Ideas Summit

Programmes

  • St John's, CanadaThe Travel Show Watch

    It’s a ships’ symphony – listen to these freighters in Canada play music with their horns

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.