In prison with al-Shabab: What drives Somali militants?

Hundreds of newly trained al-Shabab fighters perform military exercises in the Lafofe area 18km south of Mogadishu, Somalia, taken on 17 February 2011

After a year locked up in Uganda with self-confessed Islamist militants, a Kenyan human rights lawyer is able to give clues as to what drove those behind Kenya's deadly mall siege, writes the BBC's Will Ross.

"They have a conviction that what they are doing is right and the rest are wrong," says Al Amin Kimathi about the members of the Somali group al-Shabab who bombed bars in the Ugandan capital, Kampala, where patrons were watching the 2010 World Cup final on TV.

"The conviction comes from what they would say is an act of faith," says Mr Kimathi.

Following the bombings, in which 76 people died, Mr Kimathi accused Kenya and Uganda of illegal rendition - arresting suspects in Kenya and sending them to Uganda without due process.

Start Quote

Al Amin Kimathi

They feel they are hunted”

End Quote Al Amin Kimathi Kenyan lawyer

He was then arrested himself and accused of involvement in the bomb plot - a charge he denies.

Al-Shabab said it carried out the attack because Ugandans at the time made up the bulk of the African Union force in Somalia (Amisom).

Mr Kimathi's case never went to trial and he was released in September 2011.

In prison he had lengthy conversations with the al-Shabab members, including those who planted the bombs.

"They are given quotations from the Koran, the Hadiths [Prophet Muhammad's teachings], but they do not have the benefit of a critical mind to look at it in any other context and they trust the people driving them to this," he says.

"Advantage is taken of this person's feeling of desperation and that is dangerous enough to drive them over the top.

Ugandans who lost relatives light candles as they mark the first anniversary on 11 July 2011 two bars were bombed in the Ugandan capital and killed 76 people The World Cup bombings in Kampala killed 76 people

"They are given the feeling that they are a very important person and that martyrdom is something to aspire to - the anger over their deprivation is lowered to a feeling of comfort, to a point where the only thing they aspire to is a collective action.

"Whether that action leads to their survival or death that doesn't really matter any more."

Remorse

Mr Kimathi says he challenged the young al-Shabab members in prison to say which Koranic authority gave them the right to take innocent lives.

Start Quote

Our young people are being used. They don't have a job and if someone offers them some little money they'll do anything”

End Quote Muslim in Nairobi

After discussions they would often admit they were wrong: "In a lot of instances you would even see a lot of remorse. But they would just come back with the mere argument of revenge.

"They would say: 'Look you have not been out there in Somalia during this whole war - we've been there and we've seen the kind of attacks by the Ugandan forces and African Union forces, the kind of raids they conduct and this [Kampala attack] is nothing compared to what we've seen out there.'"

Mr Kimathi believes that despite being brainwashed, it is still very possible to pull sympathisers back from the brink of committing violence.

"One thing that needs to be done is to identify people who have that kind of mindset, reach out to them - which is rarely done - and show them that they belong, people care about them and that people are not hunting them - because they feel they are hunted."

Outside the Jamia Mosque in the centre of Kenya's capital, Nairobi, where worshippers were being screened with metal detectors before praying, people told me why they thought young men were being enticed to join groups like al-Shabab.

"Our young people are being used," says one man leaving the mosque.

"They don't have a job and if someone offers them some little money they'll do anything."

Kenyan army soldiers stand in dugout position at base in Tabda in Somalia on 20 February 2012. Al-Shabab has lost control of many towns and cities to the AU forces in Somalia

Another man said: "They are too desperate to earn money - some are earning less than $1 (£0.60) a day so they are easily misused.

"This person is willing and ready to do anything that is offered to him."

He said a solution could be found in Islamic schools, or madrassas.

"But the teachers there need formal education so they understand the importance of getting a proper education.

"A lot of money comes to Kenya through free primary education but those madrassas are left out."

Young men 'overlooked'

There are counter-radicalisation programmes in Kenya but some analysts suggest they rely too heavily on a counter-terrorism approach - with the police and army leading the way.

"There are still plenty of existing grievances in Kenya and in the wider region that mean people will be animated by the kind of issues that fuel al-Shabab and will be determined to join either al-Shabab or other networks allied to al-Qaeda," says Cedric Barnes, project director for the Horn of Africa at the International Crisis Group (ICG).

Those social grievances include marginalisation not just in north-east Kenya, where most Somalis live, but also in coastal districts.

While in any big city, particularly Nairobi, there will be people who feel they are not getting a chance.

"Young men in particular, I think, suffer from feeling overlooked and not getting opportunities that they see others getting," says Mr Barnes.

Residents of Eastleigh, a neighbourhood of Nairobi known for its densely Somali origin population, walking in Eastleigh on 18 January 2010 Residents of the Somali-dominated Eastleigh suburb of Nairobi fear a backlash

Al-Shabab has been severely weakened inside Somalia where it has lost territory to the foreign troops fighting under the banner of Amisom over the past two years.

September's Westgate shopping centre attack seemed to be sending out the message - "we are not a finished force" - but al-Shabab also hopes to provoke a reaction which will boost the group.

"The Kenyan people and government now control the next move," Somalia expert Ken Menkhaus wrote on the American political blog, ThinkProgress.

"If they respond to this terrible tragedy with restraint and respect for due process and rule of law, they will do more to undermine al-Shabab than all of the counter-terrorism operations conducted inside Somalia.

Start Quote

Right now there is so much sympathy for the authorities, even from those people who have stood at the borderlines of extremism”

End Quote Al Amin Kimathi Kenyan lawyer

"If the deadly attack succeeds in prompting vigilante violence by Kenyan citizens or heavy-handed government reactions against Somali residents, al-Shabab stands a chance of recasting itself as the vanguard militia protecting Somalis against external enemies.

"It desperately needs to reframe the conflict in Somalia as Somalis versus the foreigners, not as Somalis who seek peace and a return to normalcy versus a toxic jihadi movement," writes Mr Menkhaus.

Mr Kimathi also knows there is a danger of playing into al-Shabab's hands, because he has seen the way young people have reacted upon release after years in detention.

"They come out angry and indeed you would even hear in the first minutes of release somebody coming out and saying: 'I am going to [get] revenge - I cannot stand these sort of injustices any more.'

"Right now there is so much sympathy for the authorities, even from those people who have stood at the borderlines of extremism," Mr Kimathi says.

"If they can see the investigation and operations are being conducted within the bounds of some civil order then there is going to be quite a lot of collaboration and co-operation."

But what if there is a heavy-handed response?

"Then they risk feeding into the vicious cycle of recruitment and offering fodder for more terrorist propaganda," Mr Kimathi warns.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Africa stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

  • French luxury Tea House, Mariage Freres display of tea pots Tea for tu

    France falls back in love with tea - but don't expect a British cuppa


  • Woman in swimming pool Green stuff

    The element that makes a familiar smell when mixed with urine


  • People take part in an egg-cracking contest in the village of Mokrin, 120km (75 miles) north of Belgrade, Serbia on 20 April 2014In pictures

    Images from around the world as Christians mark Easter Sunday


  • Female model's bottom in leopard skin trousers as she walks up the catwalkBum deal

    Why budget buttock ops can be bad for your health


Elsewhere on the BBC

  • ITChild's play

    It's never been easier for small businesses to get their message out to the world

Programmes

  • An aerial shot shows the Olympic Stadium, which is closed for repair works on its roof, in Rio de Janeiro March 28, 2014.Extra Time Watch

    Will Rio be ready in time to host the Olympics in 2016? The IOC president gives his verdict

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.