Deadly shipwreck puts human face on Australia's asylum debate

Passengers from boat shipwrecked on coast of Christmas Island, Australia - 15 December 2010 The boat shipwrecked on Christmas Island was believed to be carrying Iranians and Iraqis

Related Stories

The deaths of at least 27 suspected asylum seekers in a shipwreck at Christmas Island has put a human face on Australia's often heated debate over how to deal with illegal immigrants, says the BBC's Nick Bryant in Sydney.

Australia's asylum seeker debate is often conducted as if the people heading for its shores were an abstraction, with the term "boat people" almost shorn of its human meaning.

With such harrowing images from Christmas Island broadcast on early evening news shows - which only 24 hours earlier had dwelt more happily on the visit to Sydney of Oprah Winfrey - millions of Australians would have seen the anguished faces of those seeking to reach its shores, and witnessed the lengths to which they would go to get there.

Put simply, it was shockingly real.

Tabloid sensationalism in Australia is normally turned against the asylum seekers, who head here from countries like Afghanistan, Sri Lanka and Iraq.

They are often regarded as "queue jumpers", unwilling to go through the normal channels to seek asylum.

Start Quote

Refugee groups here complain that Australian politicians regard the asylum seeker issue primarily as a political issue rather than a policy issue”

End Quote

Asylum seekers arriving by plane do not attract the same attention, nor what refugee groups would call the same paranoiac reaction.

In July this year, Sydney's tabloid Daily Telegraph reported that up to 800 asylum seekers could arrive in Australian waters during the election campaign. It published the report under the headline INVASION.

The banner headline on its website today offers a more sympathetic take: HELPLESS.

Troubled history

Refugee groups here complain that Australian politicians regard the asylum seeker issue primarily as a political issue rather than a policy issue.

During this year's federal election, the slogan Stop the Boats became one of the Liberal leader Tony Abbott's most oft-heard mantras.

Villawood Immigration Detention Centre, Sydney, Australia The government has announced the opening of new detention facilities on Australia's mainland

For her part, Julia Gillard tried to neutralise an issue that has long troubled the Labor Party.

In a speech at the Lowy Institute in Sydney, she tried to put the boat people question in context, by stressing that they make up less than 1.5% of permanent migrants each year.

"It would take about 20 years to fill the MCG [Melbourne Cricket Ground] with asylum seekers at present rates of arrival," she noted.

But the new prime minister also noted that the debate "must not be constrained by self censorship or political correctness," which critics complained sounded like dog whistle politics and a reluctance to take a stand against prejudice.

There is a history here.

One of the main reasons why the former conservative Prime Minister John Howard won the 2001 federal election was because of his tough stance on border protection during what became known as the Tampa crisis.

In August that year, he dispatched Australian special forces to board a Norwegian freighter, the MV Tampa, to block 439 mostly-Afghan refugees from entering Australia's territorial waters.

Pacific Solution

Closer to the election, the asylum issue flared again when the Howard government claimed that unauthorised immigrants on board a vessel intercepted 100 nautical miles north of Christmas Island had thrown children overboard - a claim a subsequent Senate inquiry found to be untrue.

Again, Mr Howard's popularity rose, because he was seen to be taking such a resolute stand. Labor, meanwhile, was deemed to be soft on border security.

Eyewitness: "It was like a scene from a horror movie"

After the 2001 election, the Howard government instituted what became known as the Pacific Solution, where asylum seekers were transported to detention camps on small islands in the Pacific Ocean - Nauru and Manus Island.

They were sent there whatever the merits of their claims, and whatever level of persecution they were trying to flee.

The claims for asylum were processed while they were kept under lock and key, a policy that was slammed by rights groups such as Amnesty International.

When it came to power, the Rudd government ended the Pacific Solution, fearing it had tarnished the country's international human rights reputation.

But the government continued to maintain what became known as the Indian Ocean Solution. It has been centred on the offshore detention facility at Christmas Island, where boat people intercepted at sea are held while their claims for asylum are processed.

The conservative opposition says the end of the Pacific Solution has led to a surge in unauthorised arrivals by boat.

Some 6,300 asylum seekers reached Australia on 130 boats in 2010. That is thought to be highest number in 20 years.

Political truce

Holding more than 2,000 people, the detention centre on Christmas Island reached its capacity earlier this year, and the Gillard government has announced the opening of two new detention facilities on the mainland.

Her preferred long-term solution is to construct a regional processing centre for asylum seekers in East Timor, but she announced the policy in the run-up to the federal election without first getting agreement from the East Timorese government.

Christmas Island

  • Named by British sailor William Mynors, who sailed past on Christmas Day 1643
  • Annexed by British Crown in 1888, administered from Singapore
  • Australia paid Singapore £2.9m in compensation for the island in 1957
  • Australia opened its A$400m detention centre in 2006, and it now houses nearly 3,000 asylum seekers
  • Population of about 1,300, more than half of whom are ethnic Chinese

Her haste in announcing the move smacked of politics rather than a carefully thought out policy.

The Christmas Island disaster has already escalated the boat people debate, although the country's politicians have temporarily called a truce in respect for the dead.

''If the Australian government was willing to properly process asylum seekers in Indonesia and resettle successful refugees in Australia, then far fewer people would get on boats to travel to Australia," Ian Rintoul of the Refugee Action Coalition has told The Australian.

The Refugee Council of Australia has called for more regional co-operation on asylum seekers.

Amnesty International says the only way to dissuade asylum seekers enlisting the help of people smugglers operating out of Indonesia is to offer viable alternatives, with other Asia-Pacific countries demonstrating a willingness to protect refugees.

Whatever its outcome, after the tragedy on Christmas Island the debate has a human face.


More on This Story

Related Stories

More Asia-Pacific stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • TravelAround the world

    BBC Travel takes a look at the most striking images from the past seven days


  • A bicycle with a Copenhagen WheelClick Watch

    The wheel giving push bikes an extra boost by turning them into smart electric hybrids

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.