Italy sinking: Bad weather hampers search for migrants

A man from Eritrea is rescued: "You have to search or 480 people are going to die"

Rough seas forced divers to postpone their search for more than 200 migrants still unaccounted for after their boat sank off southern Italy.

Rescuers have so far found 111 bodies, and 155 people have been pulled alive from the seas 1km (half a mile) from the island of Lampedusa.

Video footage showed the boat lying upright on the seabed some 150ft (45m) below the surface.

Divers have described seeing horrific scenes inside the wreckage.

The arguments have begun over how to stop this tragic loss of life.

Some officials are saying that if you close borders, then you give more power to the traffickers. Others point out that there are 26 million out of work in the EU and that Europe is reluctant to accommodate more migrants.

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon said on Thursday that there needed to be "more channels for safe and orderly migration". It might help but it remains likely that thousands will still try and migrate to Europe.

EU Home Affairs Commissioner Cecilia Malmstroem vowed to "fight smugglers exploiting human despair".

None of this is easy but officials are saying that the migrants have become a "European tragedy".

So many bodies have been brought ashore that the island has had to send for more coffins and turn a hangar at the airport into a huge makeshift mortuary.

Italians are aghast at the scale of the tragedy that unfolded on Thursday, Italy's worst ever migrant shipwreck, the BBC's Alan Johnston says.

A day of mourning was declared on Friday, with flags flying at half-mast and a minute of silence observed in all Italian schools.

An evening mass and silent candlelit procession was held on Lampedusa. Most residents of the island turned out, the BBC's Gavin Hewitt reports from the scene.

People are sombre, but also angry that such tragedies are happening all too often and so little is being done to prevent them, he adds.

Pope Francis, visiting Assisi, described Friday as "a day of tears" for the victims and condemned a "savage world" that ignores the plight of "people who have to flee poverty and hunger".

He has said he wants to use abandoned Catholic monasteries and convents to house refugees.

Key migrant routes to southern Europe
Map of migrants routes

Illegal migration numbers

  • Since 1988, at least 19,142 people died trying to reach Europe's borders - 2,352 in 2011 alone
  • 6,707 have died off Sicily in the past 10 years
  • In 2012 Italy examined 27,000 asylum claims - 24% of applicants got international protection
  • 272,208 asylum claims in whole EU in 2012, of which 25% were in Germany
  • 30,100 irregular migrants reached Italy by sea in Jan-Oct 2013 - about half were from Syria and Eritrea

Sources: UNHCR, Frontex, Fortress Europe

Lampedusa Mayor Giusi Nicolini - who wept at the scene - said: "After these deaths, we are expecting something to change. Things cannot stay the same.

"The future of Lampedusa is directly linked to policies on immigration and asylum."

Libya is attractive for migrants wanting to travel on to Europe, says the BBC's Rana Jawad

Interior Minister Angelino Alfano said: "This is not an Italian tragedy, this is a European tragedy. Lampedusa has to be considered the frontier of Europe, not the frontier of Italy."

Italian coastguard ships, fishing boats and helicopters have been taking part in the rescue and recovery operation off an area of Lampedusa called Rabbit Island.

The search has been widened beyond the initial radius of four nautical miles in an effort to recover bodies that have been swept away by tides.

But the worsening weather conditions put the operation on hold during the afternoon.

Gavin Hewitt says that at least 200 migrants are still unaccounted for

Mr Alfano said the divers had seen dozens of bodies in the wreck. "There could be even more in the hold, where the poorest of the poor are usually put," he told parliament.

Start Quote

Africa may be seeing sustained economic growth, but few of the profits appear to be trickling down to the poorest”

End Quote

Half of the bodies so far recovered are said to be women and four are children.

The skipper of the boat, a 35-year-old Tunisian, was arrested, Mr Alfano announced on a visit to Lampedusa on Thursday. "He had been deported from Italy in April," he said.

The 66ft (20m) ship was carrying about 500 migrants - mostly from Eritrea and Somalia - when it set sail from the Libyan port of Misrata, survivors said.

The boat began taking on water when its motor stopped working as it neared Lampedusa early on Thursday morning, they said.

Some of those on board then reportedly set fire to a piece of material to try to attract the attention of passing ships, only to have the fire spread to the rest of the boat.

The boat is thought to have capsized when everyone moved to one side.

Rescued migrants in image released by Italian coastguard on 3 October 2013 This image released by the Italian coastguard shows some of the migrants who survived the shipwreck.
Wreckage of migrant boat on the sea bed in video released by the Italian authorities on 4 October 2013 But their boat lies at the bottom of the sea, along with many bodies of those who did not survive the disaster.
Hearses at Lampedusa's airport on 4 October 2013 The scale of the tragedy meant a hangar at Lampedusa's airport has had to be turned into a temporary mortuary and more coffins brought on to the island.
Black ribbons tied to flags in Assisi during Pope's visit on 4 October 2013 Black ribbons in memory of those who died were tied to banners during a mass by Pope Francis in front of St Francis Basilica in Assisi.
Torchlight procession through Lampedusa on 4 October 2013 Residents of Lampedusa held a candlelit procession through the streets of the island. One banner read: "Once again you didn't hear me crying."

Footage from Lampedusa showed bodies being laid out on the dockside.

Mayor Nicolini has described the scene as a "continuous horror", while a local doctor said the hardest part to deal with was seeing the bodies of children.

An Eritrean woman who had initially been placed among the bodies on the shore was later found to be breathing and was taken to hospital in Sicily.

Why people flee Eritrea and Somalia

Eritrea:

  • UN says 3,000 people try to flee each month
  • Human rights groups say the country is becoming a giant jail, with some 10,000 political prisoners
  • Young people conscripted to army - sometimes until age of 40

Somalia:

  • Much of the country controlled by al-Shabab Islamist militants
  • Country ravaged by two decades of war

In a statement, UN High Commissioner for Refugees Antonio Guterres commended the swift action taken by the Italian coastguard to save lives.

Mr Guterres also expressed "dismay at the rising global phenomenon of migrants and people fleeing conflict or persecution and perishing at sea".

The UN said that in recent months, most migrants attempting the crossing were fleeing the conflicts in Syria and the Horn of Africa rather than coming from sub-Saharan Africa.

The number of those arriving by sea to Italy this year until 30 September stood at 30,100, according to the UN.

The main nationalities of those arriving were Syrian (7,500), Eritrean (7,500) and Somali (3,000).

Map showing departure countries for migrants who go to Italy

More on This Story

Migrant disasters

More Europe stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • FutureThe future is now

    Get the latest updates and biggest ideas from BBC Future’s World-Changing Ideas Summit

Programmes

  • St John's, CanadaThe Travel Show Watch

    It’s a ships’ symphony – listen to these freighters in Canada play music with their horns

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.