China factor to dominate top defence summit

Members of Chinese military honour guard stand in a line at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, 9 April 2012 China's ties with its neighbours will be high on the summit agenda

Related Stories

In the absence of a formal defence alliance like Nato, the annual Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore has become the pre-eminent annual security gathering in the Asia-Pacific region.

According to Dr John Chipman, the director-general and chief executive of the International Institute for Strategic Studies, who organise the gathering, "the Shangri-La Dialogue is now commonly referred to as the 'indispensable forum' for Asian defence diplomacy."

This year defence ministers and senior officials from some 27 countries are gathering in Singapore.

The US defence secretary is a regular participant as too are senior officials from China, Australia, Japan, Canada, India, Indonesia and a host of smaller Asian countries.

One of the great benefits of this gathering is that unlike a formal summit there is no communiqué to be worked on.

The plenary sessions are often used by ministers to launch trial balloons or make new policy pronouncements and, John Chipman asserts, "the event as a whole allows the defence establishments to 'take the pulse' of the prevailing mood in the region".

China factor

This may be the most dynamic part of the world in economic terms but it is also one of major security challenges.


China and India's economic rise inevitably makes them strategic competitors, though tensions on land between Delhi and Beijing have subsided. China is the main factor influencing the modernisation of India's nuclear arsenal. India will soon have its own ballistic missile-carrying submarines. India is also expanding its conventional military forces - its air force, in particular, requires a significant modernisation effort.


China is building up its ability to project its military power beyond its shores - better warships, a more capable air force and a first experimental aircraft carrier. It is also seeking to develop weaponry to deny access to the US navy. Regional unease at China's ambitions has assisted Washington's "pivot" back to Asia. Is a future Sino-US confrontation the stuff of fiction that will never happen, or a self-fulfilling prophecy?

North/South Korea

One of the longest-running and most dangerous confrontations in the region. There is mounting concern about the direction the new Pyongyang leadership may take, with indications of plans for a new nuclear test. North Korea's willingness to take direct action against the South when tensions escalate, like the sinking of a small South Korean warship in 2010 (widely attributed to the North), makes this the classic and perennial flash-point.

Scarborough Shoal

A rocky reef encompassing rich fishing grounds with ownership strongly contested between China and the Philippines. The area is a crucial shipping route for Japanese oil supplies from the Middle East. The area saw a lengthy stand-off in April-May 2012 after Chinese patrol vessels prevented a Philippines navy ship from arresting Chinese fishermen. The Philippines government is eager to bolster its defence ties with Washington.


Along with tensions on the Korean Peninsula this is the other long-standing classic dispute; with China viewing Taiwan as a break-away province. China's expanding navy and its burgeoning missile arsenal alarm Taiwan, though any Chinese effort to take Taiwan by force would necessitate an operation on the scale of the allied D-Day landings of World War II and is seen by analysts as highly unlikely. The modernisation of Taiwan's defences, especially its air force, always prompts strains with Beijing and complicates Sino-US dynamics.

Spratly Islands

At the core of the South China Sea disputes, the Spratlys comprise more than 100 reefs and small islands straddling vital sea routes in waters rich in fisheries and believed to contain significant reserves of oil and gas. They are claimed in their entirety by China, Taiwan and Vietnam while Malaysia and the Philippines also have specific claims. These countries maintain small numbers of troops on some of the islands.

Senkaku Islands

A long-running source of tension between Tokyo and Beijing, the Senkaku Islands, as the Japanese call them, have been administered by Japan since 1971 and were controlled by Tokyo between 1895 and the end of World War II. China and Taiwan see what they call the Diaoyu Islands as part of Chinese territory since the 16th Century. Diplomatic ties plummeted in 2010 when Japanese coastguards arrested a Chinese fishing boat captain there after a collision.

To old disputes like the tensions between China and Taiwan or those between North and South Korea can be added a host of new problems, many of them focused on the competition for natural resources in the South China Sea.

Recent weeks, for example, have seen serious tensions between China and the Philippines.

Start Quote

Most Asians are keen on a multipolar Asia, and fear that China likes multipolarity on the global level, but is less keen on it in the region”

End Quote Dr John Chipman International Institute for Strategic Studies

Living with a rising and sometimes more assertive China is a perennial theme at these gatherings. But, as Dr Chipman said, this year events in China itself give the discussion an added dimension.

"Given the leadership transition in China, it is hard to predict how other ministers will address the China question during this summit. There is bound to be a great deal of discussion about the South China Sea," he said.

The bubbling Korean crisis too is bound to figure. The North has stepped up its rhetorical assaults on the South and has threatened to conduct a new, third, nuclear test.

Dr Chipman notes that the situation on the Korean Peninsula is so delicate now that most of the debate on this at the dialogue will be in private rather than in public.

Of course strong economies combined with the perception of growing threats mean that more money is being spent on weaponry and defence equipment.

What appears to be a new missile is displayed during a military parade at the Kim Il Sung Square in Pyongyang, North Korea, 9 April 2012 Tension on the Korean Peninsula remains high, with no sign of talks on the horizon

China itself has deployed its first trial aircraft carrier, it has developed a stealth fighter, it is expanding both its navy and its civilian maritime patrol force and it has begun to deploy a ballistic missile capable, potentially, of striking at US aircraft carriers far out at sea.

Other countries are responding by beefing up their own air and maritime forces - submarines and maritime patrol aircraft are a popular option.

India is modernising its air force and developing a capability to launch ballistic missiles from submarines.

There are also hopes in some quarters that the US will begin to deploy new naval assets of its own to bases in the region, like the ultra-modern Littoral Combat Ships.

'Multipolar Asia'

Inevitably, says Dr Chipman, this is all going to colour much of the discussion in Singapore.

"With defence expenditure in Asia rising above that in Europe this year there is bound to be a debate about whether this is all about modernisation or significantly about competition."

"Most Asians are keen on a multipolar Asia, and fear that China likes multipolarity on the global level but is less keen on it in the region," he said.

A Philippine soldier stands guard next to fishing boats at a pier in Masinloc town, Zambales province, 230km from Scarborough Shoal, 18 May 2012 Territorial disputes in the South China Sea have left some diplomatic ties fraught in recent months

"Equally, many are worried that if the US gets the tone and content of its policy wrong then there could be unnecessary US-China tensions."

"The net effect is to impose on Asian middle and rising powers more responsibility for themselves shaping the debate."

"Look to Indonesia, Australia and others to try to define the terms of the security debate more forcefully at this year's Shangri-La Dialogue," he said.

Two key speeches are likely to set the tone at this year's gathering.

The meeting will be opened by Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono. How will he frame the policy challenges in the region and situate Indonesia in the multipolar Asia that is emerging?

Equally, the US Defence Secretary Leon Panetta's speech will be closely watched. As the draw-down in Afghanistan begins the Obama administration has announced a US "pivot" back towards Asia.

What exactly does this mean in defence terms?

Mr Panetta's speech is entitled "US Defence Policy in an Era of Austerity". Does the US have the resources to maintain its interests in the Middle East and elsewhere whilst reaffirming its role as an Asian power?

Dr Chipman will be listening as closely as the rest.

How, he asks, will Mr Panetta balance reassurance to allies, outreach to new, potential partners and the need for a pragmatic, if hard-headed, defence relationship with China? Watch this space.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Asia stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Best in show

    BBC Autos takes a look at 10 of the most eye-catching new cars at the 2015 Geneva motor show


  • A robotClick Watch

    The latest in robotics including software that can design electronics to solve problems

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.