Scottish independence: Second TV clash for Salmond and Darling

Alex Salmond and Alistair Darling Mr Salmond and Mr Darling will answer questions on key issues from audience members

Scotland's First Minister Alex Salmond and Better Together leader Alistair Darling will go head-to-head later in a live TV debate on independence.

They are expected to clash on issues such as currency, the NHS and North Sea oil and gas estimates.

It is the second time the two leaders have met face-to-face for a television referendum debate.

It will be screened on BBC One Scotland, and across the rest of the UK on BBC Two, from 20:30 BST.

Scotland will go to the polls in a referendum on 18 September, answering the "Yes/No" question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

The format

The BBC's Lorna Gordon takes a look at the venue for tonight's debate

The broadcast will be split up into four sections....

SECTION ONE: Opening statements - Alex Salmond will go first, Alistair Darling second. (Mr Salmond won the coin toss and elected to go first).

SECTION TWO: The issues- The two men will debate four topics titled;

  1. Economy
  2. Scotland at Home
  3. Scotland in the World
  4. What Happens after the Vote

(Each will be introduced with a question from the audience.)

SECTION THREE: Cross-examination - Alistair Darling will go first, Alex Salmond second. (Mr Darling won the coin toss and elected to go first).

SECTION FOUR: Closing statements - Alex Salmond will go first, Alistair Darling second. (Mr Darling opted to go second).


The first leaders' debate aired on STV on 5 August, with both sides claiming victory.

Monday's 90-minute event will be staged at Kelvingrove Art Gallery and Museum in Glasgow in front of an audience of 200 people selected by polling and research consultancy ComRes.

The debate is being presented by Glenn Campbell and will begin with opening statements from both leaders.

At the venue - Laura Pettigrew, BBC News online reporter
Kelvingrove closed

In the stuffed animal hall at Kelvingrove Museum and Art Gallery, where a Spitfire hangs overhead, there's an eerie calm.

Gone are the laughing toddlers or tourists with their cameras normally found here on a Monday afternoon. Instead a lone cleaner with a bin bag wanders through.

The museum is closed to the public for one day only. It may be unusually quiet in this part but the main entrance hall is a hub of activity. It has been transformed for tonight's referendum debate.

Kelvingrove debating chamber

A huge platform has been erected and tiered seating installed. Big pink screens form the backdrop for the televised face-to-face, with three illuminated lecterns for Mr Salmond, Mr Darling and presenter Glenn Campbell.

Production and technical stuff are putting the final touches to the set. "We need a mat over here" says the floor manager. "We'll be bringing the audience in this way."

Outside the world's media is gathered. Satellite trucks line the road and journalists prepare viewers for a "head-to-head", "clash" and "showdown".

At the door, a few eager museum-goers are turned away. They're not impressed. "Seems like a lot of fuss to me", says one. "I thought we might get to be on TV," says another.


BBC Scotland said Mr Salmond had won a coin toss and had chosen to go first with his opening statement.

There will then be four issue sections devoted to the economy, Scotland at home, and in the world, and what happens after the vote. Each of these will begin with a question from an audience member.

The two men will then cross examine each other and the debate will be rounded off with closing statements.

Watch and listen
Kelvingrove autocue

TELEVISION:Watch and read about the build-up, ahead of it all starting at 20:30 and running until 22:00. For Scotland viewers, you can watch the broadcast on BBC One Scotland. For viewers in England, Wales and Northern Ireland you can watch on BBC Two. The debate will also be shown on the BBC News Channel and BBC World News. If you miss it live, you can tune in to BBC One between midnight and 01:30 to watch again. And of course the programme will be made available on the BBC iPlayer.

For post-debate analysis, BBC Two Scotland has an extended Scotland 2014 programme, hosted by Sarah Smith, which will start at 22:00 and run to 22:40.

RADIO: The build up on BBC Radio Scotland MW and digital begins at 20:00. You can then listen to the debate live between 20:30 to 22:00. After that there will be a special phone-in programme to take your views, between 22:05 to 23:00. That will be followed by Referendum Tonight, hosted by Graham Stewart. Radio Nan Gaidheal will also broadcast the debate.

ONLINE: There will be live streams of the debate on the BBC News website and across non-BBC media outlets in Scotland and elsewhere in the UK.


Both sides in the referendum campaign insisted their man came out on top when the two leaders met for their first debate earlier this month.

Key moments of the debate included Mr Darling being asked 21 times if he agreed with David Cameron that it was possible for Scotland to be a "successful independent country".

Mr Darling's repeated questioning of Alex Salmond's currency plans for an independent Scotland elicited the biggest response on social media, with more than 2,000 tweets during that segment of the debate.

How did it all begin?
Alex Salmond and Alistair Darling

Alex Salmond and Alistair Darling have each been in the party political arena for more than 30 years. Mr Darling reached high office when he served as Chancellor of the Exchequer in Gordon Brown's Labour government. That is a quite some distance from where he started, as a passionate left-wing student activist.

Mr Salmond, born in 1954 in Linlithgow, graduated from St Andrews University and became an economist, working for the Scottish Office and the Royal Bank of Scotland. But a career in politics soon called and he is now leader of the SNP (a post he has held twice), and is Scotland's longest serving first minister.


More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1415.

    1412 canalmaniac
    "If Scotland is entitled to decide its own future so is Shetland."

    Of course they are. But the only poll I've seen on the matter has overwhelming support for Shetland & Orkney remaining part of Scotland. 8% support for Northern Isles independence.

    It's a cynical attempt at divide & rule.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1414.

    1413. Lucasti
    So not only has the BBC removed the links to the HYS comments on this article, effectively rendering them censored.

    Nah. Censorship means that you are physically prevented from expressing your opinion. The fact that you posted the above means you are not being censored.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1413.

    So not only has the BBC removed the links to the HYS comments on this article, effectively rendering them censored.

    The latest is an article "Scotland urged to 'stay in family" by the Welsh Secretary of State, who is of course is not actually Welsh, and of course represents the UK Tory government in Westminster, as opposed to representing the Welsh people or their government.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1412.


    . If your lot won the vote how I would love the Shetlanders to cut >Salmond and his ilk down to size by denying Scotland any rights to >Shetland oil. The irony of it would be wonderful.

    If Scotland is entitled to decide its own future so is Shetland.
    What Salmond fails to point out is that under international law the most of the oil that's not England's is Shetlands.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1411.

    Looks like we few who have this page open are destined to be starved of company until our resolve is destroyed


Comments 5 of 1415


More Scotland politics stories


Scotland Live

    08:00: Pakistan massacre tribute

    Glasgow City Council will fly the flag of Pakistan at half-mast from the City Chambers today in a show of support following the Peshawar school massacre.

    Jahangir Hanif and school scene

    The attack by the Pakistani Taliban at the Army Public School on Tuesday killed 132 school children and nine staff and injured 125 others.

    Two grand-nephews of Glasgow Southside Central SNP councillor Jahangir Hanif were among the dead.

    The attack was to avenge Pakistan army-led operations against the Taliban.

    07:56: 'Work together'

    Experts are warning that tumbling oil prices have left the North Sea oil industry "close to collapse".

    James Bream, of Aberdeen and Grampian Chamber of Commerce, says the oil industry and government need to work together.

    oil rig

    He told BBC Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme: "We need to see continued leadership on cost. We also need to see some significant moves on taxation in the North Sea."

    07:46: Wrap up warm BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    There is a Met Office yellow "be aware" warning for snow showers and ice affecting the Highlands and Grampian as well as highland Perthshire. Expect some difficult driving conditions on the high road routes.

    It will be a cold, windy day with plenty of blustery showers, most frequent across northern and western Scotland.

    The showers will fall as snow over high ground and to lower levels in some areas. They also bring a risk of thunder, especially across the far north.

    Fewer showers and more sunshine across the Borders, Angus and eastern Aberdeenshire and there is widespread ice risk north of the Central Belt.

    It will feel bitterly cold in the strong westerly wind, with gales along western and northern coasts touching severe gale force at times.

    07:40: North Sea 'crisis'

    Labour's energy spokesman Lewis Macdonald has said he believes there is a crisis in the oil and gas industry.

    Mr Macdonald told BBC Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme: "We are facing a critical situation. There are perhaps 1,000 jobs already gone, there are thousands more jobs on the line.

    "Yes, this is a crisis for the industry. It's not a crisis that can be controlled directly by government on its own. Clearly some of this is a consequence of global oil prices and global market shifts.

    "The responsibility of government is to respond urgently, address the issues that are raised and give some sense of confidence to people who are working in the oil and gas industry."

    07:35: Rangers name Llambias as chief executive BBC Sport Scotland

    Rangers have confirmed to the Stock Exchange the appointment of existing board member Derek Llambias as their new chief executive.

    Derek Llambias arrives at Ibrox for talks
    07:31: On the ferries BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Quite a bit of disruption on the ferries today. Best advice is to check ahead before you travel.

    • On Cal Mac's Barra and South Uist service, the 07:40 Barra sailing and the 14:30 out of Oban to the islands are cancelled
    • No sailings to Colonsay
    • Skye, that's Armadale to Mallaig off as well
    • No sailings to the Small Isles from Mallaig
    • The morning sailings to Islay are off
    • Today's Arran sailings are under review and quite a few are on amber alert
    • Orkney ferries has cancelled today's North Ronaldsay sailing, its rescheduled for tomorrow leaving Kirkwall at 09;00
    • On Northlink there is some disruption between Aberdeen and Lerwick, the 17:00 sailing from Aberdeen will sail directly to Kirkwall, but may face delays
    • The 19:00 sailing from Aberdeen to Lerwick is under review and the 17:30 from Lerwick is cancelled
    • And there is possible disruption on Argyll ferries between Gourock and Dunoon
    07:27: Oil industry crunch

    Experts are suggesting that the oil industry will cope better with the current downturn than expected.

    Total's north sea oil rig

    It comes as some oil and gas companies are cutting staff and investment due to low oil prices and a warning from a senior industry expert that some North Sea projects would not be viable if prices fell below $60 a barrel.

    Prof Gordon Hughes, a former energy adviser at the World Bank, said that the industry is used to dealing with an unpredictable market.

    He said: "The oil price is notoriously volatile, its gone up and down for the past 50 years.

    "We are going through a bad part of the down cycle but most companies have enough money and enough sense to realise that they have to look at the medium or longer term rather than simply where the price is at today."

    07:18: Court on camera

    Victims and witnesses could pre-record video statements rather than giving evidence in court under radical new proposals being considered by the Scottish Court Service (SCS).


    The BBC understands the concept is being actively explored by the judiciary and the SCS.

    The aim is to avoid wasting witnesses' time and speed up trials.

    Legal experts have raised concerns and warned it should not be a substitute for cross-examining witnesses in court.

    07:11: What the papers say

    The Scotsman leads with the Scotland Yard investigation into an alleged paedophile ring involving high profile people and its link to three murders.

    The National says a Westminster civil servant is facing a "referendum 'bias' probe".

    And The Daily Record has the story of a young woman who lost her unborn baby after her partner punched her.


    See the rest of today's front pages here.

    07:05: House prices on the up

    House prices in Scotland will increase by 4% next year, a new report predicts.

    house for sale

    Recent changes to stamp duty legislation are expected to boost the market, according to the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) 2015 housing forecast.

    The report says demand for property continuing to outstrip supply is another reason to expect prices to go up.

    It also predicts a 2.1% increase in rents north of the border.

    07:00: Paul McLaren BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and welcome to Friday's Scotland Live, where we will bring you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather between now and 19:00.



Elsewhere on the BBC


  • An ECG (electrocardiogram)Click Watch

    The wearable technology which could allow you to pay for goods with your heartbeat

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.