Russia plane crash: Flight recorder 'reveals faulty wing flaps to blame'

  • 28 December 2016
  • From the section Europe
Media captionInvestigators examine one of the aircraft's 'black box' flight recorders

A flight recorder from the Russian jet that crashed into the Black Sea on Sunday has revealed that faulty flaps were to blame, Russian media say.

The flaps, panels on the wings that help lift an aircraft, were not moving together, a source close to the probe told the private Interfax news agency.

The pro-Kremlin Life news website says this led the pilots to lose control as the plane was at a "critical angle".

It also quoted the crew's last words, including: "The flaps, hell... !"

The ageing Tu-154 airliner came down off the Russian coast with the loss of all 92 passengers and crew.

On board were 64 members of the famed Alexandrov military music ensemble, as well as one of Russia's best-known humanitarian figures, Yelizaveta Glinka.

Image copyright EPA
Image caption Flowers have been laid outside the Alexandrov Ensemble building in Moscow

The plane was heading to Russia's air force base in Syria where the choir was due to perform at a New Year's concert.

The latest findings reportedly come from a cockpit conversation stored on a "black box" recorder, found underwater about a mile from the shore on Tuesday.

The military airliner was commanded by experienced pilot Maj Roman Volkov and his co-pilot was Capt Alexander Rovensky, who had 10 years of aviation service.

An earlier audio recording, played on Russian media, said to be of the final conversation between air traffic controllers and the plane's crew, revealed no sign of difficulties.

But Life, a new site which is close to the Russian security agencies, issued a transcript of the cockpit recording taken from the "black box", indicating the two pilots were taken by surprise.


Pilots' last words:

  • "Speed 300 (inaudible)."
  • "(Inaudible)."
  • "I've pulled in the landing gear, commander."
  • "(Inaudible)."
  • "Oh bloody hell!"

Piercing alarm sounds

  • "The flaps, hell, what a…!"
  • "The altimeter [altitude meter]!"
  • "We're in… (inaudible)."

Alarm sounds about dangerous proximity to the ground

  • "(Inaudible)."
  • "Commander we're falling!"

The plane crashed soon after take-off from an airport near the city of Sochi, where it had landed for refuelling.

It disappeared from radar two minutes after taking off from Adler airport at 05:23 (02:23 GMT) on Sunday.

A second flight recorder has been found in a good condition and was raised from the seabed on Wednesday, the defence ministry said.

According to the authorities, so far 15 bodies have been recovered from the crash site.

The Tupolev airliner involved in the crash was an old model no longer flown by airlines in Russia but still used by the military. It was 33 years old.

The investigators have so far ruled out terrorism as a possibility, instead concentrating on human error, a technical fault or a combination of factors as being responsible.


Image copyright AFP

Tupolev-154: Russian workhorse

  • The backbone of Soviet and Russian airlines for decades
  • Three engines, narrow-bodied and medium range
  • Designed in the mid-1960s, came into service in 1972 and was modernised in 1986 with new engines and equipment
  • Has seen 39 fatal accidents, although few were due to technical problems. Many were as a result of difficult weather conditions and poor air traffic control. A few were lost in conflicts including in Lebanon, Georgia and Afghanistan
  • Not used in Russia's civil aviation since 2009, but is still used by the military. Only about 50 in service worldwide

Mechanical v human: Why do planes crash?


What is the Alexandrov Ensemble?

Image copyright Reuters
  • Alexandrov Ensemble is the official choir of the Russian armed forces
  • It was founded in 1928 during the Soviet era
  • The group also includes an orchestra and dancers
  • It takes its name from its first director, Alexander Vasilyevich Alexandrov, who wrote the music to the national anthem of the Soviet Union
  • Holds the right to use the term Red Army Choir, although the interior ministry's MVD Ensemble also uses it
  • Listen to the Alexandrov Ensemble here

Related Topics

More on this story

Around the BBC