New Zealand miners' recovery could take months, says PM

Photographs of 27 of the 29 miners. The miners are (top row L to R) Conrad John Adams, 43, Malcolm Campbell, 25, Glen Peter Cruse, 35, Allan John Dixon, 59, Zen Wodin Drew, 21, Christopher Peter Duggan, 31, Joseph Ray Dunbar, 17, John Leonard Hale, 45, Daniel Thomas Herk, 36, (second row L to R) David Mark Hoggart, 33, Richard Bennett Holling, 41, Andrew David Hurren, 32, Jacobus (Koos) Albertus Jonker, 47, William John Joynson, 49, Riki Steve Keane, 28, Terry David Kitchin, 41, Samuel Peter McKie, 26, Michael Nolan Hanmer Monk, 23, (bottom row L to R) Kane Barry Nieper, 33, Peter O"Neill, 55, Milton John Osborne, 54, Brendan John Palmer, 27, Benjamin David Rockhouse, 21, Peter James Rodger, 40, Blair David Sims, 28, Joshua Adam Ufer, 25 and Keith Thomas Valli, 62 The operator of the mine said it would make every effort to retrieve the men's bodies. Francis Skiddy Marden and Stuart Gilbert Mudge are not pictured

Related Stories

New Zealand's Prime Minister John Key has warned it may take months to recover the bodies of 29 men killed in an accident at the Pike River mine.

Speaking in Greymouth on the South Island, near the coal mine, he promised an investigation into the accident, saying the nation "needs answers".

The men were trapped last week and declared dead on Wednesday after a second explosion.

Messages of condolences have poured in from around the world.

Flags have been flying at half-mast and people have been gathering in churches across New Zealand for special services to mourn the 29 miners.

Members of parliament in the capital, Wellington, wore black and paid tribute to the men, singing the hymn How Great Thou Art.

John Key: "There are some basic questions that need to be answered"

Mr Key met the grieving families of the miners in Greymouth and said all New Zealanders were "deeply sorry" for their loss.

He said an independent commission of inquiry would "leave no stone unturned" into the cause of the explosions that trapped and most likely killed the miners.

"We need answers to what happened at Pike River. Clearly something's gone terribly wrong and it's now claimed the lives of 29 people," he said.

"And I think for the families, they now have accepted that their loved ones have gone, but they want answers. They also want their men removed from the mine."

The recovery operation could only take place "in a way that is safe to those that would undertake that mission", he said, adding that international experience showed this could take months.

No 'window of opportunity'

A mix of poisonous and combustible gases remained in the mine and there was the risk of further explosions at any time, said the CEO of Pike River Coal, Peter Whittall.

New Zealand mine disasters

1879: Probable gas explosion kills 34 men and boys at Kaitangata mine

1896: Suspected gas explosion kills 65 men at Brunner mine, near Greymouth

1914: Gas explosion kills 43 men at Ralph's mine in Huntly

1926: Explosion kills nine men at Dobson mine, near Greymouth

1939: Carbon monoxide asphyxiates 11 men at Glen Afton mine in Huntly

1967: Gas explosion kills 19 miners at Strongman mine, near Greymouth

2010: Explosions at Pike River mine, near Greymouth, are believed to have killed 29 miners

A rescue team had been preparing to enter the mine on Wednesday when gas levels spiked. The mission was called off just before the second explosion, Associated Press news agency said.

Trevor Watts, of New Zealand Mines Rescue, said there had been no "window of opportunity" for rescuers to enter the mine immediately after the first explosion on Friday, as some angry relatives have charged.

"It wasn't for the want of trying, or the willingness or the courage or the bravery of those that would have gone in to undertake the rescue - it was just the reality of the situation," Mr Key said.

Even before the second blast ended hopes of survival, rescuers did not manage to make contact with the miners - who included 24 New Zealanders, two Australians, two Britons and a South African.


Local high school principal Jim Luders said Greymouth, home to many of the miners, said he was devastated by events.

"Everyone here knows someone who's down the mines and that's what makes it so intensely personal," he told Radio New Zealand.

The UK's Queen Elizabeth, who is New Zealand's head of state, said she was deeply saddened by the disaster.

"I send my thanks and deep appreciation to everyone who has worked so hard to attempt a rescue, and also to those who will have a part to play in the task of healing the pain that is being felt throughout New Zealand and around the world," she said.

The board of Pike River Coal was to meet on Friday to discuss the future of the mine - seen as an economic lifeline for the region when it opened in 2008.

Analysts say New Zealand's mines have a good safety record, and this was the worst disaster for almost a century.

Pike River is not far from the Strongman mine, where an underground explosion killed 19 men in January 1967.

New Zealand's worst mining disaster was in 1896, when a gas explosion at the Brunner mine, also near Greymouth, left 65 miners dead. It accessed the same coal seam as the Pike River mine.

Graphic: Cross section of the Pike River Mine showing location of trapped miners 2km inside the main access tunnel
  • New Zealand's largest coal mine
  • Employs some 150 people
  • Operational since 2008
  • Accesses Brunner and Paparoa coal seams via 2.3km tunnel under Paparoa Ranges
  • 5.5m-wide, 4.5m-high tunnel bisects Hawera fault, through which methane gas is known to leak
  • First blast is believed to have happened at 1530 (0230 GMT) on Friday, 19 November
  • Two injured miners emerged from the tunnel entrance on Friday evening
  • Second explosion on 24 November

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Asia-Pacific stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • KnucklesGood or bad?

    For many it can be very satisfying to 'crack' the bones in your hand, but is it bad for you?


  • BatteriesClick Watch

    More power to your phone - the lithium-ion batteries that could last twice as long

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.