French bill re-opens old wounds with Turkey

A man waves a Turkish flag as he takes part in a rally in front of the French Consulate in Istanbul The revived French proposal has angered Turks

Related Stories

In 1915, the French Navy evacuated Armenian refugees from the Turkish coast to save them from almost certain death.

Nearly 100 years later, France and Turkey are again on opposite sides with the Armenians' fate, once again, the bone of contention.

The French National Assembly has decided that denying the Armenian genocide should henceforth be a crime.

The draft law must now be debated by the upper house - the Senate.

This is, of course, one of the most contentious issues in modern Turkish history. There is little doubt that huge numbers of Armenians were displaced and killed both during and after World War I.

Where Turkey and its critics disagree, is on the extent to which this was organised persecution and there are also disagreements about the overall scale of the tragedy.


It was an episode that evoked great passions in the Christian West, with journalists, clergymen and travel writers all eager to champion the Armenian cause.

Members of the French National Assembly vote on the genocide bill Some commentators suggested that the bill is timed ahead of Mr Sarkozy's election campaign

Clearly, it still evokes strong feelings. The French political debate has been variously characterised as an attempt to protect the memory of a terrible period at the start of the 20th century; a travesty of history; an electoral manoeuvre; or perhaps even a thinly-veiled attempt to distance Turkey from the European Union's doors.

There's no doubting that the Turkish government is upset. It has recalled its ambassador from Paris.

The Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has said that the French parliament has opened up wounds that will be difficult to heal.

For now, Turkey is cancelling all economic, political and military meetings between the two countries.

French warplanes will not be allowed to land in Turkey and French warships will not be welcome at Turkish ports.

This is an extraordinary step for one Nato ally to take against another. While the cancelling of military visits may not present much of a problem, the disruption of wider diplomatic contacts between Paris and Ankara is much more serious.

Election manoeuvre?

Turkey has become a key player in the region and, with crises developing in Syria and Iraq, the French - along with other key UN Security Council members - need to co-ordinate closely with the Turks.

No wonder then that there have been so far unconfirmed press reports in France suggesting a certain degree of annoyance in the French foreign ministry that this draft law came to parliament now.

Turkey and the Armenians

An Armenian woman mourns a dead boy during the deportations in 1915
  • Hundreds of thousands of ethnic Armenians died during mass deportations by Ottoman Turks in 1915-6
  • More than 20 countries say it was genocide
  • Turkey and some historians say it was part of widespread turmoil in World War I in which Muslims also died
  • Estimated 500,000 ethnic Armenians now in France
  • Turkey closed Armenia border in 1993 because of conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh
  • Turkey signed 2009 deal with Armenia to examine 1915 killings and open borders: ratified by neither side

Some French commentators suggest that there is indeed an electoral dimension here.

With French President Nicolas Sarkozy up for re-election in 2012 he is eager to court every constituency, including some 500,000 French citizens of Armenian descent.

The French parliament has a track record of pronouncing on historical events, ranging from the Holocaust, to slavery.

In 2005 there was even an attempt to force French schools to teach pupils about "the positive role of the French presence overseas" during the colonial era.

When proposals to sanction anyone denying the Armenian genocide first came before the French parliament in 2006, several of France's most-respected historians insisted that "in a free country, it was not the place of parliament or the courts to define historical truth".

That first time around the Turks were also very upset. A senior French diplomat was despatched to Ankara to reassure them.

And, in the end, the French Senate rejected the draft law in May 2011. Nonetheless, this time it may take more than just a bit of reassurance to patch up fraying Franco-Turkish ties.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Europe stories


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Best in show

    BBC Autos takes a look at 10 of the most eye-catching new cars at the 2015 Geneva motor show


  • A robotClick Watch

    The latest in robotics including software that can design electronics to solve problems

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.