MH17 crash: Dutch minister says passenger 'wore oxygen mask'

  • 9 October 2014
  • From the section Europe
Part of MH17 plane in Grabove, Ukraine (9 Sept) Image copyright AFP
Image caption The Boeing 777 disintegrated in mid-air and experts believed the passengers would have known little about it

Dutch Foreign Minister Frans Timmermans has said that one of the 298 people killed in the downing of a Malaysia Airlines plane over eastern Ukraine was found wearing an oxygen mask.

He indicated that not everybody on board had died instantly when the plane was hit by a missile.

An initial report said flight MH17 broke up in mid-air after being pierced by objects at high velocity.

Mr Timmermans has now said he regrets the remark and upsetting families.

"The last thing I want is to add to their suffering in any way," he said in a government statement (in Dutch) released hours after he made the comment on the Pauw talk show on Dutch TV. "I shouldn't have said it."

'Australian victim'

The Dutch public prosecutor has confirmed that an oxygen mask was found, although a spokesman said it was around the passenger's neck rather than their mouth. It had been secured with elastic and has been tested for DNA and fingerprints.

The plane had been flying from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur on 17 July when it went down over rebel-held territory. Pro-Russian separatist leaders deny shooting it down with a missile.

Although 196 of the passengers were Dutch, the passenger with the oxygen mask was not, the prosecutor said on Thursday. Dutch media said the victim in question was an Australian and the family had been informed about the development.

Image copyright Reuters
Image caption The plane came down near Grabove but some parts were found 8km (5 miles) from the main debris site

None of the other victims was wearing an oxygen mask, the public prosecutor added. The mask was from a Boeing 777 plane, but it was unknown how and when it had been put on.

Mr Timmermans is seen as one of the big hitters in the Dutch government.

He is due to leave his post shortly as foreign minister to take up a post as European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker's right-hand man.

He mentioned the oxygen mask during an interview with Jeroen Pauw, in which he was taken to task for an emotive speech he gave to the UN four days after flight MH17 was downed on 17 July.

Image copyright Source: NBAAI
Image caption Investigators said puncture holes showed small objects had entered the plane from above the cockpit floor

Final moments

In his address to the Security Council, Mr Timmermans imagined the horror felt by the passengers "when they knew the plane was going down" and wondered whether they had looked each other in the eyes "one final time, in an unarticulated goodbye".

When asked on Wednesday night if he had created an image that had not really taken place, Mr Timmermans said: "Oh yes? Can you be so sure about that?"

He acknowledged that those on board would not have seen the missile hit the plane.

"But do you know that someone was found with an oxygen mask on their mouth - and so they had the time to put it on?" Mr Timmermans said.

He went on to say that nothing could be ruled out about the 298 victims' final moments.

The official inquiry into the MH17 disaster had not made any mention of an oxygen mask being found on one of the victims.

But several experts concluded that the plane would have disintegrated too quickly for the passengers to have known anything about it.

Image copyright Reuters
Image caption Four days after the disaster, Mr Timmermans gave an emotive address to the UN Security Council
Image copyright EPA
Image caption Last month the remains of three Malaysians were taken home

Victims' families, angry that they had not been told about the oxygen mask before, were told by prosecutors that an inquiry was still being carried out and no conclusions had been drawn.

Mr Timmermans, who was due to give a statement to parliament on the matter, said in his statement that the disaster was close to his heart. "I sympathise enormously with the relatives," he said.

Although investigators were unable to visit the crash site because of fighting in the area, their initial report pieced together photographic evidence of the wreckage as well as cockpit and air traffic control data.

They said it pointed to "an in-flight break up" and added there was "no evidence of technical or human error".

The plane was hit while flying at 33,000ft (10,000m) and debris was found over a wide area of eastern Ukrainian territory held by pro-Russian rebels.

Image caption Parts of the plane were found 8km (5 miles) from the main debris site

Related Topics

More on this story