MPs find themselves in government - and in opposition


For politicians, one of the benefits of devolution is that it allows them to be in both government and opposition at the same time, cheerleading for one administration while lambasting another.

Prime ministers's questions, or PMQs, is the half hour in the parliamentary week when the prime minister is directly accountable to MPs, answering questions about his government's responsibilities.

But this is politics, so he is often asked about the responsibilities of governments and politicians elsewhere.

Today, he was asked about the Welsh government's decision not to follow the decision by ministers in England to enable local authorities to freeze council tax bills.

Here's the question from Tory MP Guto Bebb: "A typical council tax payer in my Aberconwy constituency will now pay £124 more than they did in 2010 because the money made available to the Labour Welsh government has been used to fund their pet project to secure their majority in the assembly. Does the prime minister share my concern that hard-working families in Wales are being used in order to fund the Labour party's pork-barrel policy in Cardiff Bay?"

Not surprisingly, given their shared party affiliation, David Cameron thought Mr Bebb had a point: "This government have made available money for a council tax freeze. That has the consequence that money for that freeze is available in Wales, so people in Wales will know who to blame if their council tax is not frozen. It is the Labour assembly government in Wales: they are to blame; they are the ones who are charging hard-working people more for their council tax."

Mr Bebb's colleague, Alun Cairns, focused on a government further from Westminster at Scotland Office questions before PMQs. Mr Cairns wanted to know if the (Liberal Democrat) Scottish Secretary, Michael Moore shared his "disappointment" that the Scottish government had rejected the idea of new nuclear power stations there.

Mr Moore resisted the bait: "Clearly, there is a significant contribution to our current energy mix from nuclear. You will be aware that planning on these matters is devolved to Scotland. It is a matter, rightly, for the Scottish parliament to determine. For my part, I am delighted that we are seeing an increase in the proportion of renewables in our energy mix as part of a sustainable, affordable energy supply in the UK."

Of course, the government/opposition mix isn't confined to the Westminster coalition partners. Labour Welsh First Minister Carwyn Jones was swift to criticise last week's deal to cut the EU budget. "The prime minister says this is a 'good deal for Britain'," he said. "He will need to explain how it's a good deal for Wales. The Welsh government has always recognised the need for discipline in the overall EU budget but it cannot be right for EU money allocated to the UK to be siphoned away from poorer regions, like west Wales and the Valleys - to richer regions elsewhere."

Mr Jones also criticised cuts in the common agricultural policy budget - although at Westminster, Labour leader Ed Miliband said the cuts in spending on farming didn't go far enough. Overall, Mr Miliband welcomed a cut in the EU budget that Labour MPs had voted for (against the wishes of the prime minister).

Today, five days after the summit ended, Mr Jones has issued another statement. "Overall," he said, "where the agreement failed to provide adequate support at the EU level for our vulnerable communities, we will be looking to the UK Government to cover the shortfall."

Mr Miliband may be genuniely relaxed about post-devolution policy differences between Westminster and Wales but as Labour MPs voted to cut the EU budget, it's difficult to see the Westminster coalition writing a cheque for the Welsh government.

David Cornock Article written by David Cornock David Cornock Parliamentary correspondent, Wales

Has Westminster become a zombie parliament?

MPs of all parties have suggested Westminster has become a "zombie parliament" ahead of the general election in May.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    In England council tax frozen councils are busy closing libraries, is this what Bebb has in mind? Here it's up to the councils, they can increase tax or not, and they can close facilities or not. Cameron really doesn't know **** from dirty pudding! As for Carwyn complaining about the EU deal, he should pay heed to what the EU are saying about regional funds not making much difference in Wales.

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    very true dis. I totally agree.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    "The Welsh government has always recognised the need for discipline in the overall EU budget but it cannot be right for EU money allocated to the UK to be siphoned away from poorer regions, like west Wales and the Valleys - to richer regions elsewhere.""

    Carwyn Jones needs reminding that OBJ1 due to West Wales has been diverted to richer parts of S. Wales to the max extent permissable - OR MORE?

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    #2 The SNP does not have a mandate it has a devolved mandate - only on devolved matters (police/education) not Union. That is why there was no referendum mandate in 2011. Mr Moore was wrong when he claimed in the HOC there was a "political mandate". The BBC should have picked this up ! He has already been challenged to withdraw the statement.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    There’s a SNP majority Government, it has a mandate to rule Scotland and If it refuses more Nuclear plants it’s their democratic right to so and not for glib lib Michael Moore to interfere. Also Guto “the Chameleon" Bebb must realise that post Devolution we are not lead by the nose to follow England donkey like as he would like. Guto Plebb, stick to what you're good at. Not much I'd say.


Comments 5 of 6


Features & Analysis

  • Baby in boxStrange case

    The remarkable appeal of the Finnish baby boxes

  • WW1 gas mask being demonstratedTrench terror

    Did the soldiers of WW1 have an irrational fear of poison gas?

  • Mitt Romney, speaks at the podium as he concedes the presidency during Mitt Romney's campaign election night event at the Boston Convention 7 November 2012Aura of a loser?

    Mitt Romney looked presidential but could never pull it off

  • A woman holds up a feminist sign.PC virus

    Is liberal speech policing out of control?

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ReadingBest books

    BBC Culture takes a look at ten books you should read in February


  • A car being driven by Cruise Automation technologyClick Watch

    The tech which could allow any car with an automatic gearbox to become self-driving

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.