World Cup: Will German victory help Angela Merkel?

German Chancellor Angela Merkel congratulates Bastian Schweinsteiger of Germany during the medal ceremony after the 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil Final match between Germany and Argentina at Maracana in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 13 July 2014 Angela Merkel's popularity may be reinforced by the German team's success

Related Stories

Will Germany's triumph at the World Cup help Angela Merkel?

She's been accused of shamelessly attaching herself to the footballers and their success, and the polls have shown upward blips of support for her as the team has progressed. But will it last?

There's no doubt the World Cup has played well for her. Within an hour of the final whistle, there seemed to be a million tweets of her pictured in the middle of the sweaty, victorious team holding the trophy, the president of Germany beside her.

She is, by all accounts, a genuine football fan, going to games way before she was politically important. But nowadays the right picture in the right place doesn't do any harm either.

She was there when Germany thrashed Portugal 4-0 at the start and she was there at the final triumph when they lifted the World Cup.

She's been described as the team's lucky charm. As she and the team's supporters sometimes put it: "Our twelfth man is a woman."

But the political benefits of sporting success are not clear - or rather, they are complex and memory plays tricks.

'Feel-good' myth?

It is one of the great myths of British politics, for example, that the victory of England in the World Cup of 1966 kept Labour in government.

The story runs thus: Labour and the Conservatives were running neck-and-neck in the election opinion polls and then Geoff Hurst knocked in a hat-trick.

The fans, also known as voters, duly rewarded Harold Wilson at the ballot box and kept him in Number 10.

German fans react at the end of the FIFA World Cup 2014 final football match Germany v Argentina played in Brazil during an outdoor screening near the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, 13 July 2014 Germany's triumph at the World Cup has delighted fans

There's one problem with this oft-quoted canard: the election preceded the World Cup Final. Labour beat the Conservatives on 31 March and England beat West Germany on 30 July.

The "feel-good factor" from victory on the field can't have translated into political success.

But it may have been true four years later. In 1970 in Mexico, England were dumped out of the contest far earlier than expected.

It was the manner of defeat that hit so hard: England were 2-0 up against West Germany in a quarter-final with 22 minutes to go and over-confident manager Alf Ramsey substituted players to keep them fresh for the inevitable semi-final - except that the Germans then scored three (two in normal time and one in extra-time).

Less than a week later, in a great political upset, Labour and Wilson were dumped out of office.

Wilson said sport was not a factor, but a string of memoirs by his cabinet colleagues at the time revealed that he had been worried about how the World Cup would affect his chances of being substituted out of Downing Street.

File photo: German Chancellor Angela Merkel, centre, poses for a photo with the German national soccer team after Germany won 4-0 in the group G World Cup soccer match between Germany and Portugal at the Arena Fonte Nova in Salvador, Brazil, 16 June 2014 German Chancellor Angela Merkel posed with the German squad after they beat Portugal in the group stage

But this is all conjecture. There has been much pontification on the link between politics and sport but not much hard evidence.

One piece of serious academic research indicated that whatever benefit there might be to a nation and its politicians from sporting success was negligible.

Georgios Kavetsos of the London School of Economics and Stefan Szymanski, now of the University of Michigan, crunched the numbers.

They used measures of happiness for 12 Western European countries from 1974 to 2004 to see if they correlated with sporting success for those countries. They did not.

But they did find a correlation between measures of happiness and hosting sporting events.

Real winners: Brazil?

The academics looked at eight separate tournaments: the World Cup in France (1998) and Italy (1990), the European football championships in Italy (1980), France (1984), West Germany (1988), England (1996) and Belgium/the Netherlands (2000).

They found that happiness indices rose in all but one of these countries.

The exception was England, but the measurement wasn't quite comparable - happiness was measured for the United Kingdom not just for England and, strange to say, the happiness of the Scots, Welsh and Northern Irish might not move in the same direction as that of the English.

It would be too harsh to say that the happier the English, the more miserable the others, but you get the drift. Either way, the British exception in the study might prove the rule.

The upshot of this research is that Angela Merkel is unlikely to get a great political benefit from the victory of Germany on the field.

She is already widely approved of in the polls and a picture of her with other successful people may just reinforce that image. Think of how an unpopular politician would be greeted if he or she attempted to piggyback on the success of a team.

Soccer fans of the Brazil national soccer team watch a live broadcast of the World Cup third-place soccer match between Brazil and Netherlands, inside the FIFA Fan Fest area on Copacabana beach, in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 12 July 2014 Despite the Brazil team's thrashing at the World Cup, the country may be the real winners in the long run

But the research does indicate that the host country for a big sporting event becomes happier by doing so, however the country's team performs on the field.

As Kavetsos and Szymanski put it: "We find that the 'feelgood' factor associated with hosting football events is large and significant, but that the impact of national athletic success on happiness, while correctly signed, is statistically insignificant."

In which case, the big gainer from this World Cup would be Brazil.

It seems paradoxical to say this after the country's football side was thrashed and then thrashed again, with much booing by the fans.

Despite that, the sheer experience of togetherness and achievement in holding the event might bring an increase in happiness. So implies the research.

Step forward the true winners: Brazil.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Europe stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

Programmes

  • A computer generated of image of a robotic probe issued by Lunar MissionClick Watch

    Scientists seek crowdfunding to send probe to the Moon, plus other technology news

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.