Desmond Tutu urges Nelson Mandela's family to end feud

Denis Goldberg said his friend Nelson Mandela looked better than expected

Two leading South Africans have called for an end to a bitter row among members of Nelson Mandela's family over the reburial of three of his children.

Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe said he hoped the public dispute could be resolved in a "dignified manner".

Archbishop Desmond Tutu pleaded with the family not to "besmirch" Mr Mandela's name with their squabble.

President Jacob Zuma has meanwhile denied reports that Mr Mandela, 94, was in a vegetative state.

Start Quote

It's almost like spitting in Madiba's face”

End Quote Archbishop Desmond Tutu

South Africa's first black president has spent the past four weeks in a Pretoria hospital with a recurrent lung condition.

"Madiba remains in a critical, but stable condition. The doctors deny that the former president is in a vegetative state," said a statement from Mr Zuma, who visited Mr Mandela on Thursday.

The statement came after court papers filed on behalf of Mr Mandela's eldest daughter, Makaziwe, on 26 June said his health was "perilous" and that he was "assisted in breathing by a life-support machine".

A lawyer has told the BBC this document was never read out in court.

Subsequent court papers seen by the BBC also on behalf of Makaziwe Mandela, do not mention that her father was in a "vegetative state".

Nelson Mandela's children

With Evelyn Mase:

  • Thembekile born 1945, died 1969
  • Makaziwe born 1947, died aged nine months
  • Makgatho born 1950, died 2005
  • Makaziwe, born 1954

With Winnie Madikizela-Mandela:

  • Zenani born 1959
  • Zindziswa born 1960

One of Mr Mandela's friends and fellow former prisoners, Denis Goldberg, who visited the anti-apartheid icon on Monday, also said he was responsive but was prevented from speaking because he had tubes in his mouth.

"I'm quite satisfied he was responsive to what I was saying," he said.

The BBC's Dr Smitha Mundasad says doctors would only diagnose a vegetative state if a patient was unaware of their surroundings and could not speak or respond to commands.

Patients may, however, breath without assistance, she says.

Crucially, the diagnosis is often only made after four weeks, while a "permanent vegetative state", which has been mentioned in the court documents, would only be made once the condition was considered irreversible and after at least six months in the UK.

She does, however, note that different countries use different criteria for diagnosis.

'Very sad'

Correspondents say there has been a long-running battle over Mr Mandela's legacy, but that it has intensified as his health has deteriorated.

The feud over the reburial of Mr Mandela's children is linked to the decision about where he will eventually be buried, as it is thought he would like to interred alongside them.

The legal documents were filed by Makaziwe and several other relatives last week in order to persuade a judge to make a speedy decision over whether to exhume the children.

On Thursday, the three bodies were reburied, following a court order, back in the village of Qunu, where Mr Mandela was brought up and where he is said to want to be laid to rest.

Mandla Mandela: "It seems like anyone and everyone can come and say 'I am a Mandela'"

Earlier, forensic tests confirmed the identity of the bodies which had been exhumed by police from the homestead in the village of Mvezo owned by Mr Mandela's grandson, Mandla.

An affidavit filed by Mandela family members alleged that Mandla had relocated the graves in 2011 to ensure that his grandfather would be buried in Mvezo, against his wishes.

At a news conference on Thursday, Mandla accused some of his relatives of washing their dirty linen in public and battling for control of his grandfather's assets.

"In the past few days, I have been the target of attacks from all sorts of individuals wanting a few minutes of fame and media attention at my expense," he said.

His family rivals were motivated by revenge as he had refused to support their legal case to oust three of Mr Mandela's aides from companies the ex-president had set up, Mandla added.

Later, Deputy President Motlanthe criticised the behaviour of Mr Mandela's family on a radio chat show in Johannesburg.

"It's all very sad, but we've got to continue keeping the family and Madiba in our prayers and hope, continue to hope, that Madiba will recover and also that the family will manage its own affairs in a dignified manner," he said.

Archbishop Tutu, who, like Mr Mandela, won the Nobel Peace Prize for his role in the struggle against white minority rule, appealed to the family to overcome their differences.

"Please, please, please may we think not only of ourselves? It's almost like spitting in Madiba's face," he said in a statement.

"Your anguish, now, is the nation's anguish - and the world's. We want to embrace you, to support you, to shine our love for Madiba through you. Please, may we not besmirch his name?"

Mandela family tree

Andrew Harding: Beyond the Mandela rumours


More on This Story

Mandela health crisis

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Africa stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Need for speed

    Audi unveils its fastest production car ever - ahead of its Geneva debut


  • 3D model of Christ the Redeemer statueClick Watch

    Using drones to 3D map the famous Brazilian landmark Christ the Redeemer

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.