Bowe Bergdahl release: US parties clash on Afghan deal


Video has emerged purporting to show the Taliban prisoners arriving in Qatar

Related Stories

The main US political parties have clashed over the deal to swap five Guantanamo Bay detainees for a Taliban-held soldier, with Republicans warning it could put American lives at risk.

Senator John McCain said the detainees, who were transferred to Qatar, were some of the "highest high-risk people".

Afghanistan also condemned the deal, saying handing prisoners to a third country violated international law.

Sgt Bowe Bergdahl, 28, was handed to US forces in Afghanistan on Saturday.

In an emotional address on Sunday, his father, Robert Bergdahl, said he was proud how far his son was willing to go to help the Afghan people, but warned that his recovery would take a long time.

He said he and his wife had not yet spoken to the soldier, who is in a good condition and undergoing medical care at a US military hospital in Germany.

Hailey, Idaho, is celebrating Bowe Bergdahl's release, 1 June The home town of Hailey, Idaho, is celebrating Bowe Bergdahl's release

Several Republicans have spoken out against the deal, warning that it set a worrying precedent and amounted to negotiating with terrorists.

Mr McCain said the Taliban released were "possibly responsible for the deaths of thousands" and may have "the ability to re-enter the fight", in comments to CBS TV.

Republican chairman of the House intelligence committee, Mike Rogers, told CNN that Washington had "now set a price" for al-Qaeda ransom threats.

Chuck Hagel: "No shots were fired - it went as well as it could have"

Questions were raised over the legality of the deal, after the Obama administration did not give Congress sufficient notice about the transfer of the Taliban detainees.

But US Defence Secretary Chuck Hagel, who is currently in Afghanistan, dismissed the criticism saying the military had to act quickly "to essentially save his life".

"We didn't negotiate with terrorists. Sergeant Bergdahl was a prisoner of war. That's a normal process in getting your prisoners back," he told NBC TV.

US National Security Adviser Susan Rice said Sgt Bergdahl's failing health had created an "acute urgency", making it "necessary and appropriate" not to adhere to the 30-day notification requirement.

Bowe Bergdahl A video grab image from 2010 showed Sgt Bergdahl in captivity

The Afghan government, which was not informed until after the exchange had taken place, condemned it as a "breach of international law" and urged the US and Qatar to "let the men go free".

The five detainees are thought to be the most senior Afghans held at the US detention facility in Cuba, having been captured during America's military campaign in 2001.

In a rare public statement on Sunday, Afghan Taliban leader Mullah Mohammad Omar described the exchange as a "big victory".

But President Barack Obama said that he had received security guarantees from Qatar - which mediated the deal - "that it will put in place measures to protect our national security".

They have been banned from leaving Qatar for at least a year.


Analysis: Bilal Sarwary, BBC News, Kabul

Taliban in Qatar The five detainees have already arrived in Qatar

The Afghan response to this prisoner exchange is both complicated and contradictory.

Nobody knows the exact conditions under which these prisoners were released but the Afghan government has reacted with anger. Part of their fury is likely to be that they were not even informed about the exchange, let alone being excluded from the talks process.

In a letter of complaint to the US they say that as the men are Afghan citizens, they should not have been handed over to a third country. The foreign ministry says Afghanistan is obliged to look after its own citizens under international law.

The High Peace Council - which is tasked with negotiating a peace settlement with the militants - is quietly hopeful that the release of these men could move things forward.

But security and intelligence sources have a different perspective. They point out that these men are highly trained, well connected and dangerous militant operatives.


Sgt Bergdahl, of Hailey, Idaho, was the only US soldier being held by the Taliban in Afghanistan. He was serving with an infantry regiment in Paktika province, near the Pakistani border, when he went missing on 30 June 2009.

"Bowe's been gone for so long that it's going to be difficult to come back," his father told journalists on Sunday.

Jani and Bob Bergdahl spoke of their love and pride for their son, Sgt Bowe Bergdahl, and said he would need time to ''decompress''

"It's like a diver going deep on a dive and [having] to stage back up through decompression to get the nitrogen bubbles out of his system. If he comes up too fast, it could kill him."

The circumstances of Sgt Bergdahl's capture remain unclear, with speculation he may have walked away from his base out of disillusionment with the US campaign.

US officials say any decision over possible desertion charges will be made by the army.

Who are the Guantanamo detainees?
  • Mohammad Fazl served as the Taliban's deputy defence minister during America's military campaign in 2001. Accused of possible war crimes, including the murder of thousands of Shia Muslims.
  • Khirullah Khairkhwa was a senior Taliban official serving as interior minister and governor of Herat, Afghanistan's third largest city. Alleged to have had direct links to Osama Bin Laden.
  • Abdul Haq Wasiq was the Taliban's deputy minister of intelligence. Said to have been central in forming alliances with other Islamist groups to fight against US and coalition forces.
  • Mullah Norullah Noori was a senior Taliban military commander and a governor. Also accused of being involved in the mass killings of Shia Muslims.
  • Mohammad Nabi Omari held multiple Taliban leadership roles, including chief of security. Alleged to have been involved in attacks against US and coalition forces.

More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 671.

    y theft, molestation , dacoity are not ideal weapons for villagers to settle their scores with others to whom they owe etc ?

  • rate this

    Comment number 670.

    al these are ungrateful to the president,who toiled day n night to retreive the sgt..strive so hard to the extent that fulfild precondition to make personal/in person request to negotiators for swap and much more ,if citizens wud have knwn that how much president cared for their life that he went a week ago their to make in person requst which was grantd.citizns should wash prersident feet n drink

  • rate this

    Comment number 669.

    murder is even wrong of the evil doers come u justify even imprisonmnt for life or some days of evil ? u wana imprison,handicapp evil by curtailing their liberty for days or so ? what use of are they in prisons? y not set the theives,robbers ,rapists ,all evil at liberty? y a justice system,a burden on tax payer? u wanna correct them ,who wil guarante their bahaviour while u work with them

  • rate this

    Comment number 668.

    they wanna put on lid on chain reaction ..keeping lid on chain reaction has not yet invented/discovered ,they have learnt it too late plus now want to prove it to be a deal of equation

  • rate this

    Comment number 667.

    its not a matter of jurisdiction but afraid of being convinced by those ppl in open courts ..they have no evidence n justice system fails to convict them.they wanna hide their inability to prove them false and dont wana let reveal truth about their barbarism/human rights....thet lack courage to confess their own wrongs done with them


Comments 5 of 671


More Asia stories


Features & Analysis

  • TricycleTreasure trove

    The lost property shop stuffed with diamonds, bikes... and a leg

  • Boris Nemtsov'I loved Nemtsov'

    A murder in an atmosphere of hatred and intolerance

  • Image of George from Tube CrushTube crush

    How London's male commuters set Chinese hearts racing

  • INDHUJA'Dorky tomboy'

    The Indian who attracted proposals through honesty

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Best in show

    BBC Autos takes a look at 10 of the most eye-catching new cars at the 2015 Geneva motor show


  • Kinetic sculpture violinClick Watch

    The "kinetic sculpture" that can replicate digital files and play them on a violin

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.