Syria Geneva II peace talks witness bitter exchanges

 

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon: "Syrians must come together to save their country, protect their children and find a peaceful path to a better future"

Syria's government and main political opposition have traded bitter accusations on the first day of a major peace conference in Switzerland.

The opposition and US said President Bashar al-Assad had no legitimacy and must step down from power.

Syria's foreign minister had a terse exchange with the UN's Ban Ki-moon over the length of his speech and said only Syrians could decide Mr Assad's fate.

The conflict has left more than 100,000 dead and millions displaced.

The summit is discussing the Geneva communique which lays out a political transition plan for Syria.

Analysis

This first day of talks was always expected to be somewhat ceremonial, with one formal speech after another. But already predictable fault lines are emerging.

Syria's Foreign Minister Walid Muallem said his country was engaged in a war against terrorist groups, adding that only the Syrian people could decide on President Assad's future. The opposition leader Ahmad Jarba said the human rights violations in Syria were reminiscent of Nazi Germany, and suggested President Assad's departure was a precondition for peace.

These two men won't be in the negotiating room together until Friday, then the talking will be in private, but it's expected to be equally tough.

Key figures here - including Ban Ki-moon, John Kerry, Sergei Lavrov and William Hague - have publicly reminded the warring parties of the real price of this conflict. An "all encompassing disaster" said the UN secretary general, which Russia's foreign minister added had caused "incalculable suffering" to the Syrian people.

Wednesday's initial meeting, involving speeches from 40 or so foreign ministers - has now ended. The direct talks are scheduled to begin in Geneva on Friday.

At a fractious evening news conference, during which there were repeated calls for calm, Mr Ban spoke of the suffering in Syria, saying: "Enough is enough. The time has come to negotiate."

He said that "the really hard work begins on Friday", adding: "We have a difficult road ahead, but it can be done and it must be done."

Mr Ban dwelt on the Geneva communique, which calls for a transitional government in Syria, saying he was disappointed with the attitudes of both the Syrian government and its ally, Iran.

UN mediator Lakhdar Brahimi said he would speak to the Syrian government and opposition delegations separately on Thursday and that he hoped both teams would meet in the same room on Friday.

This would be the first face-to-face meeting between the Syrian government and the main opposition - the National Coalition - since the conflict began in 2011.

At his press conference, US Secretary of State John Kerry stressed that the Geneva communique and its call for political transition was the paramount focus of the summit.

"Every delegation, with one exception, embraced the Geneva communique," he said, referring to the Syrian government.

Syria's foreign minister and the Syrian national coalition president delivered angry statements

"No-one has done more to make Syria a magnet for terrorists than Bashar al-Assad," Mr Kerry said. "You cannot save Syria with Bashar al-Assad in power."

A member of the Syrian team, UN ambassador Bashar Jaafari, criticised the exclusion of Iran from the meeting, and condemned many of Wednesday's speeches as "provocative and repetitive statements based on hatred towards the Syrian government".

He also accused Gulf states of "inciting terrorism" in Syria.

'Inflammatory rhetoric'

The BBC's Paul Wood, in Montreux, says there were some extraordinarily ill-tempered scenes and some very direct language at the morning meeting.

Syria's Foreign Minister Walid Muallem said some states attending the talks had "Syrian blood on their hands" and called the opposition "traitors".

Security around summit venue in Montreux (21 Jan 2014) The summit is taking place amid tight security in a Montreux hotel
Pro-Assad protesters in Montreux (22 Jan 2012) Outside the conference venue, supporters of President Bashar al-Assad staged a protest
Anti-government protest in Montreux (22 Jan 2014) Anti-government protesters staged a mock funeral, calling for an immediate ceasefire

Addressing Mr Kerry, he said: "No-one in the world has the right to confer or withdraw the legitimacy of a president, a constitution or a law, except for the Syrians themselves."

Mr Muallem ran far over the allotted 10-minute slot for each speaker, ignoring Mr Ban's attempts to intervene.

Geneva II talks

  • 22 Jan: Conference opens in Montreux. Speeches from all delegates, including Syrian government and opposition
  • Syria chief delegate - Foreign Minister Walid Muallem. Opposition chief delegate - Ahmed Jarba, head of the National Coalition
  • 24 Jan: Talks to move to Geneva. Negotiations between Syrian delegations begin, moderated by Lakhdar Brahimi. No duration set.

"You live in New York. I live in Syria," Mr Muallem told the UN secretary general. "I have the right to give the Syrian version here. After three years of suffering, this is my right."

The US state department condemned Mr Muallem's remarks as "inflammatory rhetoric", and urged the government to take "real, concrete steps to increase humanitarian access and improve the lives of the people suffering the most".

The head of the National Coalition, Ahmad Jarba, said the Syrian government must sign up to a deal to transfer powers from Mr Assad.

Mr Jarba said that this would be "the preamble to Bashar al-Assad's resignation and his trial alongside all the criminals of his regime".

He added: "For the Syrians, time is now blood."

Mr Jarba displayed a photograph taken from a report by three war crimes investigators which alleged "systematic" torture and execution of opposition detainees in Syria. The report was released on Tuesday but dismissed as not credible by Damascus.

Geneva Communique

A UN-backed meeting in 2012 issued the document and urged Syria to:

  • Form transitional governing body
  • Start national dialogue
  • Review constitution and legal system
  • Hold free and fair elections

Our correspondent says that when the talks go behind closed doors there will perhaps be a more constructive tone - with discussion of practical matters such as ceasefires and access for humanitarian aid.

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said the talks "will not be simple, will not be quick", but that there was "a historic responsibility on the shoulders of all participants".

He also repeated his insistence that Iran should be involved.

The UN withdrew its invitation to Iran this week over its refusal to back the Geneva communique.

Iran's President Hasan Rouhani said on Wednesday that the "lack of influential players" attending meant he doubted "its ability to resolve the Syria crisis".

 

More on This Story

Syria conflict

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    -9

    Comment number 851.

    At best, Geneva can only provide a ceasefire and maybe some additional aid throughput. The Syrian president will continue to refuse any transfer of power and so the rebel factions will continue to fight. A post-war Syria will be broken and divided whatever the conclusion; the West "won" the second Assad chose this.

  • rate this
    +48

    Comment number 610.

    This is beginning to look like another case where the West wants puppets in power so that they can be manipulated. Kerry should sit back and support the protagonists decisions, not make decisions on behalf of either side. Prejudiced proffering of his opinion is unhelpful.

  • rate this
    +5

    Comment number 361.

    As someone has rightly said, History is always a one sided story. Stories, Claims and Concerns from all the parties must be heard and a consensus/decision that works in favor of the majority common people should be reached.
    These are peace talks and it would be a shame if it engulfs the situation further.

  • rate this
    +4

    Comment number 350.

    Not to be unexpected this is how most talks in this kind of situation start, especially in civil wars, hopefully as the talks contiune the recriminations will start to diminish and common grounds can be found.

    At somepoint someone will have to make a concession, it all depends who blinks first.

  • rate this
    +38

    Comment number 338.

    I can't see this peace conference going anywhere. The situation in Syria is beyond a peaceful solution, & will only come to an end when one side wins or both sides grow tired of fighting. But that could be decades away. Military intervention from outside will just change the nature of the war & create a new enemy, as in Iraq and Afghanistan. It's a lose-lose situation only Syrians can stop.

 

Comments 5 of 11

 

More Middle East stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • FutureThe future is now

    Get the latest updates and biggest ideas from BBC Future’s World-Changing Ideas Summit

Programmes

  • St John's, CanadaThe Travel Show Watch

    It’s a ships’ symphony – listen to these freighters in Canada play music with their horns

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.