American The Office clocks out

Promotional photo from The Office UK The UK version of the show featured a leaner cast and a bleaker outlook

The American version of The Office closed up shop after nine years and more than 200 episodes. Its sunny optimism reflected the country that adopted it.

For Britain the joy was always short lived. For America, the river of laughs flowed deeper and ran longer.

But now it is over.

The Office - whether in Slough, England, or Scranton, Pennsylvania - has closed for business.

What became a wildly successful series in the US almost died at birth. A six-episode run in 2005 garnered calamitously low ratings and generally poor reviews.

But broadcaster NBC persevered. The style of the show was tweaked and by the second season The Office had become that rarity - a huge network hit showered with praise by the critics. It also changed the way that television, or at least some television, was made.

The original concept, as executed in the UK, was a hugely unlikely mass-market show for the US - a single-camera "mockumentary" about life in the administrative office of a paper products supply company.

'Life is stationery'

The humour is deadpan ("refreshingly laid back", the regional manager described himself, "for a man with such responsibility"). There is neither studio audience nor laugh track to remind viewers that it is a comedy or simply to indicate when to laugh.

It worked in America. But it was different. And the differences speak - perhaps a little uncomfortably at times - to the differences between the country that gave birth to the show and the one that so enthusiastically adopted it.

Start Quote

It might just be that the kinder, gentler American TV show reflects a kinder and gentler country”

End Quote

Some of the changes were superficial - Wernham Hogg Paper Merchants (where "life is stationery") became Dunder Mifflin Inc, a regional paper and office supply distributer.

The UK version ran for 15 episodes. The US version, with nine seasons and more than 200 episodes, had a larger cast and vastly expanded storylines. And Slough, of course, became Scranton.

For Office fan Michelle Dempsey, that almost became a problem.

"My husband is British," she says, "and the night we met we bonded over The Office, the UK version.

"The American version had just started, and I had to swear to him that Scranton, where I lived, was not Slough."

Dark, bitter, lacerating

Tim Holmes, of the Scranton Times, picks up on the theme.

"Even though we are a little slow-paced in Scranton, Pennsylvania, and they really played that up, there's always this endearing quality that came out," he says. "For that we were always very thankful. They were very kind."

Endearing. Kind. Not words you associate with the UK version. Dark, bitter, quite often lacerating. But really not endearing, or kind.

You rarely wince watching the American Office. The cubicle farms of the US, where tens of millions spend their white-collar working lives, are deeply conventional places, heavily represented (and ever-so-lovingly mocked) in advertisements.

The US version of The Office may have seemed risque to some, but that is because American workplaces are more regimented affairs than in many countries, with written and unwritten workplace etiquette rules often stifling spontaneity and horseplay.

Small towns mocked

So in the US version, a stapler does get embedded into jelly. But the foul-mouthed misogyny of near-sociopath Chris Finch? The unflinching mordancy of anti-hero Gareth Keenan? None of it made it to the American screen.

The US version of The Office is a kinder, gentler thing, with more slapstick laughs and more relief for the audience from the forensic dissection of life amongst the grey partition walls.

Members of the cast attend The Office 100th Episode Celebration The American version of The Office celebrated its 100th episode in 2009

"In the first season of the American show, we were trying to create the despicable boss and the despicable employees, and I guess we just couldn't follow through on it," says Hank Steuver, TV critic for the Washington Post.

"We needed something to hang on to, some sliver of hope. We kind of turned them into loveable teddy bear people who still had all their flaws and were not always nice to one another but somehow wormed their way into our hearts."

The Office in America became a funny, sometimes awkward piece of the television furniture. And when the end of the final season drew near, the people of Scranton threw a parade. Stars of the show sat on the back of pick-up trucks and the band played and played. Small town life had been mocked in the show, but gently.

It is difficult to imagine Slough, back in England, doing the same for The Office that made its trading estate home.

One critic wrote of the British version that "nobody is working, nobody has a happy relationship, everyone looks terrible and everyone looks depressed". That's not Britain - either at work at play.

But it might just be that the kinder, gentler American TV show reflects a kinder and gentler country.

Jonny Dymond Article written by Jonny Dymond Jonny Dymond Washington correspondent

With an eye on the White House, Cruz takes on Iowa

Ted Cruz reaches out to Republicans in Iowa and starts to build a national movement.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 194.

    This seems to have become a game of one-upsmanship reading some of these comments. Im just quite upset because i loved the show, and enjoyed the UK version while it lasted...Anyway, good job, though the creators have unearthed a jem with Parks & Recreation.

  • rate this

    Comment number 193.

    Americans really love to flog a dead horse when it comes to sitcoms don't they? They are still trying to breathe life into the corpse of The Simpsons several years after it died. The idea is quality over quantity.

  • rate this

    Comment number 192.

    Surely the point about the UK "office" was the originality of Ricky Gervais take on life. It was dark, bleak and sometimes childish, but it was original at the time. Personally i did not like either of the Offices, but you could see the truth of what he was saying. Making points about the whole of UK and US culture from one TV show is unlikely to result in worthwhile conclusions.

  • rate this

    Comment number 191.

    @171 Davey Trasker.

    Gareth Keenan writes - if he is the FORMER TV critic of the Standard, then it goes without saying that he does not work there anymore. (Brent stands silently, trying to think of something witty to add.)

  • rate this

    Comment number 190.

    Although I saw the UK version first I much prefer the US one. I think the summary above is about right - there are more laughs in the US version, the characters better developed, and it doesn't make you cringe all the time as Michael Scott (and his successors) weren't anything like Brent.
    Shame it's now ended as the final series was much better than the previous few but better to end on a high.


Comments 5 of 194


Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audi R8Best in show

    BBC Autos takes a look at 10 of the most eye-catching new cars at the 2015 Geneva motor show


  • A robotClick Watch

    The latest in robotics including software that can design electronics to solve problems

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.