South Africa: Has democracy delivered?

ANC supporters in Qunu on 15 December 2013

Although South Africa is in the throes of one of its worst political and economic crises since apartheid ended 20 years ago, the African National Congress (ANC) looks set to return to power after the 7 May elections.

line break
Why will the ANC win again?
ANC supporters in Mangaung, South Africa (December 2012)

The ANC is showing signs of decay, but there is no-one to rival its dominance at a national level. The small and divided opposition has failed to capture the popular imagination, except in a few areas. South Africa's first black leader, the late Nelson Mandela, once predicted that the ANC would remain in power until around 2025 - and this is looking quite likely.

Liberation movements remained in power for decades in many African countries, as well as India, where Congress governed for 30 years after independence.

South Africa profile

line break
Could South Africa turn out like Zimbabwe?
Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe delivers his speech during celebrations to mark his 90th birthday in Marondera, 23 February 2014

Some have that fear, but the chances are that South Africa will be a messy but vibrant democracy, as the ANC has a long history of its members kicking out its leaders. South Africa also has a robust media and civil society, a feisty, if small, opposition, a powerful trade union movement and a strong business sector.

BBC Africa Debate

Tune in to the BBC World Service at 1900 GMT on Friday to listen to the BBC Africa Debate: South Africa Decides - Has Democracy Delivered?

You can also take part on Twitter - using #bbcafricadebate - Facebook or Google+

They are all trying to make sure the independence of democratic institutions is maintained. So far, the judiciary has played an admirable role in keeping a check on state power, along with the offices of the public protector and auditor-general.

However, other institutions, such as law enforcement agencies, have been accused of brutality, factionalism and corruption, raising fears that the distinction between party, state and business has become blurred.

The criminal underworld has also penetrated the state. One police chief - anti-apartheid struggle veteran Jackie Selebi - has been convicted of taking bribes from a drug dealer; another, Bheki Cele, was dismissed after an investigation found that police buildings had been leased at inflated prices from a private firm, though he was not accused of criminal behaviour.

Selebi case like a crime novel

South Africa's anti-corruption crusader

line break
Why is the opposition so small?
South African opposition leader Helen Zille in Welbedacht, Durban, on 5 April 2013

Led by Helen Zille, the Democratic Alliance (DA) is the ANC's main challenger. It was once a staunch admirer of the British Conservative party and the late Margaret Thatcher, but it now sees itself as similar to the Liberal Democrats.

It has never appealed to South Africa's black voters, who largely see it as a defender of the privileges white people gained during apartheid. As a result, it won only 17% of the vote in the 2009 election, but is expected to increase this to 23% in the 7 May election, according to a recent poll conducted by Ipsos.

Profile: Helen Zille

Do white South Africans have a future?

line break
Is the DA trying to change?

In an attempt to broaden its appeal, it has toned down its opposition to affirmative action - an ANC policy which most black professionals and businessmen welcome to help overcome the effects of the racial discrimination they faced during apartheid. In the last election, many of these so-called "black diamonds" cast their ballots for the Congress of the People (Cope), formed by an ANC breakaway faction opposed to the uneducated Jacob Zuma's ascent to the presidency.

Rise of South Africa's black middle-class

But they feel let down by Cope, which has been hit by leadership battles and legal disputes. The DA is hoping its new young black leaders - especially in Gauteng, South Africa's richest province - will persuade them to vote for the party this time around, but other parties are also confident of gaining their support.

The DA has also tried to show it is a "struggle party" by marching on the headquarters of the ANC to demand jobs for the unemployed but, as the poll shows, it still has a long way to go to win the confidence of the black majority.

Working Lives: Businesswoman

line break
Where do other racial groups stand?
People shop on 13 November 2010 in  Phoenix township in Durban, South Africa

South Africa's racial divide

  • Population of nearly 52 million
  • 79% black, 9% whites, 9% coloured, 2% Indian
  • Biggest gap between rich and poor in the world
  • Income of white South African households six times higher than black ones - up from four times in 1994
  • About half the population lives on just over $2 (£1.5) a day; 10 million on less than $1

Source: Statistics SA; Census 2011; HSRC; World Bank

Like many white people, most Indian and coloured (mixed-race) South Africans tend to be fearful of ANC rule. Even Mr Mandela battled to win their votes, despite his image as a nation-builder. An opinion poll published about three weeks before the election gave the DA 78% of the Indian vote and 72% of the coloured vote.

The DA controls one of South Africa's nine provinces, Western Cape, where people of mixed race are in the majority. It is expected to retain control of the province, and fight ANC plans to introduce a new affirmative action policy that would require top managements posts in the business sector to reflect national, rather than provincial, demographics.

Is South Africa ready for mixed-race couples?

line break
What are voter perceptions of Mr Zuma?
South African President Jacob Zuma (2nd L) sings and dances on the stage at the Ellis Park stadium in Johannesburg as he stands next to Bishop Marcelo Pires (2nd R) attending a Good Friday service with the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God on 18 April 2014

Of the four presidents South Africa has had since it became a democracy in 1994, he has the least moral authority.

Spending on president's private homes

• PW Botha: $16,100

• FW de Klerk: $22,000

• Nelson Mandela: $2.9m on two residences

• Thabo Mbeki: $1.1m

• Jacob Zuma: $23m on rural Nkandla residence

All figures in 2013 financial terms

Source: Public protector report

"No-one believes anything he says," says Johannesburg-based political analyst William Gumede.

Corruption allegations have swirled around him for many years and these were strengthened with Public Protector Thuli Madonsela's finding that $23m (£13.8m) of taxpayers money was spent on upgrading his private rural residence - including building a chicken run, cattle enclosure, amphitheatre and a swimming pool.

Some believe the rot set in during the Mandela presidency, when he showed unflinchingly loyalty to then Health Minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma despite calls for her resignation after the public protector found her department had awarded a contract improperly to the minister's friend.

Profile: Jacob Zuma

How President Zuma's Nkandla home has grown

line break
So will voters punish Mr Zuma?
Voters queue to vote in local elections in South Africa (May 2011)

Some analysts believe the ANC's majority will fall to a historic low of between 55% and 60%, and it could lose overall control of Gauteng, which includes Johannesburg and the capital, Pretoria, and would be a clear sign that the party is in decay.

South Africa votes

  • About 25 million registered voters
  • Only a third of those born after 1994 have registered
  • "Born-frees" make up 2.5% of voters
  • 29 parties contesting national poll
  • ANC defending 66% majority
  • DA main challenger

Source: IEC; IOL news site

But an opinion poll conducted after Ms Madonsela's findings were released gave the party 65% of the national vote - close to the 66% it obtained in 2009.

The ANC won in 2009 despite the fact that Mr Zuma was accused of taking bribes from a businessman and a defence company - an allegation he denied. He escaped being put on trial after prosecuting authorities dropped the charges, citing political interference in the case by an ANC faction opposed to him.

Mr Gumede says the ANC's biggest electoral advantage is that about 16 million South Africans out of a population of nearly 52 million receive welfare grants, such as child income support for single mothers, to cushion the effects of poverty. This block of voters guarantees the ANC 45% to 50%, as they would not put their grants at risk by defecting to the centre-right DA, he says.

line break
What is the ANC record on other issues?
In this picture taken on May 17, 2012 a young boy who lost his parents to AIDS in Alexandra township in the north of Johannesburg enjoys a bowl of piping hot corn meal porridge (17 May 2012)

Seeing unemployment as an "assault on human dignity", Mr Mandela led the ANC's first election campaign in 1994 under the slogan: "Vote for jobs, peace and freedom". But his government and its successors have battled to fulfil the first part of this promise, with the official unemployment rate standing at around 24% at the end of 2013.

ANC successes

  • People with access to water rises from 10% in 1994 to 92%
  • Homes with flush toilets increases from 50% in 2001 to 57%
  • Homes with electricity rises from 58% in 1996 to 85%

Source: ANC; Census 2011;

It is the ANC's biggest Achilles Heel, and could cause an uprising.

As Mr Mandela's successor Thabo Mbeki once warned: "When the poor rise they will rise against us all."

Protests, often violent, by people calling for more basic services such as water, housing and schools occur on an almost daily basis.

The story is more positive regarding health - the Zuma government has ended the Aids denialism of Mr Mbeki, and is giving free life-saving anti-retroviral treatment to patients.

It is also pressing ahead with its plan to create a National Health Service, despite strong resistance from the private health industry, fuelling perceptions that its main focus is on creating a welfare state.

Lebo Diseko asks if South Africa has kept its promises

line break
Is Julius Malema a big player?
South African political party Economic Freedom Fighters leader Julius Malema (C) greets supporters in Ngcingwane in the Eastern Cape province of South Africa, on 11 April 11 2014

With his supporters saying he has charisma similar to that of the late Venezuelan leader Hugo Chavez, Mr Malema has styled himself as a revolutionary, wearing a red beret and carrying the title commander-in-chief of the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) party as he campaigns for votes.

South Africa direct logo

He strikes the most fear among white people, with his calls for the partial nationalisation of the mining and farming sectors, and his support for Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe.

But after a poorly organised campaign, he seems to have taken very little support, with the Ipsos poll giving the EFF only 4% of the vote, less than the 5% the DA got among black voters.

Five other black-led parties polled less than 3%, and AgangSA, launched by businesswoman Mamphela Ramphele in January, did not register in the survey.

Profile: Julius Malema

Malema, Marikana and Mugabe

line break
What are the battles ahead?
Members of the National Union of Metal Workers of South Africa (NUMSA) protest as they march through Durban (19 March 2014)

The chances are that the opposition will fragment even further, with the biggest union, the National Union of Metalworkers' of South Africa, planning to launch a left-wing party to contest the 2019 election.

Its general-secretary, Irvin Jim, has said that "non-racialism" is not working in South Africa, with many white people not identifying with the poor black majority. He also accuses the ANC of betraying the ideals of the liberation struggle by failing to promote socialism.

It is a sign of the battles that lie ahead between the ANC, DA and their left-wing opponents.

Do unions have a future in South Africa?

Post-Mandela South Africa is in good shape

Are you in South Africa? Has democracy delivered? Get in touch by emailing haveyoursay@bbc.co.uk with the subject title 'South Africa democracy'.

Or get in touch using the form below.

I moved back to South Africa about 5 years ago after my stint in the UK of 8 years. I frequented the country while abroad so was aware or so I thought ,of the changes within the country. On reflection and especially since the elections are around the corner , there are vast changes for the better for the people and many opportunities. People who will moan will do so in any country irrespective of the economic climate. There is a proportion of 'white 'people who have become so marginalized and it is not because of lack of opportunitues , but because they maintain a superior race stance , I see this everyday , and hear their comments. There will continue an upward increase in personal wealth amongst a few , the gap will get bigger but the tide is coming in and everyone will rise ..thats why the ANC will maintain its dominance , I am not a member and being an objective viewer , I am very aware of world politics, economics and social changes ..South Africa is the African!

Mohamed Shah, Johannesburg, South Africa

There is still huge financial segregation in SA. In restaurants, white customers are served by black waiters. The answer must lie in education which your article has not mentioned at all. The state sector education is reported to be very poor so there is no chance for many black children to aspire to the middle class through education.

Jacko, Doncaster, Uk

Look at the Indian template for democracy. Initially, the Congress Party looked invincible - now they have already reconciled to defeat in 2014 elections. So the party which wins independence gathers momentum till skeletons start tumbling out of the cupboard. Then the trends reverse. It need the opposition to have a compelling case backed by a strong leadership. Even in America, GOP was considered unbeatable. But now Obama is a 2 term president and the Dems look like stealing a march in 2016.

DHR M, Mumbai, India

We have just returned from a two week holiday which has given us a glimpse of today's South Africa. Although this is only a very short time to make any informed comment , it at least was enough to realise that the legacy of Apartheid lingers on .

Paul Velly, UK

Your correspondent has done a very bad job. He has regurgitated bits of the more prejudiced South African and Western press with little regard for the actual facts. He should give an accurate assessment of why the majority population will still vote for Zuma, He should mention the SA competition commission and the fines it has made on firms that fixed prices and divided up contracts in the old Apartheid style. He could have mentioned the shift to renewable energy sources. He could have mentioned the decreasing death rate from AIDS and improvements in the decreasing of child deaths. He could mention the still reactionary and implicitly racist attitudes of the white population working in schools, universities and in the middle civil service. He could have mentioned the general optimism of the majority of young people of all "races" in working hard for an improving future. There are many things to do in South Africa including the transformation of agriculture, gettin!

John F Sharpey-Schafer, Somerset-West, South Africa

At last, an article that stops making this simply a black & white struggle. When the ANC took power they ousted all the coloured and indian ANC leaders and replaced them with black. East Cape also has a large coloured population and the ANC only has a borderline majority there. Affirmative Action also discriminates against the coloureds. and isn't applied "fairly". It's not 2 candidates of "equal merit" it's give the job to the Black candidate irrespective of qualifications.

Peter Tanczos, London, UK

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Africa stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • HouseboatLife on the water

    Could a floating house be the home of the future? The BBC's Adam Shaw takes a look

Programmes

  • The Audi RS7Click Watch

    Tech news review of the week including a speed record for a self-driving car

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.